The fear of being stigmatized by others often leads people to avoid psychotherapy. Even worse, some of us internalize the stigma which reduces the likelihood of seeking help even more.
However, psychotherapy has been shown to improve emotions and behaviors and to be linked with positive changes not only in the brain but the body as well.
Interested in how that happens, Redditor u/annabel420 recently asked women "What's the best question your therapist has asked you?" And they responded.
As of this publication, u/annabel420's post has 777 comments, many of which detail the powerful moment when people began healing. Here are some of the most memorable ones.

This post may include affiliate links.
Therapist: "You realize you're describing domestic abuse"
Me: "Oh no, he's never hit me."
Therapist proceeds to explain emotional, psychological and financial abuse.
The most prevalent form of abuse is the kind that does not leave bruises.
I told an ex "I wish instead of lying, cheating, gaslighting and trying to ruin my life you had just hit me, because I would not have stood for it and you would have been gone." He looked me dead in the eye and said "I know that's why I didn't hit you."
Load More Replies...Took me years after a breakup from an abusive partner to realise he'd been abusive. Then when I started talking about it people didn't want to hear it because I hadn't mentioned it at the time. Can't win.
Sorry people won't listen. Maybe some recognise it and don't want to accept it? At least you got away though.
Load More Replies...It was only when I was recovering from an abusive relationship after my marriage ended that I realised my marriage was also an abusive relationship. My ex-husband never got physical but he was emotionally abusive as well as financially abusive and sexually abusive by withholding affection from me.
I used to say this about my ex until he finally hit me. It's all the same.
“Is that going to matter 5 years from now? How about 5 months? 5 day? Will it even matter 5 hours from now? Then why are you wasting more than 5 minutes worrying about it?”
This was key to beating my depression, when I realized that I couldn't remember what I was worrying about a week ago. That meant that what I was worrying about now wouldn't matter next week, so maybe it wasn't as big as I made it to be.
Ur describing anxiety not depression. U don't worry in depression. U get consumed by the sadness & emptyness of the abyss
Load More Replies...I need to remember this and also "don't stress about the things you can't control".
At the time, it can easily feel like yes, it will matter 5 years from now
That question is typically asked when the client in therapy is focused on a subject of a very low importance and can't get out of the loop created, so the question breaks the cycle and the focus :)
Load More Replies...This is my personal mantra. Sometimes, for the most part it works, and at other times . . .
Therapist: “I don’t think you’re happy or know what makes you happy. You’ve spent your whole life trying to make others happy and have never focused on yourself. You’ve worked so hard for a life you can put on a post card (wife, great house and career, etc) but I don’t think you want any of it.”
Me: You’re crazy. Of course I know what makes me happy!
Therapist: Name 5 things.
Me: …..
This conversation made me significantly change my ways and has probably been the single most impactful statement in my entire life.
She was right.
I have exactly five cats - so really, it is an easy question!
Load More Replies...Actually making others happy, makes me happy. I like making birthday and chrissie gifts, I love treating friends/family to lunch, brekkie etc, I don't do it out of obligation, I do it out of joy for myself and bringing joy to others.
My sisters, cats ( mine and in general), wild birds, weird litte mushrooms that look like brdsnests, forests, the squirels in my yard, books, knitting, machining, cooking for people I love, puzzles, gardening, just to name a few. I think this is hard for many, because people think they have to be somehow meaningful. They don't.
I logged in from pre-covid times to give you an upvote. I try heard to learn what you so wisely say! I just cannot believe I am allowed to just live. To just sit here and knit a sock, talk to a knitter friend.
Load More Replies...everyone list 5 things! mine: cats, not having to clean my house (but i have to), not having to make dinner (but i have to), playing video games and achievement hunter.
I so feel the "not having to clean my house" but conversely, a clean house makes me happy...
Load More Replies...I'm glad that I don't have that sort of problem! I have a lot of things that make me happy, and basically all of them my wife also enjoys.
Still trying to figure out the reason that you posted that you "don't have that sort of problem."
Load More Replies...
"Why do you keep referring to yourself as having anger issues and emotional issues?"
It was the first time I had even considered that the 'anger' issues I was told I had from when I was a small child were just my family not wanting to deal with my emotional needs. I'd been gaslit my whole life to think that all of my emotions were unreasonable and 'extreme', when they actually weren't.
I recently 'graduated' from therapy (my choice, with the door always open to go back). It took me 1.5 years to relearn emotions, how to express myself, and not 'protect' people from my emotions. I do feel emotions strongly (was diagnosed with ADHD), but none of my reactions are extreme.
I am a very reactive and emotional person with anger issues. Was diagnosed with ADD 2 weeks ago and started meds last week, hopefully they will help.
Parental gaslighting is just about the cruellest thing a parent can do short of physical abuse. The damage it can do and how you can get no help at all...
We can be made to think our feelings are irrelevant, silly, emotional, and if our thoughts and feelings are different from the 'families' then they are wrong X
I have two sisters that are still doing it, following the parental example. 🙄 The difference is that I've (finally!) realised that they are not very nice people and I don't need to accept their view of me any more. Awful what families can do, isn't it?
Load More Replies...I was diagnosed 10 months ago at 54 yrs old. The meds were a life-changer (for the better)
Thank you Anita. Maybe a year ago, I read the symptoms of ADHD in women and it blew my mind. it was like they Understood me in a way that no one else ever has. I figured I’m 50 and too old to do anything about it now so just forget about it. Reading what you just said makes me realize that I should get tested also. Many, many thanks!
Load More Replies...I found out lately that my "anger issues" were actually emotions that I don't understand. They used to trigger some "fight or flee" instinct. I actually just need time to process those things. I don't have "anger issues" anymore since I was diagnosed with ASD earlier this year. I'm 36...
I think most women are told our emotions are too extreme and therefore bad, though not always by parents.
