3.2Mviews
Photographer Spends 9 Years Shooting Same People On Their Way To Work, Shows How They Change Over Time
3.2Mviews
Ah, the daily grind. Love it or hate it, it's an unavoidable part of life for most of us - especially New Yorkers. Danish photographer Peter Funch spent nearly 10 years stationed outside of Grand Central Station shooting the morning commuters rushing by, and ended up capturing more than just yawns and iced coffees when it was said and done.
The impressive catalog of photos that now make up Funch's latest book, 42nd and Vanderbilt, span from 2007 to 2016, and were each taken between the tender hours of 8:30 to 9:30 AM. During the editing process, Funch realized that sticking to the same spot and same times every day had produced an amazing effect; he ended up catching the same people 2 or 3 times, sometimes years apart. "You could hardly believe it, that you’d find the same people having the same ritual over 10 years," Funch told Fast Co Design. "It’s such a New York thing, the idea that people just do the same thing over and over again."
Scroll down to see how Funch's recurring subjects changed - or didn't - over time, and tell us some of your morning rituals in the comments at the end.
More info: Official Site, Instagram, Twitter
This post may include affiliate links.
This is my favourite- a ray of sunshine among all the glum and anxious faces
Good pics but same electronic device that she is listening to? FAIL! She DOES look fab in the blk/wht polka-dots though!!
This girl is awesome...no facial expression in 9 years... still she's looking great, not getting older at all!
No, the article misleading, the photos were taken for a 9 years time period, but most of them are in the same year (2012), those are 2 weeks apart
Load More Replies...
well, i assume some are not 9 years appart, she seems to have fashion tastes but hold the same handbag ?
So nine years late he is still trying to finish that Starbucks americano lol
No, most of them don't change over time... lots of sad looking people..
Some of these are never, ever 9 years apart. Maybe 1 week apart. Some look like they are photographed on the very next day.
"It's a bird, it's a plane..." 9 yrs later: Superman vs Batman sucked.
nope different tie, top is orange with squares, other is red with circles and squares.
Most of them seem to be days or hours or minutes apart each other. Surely not a year.
If I understand correctly, not all fotos are necessarily nine years apart...but it surely is described confusingly. I think what the protographer wants to stress is that many people keep attitudes, habits, and ritualised behaviour.
Note the hair styles don't change, look at the bangs, parts, colors. Maybe some of them put their hair up in a ponytail or bun but otherwise same haircut. Also, they haven't upgraded their technology in 9 years?
Yeah. Earphones don't last more than a year or so.
There's NO way these photos were taken a decade apart. I'm disappointed.
I was wondering the little change in most of the pictures too, also see the same people years again
Topic headline is definitely inaccurate and misleading. Many of these are clearly taken on the same day, probably even within minutes of each other. Thumbs down. No inspiration.
Also, not spontaneous. Subjects have been coached to pose similarly to make it seem like they have the same behaviors "years" apart.
It's amazing the conclusions that you seem to reach with paltry evidence. Think about your own routine and the paths that you crossed in the same years. We're animals of habits. And age is something relative to many human beings, due to lifestyle, genes and the mixture of the two. It's perfectly reasonable to expect some to change not that much in nine years. For example, from ages 31-40. Are those differences really that noticeable? Not at all.
well yeah. I kinda agree. But the clothes put me off a bit. Did the photographer *really* wait for numerous people to get 'accidentally' wear the same clothes like in their old pic? huh..
BOOOO!! This post is bogus! Some of the images appear to be photo shopped, some images the subject is wearing the same clothing/accessories/etc, hell even the people in the background are even the same for some of the pictures
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Careful, you'll all end up with negative ratings for honest answers like yours. This site is all about letting people post what makes them feel they're special and unique. You have been warned, now shape up!
"spent nearly 10 years stationed outside of Grand Central Station shooting the morning commuters rushing by, " That implies this guy was stationed there most mornings. Very doubtful, and there's no way that you'd recognize someone or be able to find their pic after years and thousands of photos of different people in between. "It’s such a New York thing, the idea that people just do the same thing over and over again." Regular patterns of behaviour is a NY exclusive? This post was written in a very unclear manner.
Should've dated ALL the pictures. Those with no timeframe specified are clearly not 9 years apart - maybe as little as DAYS...
Title is misleading - if you take two minutes to actually go on the linked website of the photographer and browse the gallery, he puts the dates and times of the photos underneath. Most are a week or two apart, some only a few days. The odd few will be over a few year period, but most not. So really.
