
“Am I A Jerk For Telling My Wife That Leaving Her Used Pad In My Brother’s Place Was Inappropriate?”
By now, you’d think that pads, tampons, and periods should be normal things to talk about in today’s society. But it’s 2022 and, sadly, menstruation stigma is still a thing.
Most often, the menstrual taboo manifests in sophisticated and subtle ways that look seemingly innocent and are quite difficult to pick up on. But sometimes, there is genuine disgust, shame, and fear attached to it, where women and girls feel embarrassed for having periods in the first place. Speaking of the latter, one story on the AITA subreddit is a perfect example of that.
A man is facing backlash after he accused his wife of being “highly inappropriate” for leaving a used pad in his brother’s bathroom. In the trash. Where it’s supposed to be.
It all started when the Redditor shared a post on the AITA subreddit and detailed how his 31-year-old single brother felt disrespected after he explained what the woman did. “I was shocked and didn’t know what to say,” the user recounted. But the internet had plenty. Read on to find out how the situation evolved, the verdict readers were quick to deem, and be sure to weigh in on the discussion in the comments.
A man recently faced backlash online for saying it was “highly inappropriate” of his wife to throw away a used pad in his brother’s bathroom
Image source: Sora Shimazaki (not the actual photo)
As the situation sparked tension in the family, he reached out to the internet for advice
Image source: 99.films (not the actual photo)
Image source: Jason_Barret1029
It comes as no surprise that the vast majority of Redditors have deemed both the husband and his brother extremely in the wrong in this situation. Looking at the comments, many people believed the story reeks of misogyny and female bodily shame, and immediately called out the grossed-out men for their behavior.
But unfortunately, this is not an isolated case. There’s a long history of menstrual taboos across many cultures, and education about periods is still woefully lacking worldwide. Given the common misconception that menstruation should be secret women’s business, women are taught from a young age they must manage it discreetly.
Of course, there has been a positive shift in attitudes toward menstruation, but many women still feel ashamed. Because through harmful messages about women’s cycles and appalled responses to any mention of it, it’s what society tells us to feel. But it’s time we destigmatize it.
According to Jane Ussher, a professor of Women’s Health Psychology at Western Sydney University, periods have long been associated with “dirt, and disgust, and shame, and some might say fear.” However, she argues that menstruation stigma is in fact a form of misogyny: “it’s a sign of positioning something that is essentially feminine as other, dirty and disgusting.”
“If you talk to young women across a whole range of different cultural groups about their major concern about menstruation, it’s concealment. It’s about not knowing you’re menstruating — the worst idea being blood been seen, which leads to menstrual shame,” Professor Ussher added.
If left unaddressed, this shame can affect how women feel about this completely normal bodily function. And, alarmingly, it can also damage their well-being and how they perceive their bodies. So better understanding of menstruation is key to improving health outcomes for women.
But when these situations occur in real life, it may be difficult to know how to react in a way that wouldn’t spark tension between you and your loved ones. So to gain more insight from an expert, Bored Panda reached out to Eileen Head, a transformational coach who aims to help people to shift their mindset and release old beliefs, blocks, and patterns to create the love they desire.
“The first question is if this woman had known this was going to be an issue, would she have handled this differently?” Head asked.
The coach mentioned that it appears there already has been friction between the wife and brother-in-law, which is likely to trigger any issue that comes up. “As always, what we are fighting about is not what we are fighting about!”
“These situations always morph into other things,” Head added. “The wife is thinking her husband ‘should’ agree with her and now is upset with him. Her husband has his own opinion and feels wronged.”
Unfortunately, the woman is likely to be feeling embarrassed. Head argues that when that happens, many of us tend to go into justification “which is one of the biggest causes of disconnection in relationships. Then everyone gets entrenched with right/wrong leaving each person stuck with bad feelings.”
