Don’t believe everything that you read online or hear in person. Just because something gets repeated over and over again does not make it true. This sort of misinformation isn’t just related to the news, however. You can even find it in the world of gastronomy.
The passionate members of the r/Cooking online community banded together to reveal the top cooking myths that continue to be shared. We’ve collected some of the most egregious ones to be aware of. Read on to check these myths out.
This post may include affiliate links.
The "Detox" trend.
It makes no sense as it's your liver and kidneys that detox your body.
Just eat a balanced diet and you should be fine.
Idk why this isn't upvoted more. A cup of water right when you get up out of bed, will wake you up faster than coffee. Dehydration does a lot to yalls systems
Load More Replies...The whole "detox" thing feels like a perfectly reasonable idea, that got turned up to insanity. Realizing you have not been eating well lately and aren't feeling your best, so you cut out 100% of the junk food for a set period of time, and really focus on fresh fruits and veggies and getting enough water is a great plan. Making weird smoothies to intentionally give yourself diarrhea and starve yourself for a few days is just nuts.
Yup. It's a bunch of pseudoscientific woo. Drink the drinks because they're good sources of healthy nutrition and they taste good, not because they magically "detoxify" you That's what you have a liver and kidneys for.
That's assuming you are not over indulging in alcohol or drugs, too much red meat or other meat that is pumped full of antibiotics for no reason but to make them grow bigger. If you are over imbibing, you need to flush the system. Don't know if you need special drinks but definitely water, lots of tap water. Skip plastic bottles
Load More Replies...Phrases containing "cleanse" or "detox" are both reasons to ignore any further health advice from someone.
because lungs arent as interesting for faux crunchie types.
Load More Replies...Also to completely get rid of something out of your body takes weeks and months, not single weekend in fancy hotel. Ask any celiac - they are gluten free after six months or longer.
Stop telling me a recipe takes 25 minutes to make.
It takes me that long to get the ingredients from the fridge and finding the right bowl. Then cleaning out the sink. Need to empty the dishwasher first. Make room on the kitchen bench....
Maybe it takes 25 minutes to cook but who will talk about the extra 50 mins to soak ingredients, cut, chop other things, make pastes/spice mixes.
Mise en place, made by your kitchen staff obviously.. 😅😏
Load More Replies...yes and this is fine. its a food recipe not a tutorial on how to adult and keep your stuff tidy.
Yeah, I'm going to call BS on this one. Just because you're inefficient doesn't mean the recipe time is wrong. As long as a reasonably capable cook can do it in 25 minutes then that's accurate.
Forgot the 5 minutes to find the recipe on the webpage because they included their life story but not a "jump to recipe" option.
I don't understand why OP is coming off with such a smarmy attitude. Cleaning out a sink, emptying a dishwasher and making space for yourself to cook have nothing to do with what a recipe calls for in cook time. That is all s**t you do before you start cooking. Most recipes include what is called "prep time" in addition but that is for hands on preparation of the food itself, not getting your dirty a*s kitchen ready to cook in.
STEP 1: Preheat oven to 450º. STEPs 2–15: Here's 45 minutes of work to do while your oven was hot 35 minutes longer than it needed to be.
This! Take a moment to learn how long your oven needs to pre-heat, and just start pre-heating then. My oven is very fast so it is not unusual for me to have almost finished the work before I turn on the oven, and more often than not my oven still beats me to it.
Honestly, I don't see why this is a problem. Don't people read the recipe before trying it? Surely you would read it and say "Hmm that seems like a lot of prep. I won't turn on my oven to pre-heat until the appropriate time". The OP is just nitpicking.
Load More Replies...again, a recipe is not a tutorial on how your stuff works and how to keep your kitchen tidy. that's your responsability. the recipe is about the food and little else. yes, it requires you to pre heat your oven. When ? who the f**k knows ? its YOUR oven. you should know how long it takes to heat up.
Thank you. I'm only 3 posts into this article and my skin is already crawling from the ignorant entitled attitudes people have with what they're saying. You either know how to follow recipes and cook and how your equipment works or you don't.
Load More Replies...This isn't really fair. They put that first so it's easy to find the info when you need it. Since everyone's oven heats up at a different rate, and everyone works at a different rate, how would they know where in the steps to put the "preheat oven" instruction? They assume you're smart enough to know to do it when you're getting close to the end.
Or *gasp* turn on the oven after preparing everything. Stuff doesn´t go bad on the spot if it stands arounds a couple of minutes while waiting for the oven to get warm.
Unless I am baking I never preheat. Food still cooks in the required time. The only time you -really- need to preheat is when you are making something needs the higher temperature right from the start in order to create a reaction (rising/puffing), like bread, pastry etc.
Plus the ones who say preheat your oven, then you mix up your dough and it says refrigerate overnight.
If, at some point in your life, you’ve believed any of these cooking myths, then you’re not alone. It’s a very natural thing. People tend to believe information that they’re exposed to on a constant basis. To put it simply, the more often we hear something, the more likely we are to think that it’s true.
This is known as the illusory truth effect, and it’s how misinformation spreads. We can fall victim to the effects of repetition even if we’re highly educated and self-aware. This is because we’re exposed to so much information in our day-to-day lives that we need to simplify the way we make decisions. The more often we come across certain claims, the more familiar we become with them, meaning we’re more inclined to see them as valid.
When people say something isn't healthy because it isn't calorie free. "Pasta isn't healthy. You should use spaghetti squash." Or "rice isn't healthy. You should use cauliflower." I think there is a time and a place for those things, but carbohydrates are actually healthy for you.
Carbohydrates are healthy. Salt is healthy. Fat is healthy. Water is healthy. But in moderation. Even water can cause harm if you drink too much clean water, you will demineralize your body and you will have headaches. If you don't eat enough salt, you will have muscle cramps, if you eat too much your heart will race like crazy. Moderation is the key for good life.
This is the most intelligent comment on the internet to date.
Load More Replies...Carbohydrates are healthy for you, but processed white pasta really isn't doing much for your body.
