People In This Group Are Sharing The 30 Best And Worst Examples Of ‘Urban Planning’
According to the World Health Organization, the environment where we live determines almost 24% of our health status. No wonder adults living in and children growing up in urban settings are increasingly exposed to high levels of air and noise pollution, tend to have less contact with nature, have poorer nutrition and even lack physical activity.
Luckily, good urban planning can not only prevent these risks caused by urbanization but even improve our quality of life. Smart urban planning can make busy public areas natural and peaceful spaces capable of reducing stress, promoting sustainability and a sense of well-being.
There’s this corner of Reddit known as Urban Planning that is dedicated to collecting and sharing the best and worst examples of urban planning. From entire city infrastructures to small details like stands for bikers to grab onto while waiting for the light, there are many things that influence how we move around and feel in cities that you probably haven’t noticed before.
Below, we wrapped up some of the most interesting examples.
This post may include affiliate links.
The Dutch Prime Minister On His Way Home After A Day Of Work - Front Page, 50k Upvotes
There are many photos and film where you seen him on his bike on the way to a meeting, wearing jeans, sneakers, on his bike and munching an apple. Great !
Yep, it's a great act. Had a lot of people fooled for years.
Load More Replies...At least he looks like he can ride a bike. Boris looks like a circus clown.
Boris looks like a clown in everything he does. What a twat!
Load More Replies...Irish prime minister also very normal. Ukranian president tops the lot. We need change in our voting systems.
As a Dutch person, him riding his bike to work is probably the only nice thing I can say about Mark Rutte, though..
Load More Replies...Why has every post I've seen about Dutch people been so positive? I might just have to move there...
Not because of this guy, though. He's been in power for ages and there's only so much the country's less well-off can take.
Load More Replies...Our world needs more of these type of leaders and less of the type we have right now.
Nah the netherlands has become a really capitalist right wing country. Not as bad as USA but not a nice place.
Load More Replies...Hahahahaaaahhhaaaa. Sorry. There are A LOT of people who can't stand him. And yes, I'm Dutch. I don't hate him. Don't like him
Load More Replies...We only do that in extreme cases ( and he is too skinny )
Load More Replies...I would rather he took a limousine or a helicopter to work if it meant he'd make life here affordable for everybody instead of just the rich and stop gutting our educational systems and healthcare.
Interesting Concept
I went to college in a place that was primarily a mining town. The stuff aimed at the college kids (Taco Bell) closed down when the bars did. The stores and public services aimed at the miners and their families (grocery store, public library, etc) were open 24 hours a day because so were the mines. There were 16 year old kids working on their GEDs at 2am after getting off work and mom's picking up a replacement pair of steel toed boots in the middle of the night to get back to work after the old pair saved her toes . When I graduated and moved to the big city, I was genuinely surprised to discover Famous Footwear and the local library would close at 8pm. A larger percent of people worked weird shifts in my small college town but volume wise there are a lot more people in a city of 1 million who don't work 9-5. 24 hour Walmarts made many of those businessed moot but I still wonder why you can only improve yourself at a library when the sun is up.
Because librarians are introverts and we’re exhausted serving as pseudo-social workers, and we want to go home, curl up with a good book or TV show, and go to bed.
Load More Replies...Because homeless people where I am are drawn to them as a refuge, which is absolutely fine and understandable. But it's a default homeless shelter where nobody else now wants to go now.
That is so true I caught a homeless woman shaving in our bathroom sink in the library. So sad
Load More Replies...Libraries should be open 24/7/365! Yes, I a Bookworm! I know this will probably never happen, but I can dream
... I can dream. People work such odd hours and even our sleeping patterns have us up all different times of the day and night. Libraries could be a safe place to meet others or to get help. There are a lot of people who don't do the bar scene. WE need a place to go that doen'
Load More Replies...Retired librarian here. Most librarians do not want to be at work at 3:00 am because that kind of schedule is tough on your health and your family. I would have enjoyed it, though. I've loved libraries since I was a kid. My home life was atrocious, so I used to walk to the next city and spend hours in blissful escape at the library. My podunk high school taught me to answer other people's questions, but the library taught me to answer my own. I'll always be grateful to the women who ran it. Oh, and I never had a problem with the homeless people at the library. I was friends with one in particular. The people I had trouble with were the white-collar people who would peruse the reference business materials (Standard and Poor's, etc.), because they tended to steal.
Do people go out late at night if they're not the sort to go to a bar? I don't even understand that honestly.
Libraries are a target for the homeless. Libraries don't like that.
Hr Does Have Some Good Wants
These two absolutely don't exclude one another, the need each other. Self driving cars can couple where possible and be not just used by one person for "the last few miles" into sleeper towns for inatance or when privacy is preferable. While larger public transport vehicles are there for the high volume routes (routes between sleeper town and cities and cities and cities) and low capacity routes (inner city)
For my commute I (Dutch) use a bicycle, 40 kilometers one way. I don't hate cars, but I often find them difficult.
Load More Replies...Self driving cars will be revolutionary once they are owned by the group instead of the individual. Most cars sit unused over 90% of the time so they just take up unnecessary space waiting for the next time their owner needs them. If you could walk out the door, get into any vehicle on the block, whisked to your destination if near or taken to transfer station (like your rail station) where you could instantly be transferred to a longer haul vehicle. Columbus, Ohio did a pilot project for a neighborhood of 16,000 people (COVID killed it) and it went well. It wasn't perfect but it was a good first real world attempt that showed potential. Biggest hurdle was people said it was convenient, faster, etc but they didn't want to give up owning their own car. Car ownership is a mental thing that represents many emotions to many people.
That would be amazing. Just get in any car in your neighborhood and then park it and dont worry about it again.
Load More Replies...I'd be happy if the main bus company for my area wasn't owned and operated by two brothers (allegedly and unproven borderline criminals) who *also* happen to own and operate the major taxi firm.
The big 3 car companies lost a monopoly, anti competition lawsuit 100 years ago for buying commuter lines and shutting them down.
I'd like towns or at least large subdivisions to be car/motorcycle free. Put parking lots outside the house perimeters. Wouldn't that be lovely? No noise/gas/oil pollution close to your property. There is only one place like that I think. But that place doesn't have electricity either. Brilliant!