Load More Replies...when I was a teen my dad used to start these epic fights with me that would rage on and on with me screaming "Ok I'm sorry I didn't do the dishes just leave me alone and I will do them" I know now he was likely drunk but he would push and push until I got so worked up that I would go cold and say "something" cruel. I say Something because I don't remember what and couldn't remember the next day, I would wake up with migraines from yelling. I couldn't ask him because he wouldn't talk to me for days or said "You say the meanest s**t when you're mad, you watch people for their weaknesses then use it against them" Looking back I realize there were maybe 8 of these fights in 2 yrs but he would bring it up and even warn people in front of me "Be careful she has a bad temper and she will say the most hurtful thing you have ever heard" it was like a warning and bragging at the same time. the thing is I'm the kind of person who actually doesn't get mad easily if I do I might snap a LITTLE like
(2) I do I might snap a LITTLE like saying OK I HEARD YOU! but I don't scream or yell unless pushed and pushed (this has happened maybe 4 times in 40 yrs since I was a teen) My dad was a drinker and a narcissist and he gaslit me and lots of other people into thinking I had major ANGER ISSUES. I didn't and because of that I had horrible fear of ever expressing what anger I actually had
Load More Replies...
“Why do you always seek their approval, when you’ve never approved of their choices?”
This was an eye opener when discussing my parents with her.
I think it's pretty normal for children to seek their parents approval, even as adults. But when it impacts you negatively then of course there is an issue that you need to resolve within yourself. You can't change how others act, but you can change the way you act. (Of course easier said than done).
Totally agree with you Foxxy! I always seek my mother's approval (consciously or not), even if I know that her feedback is toxic for me... At least, now I'm aware of it, thanks to therapy. As you said, I "just" need to change the way I am with her ;)
Load More Replies...One of the best things my therapist said was, "Rather than chasing after the love and approval of those who won't or can't give it, how about accepting the love and approval of those who give it freely?"
I had to set boundaries with a few family members that are toxic to me. My mother for one.... she couldn't just be supportive in my recovery from addiction. She was always negative and let me know what a screw up I was. I call her every other day and see her 1 day a week just so I know she's ok. I love her and want her in life but I cant deal with her toxic ways. She's my biggest trigger.
Glad that works for you but I must admit I don't quite understand it. That's not to say I think your choice is wrong at all, I've just always felt that walking away was perfectly reasonable when people are toxic. I suppose, for me, it switched the love off completely. I'd help and support it necessary, I'd want to be able to live with myself, but I avoid them! Good luck with your recovery. Clearly you are strong.
Load More Replies...To avoid nasty confrontations that will ripple out into the extended family and damage relationships?
If a group of adults can't respect the opinions or choices of another adult who they supposedly love, then they don't deserve to be catered to.
Load More Replies...Sometimes parents don’t always make the best choices for themselves but if they love you unconditionally they will approve your choices if they believe it is best for you, even if it scares them.
Too many parents do love conditionally though. Eg rejecting their children when they reveal their sexuality should it not meet their view of the world. A lot of parents don't respect their children's choices, sometimes that's fair enough because a choice can be poor and sometimes just because it's not what they want.
Load More Replies...
If you weren’t related to your relatives, would you be friends with them?….if no, then why does it matter so much to you what they think?
The real-world answer to that is: Because someday, I may need something from them, and actually get it. That's one reason people put up with family members even though there's little love or liking there, because someday they may need a loan or a place to live. (Of course, if you've realized that they'll never help you or recognize your needs, life is a lot simpler in some ways.)
As long as the family member isn't physically abusive or extremely verbally/emotionally abusive, I agree. It's real-world life truth. Plus the family member might need me for something. I still care despite legitimately strained relationships. We might reduce our interactions but still maintain ties.
Load More Replies...My sister Lydia..HECK NA but everyone else (minus my dads side of the family) YAS and the family friends! My dad does not count on his side of family my papa made a racist FB post.we don't talk to him or about him anymore
You dont have to be friends with someone for them to have an influence on your life. And because you ARE related, they can have more of an influence than a random other individual. My aunt (dad's sister in law) cost me a job because she had made up her mind about me over something I said when I was eight. Her circle of influence was wider than we knew.
Often when living in a disfunctional family people tend to become rather isolated, as cutting people out of their lives is the most effective way of hidding the truth. E.g. a child who never has any friends over so they won't see how drunk mom is. This, however, will often cause some rather fragile friendships that quickly fall apart. Hence most people from nonfunctioning families are often rather lonely and have no supportive network who can assist with the breakup with the familiy. Leaving a family, even if you don't like them, therefore often becomes an overwhelming task, since the company they can offer is still seen as better than being completely on your own. Another important aspect is that most people think of what they experience in their family to be pretty standand, and hence do not realise that they can make other, and better, kinds of connections to some other humans. We are pretty stuck with our families and hence quite dedicated to do what it takes to make it work.
This is something I managed to figure out on my own. No, I wouldn't be friends with my relatives.
Because I desperatively try to be more "normal" and more like my peers. It is "normal" to have parents and be in contact with them. Being able to come back home, go on Holiday etc. I cant do it now because I went nc.
in regards to negative self-talk: “the things that you say about yourself…if your closest friends were depressed and going through a hard time, would you say the same things to them?”
Not sure why you got downvoted there, that was a shitty thing to do.
Load More Replies...Mine had me bring in a photo of myself as a kid. Then she had me say some of the things I said to myself, to her. The kid. I had a hard time. That was the point.
Wow, this made my eyes sting. Couldn't ever imagine telling my kid self how much I hate her (at times)
Load More Replies...But what I think about myself is not the same way I think about my friends. So no I wouldn't say the same to my friends coz it's not true but what I say about myself, is MY truth.
So I guess the question for you is, if your friend was depressed, would you judge them for it?
Load More Replies...
“Whose voice is saying those things?”
She recently told me at the beginning of our sessions I made a lot of negative statements about myself and she asked me that question. I said it’s my voice saying that to me. It’s 16 sessions later and I said something negative and she asked the same question. This time I said the voice is my mum’s. It really helped me realise that all the negative thoughts I have about myself are a product of what I’ve been brought up with. It was completely eye-opening.
I have had the same question. I had to give the voice a name so I would be concious about who speaks. Do I want to do what the voice says or is it pushing me in thinking I want it like that. I had to focus on breaking the sicle of automaticaly listening to the voice and thinking about what I realy wanted and press on.
