Photographer Takes Portraits Of People With And Without Clothes, Asks Viewers To Guess Which One Is Naked From Their Faces
When looking at the two close-up shots of a single person taken by photographer Dylan Hamm, you probably wouldn’t notice a big difference as, at first glance, the side-by-side comparisons look very similar if not exactly the same. It gets more interesting when you start analyzing the features, slight changes in expressions or eyes that are caused by the special circumstances of this photoshoot idea. In one of the two passport-style portraits, the model is dressed and in another – completely naked.
Being naked in front of a camera is probably a huge step out of the comfort zone for most people depending on their self-confidence level. And this was the creative plan of Dylan Hamm when in January 2016 he invited strangers to a portrait photography session to capture how our faces can speak louder than words.
Can you tell on which photo the person is going commando?
More info: dylanhammphoto.com | Instagram
This post may include affiliate links.
The artist didn't specify which side of the collage features the undressed person leaving the viewing experience as a guessing game. In one case, a dressed subject is on the right, in other - left, so the viewer decides solely by reading their faces. “I chose to mix up the faces so that it was more complicated for the viewer to decide, and would have to look closer to make their own judgments. I also decided not to say which is which, hoping to build conversation in a gallery setting among all viewers,” Dylan told Bored Panda.
Well, you can see the cloth clearly in the right picture :D The left one is also more zoomed in to reveal less of her shoulders
So far we have 3 votes for Left, and 4 votes for Right.
Load More Replies...This provocative initiative was a base for the ongoing photo series titled “Naked Faces” which derived from a question Dylan was contemplating for years – “what level of nonverbal facial expressions do we show without being conscious of them?” He was on a mission of proving that our faces reveal more than we would like to say or are aware of through comparing images of dressed and people going commando.
I had that exact same thought. Other than that, absolute poker face.
Load More Replies...This guy seems like someone who's completely comfortable in his skin. :)
Right, bc on the left his left eye is closed a little more and the left corner of his mouth is angled up a little, so he seems to be more self confident
Right side.. on left outer corners of lips are more curved, smile lines in the bags of the eye are more pronounced and eyes are slightly more squinted. Also seems to be pursing his lips on right side
Right.. left has an attempt to smile, in right picture has a ‘why bother..’ look to her
The Vancouver-based photographer gathered volunteers willing to participate in nude photography session with a deal that no actual nudity would be captured or published. Then he took the before-and-after portrait of each participant with the purpose, as he explained, “to demonstrate the differing facial expressions between clothed and not, to physically capture evidence of the impact that something as simple as being naked can have on subtle facial expressions.”
The awkard moment that you pose naked for a photo project and the photographer starts undressing too...
He had the idea in mind long before he started but he waited until his girlfriend was comfortable with him seeing beautiful people stripping down in front of him. Why naked, you ask? “I chose for people to be naked, because I was looking for honest vulnerability from the models. I had them remove clothes and jewelry, and asked for them not to cake themselves with makeup beforehand. I also had them standing on a box, to give them a sort of platform to set onto, both physically and mentally” – the artist explained.
I think left is naked because the picture on the right is slightly more zoomed in, perhaps trying to cover his shirt
Instead of the awkward behind the scenes of this unusual set, we get to see the honest reaction of a person through the unconscious micro expressions. “The approach and reaction to the act of getting naked varied from laughing, yelling and making jokes that reaction was rarely linked to the results captured,” – Dylan said. The results of the experiment ranged from very subtle to contrasting non-verbal reactions. From a slight smirk or barely noticeable spark in the eyes to blushing and laughing – each person had a unique emotion written on their face.
How do we know the answers to see if we're right or not? My guess is the left cause I think I see a shadow of a shirt on the right
He doesn't want people to know the answer. He said he wants to spark discussions.
