Secret Santa is humanity's solution to the age-old problem of divvying up gift giving. After all, in any moderately sized family or group of friends, it’s not entirely possible to give everyone something, so it’s a great way to make sure everyone still gets a nice surprise. But things don’t always go to plan.
So we’ve gathered some of the most hilarious Secret Santa fails from across the internet for you to cringe at. Get comfortable as you scroll through, prepare to raise an eyebrow or two, upvote your favorites and be sure to share your own thoughts and experiences in the comments down below.
This post may include affiliate links.
Buddy At Work During The Secret Santa Party Legit Just Got Gifted The Same Shirt He Is Wearing
This "Bottle Of Scotch" At My Office's White Elephant Gift Exchange Was Stolen Twice Before Anyone Opened It
Vienna sausages. We had them in our ration packs and called them monkey d***s.
My Gift From Secret Santa
I'm allergic. Yes they knew.
The air is crisp, the lights are twinkling, and suddenly, you find yourself staring at a tiny slip of paper with the name of a person you only know as "Dave from Logistics" or "the cousin who collects vintage spoons." Welcome to the high-stakes, low-budget world of Secret Santa. It is a tradition designed to foster holiday spirit, yet it frequently results in some of the most awkward social exchanges known to mankind.
When done correctly, it is a heartwarming way to bond with peers, but when it goes wrong, it becomes the stuff of legendary office group-chat screenshots. To ensure you survive this festive gauntlet with your reputation intact, there are a few fundamental rules of the road that every participant must follow.
My Secret Santa Is A Jerk
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Load More Replies...That is 100% line crossed and actually vile , even with a broad mind , that’s just so wrong !
I'm betting the jerk who did that couldn't help but reveal himself by giggling, so I'd throw it back in his face (literally) and tell him to go and eff himself with it.
Gift exchange at work in the 80's, one woman got a bottle of mazola oil and a "how to make love to your man" book 🤣🤣🤣
My Mom Is Struggling To Comprehend Secret Santa
I Got Picked To Go First For The White Elephant Christmas Party At Work. You Can Probably Assume No One Wanted To Steal It From Me
I work at a pool, the kid was 15. He wrapped it like it was a piece of candy.
I’m pretty sure this post was pre 2020 as OP is complaining about this
It would have been worth its weight in gold in April 2020!
Load More Replies...The first and perhaps most sacred rule involves the financial boundary. If the group has collectively agreed upon a twenty-dollar limit, you must treat that number as a divine command. Staying within the lines is vital because breaking them creates a social imbalance that even the most delicious eggnog cannot fix. If you decide to be a "holiday hero" and spend eighty dollars on a luxury gadget, you aren't being generous, you are making everyone else feel like a cheapskate. Conversely, showing up with a five-dollar trinket makes you look like the Grinch’s less-successful younger brother.
This Gift My Little Sister Received In A £10 School Secret Santa
Yeh it’s safe to say he won’t be on the Christmas card list next year.
I would find this hilarious between best friends, but only if it's given at a random time, not when you both expect something nice from eachothers
Coworker Bought Me A Box Of Chocolates For Christmas - One Missing And The Rest Were Mouldy
Do you think this was intentional !?
That's not mold. It's the fat from the cocoa that rises to the surface if exposed to heat. Perfectly fine to eat.
I have forgotten a box of chocolate once, and even after 2 years, it wasn't that bad
Load More Replies...Let's hope the missing piece was taken at the time of original purchase and not at the time of being gifted.
My 12-Year-Old Son Asked For "A Gift Card Of Your Choice" And Received This For Secret Santa. They Didn't Even Write His Name
LCBO is a wine store.
Beyond the money, there is the matter of the "Secret" in Secret Santa. This requires a level of detective work that would make Sherlock Holmes proud. If you have drawn the name of someone you barely know, do not simply guess their interests based on their choice of desktop wallpaper. Ask around or look for subtle clues in their daily habits. Do they always have a specific brand of coffee? Are they a fan of a particular sports team? A little bit of research goes a long way in avoiding the "generic gift" trap.
