40 Times Hollywood Miscast So Badly, They Almost Tanked The Movie
Interview With ExpertGood actors don’t just stumble into roles that are perfect for them. It’s a very complex process that involves lots of auditions as casting directors look for the best matches between story characters and actors, both veteran and amateur alike.
However, everybody makes mistakes from time to time. Things don’t always work out the way everyone hoped they would. Today, we’re featuring some examples of the biggest mismatches in Hollywood, as shared by self-proclaimed ‘film snobs’ in one online thread. Scroll down for their opinions about possibly the ‘worst’ casting choices ever.
Bored Panda wanted to learn more about the challenges that casting directors face, so we got in touch with entertainment expert Mike Sington, Hollywood's Ultimate Insider. He was kind enough to shine a light on the topic for us. You'll find our full interview with him as you read on!
This post may include affiliate links.
Steven Seagal as... anything, I think.
He's great at playing Steven Seagal. Actually that's the only thing he can do. If you know of a single movie starring Steven Seagal where he is not just Steven Seagal, please tell me.
Corridor crew did an episode on Steven Seagal and God it's hilarious
Load More Replies...His first few movies, through Under Siege, we good. After? Terrible. And his whole adopting Russia thing
Yeah, but that was like the first film I saw with him. And I was a kid, so my standards were not so high then 🙃
Load More Replies...Only exceeded by Jared Leto as terrible choice for anything and worse over time.
I liked him in that movie where he gets sucked out of the plane in the first 5 minutes LOL
His first few movies actually had plots and weren't too bad. But starting with "On Deadly Ground" they became ridiculous. My dad enjoyed them for the violence (he was a pacifist in real life - came home from WW II with a different perspective) but could never remember the titles. He'd say, "I want to watch the one where he's in a coma." I'd say, "Hard to Kill, Dad." Or "That one where he's looking for Richie." (Out for Justice) Or, "That one where he breaks the guy's back over his knee." (Marked for Death). I miss my dad. But Steven Seagal can go take a long walk off a short pier.
Will Smith in anything cause he's gonna over act and over do it. Most fake laugh in hollywood
According to Statista, as of January 2025, the highest-grossing leading actor in the North American movie market (United States and Canada) is Samuel L. Jackson. Films featuring him as a protagonist have amassed a jaw-dropping $5.85 billion.
Also, massively popular and highly successful actors in the North American movie market are Robert Downey Jr. ($5.47 billion) and Chris Pratt ($5.35 billion). Next up are Scarlett Johansson ($5.34 billion) and Tom Hanks ($5.17 billion).
John Wayne as ghengis khan.
Hollywood's still doing this BS and now it'll likely increase again under our new "administration". The only thing we can do is not pay to see it, that's all they'll pay attention to.
What you miss is - if you insist only xx people can play xx roles, then you are limiting those people to ONLY play those roles. If the role is "a gay Black female who plays the drums", and you only consider "gay Black female actresses who play the drums" - how many jobs are there likely to be that require "a gay Black female who plays the drums"? You are typecasting.
Load More Replies...I literally just mentioned this in my Emma Stone "Aloha" comment. Yellow face is a thing. The only thing worse was Mickey Rooney as a Japanese man.
This movie was made, and the only thing that happened was everybody involved got cancer and died.
How about Wiiliam Shatner (soon after the end of 'Star Trek: TOS') as Alexander the Great - still rocking Kirk's hair style.
He appeared in "Axexander the Great" in 1963, several years before before the start of Star Trek: TOS.
Load More Replies...Never seen it, and he was okay in "The Quiet Man" but I'm imaging him playing Ghengis Khan as Rooster Cogburn.
Tom Cruise playing the 6'5" mountain of muscle Jack Reacher. Lost my s*it over that decision.
And so much more believable and better to look at!!
Load More Replies...He’s good in Mission Impossible and Jerry Maguire but anything else he comes across as a generic action man who always seems the same person.
Load More Replies...YES of course. Totally agree. I've read most of the Jack Reacher books, and Tom Cruise just doesn't fit the part AT ALL.
Was he on a box and everyone else in a trench, or did they use forced-perspective camera tricks to make him seem taller?
He got the part as he financed the films. The series is much more believable. Roll on series 3
Well, he nailed it as much as E.T. nailed playing a character that can make bikes fly through the air. The "real" Jack Reacher probably wouldn't have lived through the first book if it wasn't purely fictional, but I wouldn't be able to take you seriously if you told me you thought Cruise payed abetter Reacher than Alan Ritchson.
Load More Replies...After reading the books, this was a huge disappointment. Reacher is described A LOT as being 6'5" in the books.
We asked Sington about the biggest challenges that casting directors face. According to him, one of the most significant ones is finding actors who embody the specific nuances of a character as envisioned by the writers and director.
"This goes beyond simply matching physical descriptions; it requires identifying actors who can authentically portray the character's emotional depth, motivations, and inner world," the entertainment expert explained to Bored Panda.
"This can be particularly difficult when dealing with complex or multifaceted characters, or when the role requires a very specific skill set, such as a particular accent, physical ability, or musical talent. Balancing the director's vision with the available talent pool and the actors' interpretations of the role is a constant negotiation."
He added that practical constraints "often complicate" the entire casting process. There are lots of factors to keep in mind. "Budget limitations can restrict the ability to hire well-known or in-demand actors, forcing casting directors to search for lesser-known talent who still possess the necessary qualities," Sington said.
Emma Stone as a half native-Hawaiian, half Japanese woman in "Aloha".
No I'm not kidding, they actually did that.
WTAF? Never even heard of it but that's like when they cast John Wayne as Genghis Kahn in The Conqueror. That was a thing that happened too.
Yeah its already on this list. As a matter of fact its first on this list
Load More Replies...I remember a few years ago I played this guessing game when getting to know my college friends... At the time we knew little about each other so we had fun guessing which country each of us was from. When it was my turn. One said I was Turkish, Another guessed South American, narrowed to Columbian, He specifically said I looked like a Rebel/Dictator/Druglord... I would have been pissed... IF HE WAS NOT SO RIGHT I mean I did have a beard and a hoodie on... But I could see a general theme... So to "help" them I showed them what my brother, sister and cousin looked like. My sister had snow white levels of clear skin with ebony hair. My brother was a tiny shade darker than her but with blond hair. My cousin looked JUST like my brother but with a much darker complexion and hair! Think a shade between an average black american and an average Indian! They were completely discombobulated! I hope you can all see the point i am making!
If it based on a real person, alive or a historical figure with a known depiction. Then get the closest looking and best acting fit... If it is a NEW char who cares! Her Japanese mom was from German descent! Her native Hawaiian side had a 1800 sailor in there somewhere... Just don't pull s**t like casting Scarlet J as Motoko Kusanagi... The least you can do is make her look like the actual Japanese char... Or the Identity politics stunt of Netflix's black Cleopatra which was insulting to everyone involved... Unless they somehow confused one of the Nubian dynasties with the Ptolemaic dynasty... But that is a 500 year miss...
Load More Replies...She can't be born to a white parent? That would still make her a native and Japanese. What if her mother is Hawaiian and Japanese and her father is white?
Exactly. Half native Hawaiian, half Japanese, and half white. I think you've solved it.
Load More Replies...The character was a quarter Hawaiian, a quarter Japanese and half Swedish. They either should have removed the Japanese part and named her something else, or cast someone different.
Thanks for the accuracy about the character's make believe ancestry, as that would make the physical appearance possible. It would still be more believable with a different complexion, though.
Load More Replies...Probably cast by the same jackass who actually dared to say Julia Roberts should play Harriet Tubman.