Recognizing that much of we think of as 'me' is just our conditioning... learned and not real. What is learned can be unlearned to make room for new choices.
There's a line in the movie Avengers: Infinity War, delivered by a woman to her adoptive father. "Everything I hate about myself, you taught me." I related quite strongly to that line. The voice telling me what to hate about myself came from my mother.
When they're born, we should take out an insurance policy for our kids ... to pay for the therapy they'll need (regardless of our intent to do our best).
I think it is a coping mechanism, based on misguided principle: "If we can predict (we rarely can) what others are going to say, we can prepare for it and steer clear of the situation causing the suffering". The problem is that our emotions cannot really distinguish between the made up situation of someone telling us something unpleasant and it actually happening, so just by thinking it, we actually end up ruining our own day on the behalf of someone else who might actually say something completely different if ever given the chance. Sometimes it is just better to not overthink the situation and just accept that you cannot keep control of everything and let things just happen. You'll might get hurt or you might reac a new realisation helping you move on in life.
Toxic people are the worst. I think they are that way because of self loathing
We may have inherited a long history of negativity. It can stop with you.
Load More Replies...
Do you think your grief is about the relationship ending or is your grief about what you think could have been and how you thought it was going to be? It was the latter
That's the thing about breakups. Sometimes the grief is for all the plans you'd made, all the hopes and dreams associated with the person you broke up with, not the person themselves. That is, FYI, also a reason that sometimes people aren't as sympathetic to your breakup heartache as you think they should be, they can see how much is grief for the life you'd planned and not the other person, before you do.
And sometimes people don't understand your grief at all because, after all, that other person was just a controlling douche or abusive witch and it's good you've broken up.
Load More Replies...When my husband died after we had only been married 5 years I went into a very deep depression. Almost sui... I had a therapist ask me the same question. Made my grief more bearable, I still miss him but it's manageable.
I realized I was hurt by a long time friendship ending and that in reality it hadn't been good in SOOOOOO long and that all my pain was about losing those few good times and the possibility that we might ever have that kind of friendship
My therapist said this but about my crappy mom dying. I didnt care shed died, I cared she was never a good mom and id missed out on that life
I find this to be true, about family relationships, as well. We long for and/or miss what "could have been," or what we imagine that it "should have been."
This was my case, my grief was of the goals and dreams that relationship was supposed to fulfill for me... but I can do those in my own now too ;)
'If you had a child, would you let them be around this person?'
Absolutely not.
'Why do you feel you don't deserve to be protected from this kind of person and abuse?'
'Who is taking care of the child in you that never feels safe?'
Having this literal experience can be life-changing, to have thought about this could save a lot of heartache
You can begin to give comfort and care to the parts of you that still hurt.
i was in an abusive relationship that left me severely traumatized, I've been in therapy for a year now and recently we were talking about responsibility, and how I felt like I should've done more to protect myself and see the warning signs, talking about the first time he got frustrated with me for talking to another man. And my therapist asks, "When he got irritated with you that first time, did you know in that moment that he would end up throwing you against a wall and you'd have to flee his house in the middle of the night in the dead of winter with no shoes on?" and when i chuckled and said no, I had just expected that to be normal jealousy that we could work out together, and she says "exactly. You couldn't have known. Nobody expects their partner to abuse them. You need to be kind to your past self, you have experiences now that would help you if this sort of thing happened again, but you didn't then. You couldn't have known, and that's ok."
this retelling is not nearly as eloquent as her response was mind you but english is not my first language so im translating xD
These things are so obvious afterwards, but not at the time. And your English is great.
Every relationship should end with the first signs of unfounded jealousy, unfounded mental or physical aggression and with any attempt to isolate you and control your life, your thinking and your finances. As soon as you notice any of this, don't even pack your bags, just leave before it gets too dangerous to leave.
You don't seem to understand the point of *any* of these.
Load More Replies...And this is why we never ignore red flags, no matter how small. They always escalate. At the first sign of disrespect, leave. The FIRST sign. The first time you feel belittled, confused about their feelings for you, disrespected, ignored, gaslighted--leave. It never gets better, and always gets worse. Women need to learn this, and learn it early. It will save so much future heartbreak and abuse.
I do not agree! You are not going to find someone who is perfect from the start. Being in a well functioned relationship requires hard work, and every relationship is different. There will alway be a phase where you need to learn to know your partner -and some lines are bound to be crossed before they become well established and you know from experience where they are. Respect for example can have very different cultural definitions depending on where you are from and how you were raised. Hence what you see as disrespectfull behaviour may not line up with your partners definition and hence he/may not know you see it as such. If you leave a relationship as soon as you experience your definition of disrespect, you are only going to have some shortlived relationships. Do not accept serious abuse, but at least investigate the situation, correct misunderstandings and try to correct it before running away. Red flags should not be ignored, but not blown out of proportion either.
Load More Replies...Hindsight is 20/20. We all need to forgive ourselves for things that happened in the past. Just because we can see clearly now doesn't mean that we could then and neither should we expect ourselves to have been so clear-sighted when we didn't have the experience necessary to see clearly.
There's a saying that hindsight is 20/20. I would argue that hindsight is useless since you're looking out your a**e when you do it. And that right there is why: you didn't know then what you know now and had no way to know that you needed to know. Remember, you cannot change the past, but you can learn from it.
"Does that actually make you a bad mother or does it just not live up to the impossible standard you have set for yourself?" Oof, that was a hell of an eye opener.
Not a parent but I have impossibly high, binary standards. Everything is either bad or good, success or fail with no middle ground. My shrink made me understand that nobody achieves great success in all fields, it's just not possible. Helped a bit.
We are often shown the rewards of someones effort but rarely the cost. It gives us a scewed image of what is achieveable. (I often have to remind myself of this). It might be possible to get that perfect grade for that project, but what you do not see is that the person who did it spend way to much time on it and neglected some of the other courses and got bad grades in those. When comparing your achievement with that of someone else, note that the person you want to swap live with is rarely one person but rather a "Frankenstien person" you made by combining different parts of more than one person. What you are comparing yourself to is in fact a person who does not exist and who has more than 24hours in a day so he/she can invest 10.000 hours into mastering everything at once. I wish more people were brave enough to post their failed attempts so the social media could give a more honest impression to what it took for them to achieve the skill they make look so easy.
