ADVERTISEMENT

Getting a tattoo can be risky business. And not just because you might regret a tattoo you got at 18 when you're 35. If you want a tattoo that won't cause you shame for the rest of your life, there's a lot of research, planning, and time involved.

Although it can be fun to laugh and shame badly done tattoos, this time we're bringing the focus to the opposite. We scoured the popular r/TattooDesigns community for the best "What I asked for vs. what I got" moments where folks came in with doodles looking like they were done by a 5-year-old and left with breathtakingly intricate ink on their skin.

#1

What I Asked For vs. What I Got

Small black dog lying on pink blanket next to a colorful abstract dog tattoo showing tattoo expectations vs reality.

mastafreud Report

Miriam Insidecor
Community Member
1 year ago

This is nice.

View more comments
RELATED:
    #2

    What I Asked For & What I Got

    Side-by-side image of a dog and its tattoo showing tattoo expectations vs reality with detailed pet portrait and flowers.

    gilbert322 Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Soo cute!

    View more comments
    #3

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations versus reality showing a simple drawing next to a detailed otter cooking tattoo on forearm.

    Chance-Character5408 Report

    Brazen
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    At first glance, I thought the drawing was of a pig cooking bacon. Oh boy.

    View more comments
    #4

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a cat portrait tattoo wearing a red Hawaiian shirt on a person's upper arm.

    Ecstatic-Crow-2502 Report

    Lulabelle
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Meowgnum P.I?

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #5

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got!

    Tattoo expectations versus reality showing a colorful Egyptian dog design tattoo drawn versus the final detailed ink on forearm.

    miserySeason Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Dude no way. Gorgeous.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #6

    Tattoo Recreation Of My Favorite Sibling Photo

    Photo of three children by a pond compared to a tattoo attempting to recreate the scene, illustrating tattoo expectations vs reality.

    Inner-Earth4674 Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Aw

    View more comments
    #7

    What I Asked For; What I Got

    Tattoo expectations versus reality showing a child's rabbit drawing compared to a detailed realistic rabbit tattoo on the arm.

    Upbeat-Law-4115 Report

    LakotaWolf (she/her)
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    Oh, this is DEFINITELY a Monty Python reference XD

    View more comments
    #8

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Woman kneeling and hugging her dog on the left, and a minimalist tattoo of the same scene on the right, showing tattoo expectations vs reality.

    duprect Report

    Roni Stone
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    Simple line drawing can say so much.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #9

    What I Sent The Artist vs. What He Created

    Tattoo expectations versus reality showing a detailed design sketch next to the actual geometric and classical style tattoo.

    Goinsey Report

    Nina
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    They really deserve the classification 'artist' indeed

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #10

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a detailed stencil design compared to a distorted final tattoo on skin.

    crownroyalvic Report

    Luke Branwen
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Meteora. What an AMAZING album.

    View more comments
    #11

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side image showing a deer with mushroom antlers and a colorful tattoo of the same design on a person's arm, illustrating tattoo expectations vs reality.

    PhillyGoldenTeacher Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Love how the deers face turned out

    View more comments
    #12

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality on legs showing simple sketches versus detailed dragon tattoos.

    senor_apple_sauce Report

    StrangeOne
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Excellent use of placement and motion.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #13

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got - Sol Invictus

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a hand-drawn sun face design and a vibrant, detailed sun tattoo on an arm.

    SockofBadKarma Report

    Lyop
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Wow!

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #14

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Cat photo next to a simple tattoo outline of the same pose, illustrating tattoo expectations vs reality humor.

    OneL_TwoTs Report

    eloop
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    even captured the stretched out toes 😊

    View more comments
    #15

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Leg tattoos showing tattoo expectations versus reality with wizard and skeleton designs in black ink on legs.

    Enteito Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    😃

    View more comments

    Never miss a story that brings joy to the world. Add us on Google

    #16

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Real fox curled on leaves beside a tattoo of the same fox on a forearm showing tattoo expectations vs reality.

