People Removed These 29 Statues Because They Stood For What’s Wrong With Humans
The movement against racism and social injustice following the killing of George Floyd has called out many to reconsider the statues, monuments, and memorials currently standing in a number of cities around the globe.
What started off as the toppling of statues that honored and celebrated slavery and racism has now grown into a whole parallel movement that pushes everyone to rethink people and events in history. Since protesters started taking down certain statues, city governments and private owners started to do the same.
Now, this may be one of the few times when statues are taken down virtually en-masse, but it is definitely not the first time statues are taken down in general as the people associated with them were later proven to be not worthy of one.
Bored Panda has collected a list of some of the most memorable statues that have been taken down for one reason or another. Check out the list below, and while you’re at it, be sure to vote and comment on them! And if you want more statues, Bored Panda has recently published an article on 29 statues that are better than the ones protesters are tearing down, commemorating heroes and events against the evils of the world.
This post may include affiliate links.
Bust of Bill Cosby (American comedian) in Walt Disney World, Orlando, Florida, taken down in July, 2015 due to accusations of sexual assault.
Tom Hanks is America's new dad, and i think we're more than okay with that
Load More Replies...Why ... why would Disney have a statue of him in the first place? I'm confused.
On the face of it he was a successful black American actor and comedian - why shouldn't they have a statue? Not enough people like that celebrated. At least until the truth about him emerged of course.
Load More Replies...I loved the Cosby show. No more of that now thanks to this disgusting pervert
Disney should have an exhibition for these kind of a******s, it's a didactic way to learn that anyone can be an abuser.
There should be a place for that but not in a children’s amusement park.
Load More Replies...Due to accusations! Surely later they were proved to be right, but they should have waited until the final rule was out.
Commemorative brick dedicated to Gary Glitter (English glam rock singer) removed from the Wall of Fame at the Cavern Club in Liverpool. It was taken down in November, 2008 due to Glitter's possession of child pornography, child sexual abuse, and attempted rape of minors.
Why did they even dedicate a brick to him in the first place if he'd done such terrible things 🤔🤔
Load More Replies...He was a weird glam rock singer from the 1970's. Then got caught messing with kids. And now lives in Thai land being creepy.
Load More Replies...Statue of Joe Paterno (American football player) in Penn State's Beaver Stadium, Pennsylvania, taken down on July 22, 2012 due to his child sex abuse scandals.
Burn it. Anyone who takes advantage of children deserves to be erased from history.
they definitely shouldn't be celebrated, but i don't know about erasing them. perhaps we should use them as examples of the many types of human scum that exist, and do everything in our power to make sure others are caught and our children are safe
Load More Replies...OK, just to be clear... Paterno was the Penn State coach, and he was only the POS that took part in the cover up. He was not the actual offender, but was 100% guilty of enabling one. Disgusting. Statue hopefully has been melted down and sold to help pay compensation to anyone hurt by his actions.
Paterno wasn't the pedophile one of his staffers Jerry Sandusky was. It's speculated on how much he knew about it and whether or not he was trying to cover the whole despicable act up. Certainly not defending him, just clearing up any confusion
The caption for this one is wrong and misleading. Joe Paterno is not a pedophile or a rapist. One of his staff, Jerry Sandusky was. I believe what happened was that Joe Paterno knew about it and reported to his boss, the university president. The university decided to cover it up and Joe Paterno let the cover up happen. When all of it came out, Joe Paterno no was fired from his job and he passed away a few months later from cancer.
To be clear, Joe Paterno was NOT accused of child sex crimes, but for ignoring complaints about his assistant coach Jerry Sandusky.
What made him worse is he actually used a guise to make parents think he was helping their children. Hell cant burn him fast enough
Statue of Leopold II Of Belgium (King of the Belgians) in Ekeren, Belgium, taken down in June, 2020 for colonialist exploitation and other atrocities.
This guy was particularly bad. Murdered hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of Africans for rubber. Slavery had been abolished in Belgium, but since Congo was a colony he got away with it into the 20th century.
The companies that grew big due to this exploitation of a huge privately owned property are still there enjoying their profits.
I can understand taking statues down for child abuse etc. but the others are history, bad history but still history. Removing them does not remove what they did and generations after us may forget, we do not wish atrocities to be forgotten, do we?
Not really. Because there is a fundamental difference between acknowledging a person in history books and honoring them via a statue. One prevents history from repeating, the latter encourages it to. You can see that, right?
Load More Replies...Statue of Edward Colston (English merchant) in Bristol, UK, taken down on 7 June, 2020 for his involvement in slave trade.
