Guy Says That Native Americans Would Be ‘Starving To Death’ If They Weren’t Colonized, Regrets It Immediately
Genocide of any sort is an extremely sensitive topic that some even consider taboo and avoid touching the subject altogether. However, one should never turn a blind eye to the atrocities of the past with an excuse that what happened years ago should be left “where it belongs” – in the dusty pages of history. Adopting such an attitude poses a risk of repeating the same mistakes our ancestors did.
Recently someone shared their opinion on a Reddit thread, expressing their sympathy towards genocide of the indigenous people, implying that the technology of the modern days justifies the deaths of millions. Another person was having none of it and replied with a strong message which sparked a huge debate between other users. Scroll down below to see what they had to say and don’t forget to tell us what you think. (Facebook cover image: Joshua R. M. Dewberry)
Recently, one user expressed sympathy towards genocide, justifying senseless deaths
Someone was having none of it, however, and wrote a strong reply
Which started a long debate between other users
15Kviews
Share on FacebookI don't care if I wouldn't be able to go on Bored Panda, or if I wouldn't have an iPhone X. I would rather have all those millions and billions of lives back. That user needs to be hit on his head and screamed at.
Look..this is the way it happened. The Spanish and Portuguese showed up on South American shores. The Mayans were already in rapid decline from starvation and the Aztecs dropped their guard because they thought Cortes was one of the Gods come back to earth. Native American indians were in high population (around 112 million) but were decimated by disease when small pox laden blankets were given to the native populations causing numerous outbreaks between the early 1500's to early 1700's. And it was all planned by the settlers that sought to reduce resistance when it was learned what plentiful resources America provided. After that, Europeans used the Bible to justify slaughtering the majority of the rest by rewording a passage to mean 'A man is not truly a man unless he takes God into his heart.' The colonist took this to mean that unless Native Americans converted to Christianity, they were animals and, therefore, could be slaughtered. Our whole country was founded on murder.
I read about the small pox laden blankets before - shocking. We have done, and still do, some truly horrific things to our fellow humans.
Load More Replies...Struggling to read this, it's so painful. What happened is a disgrace, more than a disgrace. OK, nothing at all can put it right now, but at least acknowledge the theft, rape of lands and peoples and whole cultures. I am English. I am ashamed and I wasn't even born then. This can never be corrected, it's too late. I am, however, very shocked at the ignorance of how America is what it is now. Similar in Canada and Australia. Indigenous people denigrated when they really should be the rulers. They were there first. It's their land. I just wish the thieves were made to give it back. Not a chance I know. Am leaving Panda for today. Take care all.
Do we have to even give this ignoramus airtime? Can't he just slide into the abyss of ignorance he crawled out of with his clueless comment?
Agreed. People who say stuff like this just want to stir things up. I support freedom of speech but there's also the freedom to ignore.
Load More Replies...So called white Americans need to be reminded daily that they are settlers and not the original owners like the native americans
Agreed. It is humbling to remind myself whenever I walk around this beautiful country that I am on Native land. I feel grateful and immensely privileged to be here.
Load More Replies...No one mentioned the (White) savages who decimated the buffalo herds that were a mainstay of the livelihood of the People in North America. They shot them for sport, often from trains, killing as many as they could. And they knew what they were doing.
The initial post makes it sound like invasive colonialism and genocide was a benevolent act, as if the colonists and native people got together with their attorneys and worked out the details. Colonists: "We are seeking a mutually beneficial agreement. We propose to murder most of your current population, drive out and impoverish the remaining survivors for centuries, in return for giving the few surviving descendants some technology in a couple of hundred years they would not otherwise have...built with funding and materials we expect to steal from other indigenous cultures we intend to murder and displace. Sound good?" Indigenous people: "Wow, great...Wait!...you mean TV and Iphones, right? Great, where do we sign?"