We Did A Secret Santa And Someone Got A Package Of Oreos With The Creme Separated From The Cookies
So make triple-stuffed Oreos and crumble the remaining cookies into Ice cream. Delish!
Book I Got For A Secret Santa
Definitely in the bath, but debatable if actually read.
Load More Replies...Oh! That's a wonderful manga! A shame it's the third in the series and the condition is awful, but I do hope OP ended up reading the series anyways.
I had a coworker secret Santa a second hand book called Living with HIV.
Everyone At Work Got Amazing Heart Felt Gifts For Secret Santa And I Got A Bottle Of Car Detailer As A Joke
I work at Starbucks. The thing is, she doesn’t even hate me or anything. In fact, we get along really, really well.
Someone forgot and just stopped at the service station fir a panic buy.
Load More Replies...Does your car need a good cleaning and she thought she was being helpful???
Then, of course, we must address the "Don’ts," which are often where the most spectacular fails occur. Re-gifting is a delicate art form that most people should probably avoid. While it is technically acceptable to pass on a brand-new, high-quality item that simply wasn't for you, the danger lies in the details.
Thanks Secret Santa... I Would Have Rather Gotten A Trash Can
Why participate at all if you’re not going to put any effort in at all!
This looks like a secret Santa from inside a maximum security prison. Empty cigarette box and a fake inside foot pad for smuggling things past security. A multi use recharger that is always useful. And a shiv. Surly I don't have to explain how useful that is. Good luck getting out of prison.
Secret Santa Gift I Got For Coworker Unintentionally The Day He Got Fired
Showed up to work to give coworker of 2 months his secret Santa gifts. Left this in his cubicle and when I walked out into the hall the boss told me he had been fired and wouldn’t be coming back to collect any gifts. Explained why the cubicle looked so sparse.
Tried To Buy A Secret Santa Exactly What They Wanted, But Alas My Dreams Are Shattered
Doing a family secret santa this year with my partner's family, and I got her mum. She wanted these specific cocktail coupes (on her wishlist), so I tried to track them down as they're sold out in a lot of places online. Finally found some, and they arrived yesterday like this. The business is now out of stock and had to refund instead. There's no chance she'll have her cocktail coupes on Christmas morning now.
Happens a lot because many businesses now hire people for shipping who know nothing about packaging/shipping. I run into it almost daily. 45 pound items wrapped in 2 pieces of paper and shipped in a single wall box for example. Received a shipment yesterday and the item was completely missing. Hole in the end of the box which FedEx taped over, clearly indicated the item tore through the end of the box. 20 pound item wrapped in 1 piece of bubble wrap which was the only thing left in the box.
Load More Replies...There are legendary stories of people receiving gifts that still contained the original "To/From" tag intended for the previous owner. Even worse is the "used" gift. There is a special kind of holiday horror that occurs when a recipient unwraps a beautiful jar candle only to find a charred, black wick and half the wax missing. It tells the recipient that you didn't just forget to buy them a gift, you actually searched your own trash for a solution.
Had Given Up All Hope On My Secret Santa. After Three Months My Gift Arrived. Still Pretty Much Sums Up My Experience
Bad Luck Brian, an ancient meme. Usually upper line states something happens to him, and the lower line is about him defecating himself (or, sometimes, perishing.).
Load More Replies...I (30m) Participated In Secret Santa At Work, Asked For Sport Equipment, Got This Instead
Coworker came up to me after and said, “I thought it was funny.”
What's the spend cut off if he's asking for sports equipment?! Also, since when are you allowed to tell people what you want for Secret Santa... It's a secret.
You give them an idea of things you like so they don't get you something stupid that you hate.
Load More Replies...Particularly that one, since it's a wine bottle stand...
