Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
2
Student Anonymously Exposes Details About Essay That Got Trans Instructor Removed From University
Students at the University of Oklahoma are now weighing in on the controversy surrounding the transgender graduate instructor who was removed after failing a student last month for citing the Bible in a gender essay.
The failed student, Samantha Fulnecky, addressed the situation on Wednesday, December 3, shortly after earning a new win in the dispute, but some of her peers claim the viral narrative left out key details.
Highlights
- Students at the University of Oklahoma say Samantha Fulnecky’s Bible-heavy essay did not meet the assignment’s academic criteria.
- The controversy escalated further because the removed instructor, Mel Curth, is transgender.
- Faculty and students are now organizing protests demanding Mel’s reinstatement, as peers publicly dispute claims of religious discrimination.
While the university sided with Fulnecky, several students have voiced support for instructor Mel Curth as new, unexpected details emerge.
“She didn’t have to do all this extra stuff,” one social media user reacted.
RELATED:
Mel Curth had given Samantha Fulnecky’s psychology essay an F, a 0 out of 25, a score that could have significantly impacted her overall grade
Image credits: University of Oklahoma
The assignment at the center of the dispute asked students to analyze how society perceives people based on gender expectations.
Mel Curth designed the task around a 2014 academic article by Jewell, J. A., and Brown, C. S., titled Relations among Gender Typicality, Peer Relations, and Mental Health During Early Adolescence.
The core discussion in the paper states that “gender stereotypes regarding what it means to be a ‘typical boy’ or a ‘typical girl’ permeate American society.”
However, Samantha Fulnecky’s 650-word submission, instead of engaging with “empirical evidence,” relied heavily on “personal ideology.”
Image credits: University of Oklahoma
The student cited the Bible multiple times, arguing that traditional gender roles should not be considered stereotypes because “that is how God made us.”
“Society pushing the lie that there are multiple genders and everyone should be whatever they want to be is demonic and severely harms American youth… there would be less gender issues and insecurities in children if they were raised knowing that they do not belong to themselves, but they belong to the Lord.”
The rubric for the assignment stated that students were expected to present “a thoughtful discussion of some aspect of the article,” rather than simply summarizing it
Image credits: ou_wtennis
According to Curth, “To call an entire group of people ‘demonic’ is highly offensive, especially a minoritized population.”
She also encouraged Fulnecky in her grading notes to “apply some more perspective and empathy” in future assignments.
Fulnecky, however, argued that the essay was opinion-based and claimed the failing grade amounted to “illegal discrimination” by the instructor.
Image credits: MaileOnX
She even filed a complaint with the university, which promptly responded by placing Curth on leave on November 30, 2025.
But an anonymous classmate of Samantha, who requested anonymity due to fears of backlash, shared additional context, including the exact rubric Curth had provided for the assignment.
The controversy gained traction because Mel is a transgender instructor, which added further tension given the content of the submission
Image credits: lanebrown_3
The student told local outlet News4 that one of the main criteria was producing a “thoughtful discussion of some aspect of the article… The best reaction papers illustrate that students have read the assigned materials and engaged in critical thinking about some aspect of the article.”
Other rubrics included a “discussion of why you feel the topic is important and worthy of study (or not),” “application of the study or results to your own experiences,” “suggestions for further studies or experiments that might help researchers better understand the topic,” and “your own thoughts about how development proceeds in the domain article,” among other criteria.
Image credits: UofOklahoma
According to the anonymous student, Samantha hardly referenced the article she was supposed to analyze and instead centered her paper almost entirely around biblical citations.
She reportedly mentioned the reference article only once at the beginning and did not cite the author’s name throughout, unlike other students who incorporated it several times in their responses.
The student told the outlet, “There was simply talking about beliefs associated with the Bible, which I feel as though is not academically stable.”
Image credits: samanthafulnecky
“Her name wasn’t on it. The instructor’s course was not on it. There was no relation to the paper cited anywhere in the source, which the paper was about the source that was given in the actual assignment itself. So there shouldn’t be any points towards that, even if it was a well-written paper that had grammatical issues…”
“If God wanted her to have an A, he would have given her one. It’s all in his hands! <sarcasm>” joked one user targeting Samantha online
Image credits: samantha_fulnecky
Image credits: summerh0usee
However, yesterday, December 3, the university ruled that the controversial essay, despite receiving an F, would not count toward Samantha’s final course grade.
Officials confirmed that the review had been completed and “resulted in steps to ensure no academic harm to the student from the graded assignments.”
Fulnecky addressed the development, saying, “To be what I think is clearly discriminated against for my beliefs and using freedom of speech, and especially for my religious beliefs, I think that’s just absurd.”