Load More Replies...I had one therapist say something like this because I was constantly feeling like I wasn’t doing enough and that working and trying to support myself and my son and going through court battle after court battle with the father was just killing me. Then being in a mode of burned out for years not graduating feeling like s**t because I missed time with my kid and didn’t do enough then or now over and over thinking and punishing myself …. It’s hard being a mother or father especially when life just keeps hitting you.
This should be the rule for mums. Trust your instincts, you're doing fine!
That's not what this is about at all. This mom's instincts were leading her down a self-destructive path and she needed to use logic and intellect to check if they were true.
Load More Replies...Either you are too emotionally dense to understand what the therapist is saying here or you're just so determined to create a reaction that you'll post any old nonsense.
Load More Replies..."Are you upset because of something someone said, or are you upset because of the way you heard it?" This led to me learning that I overthink/overanalyze situations and create my own perception of people being mad at me.
Can totally relate to this. I always over analyze situations, and sometimes misinterpret what others say to me, which can create unnecessary arguements. I've become more conscious of this, but still, it can create big divides
Letting yourself feel what's underneath the attempt to intellectualize it all works better by far
Load More Replies...Like judge Judy said:" There's a reason why you have 2 ears and just one mouth." And my father once told me: "When we argue, you always start answering me right after I've finished speaking. Which means that you didn't even take the time to process what I said or tried to explain to you. I suggest you take at least 15 seconds to think, before answering. You'd look less stupid and you'd learn so much more."
I had a friend tell me once, as an outside observer to a romantic relationship I was in, tell me "you think too much."
If possible, I find that it's useful to repeat back to the person, what you heard. However, it's not always possible, especially if emotions are high.
"You're free to lie to me. Have you considered, not lying to yourself?"
Was a slap in the face, but in the best way possible.
You know you lying to me doesn't hurt me, it cost you money, and the time and effort you put in coming here AND your chance to deal with these things with someone who won't and can't hold it against you
"Do you want to die or don't you know how to go further?" Really made me think
Yonks ago when volunteering on a crisis helpline one of the most effective 'tools' they gave us in training was, when speaking with someone suicidal, to ask them if they wanted to be dead and gone forever or if it was more that they wanted to avoid living through the current time. To anyone going through it, things can get better than right now and you don't have to go through it alone. Please reach out.
This was one of the things I learned to ask as a Samaritan, do you really want to kill yourself or do you just want this pain to stop.
Load More Replies...I really want to die, although I know how to go further and why I have to. So I wait to do what has to be done and then to rest in peace forever. I am looking forward to it. I am so tired.
What if it just gets worse the further I go? It's already been awful, I don't want to imagine what it will be like 10 years from now.
“Why aren’t you allowed to be happy right now, instead of when you’ve lost weight?” I suffer from binge eating disorder, and this is the reason I went to therapy in the first place. The hardest thing I learned through therapy is that I had to accept myself for who I am now in order to make any progress. This helped because I wasn’t putting so much pressure on myself to lose weight — like everything was riding on it."
"I gained a lot of weight and went back and forth with diets, calorie counting, and excessive exercise to try and counteract my excessive eating. Obviously, none of this worked, which just made me feel completely hopeless as I gained more and more weight.
I had to like my body and be happy and content in my skin. I am happy with the way things are now, although I accept that I have to make healthier lifestyle choices since I am still overweight.
If this sounds familiar to anyone, get professional help. You are not lazy, you have a mental health issue that needs treatment. It was like a weight lifted from my shoulders that felt like it had been there my whole life.
Because many people are constantly acting like we don't deserve to be happy. We know we are overweight, we know the health issues that excess weight causes, we are fat, not stupid. We deserve to be treated with respect and please stop patronising us.
In my opinion those comments are fuelled by insecurity. Rather than dealing with their own problems these people lash out to someone else with devastating consequences. Just to feel better about themselves or hide their own vulnerability for a couple of seconds. Every person deserves to be treated with respect. Especially you foxxy. I always read your comments and most of time they make me smile. Thank you.
Load More Replies...And that's why I keep defending the "Body Positivity" movement, even though I don't agree with everything said in the name of body positivity. Bullying and self-hatred don't lead to positive life changes, self-confidence and a good self-image do, so if you want someone else to change in any way - back off with the criticism and let them learn to value themselves.
This should be more widely known: in the 1920s Germany had a FKK movement (“Freikörper kultur”) that said the human body is beautiful in all sizes, shapes, colors and ages. Since then it has been clear that if you make fun of or criticize someone based on their physical appearance, the real problem is YOU. Every culture needs to adopt this.
Load More Replies...I have been binge eating when I was unhappy, though not when contented, we just need to recognise that eating something is not going to fill the gap in your self that has been created by not being loved and respected.
It's true: the first step to fixing a problem is to acknowledge that you are not the problem! If you go into any effort blaming yourself for the way things are, you're automatically sabotaging any chance of success.
Wouldn't it be nice if for once someone would take care of you?
I don’t know how to let anyone take of me. And people around me are all I have left in this world. I can’t let them down. And part of me gets so mad that they now just expect of me. I should know better. I know how silly it sounds but oddly, here are bored panda, I am more expressive. No one judges me. In my life, I need to be the invisible mute. But here? I can say it. So, I guess, thank you to everyone is in order.
Ofcourse share and discuss ur feelings online. Please also take baby steps to connect with ppl around u and let them know too.
Load More Replies...I feel ya. I'm am such a people pleaser and often forget about my own needs
it would be nice. i haven't been taken care of since i was a kid. no one in my life offers to do anything for me, and if i ask, i'm 50/50 that it'll be done. it would be really nice if i could have just a day or two a year when i don't have to do anything for anyone.