It's already been fished out. There are plans for it to be a museum exhibit which will also contain the relevant information on his deeds.
Load More Replies...The funniest part was when somebody updated the location on google maps. There are far better people to erect statues of.
That map update was hilarious! I love those kinds of people!
Load More Replies...Is there any other way to annihilate statues that's been taken down other than just drown it at the bottom of some river? I don't know. Certainly the fish don't want them there either.
In Lithuania we have Gruto Park http://grutoparkas.lt/en_US/about-us/ which we built to keep all the statues we took down. They can take example from that.
It was erected in the 1890’s because he used his slave money for philanthropic projects in the area.
Load More Replies...also all the brits should remove all their king's statue. for the same reasons
Statue of Saddam Hussein (President of Iraq) in Baghdad, Iraq, taken down on April 9, 2003 during the invasion of Iraq by the US forces.
Well, Trump has ordered his own commemorative MAGA coin.
Load More Replies...Am I the only one who thinks Americans had no business taking down a foreign statue on foreign land? Did the Iraqis ask for their help in removing it or did the soldiers just decide they know what's best for everyone?
Found this interesting... https://time.com/4394274/iraq-kadhim-al-jabbouri-saddam-hussein-statue-toppled-baghdad/#:~:text=When%20Kadhim%20al%2DJabbouri,triumph%20and%20hope%20for%20Iraq.
Load More Replies...Yeah this turned out to pretty much be a US government staged photo op. And all the US has done is kill millions of Iraqis and destablize the country
For the record, we caught him. He stood trial in Iraq and the Iraqi government carried out his execution. He was a president who decided he didn't want to step down
He wasn't a "self appointed" dictator, but a CIA appointed dictator, like so many are
Load More Replies...Statue of Christopher Columbus (Italian navigator and admiral) in Richmond, Virginia, taken down, spray-painted, set on fire, and thrown into a nearby lake by protestors on June 9, 2020 in solidarity with Native Americans.
I'm assuming the people who took the statue down also gave their land back to it's original owners and Richmond, Virginia is currently the property of Native Americans? Otherwise it's just "thoughts and prayers" with vandalism.
To people replying to Ksenia with "read history, he was horrible and so are you"; know that Ksenia could infact be Native American herself. Please re-read her statement through those lenses.
Load More Replies...I am Native American, and the past is the past. We cannot change it, or reimburse for it for any race of people. We can only change the future and the present. I do not condone destruction of property of any type. Violence and destruction is only going to yield violence and destruction. There are ways to legally have had this statue removed, recycled, and or repurposed.
Even if you all rip down Statues of such Ppl, it wont change the Fact theyr Part of the History, and only looking for the negative Part isnt good either.
OTOH, the Columbus legends have enjoyed over 500 years of sanitized good publicity in the history books, schools, museums and other cultural institutions. After half a millennium, some iconoclastic corrections are inevitable.
Load More Replies...A metal statue set on fire? Now that sounds like the really clever oney were at work...
Bronze statues are hollow and surprisingly thin. That's why it's so easy to decapitate them. In fact, they require quite a bit maintenance. Hailstones, birds and regular movements of the Earth cause holes and cracks in them. Setting them on fire warps ave cracks them, then dousing them in cold water really does a number on them.
Load More Replies...By the way, Columbus never found "america". That was a guy named Amerigo Vespucci.
If we want to get really technical, it was the Norse, specifically the merchant, Bjarni Herjoifsson. First (officially) physically visited by Leif Erikson in 1000 AD.
Load More Replies...By doing so you'll forget the history. You can't just erase eras that you don't like or agree with. That'll only lead to future people repeating the same mistakes. Btw, no one knows for sure where Columbus came from, but the expedition was financed by the Spanish Crown. There were for sure murders and some violence, yet the Spaniards weren't sanguinary people. They married indigenous people and accepted their culture. Their only aim was to spread the Catholicism. He wasn't the first man to travel to America, yet the first one to make it public in Europe. Also, the vikings only reached Canada and Columbus explored North and South America. Countries celebrate his discovery because of the changes it provoked in the known world. How would you feel if, suddenly, someone discovered a new continent out of nothing in an era where you thought everything had already been discovered? It was a huge milestone in history.
Your core argument is not well considered. The monuments celebrate individuals who no longer meet the criteria for public honor. That's why statues of dictators are removed when the dictators are removed from office. But that doesn't remove their actions from history. You know full well what Hitler did, but it doesn't require a statue to him to remind you.