Image credits: theoudaily
“It has to do with me talking about god and my stance on gender. I think I should have gotten 100. I’ve got 100 on every single essay I’ve written in class.”
But her peers disagree that the grade reflected discrimination.
One student told News4, “This isn’t about religious discrimination. People are sick of these things happening, and that across the board, things like TPUSA and things like other extremist organisations have a chokehold over people like the president of OU.”
Students are now protesting in support of the dismissed instructor, even as the higher administration has shown support for Fulnecky
Image credits: theoudaily
Image credits: flonjau
“I’ve never really been interested in politics, if I’m being honest, until now,” the anonymous student concluded.
According to reports, several students are organizing a protest on Friday, December 5, at noon, marching from the Union to the South Oval on campus.
They are calling for the university to reinstate the dismissed transgender instructor immediately.
Amid the controversy, instructors teaching another section of the same course have also backed Mel’s original grade, calling Samantha’s essay “concerning.”
Image credits: GabeGwoolley
Teaching staff member Megan Waldron wrote in her feedback to Fulnecky, “Your paper directly and harshly criticizes your peers and their opinions, which are just as valuable as yours. Disagreeing with others is fine, but there is a respectful way to go about it.”
So far, Mel has not publicly commented on the headline-making controversy or her dismissal.
“It sounds like the student did not critically discuss the article, just gave her opinions which don’t hold water,” wrote one netizen
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
What do you think ?
Jaya 3 days ago
It's probably no coincidence that the teacher is trans. If the teacher wasn't, nobody would probably bat an eye about some student who thinks she shouldn't have failed her paper. But as soon as a story involves a trans person, the right wing start spreading the story like wildfire, just to flood people's timeline with stories of trans people doing things wrong, hoping that it will make people dislike trans people. And if the trans person wasn't actually wrong, as in this story, they will twist it around to make it seem like the trans person did something horrible. Trans people are not our enemy, they're just people who were born in the wrong body. Just normal people who are trying to live life in a way that makes them happy.
Ms.GB 3 days ago (edited)
The student didn't cite any sources and it's hard for me to believe a college student doesn't know how to write a proper essay. I think she wrote a subpar paper on purpose knowing her trans teacher would fail her so that she could make a big to do about it and try to get her fired.
Load More Replies...
Jaya 3 days ago
This is why it's important to know the full story before getting outraged. 'Failing a paper because you mentioned the Bible' is a completely different thing than 'Failing a paper because you only wrote that the Bible is against it instead of actually doing a good analysis of the issue'. It's like saying "The professor failed me because I'm a Christian!!" when you actually failed because you answered all the archeology questions with "The Bible says the earth is young so dinosaurs must be fake!"
Alder 3 days ago
Heh, I haven't heard that phrase in a while. You're not from Scotland by any chance...? :D
Load More Replies... Norfolk and good 3 days ago
"What you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul."
Apatheist Account2 3 days ago
Have you been reading Crystalwitch's comments?
Load More Replies...
TACO Don's Authentic TexMex 3 days ago
I read the essay. It is absolutely slop. If someone in one of the classes I taught turned in that utter pile of s**t I would have asked her to drop my class, since it shows that she isn't serious about the class or her education or she is entirely too dumb to be attending higher education.
E Henry Todd 3 days ago
My favourite part is that she submitted an essay, at university, that was only 650 words and believed that she should get 100%.
FreeTheUnicorn 3 days ago
Wait, the student called groups of people demonic and is the complaining about discrimination? Maybe don't put the hate speech in the paper.
TACO Don's Authentic TexMex 3 days ago
Those snowflakes have absolutely no self-awareness
Load More Replies... Tabitha 3 days ago (edited)
How did she get into college if she can’t tell the difference between a psychology course and a creative writing course? And OU—-not to mention the other colleges, universities, law offices, and businesses that caved to the fascists, the holy rollers, and all the other fanatical republican bullies—-is going to have a huge lawsuit on its hands once Fat Donald and his evangelical minions are in prison or firmly under their rocks, and this nightmare is finally over. Little Miss Thing will have to hide under her own rock forever once the intelligent, rational, and reasonable people have finally taken over again.
Andy 3 days ago
I completely disagree with what OU did, but at the same time I can see they are in a predicament. Already they have lost jobs, had funding and grants cut, students removed by ICE etc for having opinions differing from the f*ckwits in power. If they did the right thing and said this girl was failed because she is a moron, who knows what the government retaliation would be. And sadly, people said the same thing after Trumps last term, that sanity would return. But here we are, they are back and far worse than before.
Load More Replies...