In a previous in-depth interview, we spoke with Lisa Yaszek about urbanization and the challenges it poses to our lives. Yaszek is a Regents Professor of Science Fiction Studies at Georgia Tech, where she researches and teaches science fiction as a global language crossing centuries, continents, and cultures.
The professor explained that the traditional advantage of urban life is that cities are engines of technoscientific development and cultural exchange. “That is true now more than ever, as we see new megacities of 10 million or more people springing up around the world,” she added.
The Big Dig Before And After
"The Big Dig" was the nickname that this project became known as. It was a huge project to move all traffic under the city and make getting to Logan Airport easier. The name came about due to the project taking over 15 years to complete and being way over budget. For years every time you drove into the city you never went the same way twice due to construction and this was in the days before Mapquest and GPS on your phone. Dark days my friends, I still get nervous when I have to drive into the city.
Thanks for the info! I was looking at this thinking, it looks a lot nicer, but where was the traffic rerouted?
Load More Replies...It just needs time for the ones they have planted to grow.
Load More Replies...It has those things now. The bottom picture dates to when the park was new.
Load More Replies...Does it ever get used by people - I count only one or two people. Is it attractive to wildlife? any birds or small mammals? Green space is nice to look at but seems very sterile.
It Really Be Like That
Yeah because 1. Americans are insane for sports and athletes make WAY TOO MUCH MONEY. 2. They rely on the tourism/income that Stadiums bring to the city. Stupid if you ask me. Should be spending that money on the poverty sticken/homeless and feeding their hungry.
Quite a few city government elected officials favor the BIG, BAD, BOOM community projects (stadiums) over common sense, long lasting and community projects that any and everyone could utilize and helps move people around without the large amount of pollution. Imagine the family that feels it needs to buy a $65,000 SUV versus one that costs $35,000. The less expensive SUV seats the same number of passengers, it is as safe, gets better milage and is stylish without the BIG, BAD, BOOM. It's sometimes a "pride" thing and not necessarily always a good return on the initial investment for the community.
Its about what brings in money versus what costs money after its built
Berlin Is Planning A Car-Free Area Larger Than Manhattan
Usually deliveries and residents are allowed to pass and park, even in car-free areas. Otherwise how could shops and stores get their stuff delivered?
Load More Replies...Ummm... what happens if it snows? Or if you're physically unable to ride a bike?
You are unacquainted with how efficient German snow removal is!
Load More Replies...More importantly, how about the disabled people that cannot ride bicycles, and cannot afford an expensive motorized wheelchair? I’m all for limiting autos, but what can be done for the disabled population, who always seem to be invisible.
Accessible public transport, plus many pedestrian areas around the world DO allowed car access for people with disabilities. Ambulances, fire engines, buses and trams are also allowed. It's just the everyday, ordinary cars that are denied entry. Without them, it's a huge deal safer, quieter, and there's less pollution.
Load More Replies...I don't think, the title is true. There are always people demanding to make all of the historical center of Berlin Car free, but it won't be happening in the near future. Maybe the road Unter den Linden, but it will still have busses and it is not larger than Manhattan!
That photo shows part of the Friedrichstraße, and it is just that: only bikes and pedestrians. Source: walked there a few weeks ago.
Load More Replies...Get through the city faster and easier, when there are no other cars.
Load More Replies...In fact, a whopping 4.2 billion inhabitants which make up 55% of the world's population today live in cities. Experts are convinced that this trend will continue.
But since the development of large industrial cities in the 1800s, the downsides of urban living have become increasingly evident. “Cities organized around factories and power plants tend to be environmental disasters, with clouds of pollution sometimes literally blotting out the sun and preventing the growth of anything green on the ground,” Yaszek told us.
Interesting
No, he would have to clean up his garage. To avoid damage to his favorite belongings when visiting the bathroom at night.
Load More Replies...I actually want something like this, preferably a converted warehouse. Not for my car, just cause I like how open it is
That's my lottery house. Although the area for the cars would be a lot bigger
I'd k1ll to have a house like that. Although, to be realistic, it needs a bigger garage.
I get the sentiment here, but I wouldn’t build my house like a cheese factory, or a cheese factory like my house either. Sometimes comparing apples to oranges doesn’t really get you anywhere.
If you are going to present a valid argument, why exaggerate? That is not to scale for any home plan I have ever seen.
No, but that's the point they're making: cities are proportioned like this so imagine if homes were.
Load More Replies...How One Change Can Make A Big Difference
The fountain was clearly moved or photoshopped. Pavement markings don't lie.
Load More Replies...This is where the Dutch government and parliament reside in The Hague.
I am sure it took more than one change. Traffic flow, rebuild parking structures, a move to bicycles, improved public transportation. All good and well worth it.From the late 60's to now?
Seems to be about the same number of people wandering around the new square as there were drivers and pedestrians in the old picture.
The Elevated Freeway Got Torn Down. Seoul
i, being the clutz i am, would probably be in it
Load More Replies...That works in CERTAIN places, like new York where everything is right on top of each other. Where I live it would not. And if you don't have your own car how do you visit another town? Or do shopping? Like I don't think you can easily get enough food for a family of 8 on a city bus without making some one mad.
Load More Replies...Nice to see. So many places redirect or stop natural water flow to build houses for more money
There are more downsides to urban living. It turns out that industrial and post-industrial cities tend to attract disproportionate numbers of both highly skilled workers (often in finance or business) and unskilled laborers (often in factories or domestic work). “As such, they make evident the very real and increasing gap between the rich and the poor,” the professor noted.
A Stand For Bikers To Hold On To While Waiting For The Traffic Lights In Sweden.
This is such a good initiative… saves you having to try balance or get if the bike!
You want your bike set up so that your feet barely touch the ground and you are on your tippy toes when stopped. That's the best set up for efficient and comfortable riding. (At least for the type of bike I ride). It makes it uncomfortable at intersections but hopefully you are spending more time moving than stopped. This way too you can get going faster after the light turns green so it's better for traffic as well.
Load More Replies...The way to go are tricicles. They are more stable, you can carry more and unless you are using the bike for sports they dont have many disadvantages (except that they take more space). If i could cycle i would get one. I also see lately more scooters with three wheels for stability
Not even sure if this is swedish. I'm from Sweden and I've never seen it, can't even say I know the brand of the bicycle.