Umm. It's filling me up. That's something. Balance it with protein and veg I see no problem.
Load More Replies...About the only "food" you should avoid is super saturated fat, blowfish which can kill you if not prepared properly, and highly processed foods.
I would say only really blowfish. If you don't do it every day, saturated fat and highly processed food will do nothing for you
Load More Replies...That reminds me of the woman who asked in a forum whether it would be a good idea to use Stevia in home made hummingbird nectar, so the hummingbirds would not get all that evil sugar. Ehm- that's what hummingbirds eat. Imagine those little guys filling up on what they believe is nectar, and all they get is calorie-free sweet water..
Spaghetti squash my @ss, people have been enjoying pasta for hundreds of years and didn't need to substitute a squash product before. That's your preference/necessity, own it and STFU and let the rest of us enjoy our pasta or rice. We don't care what your preference is, Myrna, and you can go on till the cows come home about it's "benefits" but at the end of the day, it's your CHOICE.
Not all carbs are created equally. Whole grains and complex carbs can be fine but we strip all the fiber and nutrients out of everything because it tastes better. Therein lies the problem.
Highly processed carbs are still carbs though and it's better to eat them then to eat no carbs at all. Like, sometimes you just need to get a doughnut so you can think straight again.
Load More Replies...
As soon as the word "superfood" appears, I'm out.
I kind of agree, but it's undeniable that some foods are more nutrient dense than others and, if possible, these should be favoured.
That's the key: foods should be referred to as "nutrient dense" or "nutrient poor". Superfood is a buzz word created by a clever ad agency.
Load More Replies...As soon as the word superfood appears, I ask myself, "do I like it anyway?" and "does this cost way too much?" If yes to the first and no to the second, I'll eat it.
I'm Dutch, and kale is an old-fashioned winter food here. It's part of the beloved national dish "Stamppot Boerenkool", which most families eat weekly during the cold season.▪️▪️▪️ When it was branded a superfood and sold for top dollar we collectively peed our wooden shoes in laughter. It's dirt cheap here, and just a cabbage. ▪️▪️▪️We still frown or laugh at kale smoothies. Just boil it with potatoes, make a creamy mash, add baked lardons, brown gravy, and a smoked sausage. Perfection!
Also promoting "superfoods" can put high environmental pressure on the regions where it is produced and once the fad is over, the farmers are left to their own devices. Take chia seeds, for example. When they were the new superfood a few years ago, some newspaper article pointed out that flaxseeds have almost the same properties, grow in my region and don't even cost half as much.
Chia seeds are good, really tasteless and flax is just nasty. I don't know if flax lowers A1C but chia does
Load More Replies...just wondering what superlative will came after "super".... megafood, hyperfood, or food²?
Me too, when I hear the word Superfood I know it's going to be something that's overpriced and will disappear from the shelves as soon as the next one becomes the latest trend
What gets me is that? It always seems to be some kind of obscure fruit or vegetable and some tropical country that no one has ever heard of any cures cancer, insomnia, bad credit, death, Resurrection…
There are some foods that per equivalent weight hold far more vitamins and minerals than many others. Spinach has far more vitamins and minerals then ice berg lettuce. Choose vegetables with deeper and more color than pale or white ones.
One of the best is stinging nettles. It has stinging hairs because it doesn't have chemicals like tannins which bind to the protein to discourage browsers.
Load More Replies...
Someone one told me they don’t use salt when they cook because “people can add salt to their own portion if they want”. Sorry no, that’s not how seasoning works.
my approach: just use a pinch while cooking and have the others salt it to their tastes
Sometimes a pinch is not enough. Also, I heard quite often that you should season at every step, not just at the end
Load More Replies...You need to salt each ingredient as it goes in. This enhances the flavor of the final dish. You don't need a lot of salt, just a pinch
Adding salt to food DURING cooking enhances the flavours. Adding salt to food AFTER cooking makes the food taste salty.
Huh. I didn't know this. Although I had a friend whose family had a professional chef. This was back when everything was non-fat. So all the food had no fat. To try to make up for it this chef over salted everything. It was horrible. The family was so used to eating that much salt they didn't notice. But it was really awful. Sometimes it's better to leave a little room for folks to salt the dish to their tastes.
Load More Replies...I was invited to a party at someone's house once who is proudly anti-salt. She had made pizza dough from scratch (easy, with just four ingredients - I do it all the time) but left the salt out. It was practically inedible and there was tonnes left - it was such a waste of toppings!
Salt helps to bind n hold in flavors while cooking just dont add too much. If ppl want it to taste saltier they then can add more
Salt is a chemical that aids in cooking. It extracts moisture from vegetables, for instance, and helps soften them. Salting meats and fish helps them retain juices. It enhances other flavors, even sweet flavors. I salt judiciously as I cook and rarely salt after cooking. And don't be afraid of the word 'chemical'. You are made of chemicals.
My mom never used salt. We were fine with it. Dad still had a heart attack at 50. They would catch me with the container of salt, free pouring in my hand licking it up. Try to li.it salt, but do use it.
Avoiding the illusory truth effect comes down to having the time and energy to dig a little deeper. That means doing research, even about claims that we think are completely true. It helps to have a more nuanced position.
The general rule of thumb is that if you keep hearing the same claims over and over again, you may want to be slightly skeptical about them. We’ve seen this sort of misinformation in the food industry before.
When they open their recipe by saying “add garlic and onions to the pan and caramelize”…. Why do y’all like burnt garlic?
Our son was challenging my husband and I the other day about us teaching him not to put the garlic in to the pan until the onions are cooked. We had to admit we have no idea why so many (otherwise good) recipes state to put the garlic in at the same time. It burns and sticks. The garlic just needs heating through enough to remove the 'sting'.
For me one of the biggest tricks for garlic is removing the sprout. You don't have to if you will bake the garlic or if you add it to soup for at least 5 minutes, but whenever you use raw garlic, remove the sprout! It will remove the unpleasant sting, garlic burps, most of the toxic farts, and to some extend even garlic breath.