Load More Replies...There is so much nonsense fake-history about Columbus these days. He's currently blamed for everything that happened during his time-frame. For instance, impressions that he had anything to do with slavery, is a plain distortion of historical evidence. And modern "historians" want to paint him with all manner of evil intent, when we can read in Columbus's own words why he took those journeys.
By extension of this line of reasoning, I am so looking forward to Donald Trump’s autobiography “in his own words” to set the historical record completely, absolutely, indisputably and unimpeachably 100% straight once and for all. After all, what could be closer to the real truth of actual historical events than the transcriptions by his own hand, corroborated by his own inner circle, play-by-play from his own unchallenged recollections, once the first-person narrative by this self-declared “very stable genius” have been memorialized in the printed word?
Load More Replies...He didn't kill hundreds of thousands. Do you ever read?
Load More Replies...Statue of Frank Rizzo (American police officer and politician) in Center City Philadelphia, taken down on June 2, 2020 for his strong opposition against desegregation.
My family hated that man. I heard some horrible stories about him. How he treated blacks was despicable.
the guy was not only a racist, he was corrupt and incompetent on many levels and people knew it while he was alive. I'm amazed he had a statue up in the first place.
Frank Rizzo, he works on race cars, you bring in a tank, he'll sell the f*****g thing.
A Confederate memorial in Jacksonville, Florida, taken down on June 9, 2020 as part of the mayor's plan to remove all confederate monuments, memorials, and markers during the George Floyd protests.
the column is beautiful, maybe they could have change this monument a bit, not take down entirely
I'd love to see the bases of these statues repurposed for more deserving historical figures.
Load More Replies...removing history. history cant be left only with the good moments but with the bad moments as well.
the mayor's plan? I doubt that. More like the mayor's fear of reprisals. They're all running scared
Maybe the name of the city will have to be changed. The school board is planning to rename several schools named for confederate generals.
Load More Replies...Sorry I'm late! It still is part of history, but they probably removed it cause they don't want to glorify him with a statue he doesn't deserve.
Load More Replies...Statue of Edward Ward Carmack (newspaperman and political figure) in Tennessee Capitol, taken down in June, 2020 for his views against African Americans and encouraged retaliation against the support of the Civil Rights Movement.
I work across the street from that statue. What this story doesn't tell you is that right behind that statue, in the state capitol sits a bust of the man who started the KKK , and the legislature has refused to take it down 3-4 years in a row because "its a part of history"
If you don't agree with popular sentiment, you must be destroyed. It is but to laugh...humans really are laughable.
It's not that he 'didn't agree with popular sentiment' - at the time it was not so unpopular. The reason his statue is being 'destroyed' is because of his racist views, and what's truly laughable is your casual ignorance.
Load More Replies...Statue of J.F.C. Hamilton (British Naval Officer and namesake of Hamilton City) in Hamilton, New Zealand, taken down on June 12, 2020 by the request of the Maori Tribal Confederation Waikato Tainui.
Think some people need to research the mans history looks like he died very shortly after he arrived in NZ so couldn't have been responsible for anything
The only reason he has a statue at all is because he died shortly after arriving. In a Battle fighting the Maori. So why should he have a statue in the first place?
Load More Replies...all the british statues that represents their "political or historical figures" should be taken down. how did the british empire got born? by invasions, oppresion, stealing other nations resources and so on
How literally every nation was born from every nation in Africa to Asia, and from there to the west; I say that as an Irish person, my people were genocided by the English. Every nation has a history of human history
Load More Replies..."One Riot, One Ranger" statue In Dallas, Texas, removed on June 4, 2020 for its reference to a riot by a white lynch mob and for the statue's model being used in helping prevent black students from enrolling in public schools.
I'm confused by the history of this statue and find the explanation provided ambiguous. Maybe in just being thick. Could someone clarify?
The statue is modelled after a Texas Ranger named Jay Banks, who lead a Ranger division charged with preventing Black students from enrolling in local schools. The "One Riot One Ranger" phrase comes from a trial at Grayson County Courthouse where a mob of people set fire the courthouse, killing a Black man who had been accused of assaulting a white woman.
Load More Replies...No they aren't. Statues are meant to celebrate, glorify or commemorate someone. There are other ways to remember.
Load More Replies...Statue of Cecil John Rhodes (British mining magnate and politician) in Cape Town, South Africa, taken down on 9 April, 2015 as part of a protest to decolonialize education in South Africa.
Why then do the same people who tore down this statue accept the famed "Rhodes scholarship" to study at Oxford??? Funny how the scholarship is less offensive
For the same reason people accept the Nobel Peace Prize from the guy responsible for the highest body count in history.