Load More Replies...If you are not used to someone caring for you it can be a rather confusing thing to handle when it happens. Paradoxically suddently having someone caring for you can be a rather stressful event. You know what is up and down in your world and you can go through it half asleep and on autopilot. When a new element is introduced, e.g. a person who does not act like everyone you know, it can cause mental overload when you are trying to learn the new rules and adjust to the situation. Suddently you are forced to be very aware of what is happening around you and your internal system will fight to make things go back to "normal" and easy to handle with the usual mechanisms in order to save energy. Most people who has no one caring for them has pushed those who tried to come into their lives away due to it not matching with some rule of theirs (e.g. "I should be able to deal with matters myself, or else I am weak"). Living by the old set of rules is much simpler than reevaluating them. That is why it can be so hard to help people who are not used to getting any help or love at all as it does not fit in with their world wiev and they will be quick to explain to you why you are wrong for taking care of them, or they can feel like they are a burden to you etc. A good cure for this is thinking about the joy you sometimes get by helping others and ask if it is fair you deny them of a similar feeling?
Some people, like me, have big anxieties about letting people take care of us. I can't define it for everyone, but for me, that is WAY too vulnerable.
this is a thought that occurs in peoples head, negetaivly. if my therapist said this to me i would be sadder and even deeper in negetive thoughts
M sure it's just a specific situation where ppl build walls and not let anybody help them or even consider it.
Load More Replies...“How can you get better if you still live with your trigger?” Moved out a month after she asked that.
I started grinding my teeth around 30. My dentist of 15 years knew I was single, asked about my current boyfriend. I said we were still adjusting. He told me to leave as soon as possible. Thought he was rude. After 6 months, broke a tooth grinding. Still with that man, he asked. Well . . . yes . . . but left him not long after that. Never had to grind my teeth ever again. A professional/objective observer could have the answer you need . . .
What is it about dentists? They always say the rudest, bluntest things that have nothing to do with your teeth, but darn it if they're not always right.
Load More Replies...
“Did you know that ‘no’ is a complete sentence?”
Yes! Just bc someone asks you do not have to answer right away and the answer can be no, with no guilt or explanation attached.
Why does the therapist have pictures of Brian Pohsen and Isaac Asimov hanging in her office?
"No" is also a perfect answer. Or as one of my bosses thought me: "You are asking more than I'm able to do."
“Do you realize you don’t have post partum depression, but are the victim of an abusive relationship?” Changed everything for me.
Sometimes it takes someone who has the guts to tell the emperor that his clothes don't exist.
It is a therapist's job to have the guts to say things others won't.
Load More Replies...PPD is still bad though.My parents friend has it.The baby is super cute though
... and what's stopping you from doing that?
Sometimes it's helpful to have someone point out that in many ways we are/create our own obstacles.
Sometimes you can't put into words that mental block that's telling you that you can't do something, that you'll mess it up, that you shouldn't even bother...
Another one of mine is: "Is that something you know or something you believe?" ...Very often we do not live in the real world but in a world that works by some rules we have constructed on our own. Those rules are often constructed based on pased experiences which are extended way to far into areas where they do not apply. E.g. we get a lot of experience about how people react in our familiy, and easily forget that not everyone reacts in the same way as our parents do when presented with the same kinds of circumstance (this is especially true if you lived isolated in a disfunctional family). However scary it may seem, if you want to move forward in life you need to test the rules every onces in a while, but doing so on a sufficiently small scale not to cause any ireversable harm.
I often say, 'the only thing stopping you is you'. This is true for many things both good AND bad!
It isn't always that easy... often there is also a reason why I don't do something. As it often comes out later. Sometimes it's my instinct preventing me to do a mistake I most definitely would have regretted
Often it's reality what's stopping you from doing it. Because actions have consequences that can get you in real deep trouble. It's very easy to say "You should quit that boring or stressful job." But that's not possible if you don't have another job lined up, cause the bills have to be paid.
true but many people just run on autopilot and do not even do the analysis to realise what is stopping them and how to prevent it. Succesfull people are those who are aware of what is going on and look for the options of changing their future, whereas unsuccesfull people are just grinding the same groove day in and day out. Realising this is not a garanty to reach success but it is an important step in the right direction which many people never even take. Start looking for a better job, then quite the one that is wearing you down.
Load More Replies...This is something I struggle with. The "should I / could I" thoughts in my head.
I do not think the "should I"/"could I" thoughts are that dangerous, since they are a calling for action and a part of improving the conditions you are living under. See them as an indication of an analytic process you are going through in order to make sure you are not becomming stagnent in life. On the other hand "I should...","I ought to..." and other versions of the same theme is just hitting yourself with shame and that is often not the cause of anything productive but rather just a mood an initiative killer.
Load More Replies..."Guilt implies that you did something wrong. Do you think you did the wrong thing?" In terms of ending a relationship that was hurting my mental health.. really made me rethink the things I have felt guilty about in the past! He also said that guilt is a learned feeling. We aren't born feeling guilt. People make us feel that way. Interesting!
I haven't personally heard this but needed to. I've held a lot of guilt for the death of my parents (my mum was a GI bleed while babysitting my children while I was at work, my father was in end stages renal failure and passed a month later the morning after my mum's memorial service). There is nothing that I could have done that would change the outcome and I've struggled with telling myself that.
I feel guilty for not getting there fast enough when my mum said 'I'm not okay'' on the end of the phone - she died due to an aneurysm within seconds of ending the call but I was 15 min drive away. Truth is nothing would have saved her unless she was in the doctors hands while it happened. We can't be there all the time, we can't stop medical issues taking their toll. It wasn't your fault Terilee and your parents would not want you to blame yourself.
Load More Replies...Maybe a better question would be do you think you did the wrong thing KNOWING WHAT YOU KNEW THEN. Many times, the answer is Yes, I did the wrong thing. But maybe it was only wrong because of random things that happened to follow your actions, other people's decisions, something else going on you had no way of knowing. Being "wrong" does not have to lead to guilt if you can accept that you are not omnipotent.
“You can’t give someone the shirt off your back…if you do, what are you going to wear?” Hated this in the moment, because at the time giving to others was a huge part of my identity - always making sure I was there for other people. And I used to get angry when I would never get that back, because in my head it meant that no one cared enough about me to give what I was giving. Turns out, they were just establishing their boundaries for what they’re able to give without emotionally draining themselves like I was. I still struggle with it to some degree but at least now I feel better about taking care of myself first. Nine time out of ten, people understand that and have been very supportive.