Load More Replies...This! And - caramelizing onions takes much longer than the vast majority of recipes state. A tiny hack is to add just a pinch of sugar to help it along.
Garlic should be added for no more than a minute or max two (depending on the pans heat) and always at the very end! Once you can smell it, it's done cooking
Yes, they don't cook at the same rates. Add the garlic one minute before the onions are done, so as not to burn it.
"onion takes minutes - garlic takes seconds" or so i heard
Load More Replies...If you burn the garlic while caramelizing onions, you are cooking with waaaay to much heat.
Definitely not. I cook all the time, garlic and onions are in most things I cook, and the garlic is always overcooked if you put them in the pan with the onions at the same time.
Load More Replies...Also, caramalise onions for ten minutes. Nope. It takes far longer than that. Totally worth it but so many recipes underestimate the timing and it maddens me.
“You can‘t cook with extra virgin olive oil.” Yes, you can, just don’t heat it past the smoke point.
I think they just say this for people who didn’t grow up with olive oil. Where I live olive oil is a relatively recent addition to the local cuisine and I know of people who have tried to heat like other, much more temperature tolerant oils. It is just easier to say that you cannot cook with extra virgin olive oil, than give specific temperatures. Maybe one day in the future olive oil will be as common as in Mediterranean cultures, but for now it just wouldn’t work, I think.
In parts of the Mediterranean, notably Greece, they even use olive oil to cook chips (fries). I love Greek chips, although you must not expect them to be crispy. Yes, cooked at much lower temperatures.
Load More Replies...I am Italian, this is what I do: I use the cheaper "Olive Oil Blended" for cooking. This is like the one millionth press and it's not very thick or flavorful (but still better than "oil"). Then once I am done cooking, I add my handcrafted, Extra-Virgin Olive Oil where each individual olive was sung to sleep by a certified Olive Nurse every night and left to roam the Uliveto free-range until ready for pressing.
If you can, I highly recommend trying some other oils, like rapeseed, grape seed, and sunflower. Not to replace at all, but because cooking oils do change the flavor of things and those all have different flavors. Obviously only if you're curious.
Load More Replies...I wanted to try it and made mayo tith olive oli... didn't make a good mayo but a great salad dressing.
I'm Greek and I don't like cooking with olive oil. I only use it raw. 🤷🏽♀️
I use it to sauté vegetables or to drizzle it on salads and some other preparations. For other processes, other oils (or clarified butter) seem to have a better flavor profile besides the smoking point thing. Not to mention that this advice is, I think, mostly applicable to deep frying. And where I live, it’s prohibitively expensive enough to try that, so we’re safe.
I found I have first stage fatty liver and I was advised to use only extra virgin olive oil. I have not used it for deep frying but I have cooked Indian recipes using extra virgin olive oil.
Olive oil is for eating. There are other oils for cooking. I drizzle on the plate helps the fat come through. Just buy avocado oil and canola. Mix them yourself; 25 to 75 will give flavor and you can cook anything. Finish with the good stuff.
I may be wrong here, but I'm wiling to die on this hill - there is absolutely no such thing as air frying. What you are doing is convection baking.
-- edit: I'm not knocking the appliance here, but the marketing gimmickry annoys the hell out of me. The appliances sold as "air fryers" are more efficient and better in a lot of ways, but stop calling it what it isn't. This is why we all have trust issues!
I do not think that a normal user cares if it is called air frying or convection baking. The ease of use and the final result matters.
I think the problem is that if you already HAVE a convection oven (a lot of ppl do) you can 'air fry' without buying a whole separate appliance. People wouldn't necessarily know that though, because its being marketed as something completely different that you need their special thing to accomplish. They're misleading by omission and its scammy af.
Load More Replies...One good thing about "air fryers" is that you don't need to use your whole big oven for what is aa relatively small amout of food. Plus, my stove/oven doesn't have the option of using convection.
That's why we love ours. Our oven is small about about 50 years old. It doesn't self-clean, let alone have a convection setting. It's just two of us, so the air fryer works well.
Load More Replies...I mostly agree with this sentiment. But where I live, proper convection ovens are just too expensive and hard to come by. So I just use a good sized “air-fryer” for my convection preparations and it’s all good
I live in senior housing and we have older ovens that only have one heat source from a bottom element. No convection available. My kids bought me a large tabletop French door convection oven and I use it daily. If I could just ask them to replace the big stove with more counter space and a dishwasher underneath I would cook in my tiny kitchen every day. Add two induction plates and voila!
Load More Replies...I have a convection toaster oven, purchased before air fryers really became a thing. Same process, nice and small, just the air isn't pushed around as quickly. Works for me, until it doesn't, then I'll probably get an air fryer.
Difference between and air fryer and convection oven is the placement of the heat source.
Load More Replies...I used convection fryer for almost 10 years. Switched to air fryer thinking it is literally the same, but would be just easier to use and it also looks better. I was wrong. Food, prepared or just heated in air fryers tastes so much better, than in "classic" convection frying and is way less dry.
Yeah, and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is just Nuclear Magnetic Resonance imaging, but it sounds nicer. It’s a name, not a conspiracy.
For example, last century, we saw lots of bad science and outright misinformation about all fats supposedly being bad for our health. As a result, many people started replacing the energy from fats with sugars. Fat-free foods are not automatically ‘healthier.’
Similarly, sugar isn’t somehow a purely evil supervillain, either. However, many people do eat too much sugar, which can lead to health problems down the line. We all need to avoid excess and embrace moderation in our diets. Too much of anything can be bad for us, whether that’s sugar, bad fats, or caffeine.
"Don't clean cast iron with dish soap" is the biggest one for me. Used to be true, but modern dish soap doesn't contain the lye that was the cause of the seasoning stripping.
Note, if you keep up with your cast iron **LIKE YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO** you're hardly ever going to need to use soap. Even then, it would be to remove any lingering flavors; Don't want fish taste in your cobbler!