Genocide is never okay, but the first reply forgets to mention that a large part of it was disease spread by bacteria the natives were not immune to. Which makes the tragedy even worse. The invaders, having the technology and knowledge, could have helped the natives, but they chose to fight them. As a result, they built a civilisation of fear and hate, rather than a society that could have been beneficial to all.
To be fair, you could spend your whole life pointing out the obvious to numpties on the Interweb.....
You could spend your entire life responding to uneducated numpties on the web...... and they still wouldn't get it.
Yeah cause places they didn't colonize don't have iphones, right?
I don't care if I wouldn't be able to go on Bored Panda, or if I wouldn't have an iPhone X. I would rather have all those millions and billions of lives back. That user needs to be hit on his head and screamed at.
Look..this is the way it happened. The Spanish and Portuguese showed up on South American shores. The Mayans were already in rapid decline from starvation and the Aztecs dropped their guard because they thought Cortes was one of the Gods come back to earth. Native American indians were in high population (around 112 million) but were decimated by disease when small pox laden blankets were given to the native populations causing numerous outbreaks between the early 1500's to early 1700's. And it was all planned by the settlers that sought to reduce resistance when it was learned what plentiful resources America provided. After that, Europeans used the Bible to justify slaughtering the majority of the rest by rewording a passage to mean 'A man is not truly a man unless he takes God into his heart.' The colonist took this to mean that unless Native Americans converted to Christianity, they were animals and, therefore, could be slaughtered. Our whole country was founded on murder.
I read about the small pox laden blankets before - shocking. We have done, and still do, some truly horrific things to our fellow humans.
Load More Replies...Struggling to read this, it's so painful. What happened is a disgrace, more than a disgrace. OK, nothing at all can put it right now, but at least acknowledge the theft, rape of lands and peoples and whole cultures. I am English. I am ashamed and I wasn't even born then. This can never be corrected, it's too late. I am, however, very shocked at the ignorance of how America is what it is now. Similar in Canada and Australia. Indigenous people denigrated when they really should be the rulers. They were there first. It's their land. I just wish the thieves were made to give it back. Not a chance I know. Am leaving Panda for today. Take care all.
Do we have to even give this ignoramus airtime? Can't he just slide into the abyss of ignorance he crawled out of with his clueless comment?
Agreed. People who say stuff like this just want to stir things up. I support freedom of speech but there's also the freedom to ignore.
Load More Replies...So called white Americans need to be reminded daily that they are settlers and not the original owners like the native americans
Agreed. It is humbling to remind myself whenever I walk around this beautiful country that I am on Native land. I feel grateful and immensely privileged to be here.
Load More Replies...No one mentioned the (White) savages who decimated the buffalo herds that were a mainstay of the livelihood of the People in North America. They shot them for sport, often from trains, killing as many as they could. And they knew what they were doing.
The initial post makes it sound like invasive colonialism and genocide was a benevolent act, as if the colonists and native people got together with their attorneys and worked out the details. Colonists: "We are seeking a mutually beneficial agreement. We propose to murder most of your current population, drive out and impoverish the remaining survivors for centuries, in return for giving the few surviving descendants some technology in a couple of hundred years they would not otherwise have...built with funding and materials we expect to steal from other indigenous cultures we intend to murder and displace. Sound good?" Indigenous people: "Wow, great...Wait!...you mean TV and Iphones, right? Great, where do we sign?"
Genocide is never okay, but the first reply forgets to mention that a large part of it was disease spread by bacteria the natives were not immune to. Which makes the tragedy even worse. The invaders, having the technology and knowledge, could have helped the natives, but they chose to fight them. As a result, they built a civilisation of fear and hate, rather than a society that could have been beneficial to all.
To be fair, you could spend your whole life pointing out the obvious to numpties on the Interweb.....
You could spend your entire life responding to uneducated numpties on the web...... and they still wouldn't get it.
Yeah cause places they didn't colonize don't have iphones, right?
28
25