    TheOnlyMachoNacho Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    🥰🥰

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #17

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a simple drawing next to a detailed Star Trek-themed tattoo with cats.

    sparklerfish Report

    LakotaWolf (she/her)
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    Both are peak tier. I love both. I would legitimately frame the left-hand drawing and put it on my wall. It's adorable.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #18

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side tattoo expectations vs reality showing an outlined octopus vs a detailed colorful octopus tattoo on a leg.

    yungmevo Report

    DaisyGirl
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Blue ringed octopus

    View more comments
    #19

    What I Asked For V What I Got:

    Tablet displaying dinosaur tattoo design next to a colorful tattoo on a leg showing expectations vs reality.

    fadetoblack47 Report

    Crystalwitch60
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Oh wow that’s almost identical x

    View more comments
    #20

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got: Medusa

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing detailed Medusa head design compared to less defined snake-haired tattoo on arm.

    angrygoosequeen Report

    Binny Tutera
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    I had to go to the link- It is absolutely beautiful.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #21

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations and reality featuring a shinobi theme with detailed mask and character design.

    CardiologistEqual336 Report

    Robert Beveridge
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    That is exquisite.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #22

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a sketch of planets and a wolf compared to a colorful detailed outer space tattoo on arm.

    ainyy Report

    Delicate Fcuking Flower
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    This looks like a freaking sticker, I am gagged

    View more comments
    #23

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Arm tattoos showing detailed design vs faded and distorted ink, illustrating tattoo expectations vs reality example.

    stefisith Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    They delivered 🫡

    View more comments
    #24

    The Idea vs. The Final Tattoo!

    Side-by-side comparison of a hand-drawn sketch and a detailed gothic raven tattoo showing tattoo expectations vs reality.

    nataliemitchxo Report

    Delicate Fcuking Flower
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Lovely 🖤🥀

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #25

    What I Asked For - What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing colorful lightning tattoos on ankles with different shapes and colors.

    FuggityWild Report

    Ren Karlej
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Colours are amazing

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #26

    What I Asked For And What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations vs reality showing a simple sketch and a detailed raccoon tattoo on a calf.

    jarzbent Report

    Sarah K
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Adorable ❤️

    #27

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Woman's arm showing tattoo expectations as a simple cartoon and reality as a detailed, dark artistic design.

    UpsetCheetah22 Report

    LakotaWolf (she/her)
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    Wonder if it's meant to represent the Black Rabbit Of Inlé?

    View more comments
    #28

    What I Asked For, vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a detailed bird design sketch compared to a vibrant chest tattoo version.

    klierlykilling Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Beautiful

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #29

    What I Asked For / What I Got

    Black and gray tattoo showing a frog sitting on a skull, compared to the original pencil sketch, tattoo expectations vs reality.

    Lendenwirblel Report

    Miguel M.
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Artist name, please.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #30

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side images showing tattoo expectations versus reality with space-themed lightning bolt designs on forearms.

    mauralarshall Report

    Amused panda
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    For a second, I thought the request image had a fried egg instead of a backlit moon.

    View more comments
    #31

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Painting of woman floating in water versus tattoo interpretation, illustrating tattoo expectations vs reality with notable differences.

    MmMmNope_ Report

    Ciera Corca
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    one of the ophelias... the more well-known is by John Everett Millaisi, but this one is by Friedrich Wilhelm Theodor.

    View more comments
    #32

    What I Asked vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a simple cherry design turned into animal faces tattoo on arm.

    ali-sie Report

    eloop
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    so cute

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #33

    What I Ask vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a hand-drawn chicken-dinosaur design and a realistic tattoo version on skin.

    TheAeoloz Report

    CF
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    I wish the photo was better- I suspect the tattoo is even better than represented here

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #34

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got -Finished Version-

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a rough butterfly sketch above and a detailed butterfly tattoo with flowers below on chest.

    onyxia_x Report

    Mreoww
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    What about the moons

    View more comments
    #35

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side image showing tattoo expectations as a sketch and tattoo reality as a colorful leaf and bandage design on skin.

    Carolineas Report

    LakotaWolf (she/her)
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    From OP on Reddit: "I spent a lot of my childhood outside and wanted to get something nature related as I still love anything outdoors and green. And after the loss of one of my parents last year I wanted something related to them as well - hence the bandaids and initials, as they always took care of me and protected me. So you could think of it as things that heal my heart and soul, as sentimental as it may sound. :)"

    #36

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations vs reality showing a simple drawing and a colorful octopus tattoo on a leg.