I never use soap with a cast iron pan. Vinegar is a perfect, natural and cheap solution for that fish taste OP is talking about.
I use it almost every time, if not to much, the seasoning will be left intact. If to much, then I heat it up and apply a new coat - done. Or if I boil "Bolognese sauce" for 5 h, then the coating will almost be gone anyway and have to be reapplied. 👍
Load More Replies...I inherited a cast iron skillet from my grandmother, but my mom scared me away from using it for so long. There were so many rules about what you couldn't cook in it, and cleaning it she made it seem like it was the most fragile delicate thing ever that I would destroy if I so much as looked at it wrong. Then I started using it and realized it's practically indestructible! Even if you mess up the seasoning (finish) all you have to do is rub some oil on and stick it in the oven, and it's good as new.
Growing up, mom never washed cast iron.. but now I wash it every time with some dish soap, and as yo say just reapply oil. I Usually just heat it up on the stove, then apply oil when warm.
Load More Replies...I ALWAYS use dish soap when I wash my cast iron skillets and have NEVER had a problem.
The one thing from my childhood that my mom didn’t oversale about how awesome it was. When our house burnt she went in to get our cast iron and it’s still in use today.
But...couldn't she have just waited until after the fire was out? Of all the things to save from a fire, a cast iron pan will probably make it through just fine
Load More Replies...Lye is NOT the reason you shouldn't use soap on a cast iron. Iron reacts with oxygen to form rust. The oil is a barrier between the 2. Strip the oil off, get rust.
Lye is sodium hydroxide, it saponifies the oil, creating soap, which means it leaches the oil to bind as it's highly reactive. So if the oil, the seasoning is forced to bond with the hydroxide ion, then the cast iron loses the barrier, this exposing it to oxygen. Chemistry.
Load More Replies...Those pans they are showing in the picture are not cast iron pans. They look like so called non stick pans.
My sister Nd I have inadvertently experimented with this. My mom had 2 cast irons that she gave us each years ago. Both identical. My sister Never washes hers with soap and uses oil to clean it. I on the other hand have used soap on occasion when I was paranoid about using after something strong smelling/taste. I've only ever used good and natural soap. They have both held up really well and have had about the same use. Mine does look a bit more used though but still perfect.
I don't get cast iron, if a flavoring from your food comes from something unrelated that you cooked 5 years ago, then I'm out. I don't care if no one's ever died from it, I don't care if the heat kills the bacteria, I just can't handle it.
Seasoning is the oil coating. I can cook eggs and chorizo, then clean it and make caramelized onions without a hint chorizo flavor... I clean it with oil and salt, or hot water, or if I need to dish detergent.
Load More Replies...Cast iron is a perfect heat conductor and as so one of the best types of pans for cooking. The difference is the care- where you can't put it in the dishwasher like with other pans. You need to wash it quickly with soap and not let it soak since it will rust, and occasionally season it - which adds a non stick coating, when needed.
I use soap to get rid of lingering after taste. Rinse well and re-oil. Just a light amount of oil. Never a problem. I do reseason it periodically.
This is more diet than cooking but that fat is bad for you. Fat is flavor and nutrition
Not all fat is made equal. Some are way healthier than others. And needless to say, fat is more caloric dense than protein or carbs. If your food choices are not on point and you eat a lot of fat, you're gonna get... Well... Fat.
You can lose weight on high fat diets. Hence the Keto and Adkins trends. And my triglycerides and cholesterol actually get better when I’m eating more fats, including annimal fats, and less carbohydrates. Fat isn’t bad. Sugar and simple carbs are bad.
Load More Replies...There you go! This person gets it. It’s the combo of high fat and high carbohydrates that’s dangerous.
Load More Replies...If you look at nutrition labels for butter and lard, you can see that lard is only slightly better for you than butter. It’s all about marketing. The dairy industry did a wonderful job at villainizing animal fats and making butter a “better” alternative.
Butter is still an animal fat, just not directly from the meat.
Load More Replies...Fat is flavor 😁, but if that is pork belly, no thank you. Tried it, way too fatty for me 😕
That drinking “alkaline” water or foods is good for you. This trend is based on an experiment in essentially a Petrie dish showing cancer cells couldn’t survive at high pH. Know what else can’t survive at high pH? YOU! Your food is digested and your blood (which is pH buffered) stays at the same pH. If it didn’t you’d be in the hospital.
Your body will automatically correct the pH. That is called homeostasis: a self-regulating process by which an organism can maintain internal stability (normal pH) while adjusting to changing external conditions (higher pH).
This whole superfood and cancer near conspiracy thing makes me mad. Killing cancer cells is easy. Not killing the person in the process is the hard part.
This is why I love Chemotherapy- " we're going to poison you enough to kill everything in your body, but not kill your body.... just let us know if you're feeling too bad or can'tfeel your fingers or toes"
Load More Replies...My favorite example of this was Gwyneth Paltrow drinking alkaline water with a slice of lemon....
If people are able to really change the alkalinity of their blood, they are either dying or on their way to the emergency room. Your body has a very limited pH range conducive to life, that it handily maintains all on it's own. F*ck around with it at your own risk. Alkaline water is a marketing scam, don't fall for it.
"Balance your body pH" - A difference from 0.6 pH of the normal value can be lethal, our body already does that on it's own
What makes me laugh is people who tell me lemon juice is alkalizing. OK so yeah that's why my litmus paper tells me it's acidic.
My favorite is when people (looking at you Gwyneth!) add lemon to their alkaline water... basically turning it back to plain ol' water
Never put seafood and cheese together.
Boy, do you have some discoveries to make. Just put the *right* seafood and the *right* cheese together.
I'm just going to say that: toasted bread, cheese and anchovies... You're welcome.
Sure, that smoked salmon and cream cheese filling is a classic, had some just last week. But I've never heard anyone suggest that any seafood and cheese combo is somehow inherently 'wrong'. Lobster with a cheese sauce, anyone?
Anchovies and Parmesan-- the basis for Caesar salad dressing?