I've never had a relationship like that if someone I consider a friend says something bad about someone I know or me.dropped.immediately
"Why do you gaslight yourself so much?"
I wasn't even aware that you could gaslight yourself. Comming to terms with my trauma was difficult. Somedays I still tell myself I'm still just overreacting or remembering it wrong..
I experience the same thing with doubting myself when it comes to my abuse. Thinking I'm remembering wrong, mostly because someone else has already started doubting me but it lasts a long time.
I could see to reasons for this: 1) someone (e.g. a parent) installed a gaslighting voice in his/her head by being a gaslighter themself and hence it was considered the normal way to think/behave 2) it is coping mechanism whereby you avoid facing the actual world as it may be too painful but instead you can "swoosh away" your major defects by calling it something else ("I didn't really treat XX that bad, it must be something I do not remember correctly...").
Why? We can definitely question and delegitamize stuff to shame ourselves to the point we think we must just be remembering things wrong. Or that a person isn't abusive because everyone else thinks they're great. Or convince ourselves to sweep big things under the rug because we should focus on the positive instead.
Load More Replies...
“At what point does trying become doing?”
I was having a rough time and felt like nothing was going right despite how hard I was trying, and I said just that: “I’m trying, I’m trying”. And she asked when does ‘you’re trying’ become ‘you’re doing’? You’re trying and you’re doing this this and this, so are you ‘doing’ or trying? Basically I needed to give myself more credit and stop being so hard on myself and recognize what I was doing right.
Also one of my all time favorite things she said that anyone has ever said was “Emotions that get buried alive never die”. So, let that sh*t out and deal with it.
“Emotions that get buried alive never die”. So breathe and let your feelings be okay.
What are you hearing me say?
Ironically your question nails the point of that statement perfectly...
Load More Replies...When talking with an air trafic controller you "read back" (repeat the essential part of what they said to you) their instruction so both part agree on what was said and that nothing was lost in transmission. Likewise a proper read back on important topics can be usefull to show another person that you heard, and more importantly understood, what they said and that nothing has been lost in translation. It may feel a bit odd in the begining, but with time you may realise how different what you say and what the listener understands can be. Hence this small check proceedure can save you a lot trouble and misunderstanding down the road, and it acts as powerfull tool during negosiation by building repour with another person by you showing that you understand him/her. Start your sentence with: "So what you are saying is.." and then rephrase what they said to avoid sounding like a dumb parrot. "What are you hearing me say" is the other important side of this check procedure.
“How would you feel about that situation if a child was present-any child, not anyone’s in particular.”
Made it easier to accept and set my boundaries
You never stop being precious, no matter how harsh and ugly the "real world" is. You don't have to accept the trash people throw at you, and you don't "deserve" certain things simply because you're not a child anymore. I had to learn that, too
Nor do you "deserve" certain things if life forced you to "grow up" too fast.
Load More Replies...For your own benefit. Children tend to bring out our caring side.
Load More Replies..."Can you control other people and their actions?" I struggle hard with anxiety and I was in a relationship with a narcissist. My therapist asked me this in the middle of a rant about how I always felt like I had to explain my ex's bad behavior to others. And I just kind of sat there like.... You know what, no. I can't. Nothing I do will make my ex change or stop doing what he does. And it's not my job to make him decent to be around.
A therapist once told me that a lot of people think that everyone is watching them. In reality no one is even noticing you when you're walking down the street or crossing a square. He proceeded to point out some people in a crowd who stood out for some reason, yet I didn't notice them. Point proven.
No kidding I mean unless you’re walking naked down the street no one will really pay attention.
Load More Replies...Yes indeed you can. We have some influence on what behaviour other people have, but only to a certain degree. That is the cornerstone of raising children, where you use different meassures to shape their behaviour. However once we are grown up the "training" of people around us should be kept at a minimum, and only be don when it will help them act wiser in the future. What you do, can chance how other people act, and you should behave accordingly. Act like an idiot and it will probably change their actions in a way so they avoid interacting with you. Like with everything else, it is only when we try to contol other people in excess amounts or think we can achieve something impossible that it becomes a problem. Saying "I didn't like what you did there", in an attempt to make people realise the impact of what they have done and hoping it will make them change their future actions to a avoid doing it again is perfectly reasonable.
My therapist doesn't usually ask questions but she did ask me something that made me think deeply during my architecture licensure examinations.
She asked me, "If you were an honor graduate in college, you tested well, and you studied, why wouldn't you pass the exam?"
I guess my imposter syndrome is really really on high and I was totally afraid of failing. I passed, and it's been three years since then.
My guidance counselor in college made me realize how much I needed psychotherapy.
She asked me, "Some people would be happy when they tell you your strengths, but why are you crying?"
It made me realize that I don't believe myself even when I'm telling the truth. I don't believe that I have the capacity to do anything good.
Apparently, it's not a good sign if you have difficulty accepting praise. When people are nice to me, I tend to reciprocate by sobbing loudly in their face.
You mean you aren't supposed to tear up at the slightest compliment?
Load More Replies...I'm living in a culture where praise and compliments aren't the norm once you grow up. When people like you or what you've done you'll get some sarcastic joke thrown at you. Which is way better than fake friendly compliments.
Why would you assume the compliments are fake? Most Americans mean things like "Congrats on the new job" when we say them. Your successes don't diminish my opportunities or successes, which seems to be the mindset in some cultures.
Load More Replies...This all stems from selfish, narcissistic parents, who seem to want you to fail.
“And is that working for you?”
She says it all the time. It’s really helped me understand that there are reasons I’ve thought about or done things a certain way and that isn’t bad, but now that my life is different those ways are not working for me anymore.
I think this depends heavily on how it's said and in which context. There are certain situations where if somebody said that to me, they would be wearing an overdone cheese and tomato quiche faster than they could say 'therapy'.
