Teen Who Never Met Bio Dad Considers Stepdad Her “Real” Dad, Bio Sister Rages At Her Over It

All families have their ups and downs, but life in a blended family can be like a trip through the whole theme park. Keeping the family dynamics balanced can feel like a full-time job, especially for stepparents, but stepkids carry their fair share of the burden too. 

One woman turned to an online community to vent after her sister accused her of disrespecting the memory of their biological dad just because she wants a healthy dad-daughter relationship with her mom’s second husband. Now netizens are divided.

 More info: Reddit

Growing up without a dad is never ideal, so if you get a second chance at having one, you can’t really be blamed for grabbing it

Wreath of white flowers and lanterns at a gravesite symbolizing family conflict over teen calling stepdad dad.

Image credits: New Africa / Freepik (not the actual photo)

One woman, who lost her dad while she was still a baby, was thrilled when she started bonding with her mother’s second husband

Teen calls stepdad dad, sister screams treason, teen suggests therapy instead of conflict over family roles.

Text about teen calling stepdad dad causing tension, with sister reacting strongly and teen suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Teen calls stepdad dad, sister reacts with treason accusations, teen suggests therapy instead of arguing.

Teen calls stepdad dad causing sister to scream treason, teen suggests therapy instead of arguing about family titles.

Text describing a teen calling their stepdad dad, while sister reacts with treason and teen suggests therapy instead of screaming.

Two women smiling and looking through photo albums, discussing family moments and relationships at a table.

Image credits: Freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The only issue was that her sister saw their stepdad as an usurper, and the woman’s affection for him as betraying the memory of their lost dad 

Text excerpt discussing a teen calling stepdad dad and the sister's reaction suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Text on white background saying My sister don’t take it well we got into an argument about stepdad and therapy.

Text excerpt showing a teen explaining calling stepdad dad despite sister’s accusations of treason.

Teen calls stepdad dad causing sister to scream treason, teen suggests therapy to resolve family conflict peacefully.

Text excerpt about a teen expressing feelings toward stepdad and sibling conflict over calling him dad.

Text on a plain white background reading it wasn’t even the same themepark, the one we went to opened last year.

Teen enjoying amusement park on sunny day, holding lollipop and wearing sunglasses with roller coaster in background

Image credits: Freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

After she posted some pics of a day out at a theme park with their stepdad, her sister lost the plot, accused her of general dad treason, and turned their other siblings against her

Text showing an update about sister causing emotional conflict when a teen calls stepdad dad, suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Text about feeling tired of hiding affection for a father figure and being screamed at for calling stepdad dad.

Text message with a teen expressing frustration over sister screaming after calling stepdad dad, suggesting therapy instead.

Text image showing the phrase My relationship with him doesn’t affect her at all, relating to teen and stepdad conflict.

Text on a white background reads a personal statement about not walking on glass around a sister anymore, relating to family conflict and therapy.

Text on white background expressing frustration about not being able to post about a dad-daughter day without being screamed at.

Image credits: Weary_Bumblebee_7990

With the help of her grandma, though, the woman drew up a list of all the hurtful things her sister has done to her and decided to take a step back from their relationship 

The original poster’s (OP’s) biological dad met his maker before she could even form a memory of him, leaving her childhood dad-shaped but dad-less. Family stories helped, sure, but they were basically movie trailers, not the whole film. Then, when she was 11, her mom married “Jim”, a man who stepped into the role and became her dad.

Her sister, however, never got the memo. While Jim became a safe landing place for OP, her sister treated him like an unwanted sequel no one asked for. Cue years of guilt-tripping, accusations of “replacing” their lost father, and a sibling relationship that slowly cracked under the pressure like a dropped phone screen.

Things calmed down after OP’s sister left for college, until a harmless scroll through old photos stirred up drama. After seeing pics of her biological dad taking her siblings to theme parks, OP asked Jim for a similar day out. He said sure, they had a blast, she posted photos, and… accidentally opened the gates to Emotional Rollercoaster Land.

Her sister exploded, accusing her of betrayal and general dad treason, despite it being a different theme park and a different decade. After one fight too many, OP snapped. With her grandma’s support and a long list of past hurts, she stepped back from her sister, but she’s still asking netizens if she’s a villain, or just a daughter entitled to a dad too.

Let’s be honest, who can blame OP for wanting a father figure? Either her sister is secretly jealous of her relationship with Jim, or she’s just plain toxic. So, what’s the best way to deal with a toxic sibling? And how can OP sidestep the guilt trips her sister keeps trying to send her on?

Teen calls stepdad dad while sister reacts, showing family tension and suggestion of therapy instead of screaming outdoors.

Image credits: Getty Images / Unsplash (not the actual photo)

The experts over at Psychology Today say a few characteristics of toxic people include them being manipulative, shifting blame, being critical, judgmental, and cruel, and making you feel guilty for things you didn’t do – we’re looking at you, OP’s sister.

So how does OP cope? Well, there are a few expert-backed strategies she can turn to, including creating boundaries, limiting contact, simply not engaging, and creating a solid support system – thank goodness OP has her grandma, right? 

Now, what about the guilt-tripping? The pros at PsychCentral say guilt trips tend to happen most in close relationships because the guilt-tripper has to know that the other person wants to avoid causing them harm.

Psychologists say the best ways to deal with a guilt-tripper include depersonalizing the guilt-trip by realizing that the person trying to guilt-trip you is doing so because of their issues and not yours, articulating your boundaries, validating their feelings, and offering a compromise.

We’d say putting some distance between herself and her sister is probably the best move. Here’s hoping the siblings can bury the hatchet in time, because it’d be a shame to lose a sister just as you gained a dad.   

What’s your take? Does OP’s sister have a point, or does she need to get over it and let her sister have a dad? Drop your thoughts in the comments!

In the comments, readers were torn, with some saying the original poster is blameless, and others saying everyone in the mess is a jerk

Screenshot of an online discussion where sister screams treason after teen calls stepdad dad, teen suggests therapy instead.

Teen suggests therapy as sister screams treason over calling stepdad dad in family conflict discussion.

Reddit conversation about sister screaming treason after teen calls stepdad dad, teen suggests therapy instead of yelling.

Screenshot of an online discussion about a teen calling stepdad dad and a sister's reaction suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Reddit comment discussing sister's reaction and teen suggesting therapy after calling stepdad dad in family conflict.

Text comment discussing sister screaming treason when teen calls stepdad dad and suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing sister screaming treason when teen calls stepdad dad and suggesting therapy instead.

Reddit comment discussing sister yelling treason after teen calls stepdad dad, suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Comment discussing sister's reaction when teen calls stepdad dad and suggests therapy instead of screaming.

Comment discussing sister's reaction to teen calling stepdad dad and suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Reddit comment discussing teen calling stepdad dad and sister's reaction labeled as treason and betrayal.

Screenshot of an online comment about a teen calling stepdad dad, with sister’s reaction and suggestion of therapy.

Alt text: Online discussion about sister screaming treason when teen calls stepdad dad, teen suggests therapy instead of screaming

Comment discussing sister screaming treason when teen calls stepdad dad, with suggestion of therapy instead of yelling.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing a teen calling stepdad dad and suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Comment on Reddit discussing sister screaming treason when teen calls stepdad dad, suggesting therapy instead of screaming.

Comment on sibling conflict over stepdad called dad, suggesting therapy instead of yelling to resolve issues.

Comment explaining sister’s reaction to teen calling stepdad dad and suggesting therapy instead of screaming

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!