Load More Replies...My Family Secret Santa Gift Was A 1000 Piece Impossible Puzzle. Opened To Find 790 Pieces Missing
Must have come from a charity shop and no one had checked the contents. There were no edges.
Speaking of fails, we have to look at the "accidental insult." Secret Santa is not the time to suggest self-improvement to your colleagues or friends. Gifting someone a book on how to manage their time or a "Guide to Better Breath" kit might feel practical to you, but to the recipient, it feels like a public performance review.
Everyone's Posting Amazing Secret Santas. My Was Worst Secret Santa Ever
I can't tell what's in the blue wrapper. I'd guess a c****m, but who knows?
My Secret Santa Sent Me A Trash Can Lid. I'm Done
I put my likes as soccer, trucks, my dogs, and being outdoors. I like to make others happy. Definitely not anything to do with trash can lids.
This sounds more like the warehouse shipped the wrong thing.
Load More Replies...This Is What I Have Received From My Secret Santa
Unless it is a high-end spa kit that everyone would enjoy, giving someone soap often sends a message you didn't intend to send. One of the most famous Secret Santa fails involved a man who received a singular, loose potato wrapped in expensive silk ribbon. While the gift-giver thought it was a hilarious "anti-gift" joke, the recipient spent the rest of the party wondering what they had done to offend the "potato-wielder" so deeply.
Got This At The Office "White Elephant" Gift Exchange - Wrapped Together. Everyone Else Got Gift Cards And Electronics Accessories
Pollyanna Positivity Is Definitely Mildly Infuriating
Ok, pigs can't fly so saying anything is possible if you just think positive is beyond annoying to me. Living within possible limitations is not negative, it's realistic. This is what is called false hope since it's impossible. I have to look at this every day at work. I soooo would like to sabatage this little pig.
I have a little crochet Emotional Support Dumpster Fire on my desk. Its card reads, " It's fine. I'm fine. Everything is fine!" I tend to read that in my head with a voice of desperation.
I Brought 2 Xbox Games To A White Elephant Gift Exchange And The Gift I Got Was Bubble Wrap
Stand next to their workspace and slowly pop them one at a time with a dead look in your eyes.
There is also the "Office Supply Heist" to consider. Every year, at least one person decides that the best gift for their coworker is a stapler or a box of high-quality pens they "borrowed" from the company supply closet. This is not a gift, it is a chore. If someone wanted a stapler, they would have filled out a request form with HR. Your goal is to provide a moment of joy, not a reminder that they have three more reports due before the end of the year.
My Secret Santa Gift That I Got Last Year. I Wanted An Animation Book
Ew, I would NOT gift that to anyone unless they ask for it. How did that gifter even think this was appropriate?
Got Waxing Strips As Part Of My Secret Santa
Oh they got me when I wasn’t paying attention, it wasn’t my choice.
The comment under the picture is pointing out that he didn't use them by choice, the gifter used them on him without him wanting them to.
Load More Replies...This Was One Of The White Elephants Gifts At The Christmas Party Last Night
Find a collector. Those really niche Barbie Dolls, like the Magic Earring Ken, or the African American Oreo Barbie-ones that were either so short lived, or sparked a controversy-can be worth a ton. I actually sold an In Box Magic Earring Ken I got at a Kay-Bee Toy Store at an Outlet Mall. Retail: $14.99. I paid at the outlet: $5.99. What I got for it: $400. Apparently it became a cult favorite with the emerging LGBTQ+ movement. Mind you, this was in the 1990's, so the LGBTQ+ wasn't as open as it is now.
Finally, remember that the "no-show" is the ultimate holiday villain. If you sign up for the exchange, you are entering into a social contract. When one person fails to bring a gift, it leaves another person sitting in a circle of festive joy with empty hands. It is a lonely feeling that can put a damper on the entire event.