Good grief, folks. Reading is important. Yes, some people he photographed several years apart, but not all. If anyone had actually read past the headline, they would know this. "The impressive catalog of photos that now make up Funch's latest book, 42nd and Vanderbilt, span from 2007 to 2016, and were each taken between the tender hours of 8:30 to 9:30 AM. During the editing process, Funch realized that sticking to the same spot and same times every day had produced an amazing effect; he ended up catching the same people 2 or 3 times, sometimes years apart."
People wearing the same clothes on different photos or 'same bus' etc doesn't necessarily mean it's on the same day. The photographer spot was near Grand Central station, where the CoachUSA bus often stop and park, people wearing the same clothes on different days sometimes months or years apart. What's interesting for me is how the photographer remember those people...from the thousands passing him on that spot. If you know Grand Central, you know what I mean...
Judging by the faces, he only shot on mondays o_O
Stupid waste of time and film.
I thought it was fun, why all the negativity
what really bother me is that in almost all of these photos there are no smiles. as if smiling was too tiring. I understand it's matine and they're going to work, but if they smiled they could have improvements for their health, because a smile improves the day to yourself and to those around you. and costs so little.
You think people don't research the truth behind the hot title? It'was not 9 years time!
They all look unhappy !
He spent 10 years in the same spot? Must've been rough!
they are all in the same position like it is set up
I didn't see any differences between them, 9 years pass by and your face and outfit be the same? I don't think so! the coincidence was very high in his photos :D Good Luck with the next project ...
Went to the photographers page. Most of these photos are days or weeks apart. A couple are more than a year one is actually 9 years.
I wonder what the lady in pic no 7 must be feeling about the injustice of assumptions created in people minds... That she has been wearing the same watch over the decade's 😂😂
The topic of the article got me interested, but it got me disappointed when I realized that it just was clickbait! Most of the pictures are taken on the same day, or even some days apart. Misleading...
they all look the same :/
This is garbage. Doesn’t take any skill to shoot these photos. There’s zero composition. Just some guy pressing the shutter.
Many wind up in a crowd. Who wants that?
People are getting sad , sad and sadder around now a days , no one seemed happy even after years have passed .
Probably the title ought to have read:- Photographer takes photos of people on the street candidly. They do remind me though of the 'walking photographs' that were very popular in the 30's 40's and 50's. You could go and buy the photo later on after a few hours if yours was taken. However this is, as most people have said, a misleading headline of 9 years apart photos. Implied but not correct.
Impressive!!!
Five star AWESOME ! Such dedication ! Men with the same shirt years later I can understand, but that woman with the same yellow purse ? NEVER !
If you hover over the picture some of them say, 2 weeks later or one month later or two months later etc.
huh , inaccurate, uninspiring , the title is different from what's in the pictures....
Interesting how most people sont change at all
#27 a white man turned black ,must be an anti dove commercial
Totally a fake!
So living in New York makes you unhappy. Next photo series!
creepy and unnecessary
Was it nine years? No changes. Was hoping for better
This was lame! Photographer should be ashamed of himself
At least the pictures are good, oh wait they are not
What's with the light in all these? Look photoshopped mostly :/
What a brilliant and telling idea for a piece of artwork.
Couldn't you make this any more boring and pointless?
This an obvious fake :)
This is an obvious fake :)
Bullshit panda
Why do they all seem so sad? They can’t all be
just boring. not really a good project. Most people aren't going to really have changed all that much in a year, or ten years if they are with the same company. And adults style don't really change that much from year to year. You've already got what works for you and you buy newer versions of that when you need to. Just normies doing their normal things... weak.
Not to be a jerk, but this is clearly not nine years apart. The photographer probably spent a lot of time on this cool idea, but a poor introduction completely ruined it for me. This just comes across as fake and dishonest.
Did you actually read the description, and not just the headline? "The impressive catalog of photos that now make up Funch's latest book, 42nd and Vanderbilt, span from 2007 to 2016, and were each taken between the tender hours of 8:30 to 9:30 AM. During the editing process, Funch realized that sticking to the same spot and same times every day had produced an amazing effect; he ended up catching the same people 2 or 3 times, sometimes years apart."
