Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
“She’s Terrified”: Erika Kirk’s Fox Interview Fuels Theories She Knows The Real Culprit Is Still Free
Erika Kirk, the widow of Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk, has broken her silence in an emotional Fox News interview, her first since her husband’s assassination in September.
The appearance, meant to be a reflection on the life, loss, and faith of the conservative figure has instead triggered a wave of conspiracy theories online, most notably one that claims the real culprit has never been caught.
Highlights
- A conspiracy theory claiming the person responsible for Charlie Kirk’s shooting hasn’t been captured spread online.
- Some netizens took a clip of a recent Erika Kirk interview as proof of her “being afraid to tell the truth.”
- Several users condemned the theory as offensive and disrespectful toward the grieving widow and her family.
Her interview with Jesse Watters has now become the center of online chaos, as some accused her of giving what they called an “evasive” answer when discussing Tyler Robinson, the man charged with her husband’s murder.
“Do you think they caught your husband’s k*ller?” Watters’ asked.
RELATED:
A theory claiming that Charlie Kirk’s shooter hasn’t been caught went viral after an Erika Kirk interview
Image credits: Villgecrazylady
During her sit-down with Watters, Erika spoke about the grief her family is going through, how the incident affected her view of life itself, and the trial ahead, which is expected to begin early next year.
“It’s a fearlessness that’s rooted in the understanding that I will have my day and my time, whenever that is, when the Lord knows that I have completed my mission, and I’m not afraid,” she said.
“Charlie wasn’t afraid either. We never lived in fear. If we did, we wouldn’t get anything done.”
Image credits: Charlie Kirk
She also shared how she’s guiding her young daughter through the loss.
“My daughter continues to ask [where Charlie is]… and I said, ‘If ever you want to talk to Daddy, you just look up to the sky and start talking. He can hear you.’”
Image credits: Villgecrazylady
But the moment that caught some netizens’ attention came when Watters asked about the man accused of her husband’s assassination: Tyler Robinson.
Instead of giving a straight yes or no answer, Erika stopped, meditated for a while, and said she trusted “her team.”
“I’ve seen the autopsy. I’ve seen portions of the evidence that were collected, and I know the team that’s working on this. They’re the best team. I trust them completely.”
The theory claims that the FBI is covering up the case to hide the “true culprits” behind the crime, and that Erika knows it
Image credits: Villgecrazylady
Within hours of the broadcast, a former podcast host named Mel published a thread claiming the “real culprit” was still free.
Mel argued that Erika doesn’t believe the authorities have caught her husband’s k*ller, claiming she knows this because the autopsy report allegedly conflicts with other collected evidence and that her hesitant response suggested there were things she couldn’t openly say.
No. The answer is no, she doesn’t think they’ve caught her husband’s killer.
And she knows that because she’s seen the autopsy report and it doesn’t align with the other evidence that was collected.
This was a very straightforward question, literally no one answers like this… pic.twitter.com/Sbajeot9g2
— Mel (@Villgecrazylady) November 6, 2025
Her thread quickly gained traction among users who accused Erika of being “afraid to tell the truth.”
Image credits: realstacyharmon
Image credits: Twins1020
“My money is [she’s] terrified,” a netizen replied. “They k*lled her husband in front of the whole world. She probably doesn’t trust anyone. She’s playing along for safety reasons and that’s why she seems fake.”
Image credits: Gage Skidmore/Flickr
Others went further, suggesting that when Erika said she trusted “our team,” she was referring not to law enforcement but to conservative media allies.
“Note she says, ‘I trust our team.’ Not ‘I trust the FBI,’” a user wrote.
It didn’t take long, however, for others to push back against the theories.
Several users condemned the theory as disrespectful and offensive toward a grieving widow
Image credits: mrserikakirk
Not everyone was willing to entertain the conversation. Many users called Mel’s claims irresponsible and borderline defamatory.
“The autopsy matched,” one person replied. “There were multiple confessions, fingerprints on the weapon, DNA on the ledge, and a firearm registered to his family. Dunno what more you could want.”
Image credits: mrserikakirk
Others defended Erika’s right to remain cautious in her phrasing before the trial begins.
“If she comes out and directly says ‘yes,’ she risks a mistrial,” one user explained. “She has to be careful not to prejudice the case. That’s how the law works.”
“There are things we likely are not aware of, and she cannot speak on,” another added. “ None of us have the right to decide for her.”
Image credits: Gage Skidmore/Flickr
Meanwhile, supporters of Erika accused conspiracy theorists of exploiting a grieving widow for clicks.
“She’s still in mourning,” one comment read. “To twist her words into some deep-state mystery is disgusting.”
The theory was popularized by Candace Owens, a conservative commentator known for pushing similar claims
Image credits: Stephen60908911
Image credits: DanSeemill5186
Despite the noise, prosecutors maintain that Tyler Robinson remains in custody, facing a first-degree charge. His trial is expected to begin next year, and Erika has urged the judge to keep cameras in the courtroom for transparency.
Image credits: Utah County Sheriff’s Office
Perhaps the most prominent figure amplifying conspiracy theories surrounding the case is conservative commentator Candace Owens, who has previously spread similar claims.
For instance, she has alleged that French First Lady Brigitte Macron is secretly a man, and suggested the COVID-19 fatality statistics were deliberately inflated to control the public.
Image credits: Candace Owens
Beyond the snippet shared by Mel online, further segments paint a much clearer picture of what Erika Kirk thinks of Tyler Robinson, something several users pointed out to her.
“Well, if you watched the rest of the interview you’d realize that she thinks that law-enforcement got the guy who k*lled her husband,” one wrote.
“We deserve to have cameras in there. Why not be transparent?” Kirk told Watters. “There’s nothing to hide. Let everyone see what true evil is.”
“The perfect answer.” Netizens continued to argue over whether the theory was true or not
Image credits: Dustiguminsky
Image credits: Queenlourdess
Image credits: RickAddante
Image credits: PaBo3133
Image credits: darlanorene
Image credits: PBSportstalks
Image credits: GhostOfFlappyD
Image credits: Bo_Thomas
Image credits: Hal9000_T1
Image credits: ItsMeAmberBell
Image credits: targirl81
Image credits: Leg0King
Image credits: PriezPourNous
Image credits: mike1010011
Image credits: dtgrambo
Image credits: FTLA308
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
What do you think ?
Tiilynn 1 month ago
Uh-oh she's feeling like her 15mins isn't long enough. Listen, people don't care - they're vile people who preach hate. Does that make me a bad person for not caring?? Don't much care about that either. Children were getting hurt from their rhetoric, innocent people were getting hurt from their rhetoric. Their *God* is evil. Nuts (insert the F word) them.
Tiilynn 1 month ago
Uh-oh she's feeling like her 15mins isn't long enough. Listen, people don't care - they're vile people who preach hate. Does that make me a bad person for not caring?? Don't much care about that either. Children were getting hurt from their rhetoric, innocent people were getting hurt from their rhetoric. Their *God* is evil. Nuts (insert the F word) them.
You May Like Child Kidnapped From Kentucky In 1983 Found Alive Over 40 Years Later “Everyone Felt It”: Conspiracy Theorists Go Wild Over Clip Of Soldier During Presidential Speech Mom Claims She Discovered Her Son's Skinned Body On Display In Las Vegas Museum
Analice Couto
Gabija Saveiskyte
Analice Couto
Related on Bored Panda
10
3