Ordered Something From Amazon To Give My Coworker For Secret Santa Tomorrow. It Was Delivered, But That's Not My House
Amazon says I have to wait 24 hours to ask for a refund and if I need the item sooner, I should just buy another. I remember now why I don't often order from them! If only there weren't so many gluten free items on there.
Rural area consumers. Brick and mortar stores are miles way, and the selection isn’t great. I use Amazon because it’s the only way to get supplies without taking all day to drive hours to acquire them.
Load More Replies...This seems to happen regularly where I live. However, it's a small town, so you can just post the image on the town FB page and eventually someone says, "Hey! That looks like so-and-so's door!"
White Elephant Gift Came Today, Part Was Yesterday
Now to figure out if I keep it until next year and give it then or hope Amazon will let me return it. The tin is dented but also bloated. Is it going to explode in my basement if I keep it for a year.
That is a swedish speciality. Very special. Think of Durian fruit level special: the odor is different, but comparabel in intensity and tolerability. The bloated tin however is correct: this means that the fish inside is ready for consumption. Don't worry about explosion: the tins are built to hold the bloating. An for heaven's Sake: DON'T OPEN IT INSIDE YOUR HOME!!!
If it's bloated it's fine, it's supposed to be. Just don't open it inside,for the love of Mike.
No, OP isn't complaining about something they received from their secret santa! OP is saying they ordered it for their secret santa recipient but it arrived too late for the gifting day.
Load More Replies...I Got The Worst Secret Santa Gift
It looks and smells so bad.
A quick search, the company is based in Mumbai, India.
Load More Replies..."Squalane is a stable, hydrogenated version of squalene, used in cosmetics as a lightweight, non-comedogenic moisturizer that hydrates the skin and supports the moisture barrier. It mimics natural skin lipids, is non-irritating, and can be used on all skin types, including oily and sensitive skin. Squalane also has antioxidant properties and can be sourced from olives or sugarcane."
Load More Replies...Even if you aren't thrilled with the person you drew, the holiday spirit is about the gesture itself. By sticking to the budget, doing a tiny bit of research, and avoiding the temptation to gift used candles or loose vegetables, you can ensure that your Secret Santa experience is memorable for all the right reasons.
This Is What I Got From My Office Secret Santa Today
I left her on display at my desk for an indefinite period of time.
Secret Santa Gift?
I was sent this as a secret Santa, there was no note, instructions or explanation. Simply two plastic white shapes, they hardly weigh anything at all, and when I google ‘Spyn’, nothing relevant comes up. Any ideas??
White Elephant Gift. What Does It Mean
Yes indeed this was someone’s gift they seeded for our $100 minimum white elephant.
Is it cooked? Because crabs are expensive. And you need to eat a lot of them to feel full. 😁 But this is just gross!
$100 minimum????? Are thru crazy or just stupid? Not everybody has $100 to spend on another employee for a gift.
Everyone's Secret Santa Is Sending Them Nice Things, And Mine Is Trying To Unalive Me
If you're going to edit the title, mark that you edited it bp. The title says kㅤill.
Seriously, just get over it already. Or find a different site. Nothing we say is going to change the censor. All the whining gets old.
Load More Replies...I can see my family buying me this....I sleep through most alarm clocks!
Had Secret Santa At School, I Got This! And Guess What, It Contains Traces Of Peanuts, Something I’m Very Allergic To
to be fair all chocolate made in shared facilities state that they may contain traces. something I dealt with a lot as someone else allergic to peanuts
We Did Secret Santa In The Office Today. As The Only Black Guy In The Company, I Am Not Sure How To React To Receiving This Stress Banana
But, we'll need a real banana first to make sure it's to scale.
Load More Replies...Secret Santa At School, $10 Minimum + I Specifically Asked For No Candy
The guy was on vacation, so he made his friend give me the “gift”, so the guy who got the person I got for the gift trade gave me his gift bc he‘s on vacation.