I'm not a film snob but Jared Leto as the joker stands out as a WTF? Choice.
You cant just put in Leto between Jack Nicholson and Health Ledger. Its bad for business baby!
Load More Replies...I don't think he was necessarily a bad choice. It's just that the choices made for his performance, whether they be by him, the director, or someone else, were terrible. He had like 45 seconds at the end of the Snyder Cut of Justice League where he actually showed he could be a good Joker. It was one of the few good things about that film.
I think any actor playing Joker would suffer, coming after Heath Ledger
I will always love Heath Ledger's portrayal of the Joker. But there is one actor who I think would make an amazing Joker. William Dafoe, his acting is methodical, funny, and over the top. He's been in more serious roles, but Boondock Saints gave him a great deal of room to stretch his theatrical muscles and he is a highlight from the movie.
Load More Replies...But do we know whether his protrayal is HIS fault or not? Directors don t always give actors the choice to act the role in the way they want it, there are actors who had to horribly overact in a movie because that was what the director wanted. So I do wonder, do we actually know if his portrayal was his vision or the director's vision? Because we know that Jared Leto can really act, didn't get an Oscar for Dallas Buyer's Club for no reason.
I think he's a d!ckhead in real life. Whatever they cast him in, I'm not going to enjoy it. Even in the Blade Runner sequel. You could just have had a normal businessman and it would have made more sense. It's like he was on something making that movie. (Although I like Urban Legend, but he was normal in that.)
I rather liked his portrayal. The character design, not so much. Still leagues better than 2 hours of Joaquin Phoenix smoking cigarettes shirtless and that forced laugh, and I will die on that hill.
Amber Heard in Aquaman. Or in anything, actually. Except the televised court cases she gave a stupendous performance there.
Giver her a break. She was upset. Her dog stepped on a bee.
Load More Replies...Yeah, she's awful in general. Guess that's why I never Heard of her....lol
100% agree she was SO bad in Aquaman. I said that before all the court stuff.
Ok...so if someone comes up to YOU, and starts punching you the face....and YOU, respond by hitting them back. In self defense. To protect yourself. Would it be fair for someone else to come along and say "They're both awful?" That's what you're doing. Negating the actions of the aggressor....the only person involved with a HISTORY of being abusive and generally terrible... and blaming the abused for not responding with a smile. If their roles were reversed, i find it very hard to believe that anyone would be saying "they're both awful"
Load More Replies..."Scheduling conflicts, particularly with actors who are already committed to other projects, can also present obstacles. Additionally, the need to create on-screen chemistry between actors playing key roles adds another layer of complexity. Casting directors must consider how different actors will interact and whether their energies and acting styles will complement each other, all while navigating tight deadlines and production pressures."
Bored Panda was also curious about some of the green flags that casting directors keep an eye out for, indicating a potentially great fit for a role. "An outstanding actor for a role embodies a compelling blend of talent and suitability. This includes a strong physical resemblance or the ability to convincingly transform into the character's appearance, a deep understanding of the character's motivations and inner life, and the technical skill to portray a wide range of emotions and behaviors authentically," Sington told us.
"Beyond mere mimicry, the actor brings a unique interpretation that enriches the role, making it feel both fresh and true to the source material. Ultimately, a perfect fit is when the audience forgets they are watching an actor and fully believes in the character they are portraying."
Denise Richards trying to play a nuclear physicist in The World Is Not Enough. She's pretty, but she's about as convincing of a nuclear physicist as a dog chewing on an atom shaped chew toy.
And very fine chesticles they are. If I've seen her in anything besides "Starship Troopers' (excellent book, mediocre movie) and "Wild Things" I can't remember. I think she was okay in both, but neither character was deeper than a puddle in a bottle cap.
Load More Replies...Okay, look at this photo - the men in the background are wearing ties and lab coats, and she's wearing short-shorts and a crop top. At least part of the reason she was unconvincing as a nuclear physicist was the fact that they costumed her as a sex symbol rather than a scientist who wanted to be taken seriously by her colleagues.
Yeah, well, even if a woman is a nuclear physicist, she HAS to be gorgeous, right? /s
Just actors and actresses... not women specifically... It makes sense. Ppl love seeing attractive ppl. Think about it... Indiana, Jurassic Park guy, the archaeologist from the mummy, tony stark, Angelina jolie being a hacker...
Load More Replies...Casting for women in in James Bond films were always attractive. Look at Dame Judi Dench as M.
Your first mistake is thinking you're going to get political correctness or realism from a Bond movie.
A Nuclear physicist can look like her. It was a Bond movie, don't see anything wrong with it
Unfortunately, those Bond girls were never casted to be convincing, just to be eye candy and sex toys for James.
Any movie where Mark Wahlberg needs to appear intelligent. It can’t be done without him constantly verbally reminding the audience how smart he is. Even then it doesn’t work.
-and the Funky Bunch. Don’t forget get them. It’s Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch.Mark Wahlberg, Scott Gee, Hector the Booty Inspector, DJ-T, and Ashey Ace.
Load More Replies...And that seriously AWFUL rendition of "Spencer"! I watched that show in the '80's with my mom " Spencer for Hire". Sorry only one Spencer and that was Robert Urich, and definitely only one man named Hawk... Avery Brooks!!!
His 'acting' in "the happening" was hilarious EDIT: just seen the happening post a few posts down the line
Beyoncé as Nala in the 2019 Lion King. She was literally cast for the star power associated with her name and nothing else. Granted that’s true for 100% of the cast, but at least some of them had a good moment or two. Beyoncé though? Nothing. She was awful in every single scene she was in.
Remember she was in one of the austin powers movies? She couldn't even manage that convincingly. But at the end of the day, casting choices aren't really going to do anything to affect the quality of Disney's live action remakes. Bad is bad.
Calling this CG-fest a live action remake is a farce
Load More Replies...Agreed. Except about the other cast members. RIP James Earl Jones, it felt like a last gift to the fans for him to do mufasa again.
In a nutshell, casting directors have one main job: matching actors to roles in movies, TV shows, and advertisements. They work with a lot of different people to get a sense of the demands and expectations the project team has, including the directors, producers, and sometimes even writers. They also thoroughly read the script and interact with actors, who could potentially fill the roles in the story, as well as their agents.
Screen Skills notes that casting directors must consider not just an actor’s appearance but also their acting ability. So, they need a good understanding of what good acting looks like; they need to have an appreciation for this art form. They also need to consider whether an actor is available to work on the project without clashing with their other projects, how much they’ll cost, and how much box office buzz they’re likely to create.
Meanwhile, different projects will have different challenges. For example, one group of producers might not offer much guidance at all, while another team can have very strict demands for the roles that need to be filled.
Wilson for the part of Wilson in the movie Cast Away. Spalding was a far better choice.
Wilson was the greatest inanimate actor. Onions were cutting when Wilson floated away.
I can't see "SPAALLLLDDIIINNNGGGG!" being nearly as heart wrenching
Kevin Costner in Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves is a famous one, he didn't do a British accent, so he's like an american robin hood for no reason.
Then watch Mel Brooks' "Robin Hood - Men in Tights". Cary Elwes as Robin Hood explicitly calls out Costner's accent.
"unlike some Robin Hoods i speak with an English accent"
Load More Replies...He pulled it off as a movie star, but not as an actor. Loved Alan Rickman, Morgan Freeman, Michael Wincott, and Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio.
I saw it at the cinema a really long time ago. It was a fabulous, fun, action/adventure movie - but even remotely true to . . . well, anything at all it was not. But extra points for Alan Rickman.