However, the key element in this dispute is disrespect. “The brother-in-law feels disrespected in his own house, the wife feels disrespected because her husband is not siding with her, and her husband feels disrespected that she won’t acknowledge others’ feelings,” Head noted. “It may make no sense to us so we might not have the awareness that others feel differently.”
Relationship coach Head noted that to get out of this situation in a way that would make the wife feel good about it, she should consider taking the high road. “Even if you still believe that you did nothing wrong, by taking responsibility in any situation with others, this will earn you respect…and if not from others, you will feel better as being the more evolved person. Being able to do this and using this as a skill will benefit you in all your relationships,” Head concluded.
If anyone is having a disagreement, Head offers a variety of coaching programs, as well as a free call on her website, for people who’d like to create the meaningful relationships they desire.
We’d love to hear your thoughts about the incident. What do you think about the husband’s and his brother’s actions? How would you have handled the situation? Feel free to share your opinions, as well as personal experiences, with us in the comments down below.
If she is at all like most women, she didn't just toss it in the bin, she wrapped it first either in toilet paper or in th wrapper of the new pad to ensure it doesn't stick to anything or otherwise isn't a problem when emptying the trash. If so, the brother didn't just look in the trash. He had to unwrap it. Just eww and creepy that the brother did that.
Good point! Even without a wrapper from the next one a woman will fold the pad and wrap loo paper around it. The brothers are idiots.
My first thought exactly! I usually wrap it up with TP since the other wrapper usually just opens. Soooo gross he went looking for something to complain about. Imagine if it had been a tampon!
Exactly, and possibly even buried it beneath other rubbish in the bin at the same time.
That's what I was thinking the whole time. I wish we knew if she wrapped it. If she didn't wrap it anything or even just in itself, I could see where the brother is coming from. But, as you said, most women wrap it in something so I have to assume she did too.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
She didn't like BIL So I would assume she didn't wrap pad. NO WHERE does it say that she was discreet and wrapped it. That would be disgusting whether you're male or female. I PERSONALLY hate people's spitting in the sink and not washing it out! We all should be thoughtful of each other. GUARANTEE that a female apartment owner would have been disgusted in this situation!
It doesn't say if she was 'discreet' because OP isn't the one that saw it. He doesn't know. Sure, it's possible she left it gross because she doesn't like BIL. It's also possible he made a big deal out of a wrapped pad because he doesn't like her.
I fold my pads up, wrap them in toilet paper so they’re completely concealed, and throw them away. Why tf is this man-child digging around in the bathroom trash looking for something to complain about.
Just exactly THAT! As I said in the group, brother IS an Incel. One who goes outright digging in the toilet trash after women use his facilities.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Or she didn't wrap it and left it in full view. As a woman, this would offend me too. Have respect for others' sensibilities.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
This is the expected etiquette but some people just fold or scrunch and blood can seep through. I wonder how she left it in the bin? Also what if she is a right cow and let it be like that to be rude as they don't get along. There is always easy more info needed
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
In my experience, that is a serious rarity, women properly wrapping their used pads before tossing. I've called female friends out for not doing it in the past, because I find it disgusting not to wrap them up, and each time have been called crazy for expecting women to go to that sort of effort.. even though i do it. As such, when I had my own place, I did not allow women to dump their used pads at my house. The first time it happened was the last, after the pad got stuck to the side of the bin, and my friend refused to peel it off. Said it was utterly fross to expect her to touch a used pad. Her used pad, btw. So honestly, with how squicked out the brother is here, I'd say the wife didn't wrap her pad up in paper and instead just left it lying on top, exposed, or stuck to the side. If thats the case, im fully on the side of the men, and im speaking as a woman.
@Mirabelle I think it was probably just your friends. Because most women will be in the habit of wrapping it up because they don't want to see or smell it in their OWN homes or have guests in their homes exposed to that. And certainly most women are not going to want to be embarrassed by not wrapping it in someone else's home. I honestly don't believe that was the issue in this case because the brother specifically said that the issue was leaving a pad in the trash, not leaving an unwrapped pad.