Where I live most bicyclists do no obey traffic rules, they cross traffic where they please, don't obey traffic signals, ride between cars, most don't have lights at night and some don't even have reflectors, and it's a true nightmare.
I think this is a great idea, kudos to whoever came up with it!
Street In Utrecht, The Netherlands: 1969 - 2017
Less noise pollution, less air pollution, better air quality, lower temperatures due to tree shade, and just a much nicer place to live in.
And this is the second worst part of the city, so if you like it, go check it out. It's only half an hour by train from Amsterdam.
Definitely. Utrecht is beautiful i dont get how its not more known abroad.
Load More Replies...Koreans seem to be a lot better at getting out and strolling around.
The trees were planted already, it just that it takes some time for them to grow.
Tweet About The Lack Of On-Street Parking In Japan
Yes it does. This is someone who has never been there. I lived in Tokyo for two years. It 100% happens.
In extremely limited amounts and almost not at all in residential neighbourhoods. "Under the 1962 Garage Act, motorists in Japan need to obtain a "garage certificate" (or "Shako shomei sho") from local police in order to register a car (or when changing address as a car owner). The certificate is to prove that they have access to an off-street parking space." https://www.parkingreformatlas.org/parking-reform-cases-1/japan's-proof-of-parking-rule-(shako-shomeisho)#:~:text=Under%20the%201962%20Garage%20Act,an%20off%2Dstreet%20parking%20space.
Load More Replies...What they do have in the towns and cities I visited is all the smaller back-streets are one-way. Makes for safer streets, and enough width for parking in many places.
The thing that always gets me is the visible electrical wires, here they are almost always underground in urban and suburban settings.
Moreover, cities are often surrounded by suburbs with single-family homes. In theory, they offer a better balance between nature and technology. But in practice, the situation is very different. Yaszek explained that suburbs have their own problems: “Their emphasis on visual uniformity is often part of a larger tendency toward cultural segregation, and the need to drive everywhere—including in and out of the city—only adds to our current environmental problems.”
Me Irl
I'm not keen on pedestrian crossing on the entries/exits to the roundabout. On a busy roundabout you are watching several other cars and then out of the corner of your eye you spot a pedestrian wanting to cross the road. At least this one has good visibility, but locally we have one that doesn't and it would be better with the crossings further away from the roundabout.
In civilized countries, cars slow down when going to a roundabout, so this is the logical place to have pedestrian crossings, don't you think, instead to put them at a location where cars have a higher speed?
Load More Replies...We call them circles in New Jersey, not roundabouts, but they are actually fairly common here. America is big y’all.
there are tens of thousands of traffic circles in the States. People who post stuff like this are lazy morons who get all their info from social media.
No they’re much not a menace. They’re fantastic at reducing the amount and severity of crashes.
Load More Replies...This photo looks like it's in the NL, not the US. Also, there are already roundabouts/traffic circles in the US. The city I was born in has had them since way before I was born.
Washington DC is FULL of traffic circles. Part of the city plan designed by L'Enfant 200+ years ago. DuPont circle, Thomas circle, Scott circle, Logan circle.... Dozens of them
Lots of people don't have a clue how this works though NonUK_Roun...8_Cars.gif
Are roundabouts not supposed to be American? There are four around my house. I cant get anywhere without going through one
Spend a bit of time driving in France and you are going to freaking hate roundabouts.
I hate crossroads with a traffic light way more :D
Load More Replies...Trinity College Dublin Replaces Manicured Lawn With Wildflower Meadow To Increase Biodiversity
After: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/science/trinity-college-s-wildflower-meadow-what-it-was-trying-to-achieve-1.4675965
Oh, I like that! Way better, and so much more interesting and colorful than a boring old lawn.
Load More Replies...Someone should tell them that their wildflowers have all died and left dirt behind with a poorly marked football pitch.
Yet they still have a statue of George Salmon, who fought hard to keep women out of education.
And every day now hundreds of women (including myself at one stage) stream through the gates to show him that he lost :)
Load More Replies...Holiday Gridlock...
As soon as you build sidewalks! And bike lanes! With a fence or something so we don't get hit by cars
And reliable affordable public transit! Holy c**p - what don't governments understand about making it easier for people to get around without having to pay out the nose for cars/maintenance/gas/parking/insurance, etc. and how this is a benefit to the economy in the long run?
Load More Replies...Most American cites are not designed to be conveniently traversed in anything other than motor vehicles. "Get rid of your car" is useless advice.
It used to be like that in the Netherlands, too. It needs to stop and change sometime.
Load More Replies...Okay whoever came up with this didn't account for people who can't go places without a car. What if you're physically disable, what are you supposed to do, ride a scooter? And if it snows?
1. Nobody is pointing a gun at anybody's head, calm down. 2. Nobody who is for people centric planning is ignoring disabled people. They are part of the conversation. Go check out the youtube channel Not Just Bikes, he points out repeatedly how current city planning in North America is an absolute atrocity against the disabled. People centric planning will help everyone, including those with mobility issues.
Load More Replies...Give us reliable, easily accessible, free or cheap public transportation, then. And bike lanes. This is not a problem that can be solved by individuals getting rid of their cars if there are not viable alternatives to transportation.
Public transport is a chicken/egg problem. American cities, with vast areas zoned for single family homes, aren't dense enough to support decent public transport. We need to rethink the way we build housing. https://www.strongtowns.org/
Load More Replies...This sign is incredibly ironic, especially placed in such a pedestrian unfriendly area. Cities that are designed and built for cars first, pedestrians last, have a lot of work to do before demanding that people get rid of their cars. Make the alternatives more desirable and people will drop their cars without being nagged to do so.
I live in the suburbs. Every year there's a "walk/bike to school"drive. No sidewalks, few bike lanes and lots of creeps and they want us to let the kids walk to school?!?
Load More Replies...Yeah, I used to public transit to work. Then I was walking the last 5 blocks and had to cross a street and was hit by a car. I don’t bus to work anymore,
I'm disabled and live on a rural road with no sidewalks, no public transportation, and nothing within 2.5 km except for other houses and farms, so...
And you're commenting on an article about urban design, not rural
Load More Replies...Today, the harm that historic urban development practices have caused to the physical world around us is more evident than ever. However, the professor believes that we can’t simply undo it. Yet, she remains positive: “I do believe we can go forward in new ways,” Yaszek added. According to her, we can always learn from our mistakes and rehabilitate the spaces we’ve already created, rather than simply abandoning or bulldozing them.
