98Kviews
People Share 30 Weird Thanksgiving Recipes That Their Families Refuse To Abandon
Rachel Green is the Queen of Thanksgiving. Her eccentric trifle has become quite possibly the most iconic holiday food in television history. However, there are rivals who are trying to dethrone her. When Maya Kosoff asked Twitter users to share the strangest Thanksgiving dishes they came across, many have stepped up to the challenge.
The thread has received over 7.4K likes and 1.1K comments, many of which are showcasing recipes that are so terrible, they're hilarious. Like, the "magic" tomato soup cake with a creamy chocolate frosting. Or frog eye salad. Yes, I know, the title alone sounds like this abomination tastes like feet.
More info: Twitter
This post may include affiliate links.
Thanksgiving Day is one of the most important national holidays in the United States. While there were many events that contributed to the tradition, it is believed that it began in 1621.
When the Mayflower (the English ship that transported the first English Puritans to the New World) left England in September 1620, it landed in Cape Cod where colonists began to settle. After the pilgrims’ first harvest succeeded, they planned a feast with the Native Americans. This get together went down in history as the "First Thanksgiving."
In 1817, New York became the first state to officially organize an annual Thanksgiving. However, it wasn’t until 1863 that President Abraham Lincoln declared it a national holiday.
that actually sounds like a good way to make regular corn bread moist. Sounds yummy and contains no jello or pimentos
I've had similar and its actually pretty decent if way to sweet to have much of. Add some rum and it might be awesome
Doesn't sound that bad or much different from an Ambrosia or Waldorf salad
That's stuff from my nightmares right there. It sounds like something a cat would barf up.
AKA The Watergate Salad. Unlike the Waldorf Salad--from the majestic hotel of the same name--this one is just a messy scandal...
This is pretty common in the South (US). I never cared for mixing the sweet with the cottage cheese, though.
I may some how be related to this person because I know I have seen this on the table at various family diners.
We make something similar, except instead of jello, we use Pistachio Instant Pudding.
I swear ive eaten this before at some holiday dinner. Didnt know there was cottage cheese in it though.
My fam did the same thing except they also make some without pineapples because I can’t eat them
I've had something similar before. I like it but the texture can throw some people.
This little beauty is alive and well, and not just for Thanksgiving. You can find it at church suppers, potluck dinners and cafeterias all over the Southland.
OMGoodness. You guys don't know what you're missing. It's really good although the ingredients are missing a tub of cool-whip topping
Honey, The Joy of Cooking is a classic, and that copy looks like a first edition!
The thing is... you should really try the recipes out way before the T-day holiday.
This sounds like something you make when snowed in or when you are hungry but too lazy to go get groceries
It does have a particular odour that should be enough to warn people that it is not edible.
It feels like the recipe cards for a 1970s style sweet fruit and jello salad and a queso recipe got stuck together and someone didn't notice
Serious question: what is the purpose of tomato aspic? Like, do you spread it on toast, or just eat it like jello?
Now, if you used fresh pears, some nice double or triple cream Brie (and dumped all the other ingredients), that would work for me. 😋
This is probably the only dish on this list that I have made and eaten. I use chili sauce with a jar of jam or jelly; apricot is good too. The meatballs are sweet and spicy.
I've made bumblebee succotash which is blackbeans and corn. It's amazing.
My mom makes this and it's one of the favorites. The strawberry version is good too.
Another family favorite with a different name "24 hour salad" had to make it the day before to make sure the coconut softened and the marshmallows lost some of their consistency.
That doesn't sound bad. i would make my deviled eggs with the yolk, bell peppers celery and bacon
This is why kids will only eat Chicken fingers and fries. I wish I had chicken fingers and fries growing up : ( Thank God there was also turkey, mashed potatoes and real desserts.
This is really good! I used to bring that to parties and people scarfed it up. :)
wrong on so many levels but at least she used cream cheese and not miracle whip
Instant gelatin was a fad when it was still a new thing. Was a huge step up from boiling bones to get gelatin, it was impressive, and cooks searched for ways to use it. Anyway, in another few years, people will look upon kale, and matcha, and green smoothies with the same incredulous disdain - as I do now.
I just looked it up and apparently Jell-O was very popular in the 1950’s-60’s, so it makes sense that a lot of grandparents and great aunts and uncles would be making stuff with it. Jell-O needs to be refrigerated, and back then not many people had refrigerators, so it was a status symbol to have Jell-O foods. Also, it was in a lot of cookbooks at the time, so many people just assumed that it was something you were supposed to make. The last thing was that it was a fairly fun process to do, and also it was a good way to make lots of canned foods into one thing that looked more appealing to eat. Anyways, fun thing I learned, hope it was helpful!