Load More Replies...Mel Brooks nailed him for this in Robin Hood Men in Tights. "Unlike some Robin Hoods, I can speak with an English accent"
Apparently he did try, but was asked to stop because it was so poor.
Load More Replies...Sorry maybe an unpopular opinion but I couldn't give a flying one, about his accent. It's a bloody entertaining film, which doesn't take itself too seriously as shown by Alan Rickman's OTT Sherriff of Nottingham, brilliant!
Glad someone said this.... I really enjoyed it.... I mean if people really want to pick it apart you could also add that they were speaking modern English and not ye olde English... But no, because he had no English accent, they gonna hate....but then again I enjoyed water world...
Load More Replies...Just watched this movie for the first time last week, which was amusing, since I'd already seen Robin Hood Men In Tights :p
Okay, but hear me out... Christian Slater's character Will Scarlett's quote "f**k me, he cleared it" in an English accent is hilarious. And is there really anything better than Friar Tuck, "This is grain, which any fool can eat, but for which the Lord intended a more divine means of consumption. Let us give praise to our maker and glory to his bounty by learning about.... BEER!"
I always say Prince of Thieves is a fantastic movie as long as you ignore Kevin Costner.
Kristen Stewart in Snow White and the Huntsman.
depressedCucumbers:
I just watched this movie like last week; her every emotion looked the same. The thing is, I like Kristen in the new Charlie's Angels (2019). I guess she just needs to find the right roles.
Poppybiscuit:
After I saw some of her darker, edgier, more indie roles, I realized she's amazing when she's given room to be subtle. Her energy is very reserved but it's powerful. Personal Shopper (2016) is a strange movie that's one of my recent favorites for example — highly recommend it.
Has anybody seen her in Love Lies Bleeding? Or Spencer? She's a really actor, the worst part of the snow white movie was Chris Hemsworth's abomination of a Scottish? Irish? Welsh? accent.
She's talked about this. She's bad when she's being purely sexualized. She's sick and tired of it, so she can never get out of her head and bring her A game when she's just cast to be pretty. But when she gets an actual role, especially when she can be her queer self, she's surprisingly good. Great even. And I think that's fair. A lifetime of being treated like that would make me bad at work too
Now they're making an even worse live action Snow White than this one. 🤦♀️
I liked her in that movie with Nicholas Hoult, where people can't have feelings (a bit like Equilibrium).
If you "just need to find the right rolls* then you are not a foorking actor. Obviously you not going to cast Dani De Vito as a Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, but I think you get the gist.
Talented casting directors can have successful and lucrative careers. Glassdoor shares that their pay range in the United States falls between $101k and $186k per year.
The base pay falls between $84k and $155k per year, supplemented by additional pay (bonuses, commissions, tips, profit sharing) worth between $17k and $31k. The median pay for American casting directors is $134k per year while the average is just under $112k annually.
At the time of writing, Glassdoor reports that the highest-paying companies for casting directors in the US include Netflix (earning $155k to $285k per year), Entertainment Partners ($137k to $250k per year), and the Walt Disney Company ($123k to $215k per year).
I waited almost thirty years for a "Morbius, The Living Vampire" film ...then they cast Leto. F**k. 😮💨😑🤮.
It's not always who you know, sometimes it's who you do...
Load More Replies...Only good role I've seen him in is it fight club and only because he gets his a*s beat
Load More Replies...Jared Leto has had been good in some movies. I think his ego has gotten in the way now.
George Clooney as Batman just because he was George Clooney. Worst batman imo in Batman and Robin.
It truly was the worst Batman movie I've ever seen. Arnold Schwarzenegger just chewing the scenery was the best part and it wasn't even good. WTH was Schumacher thinking?
Probably binge-read a bunch of silverage comics
Load More Replies...I got turned down for a loan because they said I had bat credit. At least I think that's what they said.
Load More Replies...You're condemning a humorous Batman but letting Batgirl slide? Arthur's niece was supposedly living and educated in England her whole life with a California American accent?!?!
Only thing to blame Clooney for is taking the role in a terrible film. He could have been a great Batman in a good movie.
I think he could have done a good job with the right writer and director, so I don't think he was necessarily miscast. Everything around him was a mistake.
I didn’t like George Clooney as Batman but the cheesy script and the neon everything were too much. All the villain actors were (I assume) told to cheese it up. Jim Carrey, Tommy Lee Jones, Arnold Schwarzenegger… none of them are as bad actors as they were in those films.
Load More Replies...ROBERT PATTINSON IS/WAS THE WEAKEST AND WORST BATMAN THERE EVER WAS…. That movie was incredibly bad and painful to watch. You could almost see him not knowing wtf to do or what to act like. 🙄🤦🏻♀️
Film issues aside, casting for Batman is difficult. You are casting for a multiple personality character. George Clooney made a fabulous Bruce Wayne not such a good Batman. Val Kilmer made a great Batman, but not a good Bruce Wayne. I genuinely gave up after that and I haven't seen a Batman movie again until Heath Ledger was Joker. And then I didn't care about who played Batman. And I haven't seen one since.
Maria Bello in The Mummy 3, replacing Rachel Weisz. It would’ve been better to say Evelyn died than to use Maria Bello.
Electrical-Turnip468:
The 'joke' about not being the same woman made me cringe. Should have waited for Rachel Weisz or yes, had Evelyn dead or just really busy with a library somewhere so it was a guy’s trip. I watched the movie at the cinema and haven’t been able to rewatch it.
Not killed her off. Just said she was on a dig somewhere else in the world and since it’s long before mobile phones were invented they couldn’t contact her. But look here’s her cousin or sister or colleague to join the adventure if they needed a female lead. They cast somebody else as Evelyn and changed her personality too. She came across as much less warm.
This was a massive let down for me. The chemistry was off and Brendan looked uncomfortable.
Killed the franchise. Weiss wasn't available and instead of re-writing a little bit to say Evelyn was off on a dig somewhere, they recast for the cash grab and cost everyone their jobs. This is why Production and Distribution shouldn't be allowed to influence projects over the director.
Rachel Weisz deserted the movie. There was no 'waiting' for anything. She said she was too young to play a woman with an adult child and refused the movie. I guess it's been spun differently over the years, but Rachel turned this movie down.
I thought she was pregnant at the time of shooting.
Load More Replies...See and this makes me mad because the Chinese setting and actors were all amazing, but I can’t watch this movie, Bello was just so miscast…
Money of course, the first was good the second not that good ans the third doesn't exist.
Load More Replies...In your opinion, what are some of the most poorly cast actors in movies, shows, and adverts that you’ve recently watched, dear Pandas?
On the flip side, to be a bit more positive, what actors do you think were perfectly cast by directors in projects?
Who are your favorite actors of all time? We’d love to hear from you! Share your thoughts in the comments.
Antonio Banderas as Armand in Interview With the Vampire. The character he played was supposed to be an immortal Slavic teenager. I grew up reading those books and when I was finally old enough to watch the movie, I was so, so disappointed.
Anne Rice was was against it as well but what she saw his performance she did say he wasn't too bad. She had originally imagined Rutger Hauer as Lestat but he was too old by the time the film was made.
Load More Replies...What the heck was Stephen Rea doing in that movie? I still don't get it.
He is Neil Jordan's favourite actor. They like working together.
Load More Replies...He can definitely play a vampire just not Armand. Wrong accent & wrong age
Jessie Eisenberg as Lex Luther
They cast the wrong berg , should have been Heisenberg
Edit: drinking and posting late is a recipe for bad grammar and spelling.