Pedestrianizing Broadway
It wasn't the global start. It was already happening in other parts of the world.
LOL if the US ever adopts the metric system, you'll have yanks claiming they invented it
Load More Replies...Ahem, Times Square was definitely not the start of a global revolution. You came late to the party after other cities proved it was viable.
Cute idea that this started a global revolution. The USA has come to this very late in the day!
Funny how US americans always think they started ANYTHING when in fact they copy from other states around the world basically everything they do. The only example they give to the world is how NOT to govern a country.
I do not agree that it was a "global" revolution, as we had pedestrian streets way way way before that in Europe! Maybe it was a USA or even American Continent revolution tough
Oh, need to read comments before posting. Seams I wasn't the first one with this complaint
Load More Replies...Lol, “start of a global revolution”? You were catching up to Europe and other places who done this long ago.
The last place in the US I think of for "Global revolution" is Time square or even Manhattan at all. Watching movies and pictures of the place honestly TERRIFY me. Living or even visiting a city you can't escape from is awful. Can't even really see the sky. Forget the cost of living/visiting there!
My City Has Been Removing Some Street Parking And Making These "Parklets". It's A Much Better Use Of Space.
Before making this transformation, you have to build a good public transportation system. You are making the public walk miles from their parking lot to these areas. These little parklets are cute and everything but build a solid public transportation system first.
I agree. To me somehow this is the equivalent of wanting to refurnish your room; realizing you need to do some serious decluttering; nah I'm too lazy, I'll just put up a pretty poster.
Load More Replies...Cool concept, but where I live, someone would try to pass on the right and take you out with their car while you're eating lunch.
Better then having sidewalks full of chairs and tables (our mayor let cafés expand to the streets because of masks and studd with covid)
I'm 75 years old, mobility impaired with arthritis in my hips. I used to be able to drive and park near shops and restaurants in San Francisco, close enough to get to them with two canes, or a walker. With "parklets" like this using up street parking, there's whole neighborhoods I can no longer patronize. What do you have for me?
Doing the same here. It's a bloody menace. The only people who like it are café owners and hipster customers without cars. Other businesses hate it because people can't park, so just go to shopping centres instead. Everyone who needs to use the road to, you know, GO SOMEWHERE, hates it because it is just another half-baked council idea that increases congestion.
"The only people who like it are café owners and hipster customers without cars". Oh, so you mean other people in your city who also matter and have opinions? Your opinion is based on the idea that cars matter more than people. Probably because you're someone who only drives places. Other people in your city matter too, bub. Get over yourself.
Load More Replies...Cars still being used on the street, so I hope those planter boxes are good and solid, i.e. solid concrete anchored to the ground.
What An Atrocity To Live In
Downtown Houston, and this was at the city's lowest point. At, ironically, the peak of the city economically. Not only was there a sea of parking but the area was also extremely dangerous. You couldn't walk because it was too dangerous to do so. It's come a very long way but it took a very long time.
Yaszek argues that we can do this “by either inventing new or recovering old technoscientific practices that better respect the coincidence between nature and culture, and by practicing a different kind of urban design that springs from the lived reality of city-dwellers, rather than the abstract theorizing of planners and developers who often live in spaces far removed from the cities they design."
1 Car Parking Space = 10 Bike Spaces, Spotted In Stuttgart, Home Of The Car
My city in the USA has long had a problem with bike theft, too. However, we now have a lot of enclosed bike lockers. They take up more space than the rack in the picture, more like 2 bikes, but they’re much more secure. Plus, since they’re enclosed, you can leave your helmet in there and not worry about taking detachable things off your bike. It’s 5 cents/hour in my city. So really quite cheap.
Load More Replies...Carl Benz lived in Mannheim. So that is the home of the car. Although Mercedes is situated in Stuttgart...
I don't understand why praegard is being downvoted.... It's the truth. I am also from the USA
Better public transit for the disabled and disadvantaged would be helpful
I am disabled and can't ride a regular peddle bike. Be great if cities had more ebikes or scooters for tourists to borrow while there
Closing Central Madrid To Cars Resulted In 9.5% Boost To Retail Spending, Finds Bank Analysis | Forbes
no profit for the corps there, so not an option...
Load More Replies...For those of us with Hyperacusis or just can't handle alot of noise, these places make us want to visit more
This just makes intuitive sense to me. If you're driving, it's much more difficult to window shop and browse, and to randomly go to a destination you didn't have in mind. You're closed off from the world. Walking makes all of that much simpler.
Every shop owners association will still swear they need the parking and traffic to drive business. (No pun intended) despite the contrary evidence.
What Would Happen If Americans Were In Charge Of Rebuilding Notre Dame
Probably sponsored by one of the local Burger King's in Paris! Eye roll.
Load More Replies...Is Op under the impression that all the cathedrals in the USA are covered with cars? Just asking, cause I don't really understand this jab. I've been to a cathedral turned into a night club in Germany. I've been to a McDonalds inside a cathedral, that was in Poland. In the USA city I live in we have six cathedrals and a Catholic Mission, and they are all beautifully preserved, historic buildings.
Funny because most of the restoration work done on the castle of Versailles after WW1 was funded by American patrons, notably Rockefeller whose foundation donated upward of 30 million of today's dollars.
That doesn't change the fact that a big portion of the USA is relying on cars, cities are build around cars... you don't have decent public transportation in the US, regardless of the size. I see this as a jab towards that, and I agree with it.
Load More Replies...Seems like a lot of people hating us Americans on here. We may not be a perfect country but most of the people here are trying our best to make the world a better place . We are not all lazy and stupid. Many of us work hard every day for our selves and our families as well as trying to help others in need. And if we are so awful why do so many other countries have McDonalds and Burger Kings now.
Besides, this isn't even something you get a saying in, unless you work in urban planning or for the people who are paying for that project. By the comment, I take none of these.
Load More Replies...We have a LOT of land. We’re big af. You can’t just drives bikes, especially in TX where it takes day of driving just to leave the state. I get you guys live on top of each other and bikes work for you, but not in metro cities in the US and Canada.
Yeah, the distance from my house to Seattle is the same distance as Moscow to Madrid. I don't live on the east coast, I don't even live in a coastal state. Be a helluva bike ride.
