Bored Panda works better on our iPhone app
Continue in app Continue in browser
BoredPanda Add Post

The Bored Panda iOS app is live! Fight boredom with iPhones and iPads here.

Gamers Are Getting Upset Over ‘Forced Diversity’, But This “Straight White Dude” Shuts Them Down In A Viral Twitter Thread
190points
User submission
5.9K
106.7K
Social Issues3 years ago

Gamers Are Getting Upset Over ‘Forced Diversity’, But This “Straight White Dude” Shuts Them Down In A Viral Twitter Thread

Back in the day when I was into video games, the issue of diversity never occurred to me. I played games like Tekken and Mario Kart, happily changing between a variety of characters from an Italian plumber to a kickass Japanese woman, a mushroom and a Russian robot commando.

I was spoilt for choice for diversity, and never once thought that I needed a character ‘like me’ to feel represented. The idea of playing video games was to escape to a fantasy world and be ‘someone else’ for a while.

Image credits: Fightincowboy

But perhaps that’s because I was a young white male, and had an infinite number of role models to look up to in all areas of media and western culture. I took representation for granted, and so the thought that others might long for their own heroes to relate and aspire to never crossed my mind. Luckily, we now live in more enlightened times. Or do we?

Ellie (The Last Of Us)

Image credits: thelastofus

Apparently, these days there is “a lot of fuss over gaming “forcing diversity” and people getting upset that a character is gay, trans, etc.” In a viral Twitter thread, self-described “straight white dude” gamer FightinCowboy decided to explain why this fuss is unjustified and give his opinion on why diversity in gaming is important.

Image credits: Fightincowboy

Billie Lurk (Dishonored: Death of the Outsider)

Image credits: dishonored

Image credits: Fightincowboy

Dorian (Dragon Age: Inquisition)

Image credits: dragon age

Image credits: Fightincowboy

Battlefield 1 – In The Name Of The Tsar

Image credits: battlefield

Image credits: Fightincowboy

Chloe And Rachel (Life Is Strange: Before the Storm)

Image credits: lifeisstrange

Image credits: Fightincowboy

Image credits: Fightincowboy

Image credits: Fightincowboy

But perhaps one has to look beyond fictional characters to find the real problem. According to the games industry trade body TIGA, just 14% of people working in the UK games industry are women. Over in the U.S., the International Game Developers Association suggests that only 3 percent of game developers are African-American, a figure that has risen by only 0.5 percent in the past decade. In comparison, 76 percent of developers are white.

Image credits: FaeLalune

Image credits: FaeLalune

Image credits: yorimashigatari

So while this booming industry is giving a whole generation of people cultural cues and nuances, telling stories that are avidly followed by millions and millions of fans, these stories are being told from an overwhelmingly white, male perspective. Is it any surprise then that efforts to introduce diverse characters that better reflect our everyday lives appear forced? If we want true diversity in gaming, we need more diversity among the people that make them.

Image credits: yorimashigatari

Speaking to Bored Panda about the reaction to his posts, Fightincowboy himself seems to be a little worn out by the experience of going viral. The content creator, who himself loves games like Sekiro, Bloodborne and Dark Souls, has clearly received quite a bit of hate over it, sadly.

“I knew it was gonna be a hot take but didn’t expect that much engagement on it,” he told us. “More than anything, I blame it on politics. As much as I try to keep politics out of my content it is inevitably part of culture, and to that extent I think the current political administration has policies that empower and embolden those who embrace hate over love.

“People can debate and argue all they want but when white nationalist hate groups are using “Make America Great Again” as their battle cry, it’s pretty f**king obvious there’s a problem.”

Image credits: M_Folley247

Image credits: NachoBlueYT2

What do you think? Do you feel that there is ‘forced diversity’ in gaming? Are videogames inclusive enough? Should they even have to be? Scroll down to read the rest of the reactions below, and let us know what you think in the comments.

Image credits: BethReads

Image credits: NoisiBoi305

Image credits: Fightincowboy

Image credits: ENDERWS

Image credits: ENDERWS

Image credits: ArkBreeder

Image credits: TheFifthofBenji

107Kviews

Share on Facebook
Popular on Bored Panda
Share your thoughts
Peter Bear
Community Member
3 years ago

Also a straight white male. Also a gamer. I've played males, females, and neuters in video and tabletop games over the years. I've played straight, gay, bi, and ace. I've played as characters that have a different skin tone than mine happens to be. Hell, I've played as things that aren't even human. Why? Because that's the point of gaming; to get to be things you aren't, and to do things you can't do in real life. That's the point of fantasy. And if you don't get that, you're an idiot.

Ozacoter
Community Member
3 years ago

Exactly :) I mean i swich gender and orientation im my characters and for sure I prefer not to be human if I can avoid it ;)

Load More Replies...
Daria B
Community Member
3 years ago (edited)

I think complete character customization would solve all the diversity related problems, since each player gets to build their own individual character, their own avatar. Like it was the case in Morrowind, for example, and one of the Mass Effect games (if not all) Anywaaaaaaaay...... Personally, I've been playing as a semi-Japanese straight male for most of the time. ♥

rhyan lumilay
Community Member
3 years ago

Yeah his problem is he wants a straight white dude then custom player himself with one or just don't play the games that he thinks offends him.

Load More Replies...
Reirei
Community Member
3 years ago

I hope that as diversity increases, so does clothing and armour choice. It gets boring running around in boob plated bikini armour.

Reilly Beryll
Community Member
3 years ago

One of the reasons I cherish some of the Elder Scrolls games: they don’t sexualize all of the armor.

Load More Replies...
Load More Comments
Peter Bear
Community Member
3 years ago

Also a straight white male. Also a gamer. I've played males, females, and neuters in video and tabletop games over the years. I've played straight, gay, bi, and ace. I've played as characters that have a different skin tone than mine happens to be. Hell, I've played as things that aren't even human. Why? Because that's the point of gaming; to get to be things you aren't, and to do things you can't do in real life. That's the point of fantasy. And if you don't get that, you're an idiot.

Ozacoter
Community Member
3 years ago

Exactly :) I mean i swich gender and orientation im my characters and for sure I prefer not to be human if I can avoid it ;)

Load More Replies...
Daria B
Community Member
3 years ago (edited)

I think complete character customization would solve all the diversity related problems, since each player gets to build their own individual character, their own avatar. Like it was the case in Morrowind, for example, and one of the Mass Effect games (if not all) Anywaaaaaaaay...... Personally, I've been playing as a semi-Japanese straight male for most of the time. ♥

rhyan lumilay
Community Member
3 years ago

Yeah his problem is he wants a straight white dude then custom player himself with one or just don't play the games that he thinks offends him.

Load More Replies...
Reirei
Community Member
3 years ago

I hope that as diversity increases, so does clothing and armour choice. It gets boring running around in boob plated bikini armour.

Reilly Beryll
Community Member
3 years ago

One of the reasons I cherish some of the Elder Scrolls games: they don’t sexualize all of the armor.

Load More Replies...
Load More Comments
Popular on Bored Panda
Popular on Bored Panda
User Submissions
Also on Bored Panda
Also on Bored Panda