Load More Replies...There's American pasteurized cheese food product on Filet-O-Fish. That's a winning combo, isn't it?
I've never considered those a winner compared to other fast food options.
Load More Replies...I always wondered why Food Network calls cheese and seafood “anathema”. Cheese is wonderful on seafood. If I make a shrimp, fettuccine Alfredo, I guarantee you that I’m gonna have a lot of Parmesan in that.
On my country one of most popular sandwich spreads is smoked mackarel and fresh white farmers cheese [something between cottage cheese, and feta / ricotta, called tvarog, you could use labneh in a pinch]
MSG is bad for you
Did you know that tomatoes and salt form msg when you cook them together. As in most dishes with tomato base have it naturally. So does everything with umami.
It's not for everyone, but a small percentage of the population do have an intolerance to it.
Ya there's a minority of people sensitive to it alright but sometimes people blame MSG when it's actually something else. My partner was like this she found out that she's allergic to soya (not severely like some people but it makes her feel unwell) it just so happened that the dishes she had eith soya also had MSG so she was blaming the wrong culprit!
Load More Replies...I use MSG all the time. I have in on my counter to keep it on hand.
The first time in was in Malaysia I asked why there were 2 salt cellars on the table!!! I never realised it was used that way until then!! 🤦♀️I use it a lot more now it definitely enhances the flavours in some dishes.
Load More Replies...I used to be told this (migraines) but cutting foods that had higher levels of MSG made no difference, so I gave up on this (back in the 90s). I use it at home even, I love it lol
It does trigger migraines in some people, but for my daughter in law so does apples. No one would recommend doing away with all apples in the diet.
For some of us, it's a migraine trigger. And, it's artificial and a chemical...at least the one you buy - unless it's plant based
"It doesn't take long to caramelize onions"
Bs, it takes quite awhile. Those are sautéed onions that don't take long, it takes at least an hour or more to develop the sugars
It does take some time to cook them down so they leave a good fond in the pan. And just the word "caramelize" onions implies that they are cooked long enough for the sugars to be released.
Butter Sugar Onions medium low heat with constant stirring for 20 to 30 minutes... I cook for a living so I should know... Anyone says different is just striving for perfection... Go ahead release the flavors slowly for all that nuance... Most people eat so much salt and cheese they couldn't notice if they tried lol
Say it with me folks. It. Depends. It depends on the onion type, the cut size, the oil/butter, the temp. Or how gold n cooked you want it. It. Depends. There is NO one clear cut answer
Heh, I just had a small rant about this on the onion and garlic post. It's infuriating that actual recipes keep this myth going with their timings which are basically just enough for a really good sauté.
A lot of people have misunderstandings about the temperature of food and what is safe. Too many pork chops out there obliterated in the name of "safety"
It's not just temperature, it's also time. I never liked chicken breasts until I got a sous vide. Long, slow cook and they are tasty, succulent and safe.
Can confirm, pork responds well to sous vide, as does chicken
Load More Replies...And too many TV chefs and wannabe food experts on social media trying to insist that everyone should prefer their meat rare. If someone prefers their steak (or pork chop) well done then you have no place telling them they're wrong.
I don't care if people want their steak or pork chop well done, but if they ask for it that way then don't complain that it's tough and dry.
Load More Replies...If you can trust your butcher and keep a clean kitchen you can eat your fresh pork raw if you want. It's chicken you need to be careful with.
100%. Grew up with raw pork and raw beef, like a lot of Europeans. It really depends on the health and farming regulations (and control). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mett
Load More Replies...Trichinosis used to be a valid concern, and pork needed to be cooked thoroughly to destroy the parasites. But modern production methods have reduced the risk to practically nil. Unfortunately old habits die hard. That being said, every civilized cook should have a food thermometer to test for doneness, and an understanding of the proper temperature food should be cooked to to be safe.
Also what animals eat contributed to trichinosis. It was more prevalent when people fed hogs table scraps or whatever they had.
Load More Replies...Experts have revised the rule on temperature, the need for the temperature of pork to be cooked enough has decreased
The moment I see a recipe that says "350f" or "450f" I nope out. There are obviously instances where those are indeed the best temps but I see those numbers way too often, enough that I think ppl just default to that. Heck I've seen braise recipes that say 350f, that's insane. For me it's like 80-87c (175f ish to about 190f), if I hit 90c I'm too hot in most cases. The problem with going that hot is that it'll dry out the meat, so instead of juicy succulent braised meat you'll have dry meat that's either completely broken down cuz it's cooked too much to have any structure or dry meat that's a bit chewy
Are you confusing the temperature you set your oven to, with the temperature the food itself is cooked to?
Load More Replies...My ex MIL asked me how I manage to cook pork to perfection. She was of the generation that had to worry about parasites in pork way back when.
Never took my food's temperature. I check inside to see if its cooked
"Salting food is unnecessary and bad for you."
i admit, i believed this for YEARS and never salted my food. and then i met my friend's then-GF now wife. She was the one who told me why salting food is CRUCIAL. Hell, even desserts need to have salt
True... but salt makes the magic in some moments engraved in my soul. Pear tomatoes just gathered, still warm by the sun, and salt. I'm 50 yo and I can close my eyes and jump back to when I was 10 yo and almost can touch the scabs on my knees.
Fresh, ripe vegetables with a pinch of salt is amazing summer food.
Load More Replies...Having high blood pressure, I try to avoid salt as much as I can. Mostly, I don't find it necessary. I order fries without salt and they taste great on their own. I splurge for Corn on the Cob though!
New(?) studies show that this does not apply to all humans, for some that are "sensitive" salt would get higher blood pressure. But it's not that 100% gets higher blood pressure from salt. (Not a medic so don't take my word..)
Load More Replies...As a kid, a little salt of fresh ripe watermelon. OMG, still makes my mouth water.
That's the way my mom eats it. She says it makes the melon taste sweeter. I suppose that's why desserts and baked goods are made with a pinch of salt.
