‘What I Asked For Vs. What I Got’, Tattoo Edition: 40 Times Tattoo Artists Outdid Themselves
Getting a tattoo can be risky business. And not just because you might regret a tattoo you got at 18 when you're 35. If you want a tattoo that won't cause you shame for the rest of your life, there's a lot of research, planning, and time involved.
Although it can be fun to laugh and shame badly done tattoos, this time we're bringing the focus to the opposite. We scoured the popular r/TattooDesigns community for the best "What I asked for vs. what I got" moments where folks came in with doodles looking like they were done by a 5-year-old and left with breathtakingly intricate ink on their skin.
This post may include affiliate links.
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For & What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
It's not everyday you see such beautifully executed tattoos. Some of these might even provoke some jealousy if you feel you own tattoos are not up to par. Recently, even Miley Cyrus admitted having tattoo regret. 80% of the tattoos currently on her body are a "mistake", she said.
None of the tattoos on this list would probably qualify. Still, one the most common reasons for tattoo regrets is having them done out of impulsivity. I myself have come across some silly goose tattoos that I thought of getting, especially after scrolling through these adorable frog tattoos and these cool dinosaurs.
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got!
Tattoo Recreation Of My Favorite Sibling Photo
But even if you've had an idea for a tattoo brewing in your mind for a long time, how do you tell an artist exactly what you want? This is a problem that plagues many first-time tattoo owners. As evident from this list, talented artists can make even the goofiest draft sketches work, but what are the ways to best convey your vision to the artist?
You can think of a tattoo shop as a hair salon in this regard: bring references. Experts at Tattoo Do recommend emailing, DMing, or bringing physical copies of examples, ideas, or exact elements you'd like to be included in your tattoo. Be careful of artist ethics, though: don't expect your tattoo artist to rip off other artists. So, tattoos by other professionals should only be a reference point to explain the style or aesthetic you want.
What I Asked For; What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Sent The Artist vs. What He Created
This might sound silly, but it's important to be assertive and tell your artist exactly what you want. Remember that song by The Smiths? "Shyness is nice, and shyness can stop you / From doing all the things in life that you'd like to." If you don't speak up when your artists misinterprets your exact idea or don't like their vision, you'll only have yourself to blame later. It's okay to say "No" respectfully.
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
However, don't micromanage too much. "Changing sizes a million times, moving the stencil ¼" several times around your body, freaking out about insignificant details just to stall or make sure, just one more time, that it'll be perfect... all of this can be so stressful for your artist," the artists at Tattoo Do say.
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
It's important to remember that a tattoo artist (at least one with a good reputation) is a professional. So, trust their words when they say that something in your vision won't work. "They're not trying to rain on your parade if they tell you a certain tattoo won't work in a certain place," the experts at Mystic Owl Tattoo say. "They want to give you the design you envision while ensuring it will look great for years to come."
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
Both are peak tier. I love both. I would legitimately frame the left-hand drawing and put it on my wall. It's adorable.
What I Asked For V What I Got:
How do you find an artist that's reliable and professional? Licensed freelance artist Kevin 'Jack' Allaire has some tips. He encourages people to differentiate between 'tracers' and 'artists'. "If you look through a portfolio and see a lot of the same simple, small pieces you would find on the wall, the person is most likely a tracer and not an artist," he claims. "Variety and difficulty of the pieces in the portfolio truly speaks for itself."
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got: Medusa
The best ways to find a true artist are:
- Look through their portfolio;
- Check the reviews. A tattoo is a permanent piece of art on someone's body, people don't lie about that kind of stuff.
- Price equals quality. An average tattoo might cost $72 or $100, but better artists cost two or three times that, according to Allaire.
- Look at the artist's work closely: the lines, the skin after tattooing, the detailing in the tattoos.
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
The Idea vs. The Final Tattoo!
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What about your tattoos, Pandas? Do you have any amazing ink you'd like to share with us here? Better yet, show us your own "Expectations vs. reality" tattoos! And if you're craving some badly done tattoos after seeing these masterpieces, don't hesitate and head over here and here!
What I Asked For - What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For / What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
For a second, I thought the request image had a fried egg instead of a backlit moon.
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
one of the ophelias... the more well-known is by John Everett Millaisi, but this one is by Friedrich Wilhelm Theodor.
What I Asked vs. What I Got
What I Ask vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got -Finished Version-
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
From OP on Reddit: "I spent a lot of my childhood outside and wanted to get something nature related as I still love anything outdoors and green. And after the loss of one of my parents last year I wanted something related to them as well - hence the bandaids and initials, as they always took care of me and protected me. So you could think of it as things that heal my heart and soul, as sentimental as it may sound. :)"
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Drew vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got Pt2
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
My turn to play the clever one! This is by Artemisia Gentileschi. Caravaggio painted the same subject but his Judith was less full on. Both are stunning paintings.
Mom & Dad Inspired, What I Asked For vs. What I Got. Branly @ Tattoo House Panama City, Pa
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
That's so cool! But I've heard that vibrantly-colored tattoos can fade fairly quickly even if well-cared-for :(
What I Asked For vs. What I Got (Today)
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
From OP on Reddit: "While the artist did a rough sketch during the consultation, he said if it was scaled to match the rest of the tattoo, the deer guy would lose a bit of definition. So he suggested the antlers as the lower border. Needless to say, I loved the idea and we ran with it. Couldn't be happier with how it turned out. I'll probably get deer guy wearing a kimono as a separate piece later down the road cause I like him so much."
My Most Recent Tat ( Concept vs. What I Got)
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
This is another where I REALLY want to know what the source idea came from.
Reference vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Wanted vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
Very Happy With How This Turned Out!
What I Asked For And What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
I had a Furby. I'd never trust that this thing wouldn't come alive, pop off of my skin, and go on a rampage. XD
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Wanted vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
OP on Reddit says: "pic of my childhood cat, subbed out my sister’s car for my 2013 vw beetle"
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got (By David Robinson / Rainbow Demon Tattoo, Denver Co)
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
First Tattoo, What I Expected vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got 🥹
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For, What I Got
I'm not sure about this one. I mean....the result is well executed, with nice linework and shading. But the inspo pic looks kinda sassy and the result looks like a man-child trying to look tough.
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
What I Asked For vs. What I Got
This is much better than tattoo fails. Great artwork & people happy with the results make a winning combo.
Wow, some of these are beautiful, thank you for sharing them! There are some really gifted artists out there.
This entire thread makes me lust for the money to get the last eight I have planned done.
My daughter and son-in-law are both tattoo artists, so I always get a discount 😊
Load More Replies...I have always joked that there is no artistic connection between my brain and my hands. I can have great ideas and absolutely no way of creating them. Seeing some of the sketched ideas, I am no longer fretting about my tattoo ideas!
Amazing. I've never, NEVER thought about a tattoo, but these show amazing tattoo artists DO exist and these tats are very cool
This is much better than tattoo fails. Great artwork & people happy with the results make a winning combo.
Wow, some of these are beautiful, thank you for sharing them! There are some really gifted artists out there.
This entire thread makes me lust for the money to get the last eight I have planned done.
My daughter and son-in-law are both tattoo artists, so I always get a discount 😊
Load More Replies...I have always joked that there is no artistic connection between my brain and my hands. I can have great ideas and absolutely no way of creating them. Seeing some of the sketched ideas, I am no longer fretting about my tattoo ideas!
Amazing. I've never, NEVER thought about a tattoo, but these show amazing tattoo artists DO exist and these tats are very cool