Load More Replies...Dunham Massey Hall Sundial, taken down in June, 2020 as a degrading depiction of slavery during the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests.
when came the point when people accepted this depiction as "norm"?? Racism, nazism, and other diminishing ideology didn't become accepted over night... it's a slow process.... starting from making fun of different human features, finishing with gas chambers. We need to be aware of small things to prevent big ones. It's horrible what human to human can do...
I am not supporting the statue's return, however it was erected in front of this estate house prior to 1750. The entire estate now serves as a museum. And museums are where antiquated understandings of race and inequality belong.
Load More Replies...WTF! How the hell did that EVER manage to get put up, and STAY up?
Trying to erase history will not make it go away, I feel this is one of many that should have been left as is so people do not forget.
Statue of Orville L. Hubbard (Mayor of Dearborn) in Dearborn, Michigan, taken down on September 29, 2015 due to his strong views and policies supporting racial segregation.
Statue of Robert Milligan (Scottish merchant) in the Museum of London Docklands, taken down on June 9, 2020 for him being a slave owner.
Agree with other comments. We have history books. Statues are for deserving individuals who did amazing memorable things.
History books told you Betsy Ross designed and created the first American flag, and that Andrew Jackson was simply protecting pioneers from being mercilessly slaughtered for no apparent reason
Load More Replies...I don't disagree with taking this down but if we're taking down statues of people who owned slaves, that includes a lot of founding fathers BTW.
Haha. I literally spat out my drink. Take my upvote already
Load More Replies...Here come the hate comments on this but here we go. This is for all the statues just in general. I think that a lot of the statues should go but maybe we should look into seeing if the people freed their slaves once they were shown that slave owning was wrong. If they were figures that invested a lot into this country and should that not be commemorated if they learned the error of their ways? After all that is how a country grows and learns. Thankfully with each generation we become more compassionate to those around us and we are not our ancestors mistakes.
"Robt"? Did they run out of space to include all the letters? Is that a common abbreviation in Scotland? (Google is not helping me out here.)
Bob or Rob is the way I've known people called Robert to have their names shortened! I suspect he wasn't known by an affectionate abbreviation (not a shock seeing as he seems to be a wee bawbag) of his name and there was not enough room.
Load More Replies...This guy isn't Scottish he's more of an English person, not a Scottish person
Books can be a helpful way to remember history
Load More Replies...Monument to Robert E. Lee (Confederate General) in New Orleans, Louisiana, taken down on May 19, 2017 as part of a removal of four monuments associated with the Confederacy.
Public statues are a symbol of honor. Archaic statues, such as those of Roman tyrants, only belong in museums. History, if written as objectively as possible, will not forget the abject losers of the civil war. These deplorables authorized and administered the crime of human bondage the results of which we are still suffering. But they will not be lost to history just because they will no longer be allowed to be honored publicly.
I hope they put these statues in a place that explains history better (and obviously does not celebrate these folks)... then use the empty pedestals to celebrate the many many great people who have fought and died for equality and freedom.
History is still history! Removing confederate statues doesn't change or negate the fact that the Civil War was a part of American History.
“As regards the erection of such a monument as is contemplated my conviction is, that however grateful it would be to the feelings of the South, the attempt in the present condition of the Country, would have the effect of retarding, instead of accelerating its accomplishment; [and] of continuing, if not adding to, the difficulties under which the Southern people labour.” -- Robert E. Lee
Even Robert E Lee didn't want statues commemorating the Confederacy. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/robert-e-lee-opposed-confederate-monuments
That’s what museums are for. Removing the statues doesn’t remove the history, destroying them isn’t a great idea, but leaving them in public isn’t fair on the people that feel marginalised by them. Just put them in a museum, and write the history of the person AND the statue. It’s historically significant that these are being removed now. It should be documented and remembered.
Load More Replies...Statue of Michael Jackson (American singer) in London, though officially not stated, it is speculated that it was removed in September, 2013 due to sexual allegations against Jackson.
I've never been sure of this case. The accusers made a lot of money from it. I think Jackson was strange, but not necessarily a pedophile. The guy who wrote "Alice in Wonderland" had a thing for little girls, but as far as I know he never acted on it. He sublimated it.
Load More Replies...how often did they have to change the face on that statue before they got rid of it?
Michel Jackson IS NOT A PEDOPHILE. Creepy yes but did not abuse kids.
