“Glad You Wore Panties”: 20 Fashion Disasters On The 2025 ESPYs Red Carpet

With her husband and NFL star Jonathan Owens beside her, Simone Biles had a great night at the 2025 ESPYs.

The 11-time Olympic medalist won two trophies at the award show, including Best Championship Performance for her performance at the 2024 Olympics, during which she won three gold medals and one silver.

But fans weren’t too sure if she and Jonathan scored points for their appearance. 

Simone was dressed in a custom-designed blue sequin gown by Zac Posen, made in partnership with Athleta.

The design came out “exactly how I envisioned it,” the gymnast said in a BTS video ahead of the show.

“I would not describe this look as stunning,” one social media user said about her outfit.

“Simone Biles needs to get a refund,” another said, while yet another wrote, “dress does not fit.”

There was also rampant speculation about the gymnastic champion going under the knife to alter her appearance.

“Definitely some obvious plastic surgery,” one commenter said, while another wrote, “What happened to her face? Was she injured?”

“She needs to fire her plastic surgeon,” one netizen claimed.

Some wondered where Jonathan got his shirt from. 

“It looks like he's wearing a woman's blouse,” read one comment.

“Whyyy is he wearing that shirt?!?!?” another asked.

Jordan Chiles posed on the red carpet in a beige minidress from Cong Tri’s spring 2025 collection, with tan heels and Sterling Forever jewelry.

“I love how the texture of it is like basket material,” the gymnast told Extra TV about the dress on the red carpet.

“It’s very special. It resembles a lot … [It’s] me being me,” she added. “I love it.”

Fans didn’t share the same enthusiasm and said, “Idk if it’s her features or the artist but her makeup is always a miss.”

“Immediately no,” one bluntly said.

“She deserves better,” said another. “I want [her] Stylist or Glam team to be STOPPED.”

“Who keeps doing this to this gorgeous young lady,” one asked.

“It’s a head to to NO,” said another. “Why would that put that silhouette in her and she’s already broad shouldered with a stocky build?”

“Nope, Nope, Nope!!!” the internet said after Ilona Maher put on a daring display of skin in a black gown.

The Olympic bronze medalist and Team USA rugby star won the Best Breakthrough Athlete award at the show. 

“This was a last-minute,” Ilona told Extra TV on the red carpet. “...I went with this because I wanted to show my muscles.”

But fans asked, “Who did this to her?”

“I’m a fan of hers, but you’d think at least one of her friends would have told her that dress is not the one,” one said.

Another wrote, “Love her but there has to be a more flattering dress for her.”

“I love her, but it’s giving weird gladiator in a [loin] cloth,” said another.

“Glad you wore panties,” a social media user said after Katie Austin hit the red carpet.

With her undies on display and her confidence dialed to 100, the fitness influencer wore a teeny-tiny glitter bra with a sparkly sheer skirt.

She seemed like she was on her way to a Coachella after-party.

Daria Berenato rolled up in a kind of brave but mostly bizarre outfit to the annual awards show.

There was a crop top. There were leather pants. And then there were straps that began at her chest and dangled all the way to her legs.

There was also an out-of-place metal ring that added to the confusing vibe.

Before hitting the red carpet, Robin had a 4 a.m. workout and ate a tofu wrap that she took with her to Los Angeles from New York.

The inspiration for her outfit may have been a disco ball, as she showed up in a strapless metallic silver gown with a plunging neckline.

Ahead of the award show, Chari Hawkins dressed up in several looks and asked her fans to vote for the best outfit.

The winner appeared to be a fluffy, voluminous ball gown designed by Ines Di Santo.

The champion athlete brought some track-day energy by wearing chunky white sneakers that were hidden under the long skirt.

Less is more. And with Gabby Thomas’ outfit, it was definitely a touch more than required.

The sprinter went for an all-white trend, wearing a Feather Trim Oscar Dress from PatBo.

The design featured an asymmetrical cut and had a feather trim along the skirt. 

Like most of his jokes during his ESPYs monologue, Shane Gillis’ outfit fell flat on the red carpet.

His yawn-inducing outfit barely became a subject of conversation online after he struggled to get the crowd laughing as he opened the show.

“He seems so uncomfortable,” one commenter said, while another asked, “Is the Joke in the room with us?”

“Imagine thinking this was good,” another wrote. “They’re laughing AT you.”

Rae Burrell’s outfit had an odd, dizzying pattern that was hard to root for. But the WNBA star seemed comfortable, with a relaxed vibe on the red carpet.

When asked about how she gets herself “hyped up” for a big moment, she declared, “clothes.”

“Clothes! I’m a strong believer in: ‘look good, feel good, play good,’” she told GMA on the red carpet. 

“Being able to express myself in clothes is just something that gets me going,” she added.