I prefer a man who doesn't give his opinion when no one asked for it, and yet here we are.

I feel that they mean they prefer a woman that is naturally perfect which is an odd thing to say when they themselves are mediocre at best.

You're free to have a preference. Don't shove that on to me. And don't conflate your preference with deserving of respect.

I think they don’t know what “no makeup” looks like. What they actually are saying is they prefer makeup that they can’t tell is makeup. I don’t wear makeup 99% of the time. On the days I wear natural makeup the world suddenly changes and men treat me completely differently.