Too much work. That would require the two lead devs to rush writing the code for the "human actor mimicry" plugin 1.0.2 and installing extra motors,servos both in the upper cheek bone and the lower jaws... which means a new coat of synthetic skin too.
Load More Replies...No, they’re too busy going up against British Prime Ministers at the moment.
Load More Replies...Why is it I don’t want to like his acting, but I can’t help but think he’s actually great? Maybe because he’s so easily cast or miscast. In other words, not entirely versatile. Charlie Banks, Squid/Whale, Social Network he was amazing. Adventure/Zombie, Louder than Bombs, Now You See Me, Bat v. Super, not so much.
Cameron Diaz in Gangs of New York. She's not bad, but can't match Dicaprio and Daniel Day Lewis.
faislamour:
Honestly, Daniel Day Lewis was on another level in that movie. I remember watching it as a kid, and even then, I felt like I was watching Leo, Cameron Diaz, and a dude that time travelled from the turn of the century. Leo and Diaz basically play themselves while Daniel Day Lewis disappears in his role.
Underrated? It was nominated for 10 Oscars. It just had the misfortune of going up against Chicago, and The pianist.
Load More Replies...With Cameron Diaz, I'm always really aware that I'm watching Cameron, not whatever character she plays.I can't say she's a bad actor, she not, but I'm constantly taken out of the story and reminded of the fact that I'm looking at an actor, not a character.
The only movie I can think of where I didn’t feel this way is Being John Malkovich.
Load More Replies...That whole movie was trash. She was okay in the over-acting Olympics. But between the rest of the cast dining on the scenery and the ludicrous costumes I couldn’t make it past the halfway point.
Robert DeNiro as the young Frank Sheehan in The Irishman. There isn’t enough makeup and CGI in the world to make that work.
Miserable_Reach9648:
Yeah, that was so dumb. No amount of CGI could make De Niro walk and act like a young guy. The whole 'de-aging' gimmick I think works for maybe a flashback scene or a cameo, but shooting a whole movie with it robs a younger actor of a role that they probably could have pulled off way better.
It (the CGI ageing) put me off the whole movie - it was distracting and took me out of the story
It just looked off, and they didn't de-age him enough. When it got to the part where he was kicking a guy, looked like a guy in his 70's having a tough time standing while kicking
Load More Replies...And as if that wasn't enough Scorsese repeats the same mistake in his next film, Killers of the Flower Moon. While not a bad film, and a great soundtrack, the film is based on history and real people. Both De Niro and DiCaprio were about twice the age the actual people they portrayed were.
And he doesn't look the least bit Irish lol guy is Italian af, and can't really pass for much else
Not a film snob, but to this day I cannot stand the casting choice of Johnny Depp as Grindelwald in the fantastic beast series. I f*****g love Depp, and think he got the s**t stick with the scandal stuff, but Grindelwald was SCANDINAVIAN for Pete’s sake, no amount of makeup was going to make Depp look like that. They should have had Mads Mickelson the entire time, or even a different Scandi actor.
I’m not sure if this is a joke or you don’t know but Mads Mikkelsen played Grindelwald in the third film. Johnny Depp had a tiny cameo at the end of the first film, and then played him in the second film, then among all the JD/AH drama they recast Grindelwald as Mads Mikkelsen. Mads is great. Nothing personal against him, but I don’t like Johnny’s over reliance on crazy makeup and styling with his characters and his over acting.
Load More Replies...He attends the Scandinavian school, but I'm pretty sure he's supposed to be British
Load More Replies...I don't think that Grindelwald was intended as a Scandinavian. Also not all Scandinavians are tall and blond and blue-eyed (although they did give him that look). A white actor can play a Scandinavian imo.
Uh... your last sentence doesn't make any sense. Scandinavians ARE white.
Load More Replies...I LOVED Depp as Grindelwald. He is just so incredibly talented in the right roles.
Never got the hype with Jonny..he plays over the top caricatures. So he doesn't have to be believable because we have no references.
Well, I guess any actor can play a Scandinavian dude, if their acting is good enough, right? But I agree, I also would have loved Mads Mikkelsen in that role.
Mads Mikkelsen played Grindelwald in the third film.
Load More Replies...
Keanu Reeves in Bram Stoker's Dracula. His attempt at a British accent is hilarious.
I have to agree. My favorite book, and it was the most book-accurate adaptation I've seen. It didn't help that he was starring next to Gary Oldman and Anthony Hopkins, that just made his performance stand out even worse.
The scene I remember most vividly is when old Dracula brings the baby for his "wives". The reaction from Keanu was so ridiculous that I actually burst out laughing in the theatre. Keanu Reeves - great person, not great in these kind of roles.
Load More Replies...I still love the movie but Keanu Reeves was not the best choice.
Bless his heart. But, think of "John Wick's Dracula".. I'd watch the hell out of that, lol...
Hear me out - I think his awkwardness and stiffness kind of vibes with the character of Jonathan Harker in the novel.
Agree. I saw the movie when I was in college but hadn't read the book. I've always loved Keanu but heavily disliked him in that role. Many, many years later--I actually read the book and realized he does play the role true to the character. However, the accent is still incredibly off putting.
Load More Replies...I love Keanu, but I gotta say, I don't think he's that good of an actor in general.
I love Keanu in a number of things, but him and Winona Ryder ruined that movie. Which sucked cuz Gary Oldman and Anthony Hopkins were perfection.
Russell Crowe as Inspector Javert in Les Miserables. He just can't sing nearly as well as the other cast members. Especially for a movie that is a musical.
Oh this reminds me of a movie called "Paint Your Wagon". Musical comedy from the 70s starring Clint Eastwood and Lee Marvin. Big mistake hiring starring actors who CAN'T SING.
"I'm gonna paint this wagon. I'm gonna paint it good. I'm gonna give it two full coats because it's made of wood." (The Simpsons s09e11 "All Singing, All Dancing")
Load More Replies...Les Miserables with Liam Neeson, Ema Thurman, Claire Danes & Geoffery Rush is by far the better movie
Ever see the Gerard Butler Emmy Rossum phantom movie? Yeah, i wish i didnt either. A
At least Gerard can sing. He would have been a much better choice for Javert IMO
Load More Replies...Russell Crowe is an amazing actor in my view, but in Les Miserables he was so focused in trying to keep a tune while singing *and* acting that he failed at both. It did not help that we have professional Broadway singers to compare his role to...
He was terrible, as was Helena Bonham Carter in Sweeney Todd, there are plenty of big name actors who can really sing, yet people without a note in their heads get cast in musical films. Crowe is the main reason I can't really watch the movie of a brilliant musical.
I heard Russell Crowe “sing” for half of one song and knew that I could never watch the whole thing. Crowe butchered “Stars” It’s just terrible. What were they thinking.
Nic Cage was considered for Aragorn. This proves that, no matter how bad it gets, we are not in the darkest timeline.
That could've been spectacular. Nic Cage is a fine actor when he needs to be.
Dont go down this road! Look at what it did to ABED! ps: community is great!
Nic does some, shall we say "questionable", movies, but he can definitely act in some of them. The most recent example would be The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent, but my favorite would probably be Raising Arizona
I just watched "Unbearable ..." a few nights ago and really enjoyed it. I've found him perfectly good in plenty of things, but thought he was perfect in "Valley Girl". For those that haven't seen "Unbearable ..." it where this comes from, and I think you've all seen this by now. Untitled-6...addabd.jpg
I thought Cage tried to get cast but was turned away, not that he was considered by Jackson.
I'd have to see it happen to have an opinion that's worth much. Because he played the role Viggo Mortensen *is* Aragorn and t would be hard to see anyone else do it, but if somebody else had been cast they may have been just as good.