Load More Replies...The amount of sodium can be excessive. Sodium does terrible things to blood vessels and the heart. Many foods have exceptionally high levels of sodium that shouldnt and when its reduced few notice.
Yes, but those are prepared, packaged, convenience foods. Cooking from scratch requires seasonings, including salt. Just not in the huge quantities used in commercial foods.
Load More Replies...People often seem to think of salt just as a flavour when it's also a flavour enhancer.
When people suggest eating pudding before you’ve eaten your meat.
"How can you have any pudding if you don't eat yer meat?"
“Don’t forget to put olive oil in your pasta water, otherwise your pasta will stick.”
If you want to prevent boil overs, use a bigger pot & don’t over fill it. This negates the need for the “spoon hack”.
An 8 quart pot is not unreasonable for a pound of dry pasta.
The “rolling boil” is for when you add the noodles to the water. It doesn’t have to bubble like a movie cauldron the whole time. Just turn it down a little. It will still visibly boil.
Do NOT put oil in your pasta water. It will then prevent the sauce from sticking to the pasta. If you don't want your pasta to stick, you just need to have enough water, and the right level of boil
Or, you could use a small amount of water and simply watch it and stir for the few minutes it takes to cook. This is not brain surgery.
I have seen people become enraged over this subject... It boils down to personal preference...
Regarding the rolling boil, I actually do the opposite. I heat the salted, oil free water on medium and increase the heat when I add the pasta (that’s definitely cooler and brings the water temperature down). Then I just monitor it until it’s a little short of al dente, having the box time as a mere reference. Then toss it into the condiment pan with a ladle of the cooking water. Great pasta every time!
The spoon thing 100% works. Sometimes you have to make do with a smaller pot for various reasons.
Load More Replies...It's not a myth exactly, but when people do too much parroting of certain food-isms, true or otherwise, I'm less likely to consider them a worthwhile source. It feels like they don't have much experience-based knowledge, instead they're just a collection of food video factoids and reddit comments. It's all very ***well ACTUALLY*** Also, non-bakers who do the "baking is a science, not an art" bit. Because most bakers I know and love know that there is actually a good degree of wiggle room when baking and you have to make a few common sense calls.
Baking IS a science. And as any science, as soon as you've learnt how it works, you can create new recipes. But that's not 'wiggle room'. You can't wing it. You have to know what you're doing and still measure within the framework and balance the ingredients with each other.
Nah. I wing it all the time and I bake super nice cookies and cakes. Yes, it's science. But the wiggle room is absolutely there.
Load More Replies...You have to do quite a bit of baking before you know where you can. There are some things with zero wiggle room.
A good deal of baking is knowing what things are supposed to look, taste, and feel like. Sure, it's a science, but there's some art there as well.
Yeah, that's the crucial part. I usually have to add a little more water to dough in the winter time, because the air is drier. But how much? Over time you just get a feel for how it's supposed to look.
Load More Replies...I am a better baker because I get to use exact measures and temperatures. Cooking involves a lot of feeling, understanding, 'add as required' so sometimes the food is good sometimes bleh
So...have a small food business and make some baked goods some cooked stuff (soup etc). Share commercial kitchen w some other cooks and some bakers. Baking Def a science...can't "wing" a huge commercial batch of dough. Mismeasure and its usually trash can time. Mismeasure soup...add here and there and go all Art on it. In a batch with 3600g flour if my helper adds an extra 50g oil there is NO fixing it.
The actual creation of a well textured baked good is absolutely science. Just because there is some wiggle room doesn't make that not true. OP is projecting because he/she wants to be thought of as an artist 😂
But baking, and cooking, are based on science. Chemistry for the most part. Read some stuff from America's Test Kitchen or Cooks Illustrated. They do the experimentation and there is a great deal of learning about action/reaction. They explain the science behind it. Not everything works well together. There actually isn't a great deal of wiggle room in baking unless you're willing to waste a lot.
well, using the term loosely, baking is a bit of a science, but that is just until you know the basics of what flour to use, whether substituting applesauce for oil, There are many ways of winding up with a good end product. I make a "fruit cake" with no science at all. I just used a box of orange cranberry bread and threw a bunch of dried fruit into it, plus pistachio because I like them. I threw in applesauce instead of oil, NO measuring at all, and people loved my fruit cake. There was no science in that, just throw a bunch of stuff in a pan and bake it. The store bought mix, I figured had the basics of the science part. I just edited the hell out of it.
Exactly, the science was already covered. Applesauce is a common instead of oil and adding nuts and fruit to cake is common, too.
Load More Replies...
"Put the avocado seed in your guacamole and it won't turn brown."
Technically true for the small patch of guac that the seed covers, but otherwise nonsense.
A little bit of lime juice will help it keep the color plus it's good for the flavor
Finely chopped onions, jalapenos in vinegar and even the tomatoes also all contain acids that will stop it turning brown. But yeah, if you're going to leave it a while before serving then squeeze a lime over the top and mix it in before serving.
Load More Replies...This is absolutely true. My husband makes a good size batch of guac on vacation at the beach.. puts a pit or two in and it does not turn brown anywhere in the dish. And we're not eating it in five minutes, it's in the air for a good amount of time. ETA: he does use lime in it.... hmm so maybe that is what's keeping it green? Oy, now I don't know LOL
Lime squeeze on top.... While we're at it, a couple drops of lime on an unused half avocado back in the fridge no saran wrap needed for a day or so
Maybe not a "myth" in the proper sense, but any time someone suggests their recipe guarantees "moist" or "not dry" chicken. Food in general, but definitely meat, is dry when it's overcooked. If your chicken is constantly dry, it's because you are doing something wrong. No two ways about it. Using a thermometer doesn't make you less of a cook.
Some people don't know that meat continues cooking 'at rest' which is where a lot of the problem stems from
Skipping the rest period is the #1 failure in cooking that I see ALL THE TIME
Load More Replies...Using a thermometer makes you a better cook. Professional chefs in restaurants use thermometers for a reason, and you should too.