Load More Replies... Why on earth do people combine jello with cream cheese so much and THEN if that wasn't weird enough, call it a salad?
I miss my big family thanksgivings, We usually made Tamales, turkey, pies, ham, Birria, and Menudo. Loved it and maybe the oddest thing there was flan or Cabeza (tacos made of beef cheeks and other parts of the head), or Chivo (goat).
why are there so much jelly, salad, cream cheese and cool whip? Every time I try to understand this thanks-giving thing I just get more confused. Can someone please explain?
What's with all the jello? I think I've eaten jello twice in my life. And isn't that usually a dessert?
Jello and aspic (which is basically meat jello), were extremely popular in the 50's and 60's. So a lot of those recipes are still kicking around from then. Most often they would be savoury dishes, with just about anything thrown in. I guess it was seen as being 'new' and 'exciting'.
Load More Replies... 
My mother was obsessed with Jello molds during the holidays. They wouldn't have been so bad, but she insisted on putting either walnuts or pecans in them..and I'm not a big fan of crunchy things in Jello.
I don't know if it's weird but definitely not a normal Thanksgiving side. My. Mom makes stir fry noodles with ramen. She boils noodles and sets them aside, cooks a bunch of bacon sets aside cut up, cooks jalapeño slices in some bacon grease adds noodles and bacon.
After most of the kids moved away to different areas of the country, my father stopped having the traditional huge turkey with all the trimmings kind of Thanksgiving. Christmas was hardly ever the traditional big ham or turkey meal. We usually did things like Lasagna or Stir-fry. I remember one year setting an electric wok up on my Grandmother's table. My sister and I did a Chicken Chow Mien Stir Fry. My Grandmother was a little skeptical at first, but made all sorts of yummy noises as she ate it. She invited me to make it again when I visited during the summer.
Load More Replies...
Yes, I copied a bunch of those recipes. Yes, I will serve some at upcoming family gatherings :)
Can I say that I honestly feel unhappy and uncomfortable looking at these recipes? I'm not even exaggerating.
Our family has its traditional jello salad: orange jello, shredded carrots, mandarin oranges and crushed pineapple all combined and put in a jello ring mold. But we also have strict rules of jello: red jello has mixed canned fruit, green jello has canned pears and the orange is only for holidays. Lol.
I remember maw-in-law making some of these abominations, but she's been dead for 20+ years, and I haven't bothered with Thanksgiving since my son was killed 16 years ago just a few days before that holiday. It has zero meaning to me since then, and I just eat an ordinary dinner here at home, alone, as I have done since his death. Doesn't bother me, it's just another day, and it's just another meal, no abominal food involved, just good stuff I like.
My mom found a recipe on that Sunday insert with stories. It was Berry Mallow Bake, a sweet potato concoction. Somehow, it became Barry Manilow Bake. Years, decades later someone always says don't forget to make the Barry Manilow Bake! We also made Martin Luther King Jr. Jello. That was red, white and blue Jello that someone made at a church function that MLJ attended and commented on the jellow dish. OMG! It was copied and distributed to all the church ladies. We didn't even belong to that church, but my mom had to make MLK Jello!
I am seriously baffled by all the mayo combinations with fruit and sweet things, or such sweet-savoury combos, they are really not part of my country's cuisine and I can't say I've ever tried something similar, but thought of the combinations makes me want to barf. Some of the recipes actually don't seem too bad, the biggest problem I'd have with it is that it looks like a blob (oh, and the colors), but mere description sounds ok.
Someone in my wife's family always bring over yams cooked to the consistency of pudding topped with melted marshmallows.
I've seen many of these at pot lucks, but they were usually avoided.
Looks like all of the dishes from pot-luck dinners at the Methodist church growing up.
Honestly I'd prob try all these (except maybe the aspics) lmao Also anyone see the This Is Us episode last week with the 5 lbs of shrimp as a tradition lol
Our family tradition was Tom & Jerry's. Probably best comparison is egg nog, but with hot water. Of course, lots of bourbon. Loved 'em even w/no booze
Who remembers the "Green Bean Jello" from the "Lizzie Bennet Diaries"?
Which isn't weird at all, it's delicious. Though I can't drink too much cider... sadly.
Load More Replies...
Canned foods I can somehow understand, but the jello in everything is just baffling.