The cast for the last airbender. The acting alone was enough to make it the worst movie of that year. I mean I've seen better acting in liberty mutual commercials.
Why did they even think this needed a Live Action version? The original anime was great.
Noah was good because he was a fan of the show but everything else to do with the film was pure 💩
Original Anime was great, why make the movie? Anime don't do well with real actors.
Who the @#&$ cast Topher grace as venom. Seriously the kid's from the 70s show. He's not scary at all. Especially when hes screaming in agony I'm just thinking to myself... this is bad.
I give grace to Topher for his unwillingness to socially engage with the rest of the That 70s cast & to keep himself distanced from all the behind the scenes predatory behavior. He wanted out so bad because of it and the show ended because he couldn’t abide by their off-screen behavior.
Haven't seen it, but if I can tell it's him I'll have a hard time not seeing Eric Forman. Unfortunately fr many perfectly good actors they become so heavily associated with one role that it limits their future opportunities.
Load More Replies...At least in that you didn't expect him to turn into a killer and the Predators not care. HA HA!
Load More Replies...He reminds me of those hot shot salesmen. Actually, In Good Company was a perfect role for him. You just want to punch him in the movie. But it was sure satisfying seeing him crash his Porsche as he drove out of the dealership.
Mark Wahlberg in The Happening. I’m not sure any casting choice could have made that movie not suck, but I couldn’t believe for even a second that Wahlberg was just a dorky science teacher trying to survive.
There have been so many films that I haven’t watched because Mark Wahlberg is in them. I’ve watched several of his films and always thought “this would have been so much better if somebody else was cast.”
Load More Replies...Mark is also a known and convicted violent racist but still is a millionaire?
I don’t get it. He’s not a good actor or a good person. I guess casting agents like a famous name so he keeps getting hired.
Load More Replies...This movie as a whole was odd and I don't think any casting could have saved it. Zoey Deschanel was also a bit weird here with her wide eyes and constant "I don't like to show my emotions" whining.
He's just not good at acting...except maybe as acting like someone who isn't a racist POS.
Not the worst casting, but it’s if we’re talking major star miscast, I’d say Tom Hanks in Da Vinci Code.
The book, IIRC, described the character as a handsome hot professor. I pictured more someone like Jon Hamm or Clooney back in the days.
I love Hanks, but agree - Langdon was supposed to be an ex Water Polo player - tall, fit, handsome - and middle aged Hanks is none of those things really. GREAT actor, but that was bad casting.
Having never read the books I though he was fine in the movie adaptations. I hadn't read any of the Reacher books when the first movie came out, so for me Cruise was unbelievable more because the character and many of the events are unbelievable than because I already had an image of Reacher in my head. FWIW, I'm not sure if I ever read any of the Bosch stories before I started watching it on Amazon. I don't think the character gives you a strong image in your mind the way Reacher does, but after seeing the Bosch series and reading perhaps 20 of the books I don't think I could ever find another actor believable in the role unless they were good at playing Titus Welliver.
Well, utterly c**p book; Hanks and Audrey Tautou elevated the material to something watchable.
Ezra Miller as The Flash.
One of the most famous redheads in comics history and they cast a guy with black hair. Plus the famously-blond Aquaman was played by a brunet.
I think there was a version of Aquaman that had long shaggy hair and a beard and they used that for Jason. Was still a blonde, I think. I don't know, it's Jason Momoa in wet clothing, does anything else matter?
Load More Replies...Ezra Miller in general. He's just a terrible and annoying human being.
I don't really care about comic books, their movie adaptions (Deadpool notwithstanding) or their lore, so someone like Jason Momoa, to me, works better as Aquaman than say Chris Hemsworth would (if he weren't portraying Thor already). The movies were rubbish from what I've heard, but that's another issue. With regards to The Flash, his* hair color was really the least of a problem with casting Ezra Miller... *I don't buy his non-binary gender identity. He just needs a REALLY good therapist.
Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman in Far and Away like for f**k sake you couldn’t find at least two actors from either the Republic or Northern Ireland?
You'd have had to go relatively unknown, which wasn't really in vogue at the time. Neeson might've been able to do it, but none of the other Irish lads even close in age at that time had the right characteristics for the role.
In that age group, John Lýnch could have played the lead. And Orla Brady. Maria Doyle Kennedy? [I just found out that BP censors the name Lýnch]
A bit hot off the press so I'm not sure it really counts: Chris Pratt as Mario.
I will never not be mad about this. It may not be a popular opinion but Pratt is _not_ a talented actor and basically just acts as himself in every role. He may as well be some random, conventionally attractive dude they pulled off the street to act like themselves or speak into a microphone.
To me Christ Pratt and Mark Wahlberg give me the same kind of vibe
FWIW they're both members of rather conservative christian denominations. Wahlberg is catholic and Pratt is in some kind of VIP evangelical cult. Not to mention his BS behavior towards Anna Faris and their son. Can't be arsed to watch anything with him since that happened and I actually liked GOTG 1.
Load More Replies...That was a great movie. But again, I was a kid seeing it. 🤷♂️
Load More Replies...I've lost any respect for Pratt because of what he did to Anna Faris and their kid.
Pratt is only good in Guardians. That's it. Otherwise, he can't really act and he's not that great a person either.
Valerian with Cara Delevingne. She had no feelings and zero chemistry with the other main character Dane Dehaan. Who I’ve also never seen in another movie. Worst casting ever.
CrayonPFish:
I'm still f**king mad about the casting choices in this movie except for Ethan Hawke. They needed actors who look about 20 years older who know how to deliver dialogue. They didn't look old enough to get a driver's license, let alone a pilot's license.
I liked her okay in "Carnival Row." But man was she awful in "Suicide Squad" - stunk up the place with that bad acting!
I thought she was fantastic in Carnival Row. Surprised the hell out of me.
Load More Replies...I noped out of this one simply because the ads made it look romantic, and the leads look like brother and sister
Thank you! This was the thought I had through the whole movie.
Load More Replies...Both of them are terrible in that movie. No chemistry, bad acting, smug crapitudes. She's GREAT as the Non Stop Pop dj in GTAV though....I'll give her snaps there.
I hated this movie and I loathed her for a long time because of her acting in this. But I've come to realize she's not bad at all. She was good in Carnival Row, and I really liked her in Only Murders in the Building. I love her as the DJ of Non Stop Pop. The fact that she's good everywhere else leads me to believe that it wasn't her acting that was the issue in Valerian, but the direction.
I am sick to the eye-teeth with casting that is too young and pretty to be believable. It does happen with the whole cast at times, but often the men are all sorts, young and old, good looking or craggy or saggy, but all the women are young, conventionally attractive with taut young bodies and skin. And I have to believe they've worked their way up high in the police force/Secret Service/business etc. Takes me right out of the film or drama because it's like a massive sign flashing 'none of this is real'.
In the comics she is a redhead and and Besson had used up his redhead in The Fifth Element. Since not many people outside France know of the complex story (I do), if he cast a redhead people would say 'Wait, Leeloo?' She's just dull surprise and Dane is trying and failing to be early Keanu
Also: no one could spring for a bottle of Clairol, or a decent wig? Laureline is canonically a redhead. I would have accepted actors of any age, colour or gender - but don't mess with a comic book character's hair. She's a clever woman from the French middle ages, accused of being a witch (due to cleverness + hair), whom Valerian picks up while time travelling. The hair isn't just decoration, it impacts her arc.