Amen! My late mother was a dietitian and head of food service at the local hospital, and her thermometer was in the breast pocket of her lab coat (in it's safety sleeve); it was part of her everyday uniform.
Load More Replies...If I cut meat in small pieces I always dust them in corn flour first, keep them very moist indeed. Works especially well with chicken
I'll add to the "get a thermometer" call, although I really think that some folks would rather stubbornly continue to cook dry meat even as they continue to insist their meat is never dry. Hmm. But if you insist on cooking meat based on time or by cutting into it before it's properly rested (thereby letting all the juices out, resulting in...hm...), you really should try BRINING your meat first. All chicken breasts or pork chops need is about 15-20 minutes in a wet brine just before cooking to ensure the end product will be moist and juicy.
This was my mom even in a crackpot unless it was grilled. My mom's response when I finally said something last year her response was I followed the recipe.
There's nothing wrong with dry chicken There, I've said it. That's what the gravy is for.
De gustibus, 'n' stuff. I prefer chicken - or any meat - to be moist and flavorful. I'll be roasting one for dinner today. ETA: But still with gravy, of course.
Load More Replies...
"You can never have too much garlic.." Yes you can, especially in Italian food. Garlic is not a prominent ingredient.
Absolutely, my personal take has always been "it's not too much garlic til it hurts".
Load More Replies...For any ingredient, there most certainly is such a thing as "too much."
Take it and roast the whole thing, the you can use a butter knife to spread on your French bread 😋
Load More Replies...It's true. I grew up in Rome and I learned to cook observing my mother and various relatives. We don't use very much garlic at all. In fact, my mother used to add it to the sauce and then remove it before serving. What you want is a balance of flavors. Sometimes (rarely) I eat in restaurants where they obviously use way too much garlic, and mind you: I eat a lot more garlic than I used to, but I can't stand it when it's overused.
The "Detox" trend. It makes no sense as it's the normal function of your liver and kidneys that detox your body. Just eat a balanced diet and you should be fine.
Plus--and this won't make me any friends--the more regular heart-pumping physical activity you engage in, the more you circulate blood through the liver and kidneys, and the more capillaries you'll have for your blood to access waste products.
Not just that - the lymphatic system (which works like the body's sewage system)looks like a secondary circulatory system, but requires muscle contractions to move waste to the appropriate areas. In other words, if you want to detox, then exercise!
Load More Replies...But seriously, how many people (especially in the states) actually eat a healthy, balanced diet?
Anything buzz words like gut health, flushes/cleanses, “unprocessed” food.
Saying MSG is fake and bad for you.
Not a cooking myth, but when someone has really bad knife skills I don’t trust their recipes or advice.
Edit: this was meant to refer to unsafe knife skills. Cutting on a slippery board. Holding the food with your fingers basically parallel/flat against it.
and a sharper knife is safer than a dull one. Sharp knives easily cut through whatever you are cutting, causing less chance of knife slipping and cutting your fingers
I am MUCH safer using a mandolin than trying to thinly slice veggies! It's just a bonus that they come out so neat and even.
Load More Replies...How would they know about someone's knife skills unless they watch them cook? And what does a recipe have to do with knife skills. Clearly haven't had enough coffee this morning.
My grandmother used the same tiny old knife to slice all her veg as long as I can remember. I never saw her sharpen it. I was just thinking about this stupid knife and how it could possibly have kept cutting anything for so long. She was a great cook. Not seeing the knife corollary here. But I am getting a whiff of pretentiousness.
Load More Replies...Good gut health and good brain health go hand in hand. Not sure it’s a buzz word? And highly processed food leads to poor gut health, it makes sense to eat as unprocessed as possible
Knife skills has nothing to do with how good the food is, y'all are crazy 😆
Last time I checked the taste buds are not responsible for coordination
If you want to flush your bowels, just stir a tablespoon of olive oil into your morning coffee. No need for the fancy expensive juices.
As both chef and a knife sharpener. The very second upon stepping in a new kitchen either to collect knives for sharpening or doing a pop up. Just by looking at the guys chopping their prep away you can be 99% sure which one of them knows their recipe by heart. And it's always the one with the knife skills. Especially in this day and age it is way easier to tell.
Cooking lore is like most knowledge- the Pareto principle applies. 80% of your good results probably come from 20% of the advice, but people aren't always sure which 20% is good, so the whole body of knowledge gets handed down. Something being ineffective (like adding oil to pasta water) isn't enough to get it removed from the body of knowledge- It's not getting removed completely unless it is clearly *counter*productive. That's why I enjoy people who put all conventional wisdom to the test. A lot of it isn't completely right, but some of it is.
I used to like Alton Brown's Good Eats because he would say WHY you do things and show the science behind it.
A YouTube channel, baking with babish. He did a whole episode on cookie baking and the science behind the use of the different key ingredients
Load More Replies...This is why you always need science to prove something nkg just good results. Because you need to know why and under which circumstances something works, not just that it does work in this case, because it might be pointless or useless or actively harmful in different circumstances To make a larger point this is why ppl need to do the right things for the right reasons. If they do the right things for the wrong reasons they will end up doing something wrong eventually
The MSG haters- it is not poison. It DOES have a place in my kitchen and I would miss it and notice the difference without it in a lot of recipes!
Some people genuinely can't tolerate it, and I.really hope you don't feed it to this people to PrOvE a PoInT
I throw up like I am dying. I can't have tomatoes and other foods with naturally occurring high levels either. I have had people attempt to prove a point with me. I got so sick it ruined the evening. Sooooo, I proved MY point, I guess.
Load More Replies...Indeed, it's present in reasonable quantities in quite a lot of things, including mushrooms, cheese, soy sauce and pretty much anything natural or processed that has an Umami taste to it.
Load More Replies...For some of us, it is. Instant (well, 10-15 minutes) migraine trigger for me! I haven't tried the organic plant based on though...
In a world full of fast food as an overweight person i would leave taste enhancers out of my home cooking. Sugar comes naturally too, don't put it in everyday cooking
I sometimes add msg to my Indian curries and pulaos when I get bored eating the same flavours.