I used to think wrapping the pads up is common sense till I had to live with few other girls in a two bathroom apartment. The girls who used the other bathroom said they used to find unwrapped pads in the bin. And once, it became a great issue, coz someone had thrown a pad in the toilet and had tried to flush it. They all sat outside coz no one would take the guilt. It was probably the most disgusting think I've heard till then. None of them were allowed to use our bathroom anymore. Some of them also had other disgusting habbits and they would never clean the mess they did after a shower.
There is a hilarious SNL skit about teens doing that. I was crying laughing because it was kind of true
When traveling in a foreign country, a woman told us to wrap pads in toilet paper so it would not embarrass the male housekeeping staff. I thought this was hilarious because my dad always yelled at me for wasting toilet paper every time I did that. I thought it was gross to leave it exposed but he was more concerned about cost of toilet paper. Dudes should start putting signs up so we know what they prefer since we are not mind readers
When I visited my parents, I put it, wrapped in toiletpaper, in an empty toilet roll, because they're old and have no bag in it and the only things they throw away are toilet rolls. Else it looks so disgusting. I wouldn't be happy either if someone just threw it away and let it stick to the side. A bit weird to get mad about it and say it though. You can then better remove the bin as a hint.
Oh, I see what she did wrong! She shouldn’t have thrown the pad! She should’ve hold on to the pad and thrown the husband in the trash instead
No, stick it to her forehead! ( I had no place to put it...)
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Stop with the angry woman libber rhetoric. Focus on the issue. Off the cuff and asinine replies like this just reinforce the fact all # Metoo women are off their rockers.
How many times can I down vote this for crying out loud. Sounds like you got some pms yourself. SMH, wait, smack your head.
🎶 downvote and report 🎶 Jo, you can p**s off! 😊😘
Diggin' in trash bins for used pads again, aren't ya?
Poor Jo was the "brother" in this story.
She needs to divorce him. Get out of that family ASAP.
BP has its own agenda, but I promise you, That was the REAL consensus in the sub.
bold of you to assume this is a real scenario and not made up by someone for reddit points.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Stop with the angry woman libber rhetoric. Focus on the issue. Off the cuff and asinine replies like this just reinforce the fact all # Metoo women are off their rockers. Yes, one stupid AH move ends a relationship. How ya doing with those 50 cats?
If she is at all like most women, she didn't just toss it in the bin, she wrapped it first either in toilet paper or in th wrapper of the new pad to ensure it doesn't stick to anything or otherwise isn't a problem when emptying the trash. If so, the brother didn't just look in the trash. He had to unwrap it. Just eww and creepy that the brother did that.
Good point! Even without a wrapper from the next one a woman will fold the pad and wrap loo paper around it. The brothers are idiots.
My first thought exactly! I usually wrap it up with TP since the other wrapper usually just opens. Soooo gross he went looking for something to complain about. Imagine if it had been a tampon!
Exactly, and possibly even buried it beneath other rubbish in the bin at the same time.
That's what I was thinking the whole time. I wish we knew if she wrapped it. If she didn't wrap it anything or even just in itself, I could see where the brother is coming from. But, as you said, most women wrap it in something so I have to assume she did too.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
She didn't like BIL So I would assume she didn't wrap pad. NO WHERE does it say that she was discreet and wrapped it. That would be disgusting whether you're male or female. I PERSONALLY hate people's spitting in the sink and not washing it out! We all should be thoughtful of each other. GUARANTEE that a female apartment owner would have been disgusted in this situation!
It doesn't say if she was 'discreet' because OP isn't the one that saw it. He doesn't know. Sure, it's possible she left it gross because she doesn't like BIL. It's also possible he made a big deal out of a wrapped pad because he doesn't like her.
I fold my pads up, wrap them in toilet paper so they’re completely concealed, and throw them away. Why tf is this man-child digging around in the bathroom trash looking for something to complain about.