I had this issue with Inferno (from the Dan Brown book). The lead female is very often described with her BLONDE hair/ponytail, yet the actress/film character was a brunette. If it had not been mentioned so many times in the book, I don't think I would have cared so much, but sometimes, the smallest details make the biggest difference! In Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children they completely swapped the main female lead with a secondary female for no reason whatsoever. Couldn't watch/enjoy the movie despite some very good actors.
Load More Replies...Never seen it, don't know the plot/story, don't really care. However, in the US there's no minimum age to legally fly a plane when there's a licensed pilot in the other seat. You need to be 16 to solo and 17 to get your private certificate, and when the movie was released they were both old enough to have legally flown a 747 with 500 passengers. The guy does look about 15 in this particular picture, though.
James Corden in Cats.
Scarlett Johansson as Motoko Kusanagi in Ghost In The Shell was the worst possible choice.
Or when she voiced Kaa in the jungle book that is supposed to be a male character
Can't have a man play Kaa, that would be gay. (Please, note the sarcasm dripping from my lips)
Load More Replies...I have no idea why she's so popular and successful, but I very rarely watch a movie based primarily on who's in it. There are lots of perfectly good actresses who are at least as attractive and willing to work for a lot less money.
I don't get it either. The roles are not challenging, which might be why I just don't understand the obsession.
Load More Replies...Ghost in the Shell producers screwed up. Just do it as an American adaptation of the original material, and you can cast Scarlett or anyone really, with no controversy. I understand that the ideal thing would be to cast a Japanese actress, but studios want big names. Sadly they aren't wise enough to know that whitewashing a Japanese character hurts the bottom line of the phone probably as much as casting a lesser known star. Also, having the movie be s**t also hurts it.
She tried to save face in playing the character that she wasn't really aware of the whitewashing. Woman, did the character name not tip you off? Don't distance yourself after the scandal. Just read the source material and NOT take on the part
Jared Leto as Paulo Gucci in the film Gucci. He was horrendous and made the character into a real life Mario character with the s***tiest attempt of an Italian accent that I've ever heard in my life.
Laverne Cox as Frank N Furter. What the actual f's were they thinking remaking a cult classic into glittery hot garbage??
I was looking forward to seeing her interpretation of the character, but unfortunately she simply imitated Tim Curry (and not very well). Such a disappointment. Also WTF Bored Panda; Cox is a legitimate surname and NOT a slur/obscene word. Sheesh.
I refused to watch this remake! You cannot, repeat, CANNOT out do Tim Curry on this one! Shouldn't have even been tried!
Are we not going to talk about the fact that they have literally censored someone's last NAME???
I didn't even know this was done. LOL. What a bad idea. Not casting her, but remaking the film at all.
Should have been a crossdresser not an actual trans person. Though, I do like the representation, but part of it all was the mystery in the gender.
Gonna say that whoever made the film adaptation of Phantom of the Opera should have hired a Phantom with singing experience. Gerard Butler cannot sing and feels woefully out of place.
In a similar vein, Russel Crowe as Javert in Les Mis. Pierce Brosnan in Mamma Mia 1 & 2.
Hollywood, get actors who can sing.
I want to argue because the smouldering Phantom was my crush growing up, but...yeah.
I don't like Gerard Butler but I very much crush on him in Phantom. I love Patrick Wilson's Raoul even though I hate every incarnation I've seen. Butler's singing doesn't bother me much knowing that he was intentionally cast to NOT sing opera but give it harder sound, like a more rock sound.
Load More Replies...Pierce Brosnan's singing made me cringe. I was embarrassed for him.
He was Bryn Terfel compared to Colin Firth in that film
Load More Replies...I sadly have to agree about Pierce Brosnan. I've loved the man (or his vibes) ever since Remington Steele, but for a serious musical movie he was a bad choice. For a comic relief his singing was top notch! I'll take the attempt as proof of a star that doesn't take himself too seriously. I seem to remember him saying he couldn't pass a chance to play with Meryl Streep.
True, I adore Butler and Phantom, but he just couldn't sing. It wasn't working for me
Also who cast Emma Watson in the newer beauty and the beast? I can think of so many better actors...who can sing. (The Christine from this phantom is who I think they should have cast. SHE can sing AND is the right age.)
My personal choice would be Emilia Clarke as Sarah Conner in Terminator: Genisys. Capable, lovable actress that in no way embodies the bada*s that is Sarah Connor.
That whole movie (Genisys) was just stupid. The leads had no chemistry whatsoever, and the plot was dire.
I like to pretend that the movies 3 to (whatever number they got to eventually) never existed
Load More Replies...Lena Headey as Sarah in the Sarah Connor Chronicles was a much better casting choice
Yes! The show IMHO totally missed the entire plot of the original two movies (I'm pretending the others didn't happen) but I still loved that show
Load More Replies...
Vince Vaughn as Norman Bates
Edit: Because a lot of people didn’t know about this film, it’s a shot for shot remake of the original Psycho, directed by Gus Van Sant: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0155975/.
No, re-making Psycho was the mistake. Some movies just shouldn’t be redone.
100% agree with this. You don't remake Hitchcock.
Load More Replies...That movie was so much fun to watch :) Also really liked him in The Cell
Load More Replies...They also did a shot by shot remake of this with Anne Heche. I thought the point of a remake was to add the directors own twist. What a waste of time and money.
A major point of a remake, and likely the only point for the guy that greenlights it, is to make money. Hollywood always thinks it's a safe bet to remake something that's already successful, and they're usually right.
Load More Replies...I actually found him very convincing, was surprised by his depth since I'm used to seeing him in comedies
Mark Wahlberg in the Cary Grant role in the remake of Charade (The Truth About Charlie).
The whole thing was a train wreck, and a disgrace to everyone involved save maybe Thandie Newton.
But none of it was worse than Markie Mark in the male lead.
EDIT: to save my “Film Snob” card from revocation - I have been reminded it is (as of the past year) to be spelled *Thandiwe* Newton. I’m not enough of a Platinum-level snob to even guess how that’s pronounced.
EDIT 2: For the disbelievers:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0270707/
EDIT 3: Thank you kind stranger for the award.
Thandiwe Newton's mom is from Zimbabwe, and if the Shona pronounce sounds like the Zulus and Ndebele do, it's probably pronounced "Ton" (like the weight) "dee" (like "sea"), "weh" (like in "meh").
Justin Chatwin as Goku.
That entire film is awful from start to finish. I remember going to see it at the cinema with a friend. We had to go to the pub next door to drown our sorrows.
Honest Trailers summarized it best: "Worst thing America has done to Japanese culture since Hiroshima".
Yes, and if you love anything about DragonBall, NEVER watch it. It is barely a memoriam to the legacy, and not connected to the series in any real way.
Load More Replies...
I am not sure I would classify myself as a film snob… But Gwyneth Paltrow as Tony Starks secretary was God awful. Having been an admin for 30 years, The way she played that character, she would be an embarrassment to the profession.
Impossibleish:
I binged MCU during the pandemic and ended up loving all of it, but every Pepper scene just threw me off. Pepper Potts is genuine, and Paltrow is probably the most aloof actor I've ever seen.
Agreed, the character wasn't the most likable, and she came off as oddly stiff for the way it felt like she was supposed to be viewed, but she really wasn't as bad as she's being made out to be. At least not compared to the new movies...
Load More Replies...She was good in this. You realize she wasn't really an admin, right? Did you happen to read any of the comics to know the character of Pepper Pot, or are you just going off of your 30 years as an admin asst? I mean, I've known several CEOs and I guess they could say that Tony Stark was terrible because they never became Ironman....
And I'm sorry there is no such thing as a typical admin type. I too have been an admin for over 30 years and it's more about what the boss wants than any specific type of admin demeanor.