Sooooooo, the same people that don't like msg also don't like half the vegetables and fermented foods in this world just because msg is naturally occuring in them???
Use butter and olive oil together for a high smoke point. Somehow separately they have a lower smoke point but when combined magic happens? No.
I use butter and olive oil together because it tastes magical. Way too much emphasis is put on smoke point, which translates in my mind to people cooking on too high of heat as a matter of course. I only need a high heat oil for when I stir fry, and that would just taste weird with olive oil or butter anyway.
The melted butter is a visual clue that lets you know when the oil's at the right temperature. Oh, and the combo also tastes great.
Wash your meat. (For meat bought at a supermarket, etc... not talking about places where it's actually necessary...)
What? No! A big, huge no! Don't wash the fresh meat. Don't do that. You're going to cook that meat, true? That should be enough for pathogens like salmonella. Washing the meat could actually spread any pathogens around your kitchen.
Yes, that's what they're saying, that the perceived need to wash it is a myth.
Load More Replies...If you're in the US, it's best to rinse your meat. I'm talking more for debris than salmonella. We're absurd about how we treat our animals for the most part. And why we can't sell American chicken in the EU.
Most people dont know abount velveting. A tecnique in chinese dishes the leaves very soft and tender meat. Its a skill every cook should know. If meat NEEDS to be washed ot may be past its use buy date.
Why? Is your meat rolled in dirt? Never wash meat, unless you dropped it. And absolutely never with detergent. Some of you have never had "home killed" meat. Sometimes it's hung for two or three days to drain the blood. Gutted first before hanging. Meat is tender when cooked. And usually not 'stressed'.
That salt bae is somehow talented or unique.
Well, if someone is able to sell a can of Sprinte for $10, there must be some kind of talent there.
Don’t use salt on your raw steak, it will dry out the meat.
Depends on the cut, the method, the type/style of salt, and desired result.
Sure. Are they saying that's a good or a bad thing, or that the idea itself is a myth? :confused:
Salt pepper garlic onion blend for good flavored meat salt holds the flavors IN
Don't use a meat thermometer, it'll make the juices leak out
What? Please, don't follow this advice. Use a thermometer; it's an ally.
Yes, another one you've misunderstood. They're saying that this is a myth. Not a myth I've ever heard before, but still.
Load More Replies...Using a thermometer is fine. Just don't cut something like a steak open with a knife to see if it's cooked.
This one made me laugh... I agree for steaks (I use the rule of thumb) but anything else should be temp checked for sure
How big is your thermometer? I use mine all the time and it helps cooking perfect steaks. The amount of juice that comes out is negligible. Of course, you only use it when the meat is almost done right? Otherwise you are performing acupuncture on your food.
Don't rely on thermometer. Heard story of "chef" who threw turkey in oven, after 45 minutes stabbed it with thermometer which reads out 75°C and declared turkey to be done. Started slicing only to see raw meat. Put it back again for another half an hour and repeated. With the same result. Declared oven was broken.
These are all myths pursuant to the title. I understand how it could be confusing.
Load More Replies...I can't believe some people don't wash their mushrooms. It's so disgusting. Rare burgers being ok to eat always gets me a side eye and a double side eye when they start complaining about getting the "stomach flu" a lot.
I'm afraid this person is badly informed. But at least I won't have to share my mushrooms with them
Wait, is this one actually suggesting that mushrooms _should_ be washed? And a rare burger is fine as long as you've sourced the meat from a reliable source and made it freshly yourself. Undercooking a shop-made burger is indeed an unwise thing to do.
I wonder if OP could mean wild mushrooms? Where I live it's customary to forage them in the woods. I love the flavour, but I would never forget about washing them before cooking. To get rid of the hidden extra bug protein, for one :)
Load More Replies...The reason that ground meat as opposed to intact meat as a steak, is "more dangerous" is because there is more meat that has surface to the air that causes meat to "go bad" means you do have to be aware, and trust your butcher.
That and all the various things on the surface of the meat scraps that get turned into ground meat get well integrated when the meat is ground.
Load More Replies...Mushrooms are grown in a sterilized medium. Yes that medium is often horse s**t, but it's been cooked to kill off everything except the spores its been inoculated with.
Just realised that some people buy mushroom. Anyway, some need to be washed, others don't. At all. Never wash porcini mushroom! (Boletus). About the meat..ever heard of tartare?
Washing mushroom right before use is perfectly fine. In fact, the best sauteeing method uses *water* to cook them prior to adding butter. And if they were foraged, then I assure you there are bugs, even if you don't see them. Soak em in water and see the bugs float. Even boletes.
While most entries here are doing a good job I wish in some cases in similar posts people would make it clearer if the posted text is the actual myth or the truth opposing said myth.
That's OK, I certainly would never use an "article" as a guide to cooking my dinner. Some of these just add a little to help one form a finely tuned "c**p detector".
Load More Replies...I have 2 - that a cut potato will magically un-salt an over salted dish, and any recipe that instructs you to reduce a sauce by half and then tells you it will take 10 minutes. Bull.
The potato thing only works if you cook the potato in the dish
Load More Replies...As someone who writes and follows detailed protocols every day for a living, I f*****g hate cooking recipes. They're never accurate.
A new career in cook books with accurate and precise descriptions?
Load More Replies...While most entries here are doing a good job I wish in some cases in similar posts people would make it clearer if the posted text is the actual myth or the truth opposing said myth.
That's OK, I certainly would never use an "article" as a guide to cooking my dinner. Some of these just add a little to help one form a finely tuned "c**p detector".
Load More Replies...I have 2 - that a cut potato will magically un-salt an over salted dish, and any recipe that instructs you to reduce a sauce by half and then tells you it will take 10 minutes. Bull.
The potato thing only works if you cook the potato in the dish
Load More Replies...As someone who writes and follows detailed protocols every day for a living, I f*****g hate cooking recipes. They're never accurate.
A new career in cook books with accurate and precise descriptions?
Load More Replies...