Yes I did, and I notice you cropped before this important line "you could hardly believe it, that you’d find the same people having the same ritual over 10 years," Funch told Fast Co Design. "It’s such a New York thing, the idea that people just do the same thing over and over again."" - the same ritual over 10 years...... This backs up the original implication of the headline, which is the first words that lay down the facts of what we are about to read. The photorgrapher is paying very dearly for a not very well constructed introduction. As these comments demonstrate, there are two ways to interpret it. You interpreted it the way he meant it obviously, those of us who interpreted it the way the headline states, are left bored and scratching our heads at what comes off as a cheap attempt at deception.
Not much changed
1 There is no way these subjects had the exact same clothing, un-faded for 9 years and they so happen to be wearing the same clothing. Some have the exact same, not similar, hair styles and lengths. Obviously staged.
Maybe actually READ the description, and NOT just the headline. "The impressive catalog of photos that now make up Funch's latest book, 42nd and Vanderbilt, span from 2007 to 2016, and were each taken between the tender hours of 8:30 to 9:30 AM. During the editing process, Funch realized that sticking to the same spot and same times every day had produced an amazing effect; he ended up catching the same people 2 or 3 times, sometimes years apart."
Same newspaper in box for one set, same stickers in background for a couple of them, no wear and tear on the stickers.
Fake
this is a cool idea, but I dont know how I feel knowing that the people in the pictures didnt gave permision for the use of their image. Also, most of them dont have the year difference.
These photos are far from years apart, some of them even look to be photoshopped to change some of the fetail.
This is a complete load of crap. These photos are clearly staged. Same cars and people in the background.
false advertising. i want my money back
The title is misleading. You can tell some of these are the same week. 9 years? Doubt it. Thumbs down
Like most of these people are wearing the exact same headphones/accessories!
9 years lap ? How do we know ? Booooring
Most of them seem to be days or hours or minutes apart each other. Surely not a year.
If I understand correctly, not all fotos are necessarily nine years apart...but it surely is described confusingly. I think what the protographer wants to stress is that many people keep attitudes, habits, and ritualised behaviour.
Note the hair styles don't change, look at the bangs, parts, colors. Maybe some of them put their hair up in a ponytail or bun but otherwise same haircut. Also, they haven't upgraded their technology in 9 years?
Yeah. Earphones don't last more than a year or so.
There's NO way these photos were taken a decade apart. I'm disappointed.
I was wondering the little change in most of the pictures too, also see the same people years again
Topic headline is definitely inaccurate and misleading. Many of these are clearly taken on the same day, probably even within minutes of each other. Thumbs down. No inspiration.
Also, not spontaneous. Subjects have been coached to pose similarly to make it seem like they have the same behaviors "years" apart.
It's amazing the conclusions that you seem to reach with paltry evidence. Think about your own routine and the paths that you crossed in the same years. We're animals of habits. And age is something relative to many human beings, due to lifestyle, genes and the mixture of the two. It's perfectly reasonable to expect some to change not that much in nine years. For example, from ages 31-40. Are those differences really that noticeable? Not at all.
well yeah. I kinda agree. But the clothes put me off a bit. Did the photographer *really* wait for numerous people to get 'accidentally' wear the same clothes like in their old pic? huh..
BOOOO!! This post is bogus! Some of the images appear to be photo shopped, some images the subject is wearing the same clothing/accessories/etc, hell even the people in the background are even the same for some of the pictures
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Careful, you'll all end up with negative ratings for honest answers like yours. This site is all about letting people post what makes them feel they're special and unique. You have been warned, now shape up!
"spent nearly 10 years stationed outside of Grand Central Station shooting the morning commuters rushing by, " That implies this guy was stationed there most mornings. Very doubtful, and there's no way that you'd recognize someone or be able to find their pic after years and thousands of photos of different people in between. "It’s such a New York thing, the idea that people just do the same thing over and over again." Regular patterns of behaviour is a NY exclusive? This post was written in a very unclear manner.
Should've dated ALL the pictures. Those with no timeframe specified are clearly not 9 years apart - maybe as little as DAYS...
Title is misleading - if you take two minutes to actually go on the linked website of the photographer and browse the gallery, he puts the dates and times of the photos underneath. Most are a week or two apart, some only a few days. The odd few will be over a few year period, but most not. So really.
Good grief, folks. Reading is important. Yes, some people he photographed several years apart, but not all. If anyone had actually read past the headline, they would know this. "The impressive catalog of photos that now make up Funch's latest book, 42nd and Vanderbilt, span from 2007 to 2016, and were each taken between the tender hours of 8:30 to 9:30 AM. During the editing process, Funch realized that sticking to the same spot and same times every day had produced an amazing effect; he ended up catching the same people 2 or 3 times, sometimes years apart."