Load More Replies...I know I've seen her in a few things, the ones I most enjoyed have been "The Royal Tenenbaums" and "View From the Top" (a guilty pleasure). Oh, and when she played that cabbage in "Se7en", that was good too /s
Shannon Sossamon in A Knight's Tale. She could not match the charisma of Heath Ledger and I was rooting for the blacksmith.
Sean Connery playing a Spaniard in Highlander.
That one was worth it for the comedy value though. Practically none of the Scottish characters were Scots, then you get Sean Connery playing a Spaniard - with zero attempt at any change in accent 🤣 The bit where he's asking about haggis is hilarious.
An Egyptian Spaniard :-) From Wiki-Sean Connery as Juan Sánchez-Villalobos Ramírez, an Egyptian (born Tak-Ne) immortal. He also lives for a time in Japan and then later in Spain. Learning the Kurgan has targeted Connor MacLeod, Ramírez tracks down the Highlander and becomes his mentor in the ways of immortals. And there was only ONE Highlander movie. There were NO sequels...
Load More Replies...Sean Connery is *not* a good actor. I know that's heresy to some people, but he's not. He plays exactly the same person with exactly the same accent in every single movie. I've never understood his appeal.
He had the same problem James Coburn did. Coburn once told a director "I can act. I'm just not often asked to."
Load More Replies...That was to get a name. He filmed for 7 days and made a million dollars.
He wasn't playing a Spaniard though, that's the thing a lot of things people don't get. He was playing a guy who had lived an unknown number of lives over a who knows how many centuries. The latest version of himself had him living in Spain. He tells you this in the movie.
Sean Connery in a weeding dress, and sporting a red body thong and a pony tail. Both in "Zardoz".
Colin Ferrell as Alexander the Great.
Yes! I spent years believing Colin Farell to be a bad actor. He did redeem himself with "The Lobster", "In Bruges" or "Banshees of Inisherin"
Farrell as Penguin is S-Tier. He's amazing in that role.
Load More Replies... I’m just going to throw one in, since everyone has said most of the worst, but the one that comes to mind is Lucille Ball in ‘Mame’. She was incredibly miscast to the point the movie suffered greatly from it & it was received so poorly that Lucille Ball stopped acting all together.
Even her co-star, Bea Arthur, made no qualms about how miscast in the role Lucille was, especially when the original Broadway actress, Angela Lansbury, was considered by everyone the perfect choice for the film role, winning the Tony for it & having been nominated for two Oscars.
Lucille Ball fought hard for the role though & eventually won it, but it brought down a whole lot with it. It’s still a miscast that lives in Broadway, musical, and film infamy.
Roz Russell owned that role. The whole remake was iffy, but, Bea Arthur doing Vera Charles was pretty good, not Coral Browne but pretty good.
The original with Roz Russell is brilliant, but she did ruin the movie of 'Gypsy' remember - Merman was robbed.
Load More Replies...Well then, we’ll have to dust off a copy of Barbra Streisand in the movie version of “Hello Dolly!” and compare notes.
The original movie is one of my absolute favorites "my little love"
Will Smith as Robert Neville. They threw away a great twist because we can’t have Will Smith be the villain.
Well they actually did film the alternate ending which is a bit closer to the book (Neville as the bad guy) but apparently test audiences didn’t respond well to it. The mistake in this movie was the use of CGI for the infected - it was really poorly executed and looked sh!thouse. Otherwise, I thought the movie was pretty good.
It was good for what it was but I tend to think of it as more inspired by I Am Legend. But my favorite version will always be Omega Man Charlton Heston and his bombastic speeches. And the hippie undead are just amazing..
Load More Replies...One of those films where I can only carry on by thinking of the book and film as completely different entities. If you haven't read the book please do, it's brilliant written, claustrophobic, plays with your mind as to who is right and who is wrong, makes the mundane unbelievably meaningful and evocative, and is over all a taut little novella.
The worst of for this was World War Z (in my head it will always be World War Zed). If you like the zombie genre then this book is nothing like the film at all. The conceit for how it is written (a collection of recollections gathered by a journalist) is so clever, the way it builds up the story in thin layers, like an animation, slowly creating a full picture. It's the only book that when I read the last page I immediately turned back to page 1 and started it again, there and then.
Load More Replies...The whole movie was ruined by the audience-friendly altered ending.
I dunno about worst of all time but Julia Roberts in Michael Collins was super jarring. Her Irish accent was willy-nilly and when it was on it was still pretty terrible. Plus she just looked out of place. Like they dropped a supermodel into the middle of the Irish Civil War, not that there weren't good looking people in Ireland at the time, but you shove a big name and face like her's into a historical period piece like that, you're just asking for trouble. Shoulda went with an Irish actress.
never liked her acting or her looks, no idea why, but when she comes on screen I'm like ugh
I liked her earlier films. After those few - it's the same character over and over
Load More Replies...Yeah, it was a really awful accent. It's very hard to do a good Irish accent, and it's rarely done right.
I can do a decent Ulster accent, but for some reason just can't get anything from the Republic.
Load More Replies...Coppola's daughter in the Godfather 3.
You must be mistaken, there was no GF3. There was only two, and they were both masterpieces.
The theatrical version is...not good. But the Godfather Coda version is a worthy ending to the saga.
Load More Replies...i thought she was good....she played a slightly naive but privileged (in a way) girl...which she was, but i found her to be authentic
Maybe not worst in film history but I always thought Maggie Gyllenhaal was a terrible choice to replace Katie Holmes. Great actor but just such a jarring change. Rose Byrne would have been the perfect replacement both looks and talent wise.
I think Maggie Gyllenhaal was great as Rachel Dawes. I think Katie Holmes was terrible casting for the first film. She wasn’t good enough of an actress. Rachel was an Assistant District Attorney in Gotham City who was willing to oppose mob bosses and fought against corruption in court. The character was supposed to be strong and determined but Katie Holmes made her seem like a college student.
I loved her in that role. Exactly because she was not as Hollywood-beautiful as Katie Holmes was. Makes it even more plausible that Bruce Wayne is actually in love with Rachel Dawson. That is not to say that Katie Holmes didn't do a good job, I liked her in the role too. And I can also picture Rose Byrne in the role.
Both her and Holmes were terrible castings for that role, IMO. But if it were up to me and I had to choose between the two, I'd have had Maggie do both movies.
I don't understand this one. OP thinks Rose Byrne looks more like Katie Holmes than Maggi Gyllenhaal? I feel like I'm taking crazy pills. I remember thinking at the time that they really lucked out with Gyllenhaal because not only is she a much better actor than Holmes, but also you could not find a decent actor in Hollywood who is as similar in looks to Holmes as Gyllenhaal.
Angela basset should have played storm in the X-Men movies instead of Hallie berry.
I think she would have been pretty good in it.
Load More Replies...I don't really thing Hallie was that bad as storm. At least not in comparison to how they butchered Catwoman
Michael Gambon’s Dumbledore maybe not the worse but man I hated his portrayal in every way. Richard Harris was perfect but they could have got someone who played the character closer to how he did.
Jared Harris? He can play *anything* and would have had the advantage of actually looking like the previous actor...
Load More Replies...It was certainly a shock the first time through but I can respect it. He had massive shoes to fill, and rather than try to copy Richard Harris he went all-in to establish himself. Harris was a sort of Santa version that you looked kindly on & was how the first book or two portrayed. While Gambon took it darker & more directly powerful like how the later books were. He became the Dumbledore we needed him to be based on the backstory & material.
Guess people will never let the "did you put your name into the goblet, Harry?" scene down.