Load More Replies...It's amazing. Not even a "We think Americans are stupid" post and we are STILL getting condescended to. Thanks BP.
As an American, I consider myself to be highly critical of a lot of things about my country but this stuff is getting old and boring. These jokes are not offensive or anything and I love a smart jab about America, but come at us with something a little less tired--these jokes are lame and at best are derivative.
This site and many of it's members sure do like being prejudiced toward Americans. But its all for a good laugh . . . right?
Nobody: Southwest Us Developers:
This is common everywhere and its called coving. The modern version was pioneered in Minneapolis, MN, USA and spread. The original idea was to decrease the cost of building roads and utilities (1st generation saved ~20% in costs). Its evolved to cram the maximum number of homes into the smallest amount of space and make homeowner feel like they both have more land than the actually have and feel more secure (no one can see in your windows from another house). 4/5th generation models save close to 60% of construction costs. There is an entire branch of data science and specialized software designed to make these new neighborhoods. Badly made ones are obvious before you hit the first intersection. When buying a new home, use that street crossing as an indicator. If it feels wonky, there's a good chance the developer cut other corners so your basement will leak in a couple years and you'll hear the neighbors having sex.
It is common over lots of the USA and Canada, and is viewed as totally weird in other countries. It creates car-dependent locations, and it is nightmare for people who don't have cars. Lots of the roads attract funding from US federal funds, but when it is time for roads and utilities to be repaired or replaced there is not enough money to do so. The amount that can be raised from taxation from these areas is significantly less than can be raised from inner city areas where there is mixed use of space.
Load More Replies...Cram all those people in and THEN wonder where the water will come from! (Goodbye Lake Mead and the Colorado river!!!
You are absolutely correct. Cities are better for the environment. The amount of resources lost in creating communities like this is tremendous. From water to electricity has to stretched to reach these homes. Add on top of all the cars commuting back and forth from work, school, shopping, mail, etc.
Load More Replies...Think about the people living further away from the entrance. If they have a medical emergency or fire, it’s not going to be good.
Load More Replies...Not one damn little store or park. Imagine if a neighborhood that size just had a little grocery store, a cafe, and a small park. It would be infinitely nicer. Oh, wait. The developer wouldn’t be able to cram ten more piles of garbage drywall and plywood shacks in there. Never mind.
AZ is quickly running out of water!!!! It is hot! It's a desert! Don't move here!!!
Load More Replies...If people weren't so bloody greedy and trying to show off with ridiculously large houses, garages and fancy cars, this wouldn't be happening to its extent.
This layout actually looks nice. The problem here is that these are only family homes. It lacks businesses, a school, a park and so many other things
In Paris, The Financial District Is Isolated From The Old City Center, Allowing It To Keep Its Appearance
After millennia of people using underground Paris as quarries vast parts of the city would make a new skyscraper collapse into a sinkhole before the tenth story was finished. Not that I mind Paris keeping its charming face, but "allowed" is far too generous a term. (one example: https://parisianfields.com/2015/09/13/a-city-built-on-air/). i believe Rome, for one, has a similar problem.
The Paris underground is terrifying. People get lost down there and are never seen again, I don't think anybody know the full extent of the Paris underground. The fact that there are literally millions of skeletons down there as well doesn't help.
Load More Replies...I'd be more impressed if the city actually spent more time keeping Paris clean. It is such a filthy city compared to other major European cities
Space Required To Transport 48 People (A Car Is A Car Is A Car)
Ugh, I hate this false equivalence. It's not a question of one or the other, since we absolutely need BOTH mass transit AND electric, autonomous cars, because there is no way you can build mass transit to absolutely everywhere, but an autonomous car can serve multiple people - instead of sitting idle in the garage, it can work as an autonomous taxi - this way it brings in money for the owner and more importantly it means some people might choose to be car-less if they can just call one through an app and not have to worry about driving, parking or maintaining it...
this except i don't buy concept of "electric cars". To me it feels like farting in your own house (but constantly) vs. taking a HUGE dump at your neighbor's house. Production of electric cars IS polluting, most likelly more than a poor current generation diesel would fart in it's remaining lifetime.
Load More Replies...Bette4 yet, electrified trams and trolleys. We used to have them, before the oil and auto industries pushed them out in favor of stinky gas guzzling busses.
Load More Replies...No, not really, an autonomous car can actually act like shown, like a very comfortable train. Unlike human driven ones. Mass transit is for high volume/demand routes and low capacity routes (inner city) with as many people getting in as need to get out at one point walkable to the end destination. A train moving around with one passenger is ineffective. Public autonomous cars are an addition for the last few miles into sleeper towns and where privacy is necessary. More efficiency is found in building to omit that need. But people will always live rural too and need individual vehicles for that.
You’re totally right, Rissie. If the concept works well, there will be less traffic jams and polution, because unlike humans, the cars are more likely to act as one team.
Load More Replies...The theory behind autonomous cars is you'd need a lot fewer of them, since each one could be in service most of the time rather than being parked 95% of the day. This would lead to much less parking space being needed. The problem with the theory is we don't have autonomous cars that can be operated unsupervised. Tesla FSD is a joke, and the big robotaxi companies like Waymo need to keep a large service staff monitoring their fleet at all times. I suspect true autonomy will require solving the general AI problem (i.e. creating artificial sentience). Without that you'll never solve the infinite number of "corner cases" that only a general AI can handle.
The city of Portland, Oregon had over 200 miles of street car lines until the late middle 20th century. Car culture killed it. You can see little stretches of rail here and there in the city, peeking through the pavement. It breaks my heart.
An autonomous car can come pick people up and drop them off though, so we wouldn't need as many parking lots/garages at least...
Studies in Los Angeles found that people without cars, when offered the choice between pubic transportation and the ability to call Lyft or Uber, overwhelmingly choose the ride-call service. Not exactly the best way to reduce pollution/emissions and traffic.
Tp people complaining about not enough bushes...wonder where you live. We have SO MANY bushes where I live
Toronto Wants To Kill The "Smart City" Forever: After The Failure Of Google's Techno-Utopian Sidewalk Labs Project, Urban Planners Are Focusing On Green Space, Livability And Affordable Housing
Reuse of existing buildings too, I hope, rather than razing them and building new. The ultimate recycling program.