Load More Replies... I just looked it up and apparently Jell-O was very popular in the 1950’s-60’s, so it makes sense that a lot of grandparents and great aunts and uncles would be making stuff with it. Jell-O needs to be refrigerated, and back then not many people had refrigerators, so it was a status symbol to have Jell-O foods. Also, it was in a lot of cookbooks at the time, so many people just assumed that it was something you were supposed to make. The last thing was that it was a fairly fun process to do, and also it was a good way to make lots of canned foods into one thing that looked more appealing to eat. Anyways, fun thing I learned, hope it was helpful!
Load More Replies... Why on earth do people combine jello with cream cheese so much and THEN if that wasn't weird enough, call it a salad?
I miss my big family thanksgivings, We usually made Tamales, turkey, pies, ham, Birria, and Menudo. Loved it and maybe the oddest thing there was flan or Cabeza (tacos made of beef cheeks and other parts of the head), or Chivo (goat).
why are there so much jelly, salad, cream cheese and cool whip? Every time I try to understand this thanks-giving thing I just get more confused. Can someone please explain?
What's with all the jello? I think I've eaten jello twice in my life. And isn't that usually a dessert?
Jello and aspic (which is basically meat jello), were extremely popular in the 50's and 60's. So a lot of those recipes are still kicking around from then. Most often they would be savoury dishes, with just about anything thrown in. I guess it was seen as being 'new' and 'exciting'.
Load More Replies... My mother was obsessed with Jello molds during the holidays. They wouldn't have been so bad, but she insisted on putting either walnuts or pecans in them..and I'm not a big fan of crunchy things in Jello.
I don't know if it's weird but definitely not a normal Thanksgiving side. My. Mom makes stir fry noodles with ramen. She boils noodles and sets them aside, cooks a bunch of bacon sets aside cut up, cooks jalapeño slices in some bacon grease adds noodles and bacon.
After most of the kids moved away to different areas of the country, my father stopped having the traditional huge turkey with all the trimmings kind of Thanksgiving. Christmas was hardly ever the traditional big ham or turkey meal. We usually did things like Lasagna or Stir-fry. I remember one year setting an electric wok up on my Grandmother's table. My sister and I did a Chicken Chow Mien Stir Fry. My Grandmother was a little skeptical at first, but made all sorts of yummy noises as she ate it. She invited me to make it again when I visited during the summer.
Load More Replies... Yes, I copied a bunch of those recipes. Yes, I will serve some at upcoming family gatherings :)
Can I say that I honestly feel unhappy and uncomfortable looking at these recipes? I'm not even exaggerating.
Our family has its traditional jello salad: orange jello, shredded carrots, mandarin oranges and crushed pineapple all combined and put in a jello ring mold. But we also have strict rules of jello: red jello has mixed canned fruit, green jello has canned pears and the orange is only for holidays. Lol.
I remember maw-in-law making some of these abominations, but she's been dead for 20+ years, and I haven't bothered with Thanksgiving since my son was killed 16 years ago just a few days before that holiday. It has zero meaning to me since then, and I just eat an ordinary dinner here at home, alone, as I have done since his death. Doesn't bother me, it's just another day, and it's just another meal, no abominal food involved, just good stuff I like.
My mom found a recipe on that Sunday insert with stories. It was Berry Mallow Bake, a sweet potato concoction. Somehow, it became Barry Manilow Bake. Years, decades later someone always says don't forget to make the Barry Manilow Bake! We also made Martin Luther King Jr. Jello. That was red, white and blue Jello that someone made at a church function that MLJ attended and commented on the jellow dish. OMG! It was copied and distributed to all the church ladies. We didn't even belong to that church, but my mom had to make MLK Jello!
I am seriously baffled by all the mayo combinations with fruit and sweet things, or such sweet-savoury combos, they are really not part of my country's cuisine and I can't say I've ever tried something similar, but thought of the combinations makes me want to barf. Some of the recipes actually don't seem too bad, the biggest problem I'd have with it is that it looks like a blob (oh, and the colors), but mere description sounds ok.
Someone in my wife's family always bring over yams cooked to the consistency of pudding topped with melted marshmallows.
I've seen many of these at pot lucks, but they were usually avoided.
Looks like all of the dishes from pot-luck dinners at the Methodist church growing up.
Honestly I'd prob try all these (except maybe the aspics) lmao Also anyone see the This Is Us episode last week with the 5 lbs of shrimp as a tradition lol
Our family tradition was Tom & Jerry's. Probably best comparison is egg nog, but with hot water. Of course, lots of bourbon. Loved 'em even w/no booze
Who remembers the "Green Bean Jello" from the "Lizzie Bennet Diaries"?
Which isn't weird at all, it's delicious. Though I can't drink too much cider... sadly.
Load More Replies... Canned foods I can somehow understand, but the jello in everything is just baffling.
Load More Replies...