Gambon was a friend of Harris. He accepted the role after Christopher Lee, Sean Connery, and Ian McKellen each turned down the role. Lee didn't care for the Potterverse, Connery didn't want to come out of retirement, and McKellen turned it down because he and harris didn't like each other and so he thought it would be in bad taste (Harris had a habit of criticizing other actors which led to a rift between him and many other actors). So Gambon took over the role to honor his friend
Richard Harris played Dumbledore. Michael Gambon played Richard Harris. Badly.
Natalie portman Thor 1-4.
Jon Voight in Anaconda for horrendously pitiful accent attempt.
That dude who played John Connor in Terminator:
Genysis.
The film was riddled with problems but this casting was just awful.
It’s so easy to look up an actors name when you’re contributing to an article specifically to mention actors by name; Jason Clarke.
Nick Stahl, who played John Connor in the third movie, *looked* like most like he could have been the son of Linda Hamilton and Michael Biehn.
A lot of Golden Age stuff was woefully miscast, but Tony Curtis and Janet Leigh in The Vikings always grates particularly badly for me.
The whole movie is pretty cringe to use the youth-speak.
Load More Replies...Below comment re : Kirk Douglas ..... he was an " over - actor ".
Pete Davidson, in that taco bell advert here...
Mark Wahlberg as Sully in uncharted.
Mark Wahlberg is copping a lot of stick here. I think that is the fourth entry so far
He's quite versatile. He can be bad in anything.
Load More Replies...Leslie Howard as Ashley Wilkes. Really? Nobody seemed to notice that good old Ashley had a British accent. Not quite as egregious as Lois Lane failing to recognize Superman when he put on glasses, but still pretty pathetic.
What woman would choose an Ashley Wilkes over a Rhett Butler? Scarlett was fire, Ashley was a wet rag.
Frankly Scarlett, I don’t give a damn. (I know, not the actual line).
Load More Replies...There is a very recognized accent that you find in the South and Southeast that sounds British. Not as common now, but all of those old movies were filled with people who sounded partly British. I thought he was the perfect mousy, weak-a$$ whipped man.
I'm not a film snob but I am a musical snob - Russell Crowe in Les Mis is a very easy answer, but also Hugh Jackman was not good casting either. That whole movie is garbage except for Anne Hathaway.
Watch him in The Greatest Showman, about P.T. Barnum. He's a good singer.
Load More Replies...My God, Anne Hathaway was horrible! 100% should never sing in a movie.
No, the whole movie is garbage except for Samantha Barks. She deserved to be in a much better film.
She was picked from the actual Broadway show because of how good she was, so that's difficult to argue with. Personally I do think Hugh did his parts pretty good. Helena Bonham Carter also played her character well, although it was a bit Mrs Mooney all over again
Load More Replies...Best thing we got out of that movie was the Nosaglia Critic musical review
Minnie Driver in Good Will Hunting. There is zero chemistry between her and Matt Damon. She’s off the scale awkward in it too - and not in a cute way.
Also Andie MacDowell in 4 Weddings and a Funeral. Comes across as cold and awkward and again no chemistry.
Agree with you on Andie MacDowell in 4 Weddings--she's just awful, and so unlikable. But I liked Minnie Driver in Good Will Hunting.
Minnie Driver had no chemistry with Matt Damon??? They literally dated for a year so they clearly had SOME chemistry......
MD was amazing in that role; she portrayed the social anxiety & loveable clumsiness very well & was so endearing. That movie is a gem to me, wouldn't have been the same w/o her
Guy Pierce as the old man Weyland in “Prometheus.” Pierce is a great actor and does the younger version admirably but just didn’t cut it as the old guy (no pun intended). It would have been simple to put someone like Anthony Hopkins into that part and would have made more sense than putting Pierce through all that makeup procedure. Pierce’s physical characteristics just didn’t look right to me. I was surprised that a director like Ridley Scott allowed that.
Robert De Niro as Frankenstein's monster.
Pretty much everyone in the Netflix Deathnote movie.
Nope. Nope. I love that movie, have seen it at least twice. Wish they would make a second.
Nah, they completely butchered the manga and anime
Load More Replies...
Tom Holland as Nathan Drake for the Uncharted movie. I guess Chris Pratt was too busy filming something else that Hollywood couldn't get him to do it. :P.
I love Nathan Fillion in everything he does. He doesn't get enough credit.
Load More Replies...Danny DeVito as the Penguin in Batman Returns. Clearly should have been Catwoman.
"I'll show you my French flipper trick." Can still send me and my bestie into giggle fits.
So many of these are not actually bad casting, but bad productions that wasted their actors.
Excellent point. I can see that now. Thanks!
Load More Replies...No one's going to mention Mickey Rooney in Breakfast at Tiffany's, cast as a Japanese man, complete with yellow face stereotypes? That, surely, is the most egregious miscasting ever.
Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss in The Hunger Games. She did a great job portraying the character, but was pretty much the exact opposite of the way in which the character was described in the books
The lovely Keanu Reeves in Much ado and nothing. Dreadful British accent.
How about EVERYONE in Borderlands the movie? We all knew it would be tragic even before we saw a trailer - due to the awful, horrible casting. Uhh.
And they completely underplayed Tiny Tinas unhinged crazyness. Their best job was with Claptrap, he was as annoying as in the games
Load More Replies...It was the direction - because EVERYONE in the Prequels sound like idiots, and most of them are fine actors/actresses. George does better when he's the idea man and other people are doing the directing.
Load More Replies...Will Smith in Aladdin live action was absolutely AWFUL in so many ways. Heath Ledger as Joker (ya ya I know the movie's PR team did a great job at convincing everyone he was amazing). Jonny Depp in the remake of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. Ben Affleck as Batman, speechless on how awful he was, really though he's way over rated in dam near everything.
Listen, everyone is allowed to their opinion, and you made a couple of good points. But to put Heath Ledger’s Joker in this category is just plain ignorant. Or were you just trying to be edgy? Or looking for a reaction?
Load More Replies...any movie where Matt Damon plays an educated Boston street tough
So many of these are not actually bad casting, but bad productions that wasted their actors.
Excellent point. I can see that now. Thanks!
Load More Replies...No one's going to mention Mickey Rooney in Breakfast at Tiffany's, cast as a Japanese man, complete with yellow face stereotypes? That, surely, is the most egregious miscasting ever.
Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss in The Hunger Games. She did a great job portraying the character, but was pretty much the exact opposite of the way in which the character was described in the books
The lovely Keanu Reeves in Much ado and nothing. Dreadful British accent.
How about EVERYONE in Borderlands the movie? We all knew it would be tragic even before we saw a trailer - due to the awful, horrible casting. Uhh.
And they completely underplayed Tiny Tinas unhinged crazyness. Their best job was with Claptrap, he was as annoying as in the games
Load More Replies...It was the direction - because EVERYONE in the Prequels sound like idiots, and most of them are fine actors/actresses. George does better when he's the idea man and other people are doing the directing.
Load More Replies...Will Smith in Aladdin live action was absolutely AWFUL in so many ways. Heath Ledger as Joker (ya ya I know the movie's PR team did a great job at convincing everyone he was amazing). Jonny Depp in the remake of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. Ben Affleck as Batman, speechless on how awful he was, really though he's way over rated in dam near everything.
Listen, everyone is allowed to their opinion, and you made a couple of good points. But to put Heath Ledger’s Joker in this category is just plain ignorant. Or were you just trying to be edgy? Or looking for a reaction?
Load More Replies...any movie where Matt Damon plays an educated Boston street tough