    Photogroxii Report

    Michelle
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    The colours should pop more. Doesn't look like it's in water.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #37

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing simple chalk drawing and detailed black ink tattoo of a pyramid character.

    ereek01 Report

    Sanguina
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Bill Cypher.

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #38

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got:

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a hand-drawn sketch and the final tattoo on a person's arm.

    Thamijs Report

    Michelle
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Noise pollution

    #39

    What I Drew vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a color space-themed hexagon design sketch and a finished tattoo on arm.

    WolfiesGottaRoam Report

    Karen Startz Richardson
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Cool <3

    View more comments
    #40

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got Pt2

    Side-by-side comparison of a detailed tattoo design and its real-life back tattoo showing tattoo expectations vs reality.

    mkyuksu Report

    Robert Beveridge
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    jaw-drop.gif jaw-drop.gif

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #41

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Baroque painting comparison with tattoo showing expectations vs reality of detailed artwork interpretation.

    TheRealLanAmore Report

    Grace Note
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    My turn to play the clever one! This is by Artemisia Gentileschi. Caravaggio painted the same subject but his Judith was less full on. Both are stunning paintings.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #42

    Mom & Dad Inspired, What I Asked For vs. What I Got. Branly @ Tattoo House Panama City, Pa

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality showing handwritten note and a humorous tattoo with flowers and fish.

    Godzira-r32 Report

    #43

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality shown by a colorful 3D pie chart tattoo with uneven sections on a person's arm.

    farsonite Report

    LakotaWolf (she/her)
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    That's so cool! But I've heard that vibrantly-colored tattoos can fade fairly quickly even if well-cared-for :(

    #44

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got (Today)

    Side-by-side images of tiger tattoos combining geometric and realistic styles showing tattoo expectations vs reality.

    Goodtime_101 Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #45

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side arm photos showing a rough tattoo sketch versus a detailed tattoo design illustrating tattoo expectations vs reality.

    andrewlearnstocook Report

    Skogsrået
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    I always upvote Studio Ghibli. ❤️

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #46

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a detailed Japanese landscape design compared to a simple sketch.

    Kedzeralisha Report

    LakotaWolf (she/her)
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    From OP on Reddit: "While the artist did a rough sketch during the consultation, he said if it was scaled to match the rest of the tattoo, the deer guy would lose a bit of definition. So he suggested the antlers as the lower border. Needless to say, I loved the idea and we ran with it. Couldn't be happier with how it turned out. I'll probably get deer guy wearing a kimono as a separate piece later down the road cause I like him so much."

    View more comments
    #47

    My Most Recent Tat ( Concept vs. What I Got)

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality showing a person wearing a crown with blood details.

    EtherealV0id Report

    #48

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a detailed horse and rider design compared to a less accurate tattoo on an arm.

    esquilacs Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #49

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectation sketch and final reality of a knight stabbing another knight on forearm.

    4Jhin_Khada4 Report

    Robert Beveridge
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    This is another where I REALLY want to know what the source idea came from.

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #50

    Reference vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side tattoos showing the difference in tattoo expectations vs reality on forearms.

    ericliu555 Report

    #51

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a frog wizard design and a blurred, distorted tattoo version on skin.

    DrEwes Report

    #52

    What I Wanted vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a cat in a clown costume with a party hat next to its tattoo version.

    LadyAzarith Report

    Tiffany sanders
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Cats, cats, in party hats

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #53

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Cartoon-inspired tattoo showing a distorted version of the original design illustrating tattoo expectations vs reality.

    winternightborne Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #54

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing colorful tree and house design compared to the actual tattoo outcome on skin.

    jb4realz Report

    jo hanson
    Community Member
    3 months ago

    Clarice Cliffe?

    #55

    Very Happy With How This Turned Out!

    Side-by-side comparison of a wolf tattoo showing expectations versus reality with different artistic styles and details.

    Arcaev_NL Report

    #56

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality showing a simple design and a detailed dragon tattoo on a torso.

    xJayseph Report

    Dorota A
    Community Member
    11 months ago

    snake is awesome too

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #57

    What I Asked For And What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality showing a dragon design with muscular arm and flames on skin.

    Thrillh0use43 Report

    Juls
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Trogdor!