Just because he did something good for music doesn't mean that he couldn't be a pedo
Load More Replies...He was Innocent. Was blackmailed for money. Too many kids had a positive experience. Blackmailers were in for money and still are
Statue of Jefferson Davis in Frankfort, Kentucky, moved on June 13, 2020 by a vote of the Historic Properties Advisory Commission to the Jefferson Davis State Historic Site due to him being a slave owner.
He was more than a slave owner. He was the president of the Confederate States from 1861 to 1865.
Or you know, just a little thing called "Being the President of the Confederate Sates of America"? Not just a slave owner.
From what I've heard, the guy was a bloody overconfident, hot-headed bastard when the Confederates started to really lose.
If you look at accounts from his contemporaries, he was actually a pretty s****y leader.
Load More Replies...I live in Kentucky, it's apalling!!! We must remove Abe Lincoln statue to make it fair as bad as I hate to say it! Remove all Martin Luther King statues too! This must be fair to all!
Trump would have slaves if he thought he could get away with it
Load More Replies...Bust of John Mcdonogh in New Orleans, Louisiana, taken down on June 13, 2020 for being a slave owner.
This is a little tricky, because a lot of people owned slaves including presidents.
That's the thing, USA wouldn't be USA if not for the free labor done by slaves. Should we learn about this people in history yes, but we shouldn't admire their character.
Load More Replies...If we are gonna get rid of statues because they were slave owners then half of the dc monumunts should be torn down.
While I don’t think any of those people should have statues, you really can’t fault a person for being a man of their time. Ownig slaves was normal then just as holding animals in captivity is now.
It's a matter of how they treated the slaves and not that they had slaves because back then, they didn't know and everyone was a slave owner. But don't take them down just because of that, the reason there are statues of them are because of their actions and how they handled their problems and how they treated one another.
Yes but that doesn't mean we should glorify it w a statue anymore. Times have changed and we need to accept that this is also historic now much better people in the USA that we can glorify w a statue.
Load More Replies...Statue of Jerry Richardson (Former NFL Owner) in Charlotte, North Carolina, taken down to prevent possible vandalism due to allegations of sexual harassment and racist remarks to his former employees.
Completely fictitious large cat statues on either side. You can tell this is the sort of nouveau riche twat that places lion statues at the gates to a newly built house.
If statues are being removed for people talking trash, God help this country!
Statue of Kate Smith (American singer) at the Xfinity Live! Philadelphia Arena, taken down on April 21, 2019 due to controversy surrounding her 1931 recordings of "That's Why Darkies Were Born" and "Pickaninny Heaven".
If people knew history before acting like idiots. The song "Why Darkies Were Born" was a satire song she co-wrote with an African-American song writer, Paul Robeson, making fun of white racists and racism. In fact they both sung the song together on stage several times. "Pickaninny Heaven" was another Paul Robeson song she sung with him as well. While she was documented as having some racist views, they were par for the course for her time in the 1930's. On the other hand she opposed segregation and was friends with many of the African-American singers of her day.
She was literally against racism and segregation, the songs lyrics are satirical; just because her language is antiquated by modern standards doesn't mean her views on the topic are. The people who tore this down are probably a similar level of intelligence to the racists she was criticising
Whoever comissioned a statue with the open mouth pointed to the sky, forgot about pigeons.
She also was famous during World War 2, for her many associations with the song, "God Bless America."
https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=kate+smith+god+bless+america+youtube&view=detail&mid=AF3D2CAA462A8637F76DAF3D2CAA462A8637F76D&FORM=VIRE0&ru=%2fsearch%3fq%3dkate%2bsmith%2bgod%2bbless%2bamerica%2byoutube%26form%3dWNSGPH%26qs%3dAS%26cvid%3db28f7c7ccb9742efaf64f696c3ee73d1%26pq%3dkate%2bsmith%2bgod%2bble%26cc%3dCA%26setlang%3den-CA%26nclid%3dE1935534199BB1189D88257CB46C1E7F%26ts%3d1592607786664%26nclidts%3d1592607786%26tsms%3d664%26wsso%3dModerate
This statue is ugly, but I don’t think it should have been removed for her racist songs. Those sort of minstrel-ish songs were unfortunately par for the course for the 1930’s, and many other white performers of the era have the same or worse in their catalogue. Also, Kate Smith had a long and illustrious career, and two offensive songs are not representative of her legacy.
If you look at the song lyrics themselves and consider the verbiage of the era, the songs were not racist.
Load More Replies...Statue of Williams Carter Wickham in Richmond, Virginia, taken down on June 6, 2020 due to him being a slave owner.