Just exactly THAT! As I said in the group, brother IS an Incel. One who goes outright digging in the toilet trash after women use his facilities.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Or she didn't wrap it and left it in full view. As a woman, this would offend me too. Have respect for others' sensibilities.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
This is the expected etiquette but some people just fold or scrunch and blood can seep through. I wonder how she left it in the bin? Also what if she is a right cow and let it be like that to be rude as they don't get along. There is always easy more info needed
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
In my experience, that is a serious rarity, women properly wrapping their used pads before tossing. I've called female friends out for not doing it in the past, because I find it disgusting not to wrap them up, and each time have been called crazy for expecting women to go to that sort of effort.. even though i do it. As such, when I had my own place, I did not allow women to dump their used pads at my house. The first time it happened was the last, after the pad got stuck to the side of the bin, and my friend refused to peel it off. Said it was utterly fross to expect her to touch a used pad. Her used pad, btw. So honestly, with how squicked out the brother is here, I'd say the wife didn't wrap her pad up in paper and instead just left it lying on top, exposed, or stuck to the side. If thats the case, im fully on the side of the men, and im speaking as a woman.
@Mirabelle I think it was probably just your friends. Because most women will be in the habit of wrapping it up because they don't want to see or smell it in their OWN homes or have guests in their homes exposed to that. And certainly most women are not going to want to be embarrassed by not wrapping it in someone else's home. I honestly don't believe that was the issue in this case because the brother specifically said that the issue was leaving a pad in the trash, not leaving an unwrapped pad.
I used to think wrapping the pads up is common sense till I had to live with few other girls in a two bathroom apartment. The girls who used the other bathroom said they used to find unwrapped pads in the bin. And once, it became a great issue, coz someone had thrown a pad in the toilet and had tried to flush it. They all sat outside coz no one would take the guilt. It was probably the most disgusting think I've heard till then. None of them were allowed to use our bathroom anymore. Some of them also had other disgusting habbits and they would never clean the mess they did after a shower.
There is a hilarious SNL skit about teens doing that. I was crying laughing because it was kind of true
When traveling in a foreign country, a woman told us to wrap pads in toilet paper so it would not embarrass the male housekeeping staff. I thought this was hilarious because my dad always yelled at me for wasting toilet paper every time I did that. I thought it was gross to leave it exposed but he was more concerned about cost of toilet paper. Dudes should start putting signs up so we know what they prefer since we are not mind readers
When I visited my parents, I put it, wrapped in toiletpaper, in an empty toilet roll, because they're old and have no bag in it and the only things they throw away are toilet rolls. Else it looks so disgusting. I wouldn't be happy either if someone just threw it away and let it stick to the side. A bit weird to get mad about it and say it though. You can then better remove the bin as a hint.
Oh, I see what she did wrong! She shouldn’t have thrown the pad! She should’ve hold on to the pad and thrown the husband in the trash instead
No, stick it to her forehead! ( I had no place to put it...)
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Stop with the angry woman libber rhetoric. Focus on the issue. Off the cuff and asinine replies like this just reinforce the fact all # Metoo women are off their rockers.
How many times can I down vote this for crying out loud. Sounds like you got some pms yourself. SMH, wait, smack your head.
🎶 downvote and report 🎶 Jo, you can p**s off! 😊😘
Diggin' in trash bins for used pads again, aren't ya?
Poor Jo was the "brother" in this story.
She needs to divorce him. Get out of that family ASAP.
BP has its own agenda, but I promise you, That was the REAL consensus in the sub.
bold of you to assume this is a real scenario and not made up by someone for reddit points.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Stop with the angry woman libber rhetoric. Focus on the issue. Off the cuff and asinine replies like this just reinforce the fact all # Metoo women are off their rockers. Yes, one stupid AH move ends a relationship. How ya doing with those 50 cats?