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #58

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of a sword tattoo showing expectations versus reality on a forearm.

    Ouen132 Report

    #59

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a detailed angel design requested and a less precise tattoo result on skin.

    pinkpotato6969 Report

    #60

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a colorful hand-drawn design and a detailed tattoo version on an arm.

    octillery Report

    LakotaWolf (she/her)
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    I had a Furby. I'd never trust that this thing wouldn't come alive, pop off of my skin, and go on a rampage. XD

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #61

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing detailed fantasy character portraits compared to colorful but different tattoo design.

    CptDipStick Report

    Owen
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    What film is this character from?

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #62

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations and reality showing different frog-themed tattoo designs on skin.

    _cazb Report

    #63

    What I Wanted vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality showing a spider and web design on two different body parts.

    gompychomperr Report

    #64

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of detailed tattoo expectation artwork and a distorted tattoo reality on upper arm.

    memedigger9 Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #65

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Black cat walking on a car hood vs tattoo design of a cat on a car showing tattoo expectations vs reality.

    saltyspitooned Report

    LakotaWolf (she/her)
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    OP on Reddit says: "pic of my childhood cat, subbed out my sister’s car for my 2013 vw beetle"

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #66

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations versus reality showing detailed black panther designs compared to a rough, distorted chest tattoo version.

    Live-Progress-195 Report

    #67

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a simple drawing compared to a detailed but different tattoo on skin.

    kakbald Report

    Luke Branwen
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    What now?

    View more comments
    #68

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality showing different artistic styles on forearm designs.

    Hotelier101 Report

    Luke Branwen
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Kyoshi! That looks really cool

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #69

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Forearm tattoo showing expectations with sketches and reality of detailed skull and geometric pattern design.

    Artsonist Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #70

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a detailed dragon illustration compared to a colorful but different dragon tattoo on arm.

    deathtech Report

    #71

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got (By David Robinson / Rainbow Demon Tattoo, Denver Co)

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality on lower legs featuring colorful and abstract designs.

    raileyhae46 Report

    #72

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Hand showing a spiked mace tattoo design sketch versus a colorful finished tattoo with floral and chain details on the arm.

    Nuclear_Mistress Report

    Robert Beveridge
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    Now THAT'S a morningstar!

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #73

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side tattoo comparison showing expectations versus reality of a skull and candle design with the text XIII THE D***H.

    AltForBeingHighRN Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #74

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectation vs reality showing detailed frog warrior design vs a distorted frog tattoo on forearm.

    kukikater Report

    #75

    First Tattoo, What I Expected vs. What I Got

    Delicate floral tattoo expectation on shoulder versus bolder reality with thicker lines and less detail close-up.

    snoowieboo01 Report

    Dawn Thomas-Cameron
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    I actually don’t like this

    #76

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got 🥹

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a detailed black and white design next to a colorful, less accurate tattoo version.

    kadangit Report

    jo hanson
    Community Member
    3 months ago

    The hook is a crochet hook it's not a comment on anyone. Changing the wording spoils the card.

    View more comments
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #77

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a outlined design on leg and the final colorful dragon tattoo on forearm.

    GulakForPrez Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #78

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a detailed whirlpool design on paper and a pixelated tattoo on skin.

    ThatAlexI Report

    Ren Karlej
    Community Member
    1 year ago

    That's cute

    #79

    What I Asked For, What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations vs reality showing knight tattoos with different designs and details.

    mmmmdumplings Report

    Mother of Giants
    Community Member
    Premium
    1 year ago

    I'm not sure about this one. I mean....the result is well executed, with nice linework and shading. But the inspo pic looks kinda sassy and the result looks like a man-child trying to look tough.

    #80

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Tattoo expectations vs reality showing a 20-sided d*e with leaves and flowers, design versus actual tattoo result.

    ruebenreleeshahn Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #81

    What I Asked vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality showing a horned figure holding a bottle and smoking.

    lastdyingstar Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #82

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side comparison of tattoo expectations versus reality showing tiger and dragon ink designs on a person's back.

    rednailsgreensnakes Report

    #83

    What I Asked For vs. What I Got

    Side-by-side image showing tattoo expectations vs reality of a mermaid design on a person's arm.

    Mobile-Abalone1013 Report