(I’m going to give them names, just to help.) Andy was supposed to get a secret santa gift for Barnie. David was supposed to get a secret santa gift for Andy. However, Andy was on holiday on gift sharing day, so Andy asked his friend Charlie to pass Barnie the gift. Sadly, Barnie received sweets from Andy via Charlie. Barnie didn’t want sweets, so David offered Barnie the option to trade the sweets they’d received from Andy for what David had bought Andy. Andy gets his sweets back.
Load More Replies...What I Got For Secret Santa
Ps: budget was 500, pps: it's plastic.
I actually like this. I'm really clumsy and I'm tired of replacing my mugs. The plastic one will probably bounce 😂
She Just Needs A Bit Of Love
Well, judging from OP's picture, maybe the giver thought she would like it.
Plush doll from the movie K-Pop Demon Hunters. My niece went as this character for Halloween. It's popular with kids.
Load More Replies...This Is Game I Was Gifted Roughly 8 Years That I Just Decided To Open Back Up
It seems like there's nothing but filler cardboard in the box. How rude!
Load More Replies...Per a survey in December (it could have been on BP), 70-80% of office workers *hate* the Secret Santa game. I think the organizers get more out of it than the rest of the office combined.
Load More Replies...And this is what you get with mandatory office Secret Santa that not everyone would like to participate, but had to
Many of them looked like spite gifts because the players were forced to play.
Load More Replies...Last year's Christmas secret santa thing, we had a $50 minimum. I specifically asked no one gets me pens or writing utensils. Dude gave me a candle and 100 black Bic pens.
I think some of these are getting Secret Santa and White Elephant mixed up. Secret Santa is supposed to consist of legitimate gifts. White Elephant is NOT. Those are supposed to be fun, silly gag gifts that aren't really gifts at all. But everyone has to be in on the joke. Then it's a LOT of fun.
I think people are getting Secret Santa and White Elephant confused. In the first one, you're supposed to get an actual gift. IN the second one, you're supposed to get a gag gift. The White Elephant ones are supposed to be just for laughs.
I think these events are ok IF: it's optional not mandatory, the parameters are made clear (specify joke gifts or nice gifts, any applicable dollar limits etc) and the gifts are not mean-spirited.
Most of this list is just awful. I couldn’t even finish it. This is exactly why I don't participate in Secret Santa, White Elephant etc. at all. Overall, they’re just mean and hurt people’s feelings or make them feel like bad. Unless you have a really great group of people who know how to play nice and follow the rules, IMO, they’re a bad idea.
Per a survey in December (it could have been on BP), 70-80% of office workers *hate* the Secret Santa game. I think the organizers get more out of it than the rest of the office combined.
Load More Replies...And this is what you get with mandatory office Secret Santa that not everyone would like to participate, but had to
Many of them looked like spite gifts because the players were forced to play.
Load More Replies...Last year's Christmas secret santa thing, we had a $50 minimum. I specifically asked no one gets me pens or writing utensils. Dude gave me a candle and 100 black Bic pens.
I think some of these are getting Secret Santa and White Elephant mixed up. Secret Santa is supposed to consist of legitimate gifts. White Elephant is NOT. Those are supposed to be fun, silly gag gifts that aren't really gifts at all. But everyone has to be in on the joke. Then it's a LOT of fun.
I think people are getting Secret Santa and White Elephant confused. In the first one, you're supposed to get an actual gift. IN the second one, you're supposed to get a gag gift. The White Elephant ones are supposed to be just for laughs.
I think these events are ok IF: it's optional not mandatory, the parameters are made clear (specify joke gifts or nice gifts, any applicable dollar limits etc) and the gifts are not mean-spirited.
Most of this list is just awful. I couldn’t even finish it. This is exactly why I don't participate in Secret Santa, White Elephant etc. at all. Overall, they’re just mean and hurt people’s feelings or make them feel like bad. Unless you have a really great group of people who know how to play nice and follow the rules, IMO, they’re a bad idea.