People wearing the same clothes on different photos or 'same bus' etc doesn't necessarily mean it's on the same day. The photographer spot was near Grand Central station, where the CoachUSA bus often stop and park, people wearing the same clothes on different days sometimes months or years apart. What's interesting for me is how the photographer remember those people...from the thousands passing him on that spot. If you know Grand Central, you know what I mean...
Judging by the faces, he only shot on mondays o_O
Stupid waste of time and film.
I thought it was fun, why all the negativity
what really bother me is that in almost all of these photos there are no smiles. as if smiling was too tiring. I understand it's matine and they're going to work, but if they smiled they could have improvements for their health, because a smile improves the day to yourself and to those around you. and costs so little.
You think people don't research the truth behind the hot title? It'was not 9 years time!
They all look unhappy !
He spent 10 years in the same spot? Must've been rough!
they are all in the same position like it is set up
I didn't see any differences between them, 9 years pass by and your face and outfit be the same? I don't think so! the coincidence was very high in his photos :D Good Luck with the next project ...
Went to the photographers page. Most of these photos are days or weeks apart. A couple are more than a year one is actually 9 years.
I wonder what the lady in pic no 7 must be feeling about the injustice of assumptions created in people minds... That she has been wearing the same watch over the decade's 😂😂
The topic of the article got me interested, but it got me disappointed when I realized that it just was clickbait! Most of the pictures are taken on the same day, or even some days apart. Misleading...
they all look the same :/
This is garbage. Doesn’t take any skill to shoot these photos. There’s zero composition. Just some guy pressing the shutter.
Many wind up in a crowd. Who wants that?
People are getting sad , sad and sadder around now a days , no one seemed happy even after years have passed .
Probably the title ought to have read:- Photographer takes photos of people on the street candidly. They do remind me though of the 'walking photographs' that were very popular in the 30's 40's and 50's. You could go and buy the photo later on after a few hours if yours was taken. However this is, as most people have said, a misleading headline of 9 years apart photos. Implied but not correct.
Impressive!!!
Five star AWESOME ! Such dedication ! Men with the same shirt years later I can understand, but that woman with the same yellow purse ? NEVER !
If you hover over the picture some of them say, 2 weeks later or one month later or two months later etc.
huh , inaccurate, uninspiring , the title is different from what's in the pictures....
Interesting how most people sont change at all
#27 a white man turned black ,must be an anti dove commercial
Totally a fake!
So living in New York makes you unhappy. Next photo series!
creepy and unnecessary
Was it nine years? No changes. Was hoping for better
This was lame! Photographer should be ashamed of himself
At least the pictures are good, oh wait they are not
What's with the light in all these? Look photoshopped mostly :/
What a brilliant and telling idea for a piece of artwork.
Couldn't you make this any more boring and pointless?
This an obvious fake :)
This is an obvious fake :)
Bullshit panda
Why do they all seem so sad? They can’t all be
just boring. not really a good project. Most people aren't going to really have changed all that much in a year, or ten years if they are with the same company. And adults style don't really change that much from year to year. You've already got what works for you and you buy newer versions of that when you need to. Just normies doing their normal things... weak.
Not to be a jerk, but this is clearly not nine years apart. The photographer probably spent a lot of time on this cool idea, but a poor introduction completely ruined it for me. This just comes across as fake and dishonest.
Did you actually read the description, and not just the headline? "The impressive catalog of photos that now make up Funch's latest book, 42nd and Vanderbilt, span from 2007 to 2016, and were each taken between the tender hours of 8:30 to 9:30 AM. During the editing process, Funch realized that sticking to the same spot and same times every day had produced an amazing effect; he ended up catching the same people 2 or 3 times, sometimes years apart."
Yes I did, and I notice you cropped before this important line "you could hardly believe it, that you’d find the same people having the same ritual over 10 years," Funch told Fast Co Design. "It’s such a New York thing, the idea that people just do the same thing over and over again."" - the same ritual over 10 years...... This backs up the original implication of the headline, which is the first words that lay down the facts of what we are about to read. The photorgrapher is paying very dearly for a not very well constructed introduction. As these comments demonstrate, there are two ways to interpret it. You interpreted it the way he meant it obviously, those of us who interpreted it the way the headline states, are left bored and scratching our heads at what comes off as a cheap attempt at deception.
Not much changed