Yea. a lot of people owned slaves, that was a social norm. I think that isn't a reason to take down the statue... if they were in some way a symbol of racial oppression, that's another story. Also there is a difference between pulled over by protesters and the city removed it.
How is being a slave owner NOT a symbol of racial oppression?
Load More Replies...My question is, why did he have a statue in the first place? Did he do anything that might be considered redeeming? Or did he just buy it because he had a lot of money? I seriously have never heard of this guy, and I love history.
Statue of Appomattox in Alexandria, Virginia, removed on June 2, 2020, was planned for removal after long discussions by the owner, United Daughters of the Confederacy.
The South was and is part of this country. That type of attitude is what split this nation before. I am sick of this racist South stereotype. Ask yourself where was George Floyd killed? It is not like slavery ended, and the entire country embraced African Americans as part of their country and culture. Somehow the Spanish have escaped fault for their massive role in the slave trade.
Load More Replies...Those "daughters" if they really know their history should know that they too were just property to be sold or "married" off by their owners or "fathers" at any time. Clearly they like their whore/slave status. #brainwasheddummies
It is literally a statue marking where Apoomattox southern troops departed from to fight in the civil war; it isn't even making a statement, it is just marking history. This kind of censorship is why history is repeated by the "revolutionaries"
I just find it difficult to read human beings celebrating the death of real people without knowing if they even supported such things or not. These were human beings, in spite of their possible beliefs.
this isn't about you, Ryleigh. please go stand in the corner and be quiet.
Load More Replies...Jefferson Davis Memorial in Richmond, Virginia, taken down on June 10, 2020 by protesters for depicting Jefferson Davis, a slave owner.
if instead of him they put a godess or an eagle or something and make a fountain at his feet this could have been reused :)
Yes. It’s so sad we’re destroying these beautiful things when we could just fix them or build new ones
Load More Replies...He was more than a slave owner. He was the president of the Confederate States from 1861 to 1865.
sino8r is clearly a child of the South. The only "States' Right" the South was really fighting for was the "right" to allow the enslavement of human beings -- despite the indoctrination you received in your history class.
Yes. Doesn't mean we need statues of presidents either. We know all about them. The White House was built by slaves as well.
Load More Replies...was replaced for a time with a basketball hoop so one could dunk on the confederacy.
Protestors did not take this down, anarchists did. True protestors are not violent or destructive.
Monument to Robert E. Lee (Confederate General) in New Orleans, Louisiana, taken down on May 19, 2017 as part of a removal of four monuments associated with the Confederacy.
Captioned incorrectly. That is a picture of JEB Stuart on Monument Ave in Richmond VA
Pretty funny screw up, his name is even in the picture!
Load More Replies...Statue of Charles Linn (Captain in the Confederate Navy) in Birmingham, Alabaman, toppled on May 31, 2020 by protestors who unsuccessfully attempted to remove the nearby Confederate Soldiers and Sailors Monument.
They attempted to remove a statue commemorating soliders who fought and died? These people are the worst; they deal on absolutes but nearly all absolutes are wrong because nothing is. They think all soliders except those on this side of history had no redeeming qualities or moral complexity to their characters. This is honouring the dead.
Slave Auction Block in Fredericksburg, Virginia, taken down on June 5, 2020 as a symbol of racial oppression.
This should have been left. there is no better symbol of the atrocities of slavery, than to view the worn and weathered block men and women were stood upon to be sold as a commodity. This is not an insult, this is a testament
it was put in a museum. it's still intact and everything.
Load More Replies...So shall we tear down Auschwitz as well? This is in no way glorifying the past, it's there to make us remember. You know, with the not remembering and repeating...
It was put in a museum, so it's not forgotten. The point is it can be triggering for someone to have to walk by this everyday. You kinda have to go out of your way to visit Auschwitz everyday, so it's a choice to visit. This is in a busy city where POC have no choice. Now they have a choice to visit it in a museum if they want to reflect on the past.
Load More Replies...Nia loves art is having a hard time grasping what blm is all about. Don't need your opinion on it. You're not black or a member of the black community that should have the only opinion on what to do w these racist statues and friggin auction blocks. For the love of god it's not hard to understand friggin empathize! Shame on you once again
I think there is a difference between taking down statues that glorify racists and sexual predators, and removing something that is just a piece of history... did this auction block glorify the slave trade?
Well ... yes! Can you imagine having to walk past that every day? It would make me extremely uncomfortable.