Surprisingly, Calgary is actually converting several office buildings into residential and mixed use buildings. We have a very high downtown vacancy rate that was made much worse when people started working from home, and we have historically had a very segregated core - it's busy in the day time when people are working, but it empties out at night when everyone leaves to the suburbs. It's nice to see that our city is actually trying to improve the situation!
Load More Replies...It's dead. Google puked out because they couldn't comprehend why people don't want every single thing they do monitored by corporate business. If you are going to sell something know your customers. Nobody wanted it from the get go.
Many places in Toronto are making green walls and green rooftops now.
I like Paris' walkable neighborhoods that have nearly everything you need within walking distance.
Toronto Transit is horrible. Bus and steetcar stops are too close together making it almost faster to walk. Subway and commuter train service is all based around one main (union) station. If you don't work near Union station the only way to commute to work in reasonable time unfortunately is to drive.
Well, for starters that's not Toronto in the pic. Maybe what they want Toronto to look like in the future but definitely not how it is now
If that's not Toronto in the picture, who took their CN tower?
Load More Replies...Move People Not Cars!
I guess cars in 1950 and on can only go in straight lines but in 1920 they could go curvy. Current bicycles are ridden by drunks apparently.
It's a representation of the routes you have to take to reach your destination utilizing a given mode of transportation.
Load More Replies...It's a representation of the routes you have to take to reach your destination utilizing a given mode of transportation
I think this illustrates the problems with modern life/transport issues perfectly. I live in a small town that is within 40-odd miles of several larger towns and cities. But using public transport to get to any of these places is a nightmare. A bus is the only option, they are infrequent, can take twice as long as a car journey and then not even get you to where you need to go. I would happily get rid of my car, having lived for years without one when I lived in a city. But could not possibly manage without one now. What might possibly make a difference would be a train station. But they got rid of the one we had and replaced the only viable track route with a motorway in the late 60s.
Town planners problems in a nutshell. Who to please? The residents or the money? There's the problem.
I think it's more about how direct the path is. In todays world, cars get preference.
Sad.
What are these parking spots for? You park, and you go... where? Genuine question
Normally it’s just zoning committees having excessive minimal parking space requirements.
Load More Replies...That is quite a historical representation. It looks like the angled building across the street is a hollow shell.
F*cking parking lots, heating the environment and f*cking up the f*cking trees >:I
Always think of the positive side. At least there are some trees now....
This United Airlines Tourism Pitch For America Is Horrifically Unappealing. (In Sydney, Australia)
There are so many beautiful parts of America, and they choose this smh
2005? You really had to go digging for this latest example of anti-americanism
How about the Grand Canyon, Yellowstone Park, so much of the east and west coasts are beautiful! We have forests and mountains and deserts the ocean! And they show roads....
Neighborhood Walkability
Oooh yes! Mixed use communities are brilliant. It doesn't have to be Walmart and McDonalds, but being able to walk to places is great for keeping crime rates low, and helping to keep a population healthy. Within a 15 minute walk from my home, there's doctors, dentists, physios, 3 schools, vets, general shops, take-away food restaurants, churches, sports halls, garage, day care, newsagents.... and this is in a residential area.
Load More Replies...Where I live its 90% walkability. 2 grocery stores, 2 pharmacies, several fast food joints, a donut shop and 2 restaurants.
In Poland it is normal, that we have a lot od groceries/shops/markets/restaurants etc. nearby - both in small towns and big cities.
As a mexican who has a Mcdonalls, Walmart, cinema a bus station and a subway station all in my neighborhood yes!!! It´s far easy walk or take the public transportation everywere.
A lot of elitist judgement in these comments. This is a selling point for a lot of people who have never had anything within walking distance, and/or for people who, for example, *work* at those locations (or could in the future—inability to get to the work location due to lack of transportation is a huge barrier for a lot of people).
If it's close enough to walk there, that just means the traffic and noise if HORRIBLE.
I Don't Know How That Feels To Live In Downtown Cleveland, But It Definitely Looks Like A Giant Parking Lot.
Downtown Cleveland is now a vibrant residential area and many of the parking lots in this old picture are now gone. There is now significant greenspace and many new hotels and apartments. There are several high capacity (and some free) public transit lines, both light rail and green-fuel buses that serve the area. But you do you BP.
That's what happens when you jam a basketball arena and a baseball stadium in the middle of a bunch of warehouses-turned-apartments-over-bars.
This photo has also been cropped conveniently to remove all of the green space just past the courthouse in the upper left corner, as well as Wendy Park and Settler's Landing (you can see a scrap of the latter in the lower right).
Load More Replies...But they do have a multi-lane expressway that turns a right angle corner. Wonder of the world.
You can have my Dead Man's Curve when you pry it from my cold, dead hands! Oh wait... ---In all seriousness, that bit of infrastructure can be blamed mostly on the power that the railroad lobby still had when the interstate was mapped through Cleveland. It makes that sharp turn to go under a multi-track railroad bridge at a right angle. The railroad wanted to make their bridge as short as possible.
Load More Replies...Santa Monica In 2009 And 2017 After The Completion Of The Expo Line
American Cities. How Can We Change This? Can We Start Reimagining Roads To Be Walkable Public Spaces?
As Promised, Here's Some More "Parklets" From Around Downtown Vancouver.
Last time I was in Vancouver, the junkies were smoking crack and messing on the streets.
Penticton has some of these along their main street as well, I love them!
Inside The Main Railway Station In Berlin, Germany [1000x1000]
Currywurst that is. A sausage with either Ketchup and curry powder or with a currysauce
Load More Replies...National Association Of City Transportation Officials Animation Showing How Many People Per Hour Each Form Of Transportation Moves
Clearly we need an investigation into the wonky seating on those buses...
Big Envisions Covering Brooklyn Highway In Landscaped Waterfront Park [1582 X 890]
And it will only cost.............100 Billion dollars!
Get Jeff Bezos or another billionaire to pay for it #TaxTheRich
Load More Replies...What is the plan for venting emissions? Access for emergencies? Sea level rise?
They have vents down there and protocol in case of emergency and sea level rising is a problem even if the cars were above water
Load More Replies...Dedicated Bus/Tram Lane And Cycle Highway At My University
Old People From My Town Will Say They Miss When You Could Drive Through Downtown. I’m Glad There Are No Longer Cars.
As an old person I do not miss that, never have. Age has nothing to do with that.