I know someone that could happen to LOL! But it's more fun to smile (sort of), oh wait, I do tend to get passive aggressive. But when you know you can, you don't have to. Love your visual!
Load More Replies...Those therapists ask the questions that their clients don't ask themselves. They are helping their clients to free themselves from years of brain washing, indoctrination and humiliation. Your condescending comment is based on your ignorance and hurtful to the people who are in therapy. You call yourself Devil's Advocate but that's no free pass to being a jerk.
Load More Replies...
She asked me to come up with one thing I physically liked about myself and I just couldn’t do it. Couldn’t come up with a single thing. I broke down and cried and that was when I realized I had a problem with self image and self hatred. All of my self talk was negative. (I’m fairly pretty and I was a healthy weight, but I thought I was massively overweight)
It sounds superficial but it kind of broke down a lot of walls for me and helped me realize I had more problems to work through than I thought, and not just surface level ones. It helped me realize I needed to change my self talk drastically and learn to love myself. It’s what has stuck with me most from therapy. That was ten years ago.
“What are you going to do about it?” - made me realize that sometimes I get stuck in a rut where I’m unhappy, but I don’t actually take action to change things… and therefore I stay unhappy. I say this to myself all the time now.
“Do you know how to enjoy life? Have fun and let yourself be happy?” This question messed me up and I thought about it for days after. I had been in such a depressed state for years that I honestly didn’t know how to be happy
Me too … wow … I am not a island surrounded by shark infested waters though it feels that way.
“Appreciate the quality, not the quantity.”
I had spoken to her about some very intense emotions. My mother had me in her late 40s. She currently has cancer and has reached retirement. I’m her youngest (20) and we have an AMAZING relationship. Recently because of the anxiety that life gives, I’ve been upset because she’s getting older and I haven’t had a ton of time (in retrospect) with her. Ms. Therapist basically told me to take a chill pill and appreciate what I have. She’s absolutely right
I am very sorry for what you and your mother are going through. It's not something that seems to be taught in our society naturally - how to deal with aging/ailing parents when you yourself are not a full fledged adult yet. I am going through something similar. It's 1000x harder than anything I have ever delt with before. You are not alone. But also, record videos of time you spend together. Nothing 'special' per se just like an hour of life. Set up a camera and just let it roll. When she's gone you are going to appreciate having a video of her just being her everyday wonderful self. ♥️. Hang in there. It's hard and it hurts- but it' only is that way because you have such a wonderful relationship with her. And that's something to be truly thankful for. 🤗
"You say that, statistically, you shouldn't be alive. Do you believe that you don't deserve to be alive?"
Really hit me. Thought I'd dealt with my issues around self-worth a long time ago, but I never realised they partially stemmed from survivor's guilt and therefore hadn't addressed that source in previous therapy trajects.
Are you doing this to punish yourself?
That one question both f*cked me up and greatly expanded my knowledge of myself.
What if this person apologizes? Are you even ready to accept an apology?' It hit me like a ton of bricks when she asked that. I wasn’t ready for an apology. I was still too angry, and I wasn’t ready to let go of that anger yet. This was in regards to my dad choosing his brother over me when I revealed my abuse.
Seems like anger is the healthy and appropriate response to that. I am s sad for you going through such a thing.
Someone once said that forgiveness is a gift you give yourself. It's not letting the offender off the hook, it's freeing yourself from anger and resentment.
“Are you the same person as you were before?” This question always brings me back from ruminating about things and let me stay grounded. Because the things I was always panicking about, my therapist knew I could handle it because of my self regulation, wisdom and coping skills so I was worrying for nothing. Her reminder always lets me go “oh, right. I am no longer in the past. I have the ability to cope with whatever comes.”
"Do you think that story you're telling yourself is accurate?"
I assumed this is a different version of "Are you upset because of something someone said, or are you upset because of the way you heard it?"
I don’t know whether it’s what a therapist is supposed to say - I wonder where the good in lying to oneself is, though.
Load More Replies...Why do you feel you need to stay in that job if it’s making you so unhappy?
Maybe because bills need to be paid and you might be educated for that particular job and need the income level of that job to maintain your standard of living for yourself and possibly a family?
Why would I be downvoted? It this not a reality for many people?
Load More Replies..."Because I need the money to pay you to ask dumbass questions like that"
“Who are you comparing yourself to?” I had very poor self esteem from comparing myself to others. I truly didn’t realize I was exclusively comparing myself to people who I thought were smarter than me, more attractive, more interesting etc. Huge revelation for me.
It wasn't a question but I was supposed to have 4 covered sessions with him and at the end of the 4th session, before I told him myself, he said something along the lines of "I think I have way too little experience with the things you are dealing with to be helpful for you."
Really appreciated that.
Why? If I go to a family doctor with a painful leg and he suspects that the leg is broken, then I want her to be honest and say that he can't treat it himself. If I go to a therapist and she hasn't got the specialism or experience to handle my problem, then I expect equal professionalism and respect.
Load More Replies..."Could I ask, why do you accept these people and behaviours into your life?" After describing a previous breakup, person did me wrong, and I took it really deep into my feelings, but didn't have to.
Me : Tells therapist something that I’m doing that is actively destroying my life and causing me pain
Therapist - “How does that serve you”
Me - “[Screw] You”
No look, it must serve you in some way, some warped, ineffective way, or you wouldn't do it. Like drinking to forget you're an alcoholic means you forget for a couple of hours.
If I may. Your defensive response may be because, though you can say it, and have the strength to do so, you have to go to that place that started it, and that’s not always a cake walk. Stay the course. You are stronger than you think and have the courage to change.
Good therapists can really help you break down decades of negative patterns and suffering. I would always remind people that you may not gel well with the first therapist you find, and that's okay. When you find the right fit, it's very obvious. It's okay to do just one session with someone and then say you are looking for something different. Don't give up on therapy because you don't find the right therapist first time out.
I have anxiety and struggle with bad thought spirals, oftentimes involving imaginary conversations, or imaginary versions of people criticizing me. My therapist asked me, "Have you tried telling them to shut up?" The question absolutely stunned me. I had never before considered that because the versions of the people talking in my head are IMAGINARY, I can just tell them to SHUT UP without any consequences, because they're not real people. It's helped me immensely.