Load More Replies...Ugh for all the people saying these statues is history being removed why do the statues have to be all of white racists. How about we put up statues of all the black leaders we don't learn about. It's the same history but not from the perspective of a white racist rapist murdering slave owners.Same history! No more glorious statues of awful people and how about we ask what black peoples want. We have to agree that would be a good idea since it does not affect us white people
Confederate Soldiers and Sailors Monument in Birmingham, Alabama, removed in June, 2020, said to be taken down to ease continuing unrest originating from the George Floyd protests.
I have to disagree with this one. I understand removing confederate flags, but this is more a memorial than a glorification. However, not living in Alabama, it's hard to see how this is perceived there.
This is like removing the headstone off of a grave without even reading the inscription
This is essentially a tombstone. Imagine somebody coming to a graveyard and ripping up your granddad's tombstone because they thought he had a certain ideology.
The saddest excuse for further destruction..History is something that happened! You can remove statues till you are blue in the face, but you cannot undo facts!
Monuments are not facts. At best they are hagiography but mostly they are revisionist history. History doesn't require a statue.
Load More Replies...Considering they're all long dead, we can just make on wall of names of people who died in the civil war regardless of the side they fought on, as many fought on both sides (look it up). One wall, one war, one memorial, no sides, one country, and be done with it
Oml please stop. These people don't deserve statues, they don't deserve to be remembered for their actions. They fought for a horrible cause. All this is in the books, we don't need to have statues of such awful people up.
Load More Replies...History cannot be unmade. Educating people is more important than destroying pieces of art, even if they do not show people who deserve honour. Would you also destroy the masks of Pharaos? Undoubtedly, they had people killed and tortured and kept slaves. These masks document history and art thoguh. muesums are the right places for them!
Most of these statues were erected decades after the Civil War at the beginning of the Civil Rights movement. They were erected to remind blacks they were inferior to whites. While you are arguing for education and historical significance, it would be good to know all of the facts. I don't see those little fact nuggets inscribed on the statues. Yet, they can be posted next to the statues in museums, just like the Pharaoh masks.
Load More Replies...Important to remember that a good portion of these statues weren't made because they were important historical figures, but because they were wealthy men. Hopefully we can replace them with more deserving historical figures.
Most of these statues were places in the early 60's at the height of the Civil Rights movement to remind black Americans that they were inferior to whites. They were placed as a monument to those that owned slaves so as to say to the black population, "See this guy, he owned slaves so we honor him. We are superior to you." It is saddest time in the US History.
Load More Replies...If I am not mistaken, there were numerous requests made to government officials to take down at least some of these statues and the statues weren't removed. Please consider that before you condemn folks for taking them down. It's still happening - POTUS has been asked to rename military bases named after Confederate officers/officials and he has said he won't. And, if you are OK with the citizens of Iraq taking down the statue of Sadam Hussein but opposed people in America taking down statues of slave traders, opponents of segregation, men who committed acts of violence against women and/or children, you are a hypocrite as far as I am concerned.
POTUS is a far right sympathiser, straight up, and so all of those support him and love him and think he's'doing a great job'. I see nothing wrong with taking down these statues. Just because they were 'fine' once upon a time, doesn't mean they have to stay now that we find their origins offensive. They're just statues. It's not like anyone's being killed, just bronze or resin.
Load More Replies...I don't buy the argument that people think these should remain for Historical reasons. First, because many of these were erected during the Civil Rights Movement as a huge f**k you to the black community. They did it out of racism rather than a love of history, and they did it in prominent public spaces. 2) Given the time gap between the Civil War and Civil Rights Movement, it would be like Germany erecting Hitler statues in prominent public spaces today, you okay with that? You going to stand by that decision? 3) I am kind of hope they put the spray painted ones in museums under BLM sections. If we want to keep a piece of history, which I do agree with, keep it where it belongs, not in our town squares.
There are not a lot of statues of people who did not abuse their power in any way. Queen Victoria is not better as Cecil Rhodes or Leopold II of Belgium. Will we also change all presidents on the dollar bills, who had slaves?
Why. Goerge washington... Christopher Columbus Our first president and the guy who discovered America It's asinine to destroy these works of art
Load More Replies...Textbooks exist. I know about all of these people without having to see their bronzed faces everyday. This is not erasing history. Taking down a Jefferson Davis statue doesn’t erase him in the conscious of the public. It’s not like we’ll forget who he was or that he existed, again, textbooks. Statues do not present a layered account of a person’s life and what they were like. They are a glorified depiction of a complicated person. Taking down these statues is more symbolic than what the statues represent. It’s a show of solidarity and an acknowledgment that enshrining racists, slave owners, and sex offenders in the name of “education” is neither aligned with the general view of the public (I hope), nor the best way to educate people about them.