Current vs. Planned State Of Wenceslas Square, Prague
But doubling the width of the green areas on the sides
Load More Replies...Always fascinated by "planned" improvements. Everything looks so much better in an architectural rendering. Has this project been completed? What does it look like now? The pictures we see are often historical or hopeful and don't reflect reality.
Is this post for "Find the 10 differences in the pictures?" coz literally that is what I see here.
Barcelona Launches 10-Year Plan To Reclaim City Streets From Cars
The cars are afraid for their masculinity, so they leave the city when the giant dildo is here.
Load More Replies...And yet the citizens are pissed and complaint anytime a car lane dissapears.... people are stupid (I'm from Barcelona)
The Way Kopenhagen Prioritises Cyclists With Temporary Infrastructure Due To Roadworks Or Construction Are Better Than Most Cities' Actual Infrastructure.
Is This Just An American Thing Or Does It Occur In Other Countries As Well?
Restaurant Owners Nationwide Push To Make Street-Side Dining Permanent
I honestly don't agree with this. It is so hard to walk around these restaurants who seat people on the side walk. Now think about people with mobility issues (wheelchair, blind, etc) and how challenging it is to navigate these spaces. No accessibility.
Replace cars with people, and it frees up so much space. It makes it safer for children, those in wheelchairs, blind people etc. It makes the spaces so much friendlier. Install bike lanes, and good accessible public transport, and life in cities is good.
Load More Replies...I saw a waiter get hit by a scooter. Coffee everywhere, the dude who drove into him nowhere to be found. (And it was a sidewalk not a bike lane like in the picture)
The example looks like a nightmare. Food and drink gets swept underneath? Insects and vermin will be happy. Not wheelchair accessible either. The headline is misleading. Street side is not working during the employee shortage plus a lot of the US has weather issues like rain and heat/cold.
They are not owning it, they are occupying it. There are many rules and regulations. And being able to eat and drink outside, en terrasse we say in France, is really nice. It is done worldwild without issues.
Load More Replies...Biking In The City
What? How easily triggered are you that you're seeing sexism here?
Load More Replies...Truman Sports Complex, Kansas City, Ms, USA (Capacity 37,903 And 79,451) vs. Amsterdam Arena, Nh, Netherlands (Capacity 54,990).
"A Public Good Isn't Necessary Because I Don't Need It"
"People can walk" - except for those who can't? Because of disabilities, because they live to far from work, because it's + or - 30 degrees, because they have to travel for work all over the city, sometimes with heavy equipment? Basically, just because something works for you doesn't mean it's a universal solution.
exactly. The nearest bus stop for me is 3/4 of a mile then the nearest one to my work is over a mile. I'm not walking that when it's =50F with 2 feet of snow on the ground.
Load More Replies...Bikes are a luxury not everyone has. I drive 40 minutes to work, mostly without traffic jams. It will take probably 1.5 hours on a bike, on the freeway which is very dangerous. Also, in my country, most of the year it's 30-40 degrees celsius and most of us don't want be sweaty all day. And of course we are talking only about people who are physically able to bike. Most cities here don't have many job opportunities and most people spend about 1.5 hours each way in car\bus\train. Bikes are not a valid substitution for public transportation.
well if we all had your attitude then how are we going to share rides with co workers? what do you want? a croggy?
Loving the use of "croggy" - it's so regional and reminds me of good times as a kid!
Load More Replies...Look, I live 4 kilometers from work, I can even walk home when I don't catch bus. But what about my coworker who lives 30 kilometers away?
Does your coworker need to live 30 km away from work?
Load More Replies...People can ride a bike-i can't because of medication (dizzy spells) and balance issues. People can share a ride with co workers-not always ,sometimes you're the only one on shift. People can walk-as another commentor mentioned ; inclement weather ,disability,work gear and various other things make this difficult for humans.
Townsville, USA
American Housing Tracts And Cringe Worthy Names, Name A More Iconic Duo.
Cedar Court... I bet there's like a bazillion of places with that name lmao
Not sure the point or are we just slamming at this point?
This Infographic Stunned Me
Look at it in reverse order: for every dollar you spend on a car and it's maintenance, the city, state, and country pay 9.20$ in building and maintaining roads, building bridges, licencing and regulating vehicles, pollution-related health problems etc. etc. For every dollar you spend on biking, the infrastructure, regulation, and health costs are much less.
Load More Replies...This is from Discourse Media so we have all heard of them haven't we? Haven't we? My bike ride and walk today cost you 9 cents, he said so.
Cycling Is Ten Times More Important Than Electric Cars For Reaching Net-Zero Cities
On the contrary, a bike would give you a wind while biking at 0C or lower...
Load More Replies...Rosario, Argentina, Before And Today.
San Francisco Bans Cars On Market Street
Land Use Comparison Of A Typical European City And A North American City, Created By U/Butterslice
America has more room and didn't have to squeeze every thing into smaller areas.
Primarily the issue is that the United States was/is settled by people who wanted to get away from others: family, society, religion, etc. The immigrants were/are loners and individualists.
Load More Replies...Road Sign Seen This Morning; Probably Not The Official Message
You Could Land A 747 On This Side Street (Deal, Nj)
new jersey? or new jumper as we would call it in UK ......
Load More Replies...The Basics Of Designing A Neighbourhood
There's more to it that this. We need to add in good public transport, green spaces, little local shops that can pop into on your way home from work, schools your children can walk/cycle to, links to transport hubs to move from one area to another, local services etc.
I've lived with AND without shared walls, floors and ceilings. It's not the same.
45 Years Of Canadian Suburbia
hideous, to many buildings and people, the newer picture is a down grade.
Is it tho? Building high is better than building wide when it comes to land cosumption
Load More Replies...Jaw Dropping
Municipalities have requirements towards newly built objects - like parking lots. While some require the minimum number of parking spaces, Berkley has apparently decided to set an upper limit. So instead of "this parking lot must fit at least X cars" they go with "this parking lot can't fit more than Y cars", thus limiting the space occupied by said parking. As for NIMBY and YIMBY - these are acronyms, they respectively stand for "Not In My Backyard" and "Yes In My Backyard". Hope this helps.
Load More Replies...The NIMBY aside, here is my take on minimum parking. That means a Wendys could open with just six parking spots. Or two. An office building could open with five. How has the minimum been a problem?
