Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
“Meals Aren’t Cooked Every Night”: Mother-And-Father-In-Law Cross A Line By Threatening CPS Over Messy Home
We often think that the biggest thing parents stress about is childcare. However, an untidy home can cause just as big a headache as deciding which parenting strategy is best. Surprisingly, 60% of parents say that the cleanliness of their home is a major stressor in their lives.
Sometimes, their fears of guests seeing it are founded. This couple, for example, faced threats of CPS from the grandparents because their home looked too messy for the in-laws’ standards. According to them, it was hazardous to the new baby. But when the couple shared their story online, people deduced that the in-laws had grossly overstepped boundaries.
RELATED:
In-laws threatened a couple with calling CPS if they didn’t get their messy house under control
Image credits: freepik / freepik (not the actual photo)
The couple wondered whether the in-laws were right or straight-up manipulative
Image credits: bearfotos / freepik (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Basic-Refrigerator93
Parents often don’t find enough time for cleaning and organizing
Keeping a clean house as a parent is not easy. Even people without children admit that cleanliness is one of the hardest things they have to do as adults. In fact, one survey shows that 24% of Americans think keeping a tidy house is harder than their regular 9-to-5 job.
When kids come into the picture, it can become even more difficult to find time for tidying up. Some parents can’t even find 10 minutes to take a shower, let alone do laundry, wash the dishes, and sweep the floors. As kids grow up, they make even more messes, so it’s only downhill from there.
Parents do stress about untidy homes, but experts say that mothers are particularly affected. “Even in homes where the labor is divided pretty equally between partners, there’s often one person who takes more of the stress over appearance,” says Bonnie Scott, a licensed psychotherapist in Texas and the host of the Work and Wellness podcast.
According to a 2024 study, moms take on an average of seven to 10 household tasks. Fathers, in turn, manage around 45% of those tasks. Mothers take on more daily jobs like childcare and cleaning, while dads do “episodic” tasks like keeping the finances in order and home repairs.
A disastrously untidy home isn’t just an eyesore; it’s also a source of stress for those who live there. Relationships with family members might even deteriorate because of a messy home. As a 2023 survey shows, 46% of Americans say that messiness causes tension between them and family members. 35% of the respondents admit to arguing about cleanliness and tidying up, and for 33%, it’s a “source of stress on a daily basis.”
A normal family house will always have signs of wear and habitation
Image credits: eduard / unsplash (not the actual photo)
But what is a messy house? Clearly, as evident from this story, what’s a mess to one person might seem like a normal, uncluttered house to another. Family members often disagree about what “clean and organized” means, and that’s why arguments and resentments arise.
Some would argue that a messy house is a house that’s lived in. Bonnie Scott says that the pressure to always have a perfect, tidy house comes from comparing ourselves to people we see in the media we consume. “Comparing your space to others is in no way helpful, because you don’t live in those spaces,” she explains. “We can treat those magazine shots, HGTV reveals and social media posts as what they really are: art-directed spaces presented as perfection.”
It’s important to remember that we seldom see other people’s spaces the way we see our own. Before we come to visit, most people have scrubbed and neatly organized for a few hours beforehand.
KC Davis, a therapist and author of How to Keep House While Drowning, told Vox that a clean house doesn’t have to be sterile with no hair out of place. “As long as things are sanitary, people aren’t going to remember what it looks like. They’re going to remember the way that they felt and the time that they had while they were there.”
The in-laws had a pattern of overstepping boundaries: “What they do isn’t okay”
Commenters urged the couple to enforce strict boundaries and go no-contact if necessary
Image credits: Drazen Zigic / freepik (not the actual photo)
The author came back with a surprising update: “Under no circumstances is she to go to them”
Image credits: Basic-Refrigerator93
People congratulated the author for standing their ground and urged them not to give in to the in-laws’ further manipulations
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
Explore more of these tags
What do you think ?
FreeTheUnicorn 4 hours ago
So there is more risk in a CPS visit if you are not white cus-het Christian passing but even when there's bigotry involved, CPS needs more than just an angry grandparent's word to take custody of a child. Yes it is stressful and a huge hassle even when it's a crank complaint, but just because someone calls CPS doesn't mean you'll lose your kids. Without signs of physical harm, or testimony of an.use by the child if they are safe, warm, fed and not dangerously filthy, child services don't have time to waste on the situation. It's actually pretty hard to get a kid out of a home, even if you're a mandated reporter with significant cause for concern.
Nikki Sevven 38 minutes ago
MIL could have asked why there was clutter. MIL could have offered herself and FIL to help you sort through it, bin it, and transport it to charity. Instead, MIL decided that HER "standards" had to be met–in YOUR home–then threatened to call CPS if you didn't cave to her bullying. Throw out the whole MIL and FIL.
Jenna Kay 3 hours ago
My ex called CPS on me during our divorce. They came, saw a clean apartment, well-fed child, food in the pantry, clean clothes, etc. They were displeased about having come out. How do I know he called them? He mentioned it during the divorce ... in front of the judge ... who knew about the false call. It did not go well for him.
FreeTheUnicorn 4 hours ago
So there is more risk in a CPS visit if you are not white cus-het Christian passing but even when there's bigotry involved, CPS needs more than just an angry grandparent's word to take custody of a child. Yes it is stressful and a huge hassle even when it's a crank complaint, but just because someone calls CPS doesn't mean you'll lose your kids. Without signs of physical harm, or testimony of an.use by the child if they are safe, warm, fed and not dangerously filthy, child services don't have time to waste on the situation. It's actually pretty hard to get a kid out of a home, even if you're a mandated reporter with significant cause for concern.
Nikki Sevven 38 minutes ago
MIL could have asked why there was clutter. MIL could have offered herself and FIL to help you sort through it, bin it, and transport it to charity. Instead, MIL decided that HER "standards" had to be met–in YOUR home–then threatened to call CPS if you didn't cave to her bullying. Throw out the whole MIL and FIL.
Jenna Kay 3 hours ago
My ex called CPS on me during our divorce. They came, saw a clean apartment, well-fed child, food in the pantry, clean clothes, etc. They were displeased about having come out. How do I know he called them? He mentioned it during the divorce ... in front of the judge ... who knew about the false call. It did not go well for him.
You May Like “No Thank You”: MIL Throws Toys Out Of The Cot After Couple Rejects Her ‘Insensitive’ Baby Shower Idea Woman Shares Why She Has 7 Parents And People Online Are Baffled New Mom Goes Low Contact With Her Mother After An Alarming “Joke,” Is Unsure If She’s Overreacting
Jonas Žvilius
Indrė Lukošiūtė
Indrė Lukošiūtė
Related on Bored Panda
28
4