Emma Clark : very important point made and well said. Thank you!
Load More Replies...While some of these make sense to remove others do not. Just because someone in the 1700's, a time where Slavery was legal in every country in the world owned slaves is not a good reason. Some should be removed, others should not.
People tend to conveniently forget that a lot of African slaves were sold by African slave owners, particularly the Ashanti people who sold them in exchange for guns. Before people bombard me with incorrect accusations, I'm obviously not saying it wasn't still an horrific event but why don't people comment on that? Ah yes, because it doesn't fit the left's agenda. Modern day slavery exists all over the world, why isn't that being addressed?
Load More Replies...History cannot be unmade. Educating people is more important than destroying pieces of art, even if they do not show people who deserve honour. Would you also destroy the masks of Pharaos? Undoubtedly, they had people killed and tortured and kept slaves. These masks document history and art thoguh. muesums are the right places for them!
Most of these statues were erected decades after the Civil War at the beginning of the Civil Rights movement. They were erected to remind blacks they were inferior to whites. While you are arguing for education and historical significance, it would be good to know all of the facts. I don't see those little fact nuggets inscribed on the statues. Yet, they can be posted next to the statues in museums, just like the Pharaoh masks.
Load More Replies...Important to remember that a good portion of these statues weren't made because they were important historical figures, but because they were wealthy men. Hopefully we can replace them with more deserving historical figures.
Most of these statues were places in the early 60's at the height of the Civil Rights movement to remind black Americans that they were inferior to whites. They were placed as a monument to those that owned slaves so as to say to the black population, "See this guy, he owned slaves so we honor him. We are superior to you." It is saddest time in the US History.
Load More Replies...If I am not mistaken, there were numerous requests made to government officials to take down at least some of these statues and the statues weren't removed. Please consider that before you condemn folks for taking them down. It's still happening - POTUS has been asked to rename military bases named after Confederate officers/officials and he has said he won't. And, if you are OK with the citizens of Iraq taking down the statue of Sadam Hussein but opposed people in America taking down statues of slave traders, opponents of segregation, men who committed acts of violence against women and/or children, you are a hypocrite as far as I am concerned.
POTUS is a far right sympathiser, straight up, and so all of those support him and love him and think he's'doing a great job'. I see nothing wrong with taking down these statues. Just because they were 'fine' once upon a time, doesn't mean they have to stay now that we find their origins offensive. They're just statues. It's not like anyone's being killed, just bronze or resin.
Load More Replies...I don't buy the argument that people think these should remain for Historical reasons. First, because many of these were erected during the Civil Rights Movement as a huge f**k you to the black community. They did it out of racism rather than a love of history, and they did it in prominent public spaces. 2) Given the time gap between the Civil War and Civil Rights Movement, it would be like Germany erecting Hitler statues in prominent public spaces today, you okay with that? You going to stand by that decision? 3) I am kind of hope they put the spray painted ones in museums under BLM sections. If we want to keep a piece of history, which I do agree with, keep it where it belongs, not in our town squares.
There are not a lot of statues of people who did not abuse their power in any way. Queen Victoria is not better as Cecil Rhodes or Leopold II of Belgium. Will we also change all presidents on the dollar bills, who had slaves?
Why. Goerge washington... Christopher Columbus Our first president and the guy who discovered America It's asinine to destroy these works of art
Load More Replies...Textbooks exist. I know about all of these people without having to see their bronzed faces everyday. This is not erasing history. Taking down a Jefferson Davis statue doesn’t erase him in the conscious of the public. It’s not like we’ll forget who he was or that he existed, again, textbooks. Statues do not present a layered account of a person’s life and what they were like. They are a glorified depiction of a complicated person. Taking down these statues is more symbolic than what the statues represent. It’s a show of solidarity and an acknowledgment that enshrining racists, slave owners, and sex offenders in the name of “education” is neither aligned with the general view of the public (I hope), nor the best way to educate people about them.
Emma Clark : very important point made and well said. Thank you!
Load More Replies...While some of these make sense to remove others do not. Just because someone in the 1700's, a time where Slavery was legal in every country in the world owned slaves is not a good reason. Some should be removed, others should not.
People tend to conveniently forget that a lot of African slaves were sold by African slave owners, particularly the Ashanti people who sold them in exchange for guns. Before people bombard me with incorrect accusations, I'm obviously not saying it wasn't still an horrific event but why don't people comment on that? Ah yes, because it doesn't fit the left's agenda. Modern day slavery exists all over the world, why isn't that being addressed?
Load More Replies...