Reminder Of How Cars Ruined Cities
These are cities, not middle of nowhere. People get around with a reliable public transpot system. If it hadn't been destroyed by the car lobby.
Load More Replies...Bombs devastated many European cities during WWII. In the USA, it was the car lobby.
If you zoom in you can see people going to work and making money. Except that those few people under the bridge in Rochester, they're unemployed and hungry.
You seem pretty brainwashed by car-centric culture. If North American neighbourhoods had been developed in the European style, then people would be more than able to get to and from work without being stuck in gridlock for two hours a day, and they would have a much better quality of life to boot.
Load More Replies...A lot of people reading this article don't seem to get the point - proper urban planning isn't about banning cars, it's about making them unnecessary for most people. If cities were developed in a way that you could easily walk to your neighbourhood grocery store, and you didn't have to bus to school, and you had a lot of options for work within a walkable or bikable distance, and mass transit took priority over single user cars, then cars would stop being a necessity. But strict zoning policies that are in place in most urban and sub-urban areas in North America, along with huge resistance to funding public sector things like mass transit, have made this virtually impossible. Your grocery store is probably several kilometers away, and you probably spend over an hour of your day driving to and from work.
You guys should check out the youtube channel Not Just Bikes, it's very educational and makes a really good point for human first civic planning!
My city has closed several main streets and made them pedestrian walk ways. And closed a lot more roads and converted them to bike lanes, but it's not very well planned, it's hard to get anywhere because the closed streets are right in the middle of car roads, you'll suddenly get stuck and having to drive several blocks to get around. And no, not everyone can bike
Have you tried walking those areas? It sounds like it's easier to get around if you're a pedestrian.
Load More Replies...When I was growing up, it was hard to get through southside and downtown Seattle because of all the cars and buses. But buses that were gas powered were not allowed in the downtown area...only the buses that were able to hook to the electrical lines that ran through the streets. Now you hardly see those lines anymore. Why? Because now most of the buses have moved to underground tunnels. The result are less crowded streets and safer for pedestrian crossings. Washington also actively encourages park and rides and carpooling to limit the number of cars in the city. As a result, we didn't have the smog and filthy streets that plagued some other major cities. Light rail now makes it easier to get to downtown from the airport and down the main road that leads out of Seattle to the south where most of the industrial district is. Cheaper than paying for parking in the city.
Park and Ride is a brilliant idea. I've never encountered them here in Australia (which doesn't mean they don't exist, just that I've never seen one) but we found them at many cities in the UK. Fantastic for if you have a a bulky car/RV, or if you live in suburbia - do the hard bit by car and then a bus straight to the middle of town. Should be a more widely used concept.
Load More Replies...Awesome ableist content, well done. Btw, banning cars will do a fraction of the work regulating emissions from our largest corporates will do, but you keep going after the little people first if you’re too scared to lose your Amazon access.
Banning cars while doing nothing else wouldn't accomplish anything, I agree. But reducing the need for vehicles by planning walkable neighbourhoods that put pedestrians first (including those with disabilities) would not only reduce the amount of single occupant car emissions, but would also reduce the need to manufacture cars in the first place. That would go a long way toward reducing GHG emissions while improving quality of life for everyone. Strict zoning bylaws and massive amounts of concrete do nothing for anyone, including the differently abled.
Load More Replies...Not sure if this was an article about urban planning or american bashing, probably both
I mean...if you're bashing poor urban planning, may as well go to the source. Canada is just as bad
Load More Replies...A lot of people reading this article don't seem to get the point - proper urban planning isn't about banning cars, it's about making them unnecessary for most people. If cities were developed in a way that you could easily walk to your neighbourhood grocery store, and you didn't have to bus to school, and you had a lot of options for work within a walkable or bikable distance, and mass transit took priority over single user cars, then cars would stop being a necessity. But strict zoning policies that are in place in most urban and sub-urban areas in North America, along with huge resistance to funding public sector things like mass transit, have made this virtually impossible. Your grocery store is probably several kilometers away, and you probably spend over an hour of your day driving to and from work.
You guys should check out the youtube channel Not Just Bikes, it's very educational and makes a really good point for human first civic planning!
My city has closed several main streets and made them pedestrian walk ways. And closed a lot more roads and converted them to bike lanes, but it's not very well planned, it's hard to get anywhere because the closed streets are right in the middle of car roads, you'll suddenly get stuck and having to drive several blocks to get around. And no, not everyone can bike
Have you tried walking those areas? It sounds like it's easier to get around if you're a pedestrian.
Load More Replies...When I was growing up, it was hard to get through southside and downtown Seattle because of all the cars and buses. But buses that were gas powered were not allowed in the downtown area...only the buses that were able to hook to the electrical lines that ran through the streets. Now you hardly see those lines anymore. Why? Because now most of the buses have moved to underground tunnels. The result are less crowded streets and safer for pedestrian crossings. Washington also actively encourages park and rides and carpooling to limit the number of cars in the city. As a result, we didn't have the smog and filthy streets that plagued some other major cities. Light rail now makes it easier to get to downtown from the airport and down the main road that leads out of Seattle to the south where most of the industrial district is. Cheaper than paying for parking in the city.
Park and Ride is a brilliant idea. I've never encountered them here in Australia (which doesn't mean they don't exist, just that I've never seen one) but we found them at many cities in the UK. Fantastic for if you have a a bulky car/RV, or if you live in suburbia - do the hard bit by car and then a bus straight to the middle of town. Should be a more widely used concept.
Load More Replies...Awesome ableist content, well done. Btw, banning cars will do a fraction of the work regulating emissions from our largest corporates will do, but you keep going after the little people first if you’re too scared to lose your Amazon access.
Banning cars while doing nothing else wouldn't accomplish anything, I agree. But reducing the need for vehicles by planning walkable neighbourhoods that put pedestrians first (including those with disabilities) would not only reduce the amount of single occupant car emissions, but would also reduce the need to manufacture cars in the first place. That would go a long way toward reducing GHG emissions while improving quality of life for everyone. Strict zoning bylaws and massive amounts of concrete do nothing for anyone, including the differently abled.
Load More Replies...Not sure if this was an article about urban planning or american bashing, probably both
I mean...if you're bashing poor urban planning, may as well go to the source. Canada is just as bad
Load More Replies...