"What are you trying so hard not to think about?" Stopping to finally figure it out really hit me hard, but it was what I needed to do.
Every single image in this post is of women. The reason suicide is so high among men is because they are taught that seekign help is weak and unmanly. We need to stop supporting this toxic nonsense.
The title of the article is quite clear. Now let's wait for the masculine side of things in another article!
Load More Replies...I told my therapist I felt like I was trapped living on a rock in the middle of a river. All this stuff kept rushing at me and the best I could do was grab some good things as they floated by while dodging all the bad things. He asked, "If you could get off that rock, what would you do then?" I had no idea. Thanks to him I figured out what I actually wanted and started making plans.
Another good question he asked when I started talking about my marriage problems: "Before you go any further, are you looking to make your marriage better, or are you looking to end it?"
Load More Replies...Two things my therapist told me that kind of contradict each other. One: "You realize you keep saying how horrible your mother was to you, but then you keep giving excuses to yourself as to why she was that way." Two: "You said you would have been happier if your mother had left and your parents divorced early. My mother did that around the time your mother would have. She was given custody of all the kids, and my father was given possession of the family home. She struggled because, even though she worked back then, when times were tight, she wouldn't get paid because her boss paid the men first because 'they have families to support.' That's what your mother was facing." I finally realized..yes she was in a terrible situation..but she had no right to take that anger out on us kids...we had nothing to do with it.
I was ask by a therapist, who anx what did I want to be. I was in therapy treatment for bulimia and anorexia disorders. I told him I wanted to be a good person and a positive influence on others and to be an addiction counselor as I am an addict grateful in recovery. He point out that nothing I said had anything to do with my weight. I could be a good and positive person as well a counselor no matter what size I was. I had always been called out for being to big or to fat or not small enough. My husband was the worst. I am now a healthy woman and am pursuing my dream of becoming a counselor. My size doesn't define me as a person.
There are good days and bad days. Finding the right therapist makes the world more manageable.
I find these powerful, but with the exception of the post about postpartum depression, these are all questions that could be asked by a therapist regardless of gender. The first time I saw a therapist was about 30 years ago. The first question I was asked, and remember it like it was yesterday was: "When was the last time you were happy?" Now that I am in my 50's , the answer is "not often enough". Depression is complicated, and this is a very nice article.
I'm jealous of those with good therapists. I had a bad one. The one thing he said that I wish I could forget "Of course you're depressed. Look at you. You're fat." I have never trusted a therapist since then.
I had a bad one too. I was there because I was in a relationship with an abusive narcissist and he had me convinced there was something wrong with me. The therapist ended up being just as bad. “Why would he want to marry you? I wouldn’t want to be your husband either.” I later found a much better one.
Load More Replies...Good therapists can really help you break down decades of negative patterns and suffering. I would always remind people that you may not gel well with the first therapist you find, and that's okay. When you find the right fit, it's very obvious. It's okay to do just one session with someone and then say you are looking for something different. Don't give up on therapy because you don't find the right therapist first time out.
I have anxiety and struggle with bad thought spirals, oftentimes involving imaginary conversations, or imaginary versions of people criticizing me. My therapist asked me, "Have you tried telling them to shut up?" The question absolutely stunned me. I had never before considered that because the versions of the people talking in my head are IMAGINARY, I can just tell them to SHUT UP without any consequences, because they're not real people. It's helped me immensely.
"What are you trying so hard not to think about?" Stopping to finally figure it out really hit me hard, but it was what I needed to do.
Every single image in this post is of women. The reason suicide is so high among men is because they are taught that seekign help is weak and unmanly. We need to stop supporting this toxic nonsense.
The title of the article is quite clear. Now let's wait for the masculine side of things in another article!
Load More Replies...I told my therapist I felt like I was trapped living on a rock in the middle of a river. All this stuff kept rushing at me and the best I could do was grab some good things as they floated by while dodging all the bad things. He asked, "If you could get off that rock, what would you do then?" I had no idea. Thanks to him I figured out what I actually wanted and started making plans.
Another good question he asked when I started talking about my marriage problems: "Before you go any further, are you looking to make your marriage better, or are you looking to end it?"
Load More Replies...Two things my therapist told me that kind of contradict each other. One: "You realize you keep saying how horrible your mother was to you, but then you keep giving excuses to yourself as to why she was that way." Two: "You said you would have been happier if your mother had left and your parents divorced early. My mother did that around the time your mother would have. She was given custody of all the kids, and my father was given possession of the family home. She struggled because, even though she worked back then, when times were tight, she wouldn't get paid because her boss paid the men first because 'they have families to support.' That's what your mother was facing." I finally realized..yes she was in a terrible situation..but she had no right to take that anger out on us kids...we had nothing to do with it.
I was ask by a therapist, who anx what did I want to be. I was in therapy treatment for bulimia and anorexia disorders. I told him I wanted to be a good person and a positive influence on others and to be an addiction counselor as I am an addict grateful in recovery. He point out that nothing I said had anything to do with my weight. I could be a good and positive person as well a counselor no matter what size I was. I had always been called out for being to big or to fat or not small enough. My husband was the worst. I am now a healthy woman and am pursuing my dream of becoming a counselor. My size doesn't define me as a person.
There are good days and bad days. Finding the right therapist makes the world more manageable.
I find these powerful, but with the exception of the post about postpartum depression, these are all questions that could be asked by a therapist regardless of gender. The first time I saw a therapist was about 30 years ago. The first question I was asked, and remember it like it was yesterday was: "When was the last time you were happy?" Now that I am in my 50's , the answer is "not often enough". Depression is complicated, and this is a very nice article.
I'm jealous of those with good therapists. I had a bad one. The one thing he said that I wish I could forget "Of course you're depressed. Look at you. You're fat." I have never trusted a therapist since then.
I had a bad one too. I was there because I was in a relationship with an abusive narcissist and he had me convinced there was something wrong with me. The therapist ended up being just as bad. “Why would he want to marry you? I wouldn’t want to be your husband either.” I later found a much better one.
Load More Replies...