Sue User 3 days ago
In college, I had an English professor that was interpreting a short story a certain way. I raised my hand, objected to the interpretation. Then I started backing up my claims with excerpts from the story and referencing other literary works. Professor was not happy but could not fault my logic. You can have any opionion you want, you just have to "bring the receipts" .
Shark Lady 3 days ago
It sounds like the student saw how infamous the person who objected to the trans woman on the University swimming team is, so decided to follow her example in the hope it would get her name out there. If you can't follow the instructions for writing an essay you probably shouldn't be studying for a degree. P.s my comment is based on the information in this article, which I am taking at face value.
Jaya 3 days ago
It's probably no coincidence that the teacher is trans. If the teacher wasn't, nobody would probably bat an eye about some student who thinks she shouldn't have failed her paper. But as soon as a story involves a trans person, the right wing start spreading the story like wildfire, just to flood people's timeline with stories of trans people doing things wrong, hoping that it will make people dislike trans people. And if the trans person wasn't actually wrong, as in this story, they will twist it around to make it seem like the trans person did something horrible. Trans people are not our enemy, they're just people who were born in the wrong body. Just normal people who are trying to live life in a way that makes them happy.
Ms.GB 3 days ago (edited)
The student didn't cite any sources and it's hard for me to believe a college student doesn't know how to write a proper essay. I think she wrote a subpar paper on purpose knowing her trans teacher would fail her so that she could make a big to do about it and try to get her fired.
Load More Replies... Jaya 3 days ago
This is why it's important to know the full story before getting outraged. 'Failing a paper because you mentioned the Bible' is a completely different thing than 'Failing a paper because you only wrote that the Bible is against it instead of actually doing a good analysis of the issue'. It's like saying "The professor failed me because I'm a Christian!!" when you actually failed because you answered all the archeology questions with "The Bible says the earth is young so dinosaurs must be fake!"
Alder 3 days ago
Heh, I haven't heard that phrase in a while. You're not from Scotland by any chance...? :D
Load More Replies... Norfolk and good 3 days ago
"What you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul."
Apatheist Account2 3 days ago
Have you been reading Crystalwitch's comments?
Load More Replies... TACO Don's Authentic TexMex 3 days ago
I read the essay. It is absolutely slop. If someone in one of the classes I taught turned in that utter pile of s**t I would have asked her to drop my class, since it shows that she isn't serious about the class or her education or she is entirely too dumb to be attending higher education.
E Henry Todd 3 days ago
My favourite part is that she submitted an essay, at university, that was only 650 words and believed that she should get 100%.
FreeTheUnicorn 3 days ago
Wait, the student called groups of people demonic and is the complaining about discrimination? Maybe don't put the hate speech in the paper.
TACO Don's Authentic TexMex 3 days ago
Those snowflakes have absolutely no self-awareness
Load More Replies... Tabitha 3 days ago (edited)
How did she get into college if she can’t tell the difference between a psychology course and a creative writing course? And OU—-not to mention the other colleges, universities, law offices, and businesses that caved to the fascists, the holy rollers, and all the other fanatical republican bullies—-is going to have a huge lawsuit on its hands once Fat Donald and his evangelical minions are in prison or firmly under their rocks, and this nightmare is finally over. Little Miss Thing will have to hide under her own rock forever once the intelligent, rational, and reasonable people have finally taken over again.
Andy 3 days ago
I completely disagree with what OU did, but at the same time I can see they are in a predicament. Already they have lost jobs, had funding and grants cut, students removed by ICE etc for having opinions differing from the f*ckwits in power. If they did the right thing and said this girl was failed because she is a moron, who knows what the government retaliation would be. And sadly, people said the same thing after Trumps last term, that sanity would return. But here we are, they are back and far worse than before.
Load More Replies... Sue User 3 days ago
In college, I had an English professor that was interpreting a short story a certain way. I raised my hand, objected to the interpretation. Then I started backing up my claims with excerpts from the story and referencing other literary works. Professor was not happy but could not fault my logic. You can have any opionion you want, you just have to "bring the receipts" .
Shark Lady 3 days ago
It sounds like the student saw how infamous the person who objected to the trans woman on the University swimming team is, so decided to follow her example in the hope it would get her name out there. If you can't follow the instructions for writing an essay you probably shouldn't be studying for a degree. P.s my comment is based on the information in this article, which I am taking at face value.
You May Like Trans Instructor Ousted From College After Failing Student Who Cited The Bible In A Gender Essay "I'm Born Female": Bearded Trans Man Forced To Explain Himself After Woman Confronts Him 58 Misogynists Tried To Explain Women But Ended Up Embarrassing Themselves (New Pics)
Gabija Saveiskyte
Karina Babenok
Greta Jaruševičiūtė
Related on Bored Panda
18
79