Load More Replies...Right.. he’s blushing, or having a panic attack... he’s flushed in red
“I could hear people talking about how they felt while I was shooting. Some people were proud and excited, some people were nervous, but when they stepped into the room, some of their attitudes changed. Confident outside, but quiet and nervous inside, and opposite as well. People talking about uncomfortably, and then being loud and happy once it was over knowing they conquered the task,” – Dylan shared his observations during a whole day photoshoot in a closed off area.
I disagree. Right. Her color has drained because she is naked and mortified.
Load More Replies...He also noticed how the reactions to getting naked in front of Dylan differed from men to women: “There were women that were nervous, but then proud once they were naked, while there were men who I know that are very flirty and confident men, who had some of the most vulnerable reactions to being naked in front of me. Lots of mixup to what I had thought would happen.”
Although raised from a particular question, the project hasn’t found an answer. On the contrary, it inspired more questions that are yet to be explored with an ongoing project. “It has raised questions about gender stereotypes; the subconscious, and the way we change imperceptibly to ourselves and perceptibly to others,” – the photographer admitted.
Well, left obviously. In the right picture you can see the T-Shirt she's wearing (left side, on her chest, under the hair).
I legitimately think a few of these are the same picture a little zoomed in to test if folks will catch it.
Load More Replies...Same exact picture, or are we too believe he added/removed clothes without one single hair moving?
It's the same photo just zoomed-in on the left and slightly re-touched!
yes, all the hairs are even in the same place. what is the likelyhood of that if he undressed in between photos?
Load More Replies...Dylan plans to expand the project outside his circle of friends and acquaintances, furthermore, even outside the country. “My plans for this project is to take it out of the country and get more diversity in this work. Something in Europe, and Asia possibly. Get out of North America, and see the wider scope of my project. In a sense I would hope that it could bring people together noticing we are all on a spectrum of vulnerability.” – said the artist.
Hey, this is the old lady that tried killing me with bug spray in the car!
I don't know... do the up arrow for left and the up arrow for right :P
I Don't know… I kind of think its the one on the right because his eyes are squinted a bit, as well as the fact that hes blushing a bit more in his nose. His lips are also partially
Sure because he gets off historie pants over his head
Load More Replies...Right, because her expression is a challenge - "Yes, I'm naked - no smart-a*s remarks."
They got the lighting placement almost dead right, look at the spot below the left end of the eyelashes on his left eye in both pictures, there's two eyelashes that are almost exactly the same way lit up
ok all these people are really ugly andf im done now trying to picture people naked this is not normal way people think. Stop it....no. Stop it.
right because if she fixes her hair like I do, then her hair will end up in the front
Others are talking about his hair and lips, but his eyelashes are amazing. Also, right, he seems like he's slightly more uncomfortable.
left, look at the jaw and the press of the lips. trying to hide behind hair
I'll go with you guys and say right - expression is the same but his face is flushed.
Right I have a feeling this was some kind of trick where everybody was named in both pictures and planted the idea one was naked to see how many would judge a photo😄
Agreed; idiotic decision by the photographer. What conversation are people meant to have without the answer?
Load More Replies...At least they didn't try to guess your star sign, or favourite pizza topping from your answers.
Load More Replies...TJler is probably going to say something along the lines of, “Man, I wish I could see the WHOLE picture!”
I scroll all the way down just to downvote his comments because he keeps me entertained
Load More Replies...That people are embarrassed and uncomfortable being naked in front of strangers is no revelation. The fact that these people are willing to participate in this exercise makes them different than the majority of people who simply would not do this, hence diminishing if not nullifying whatever point you are trying to make.
So do we get the answers or not? What a waste of time that was.
I just scrolled down--didn't bother to look at the pictures. Not fun if I can't find out the answers. Sorry, just doesn't work for me.
Agreed; idiotic decision by the photographer. What conversation are people meant to have without the answer?
Load More Replies...At least they didn't try to guess your star sign, or favourite pizza topping from your answers.
Load More Replies...TJler is probably going to say something along the lines of, “Man, I wish I could see the WHOLE picture!”
I scroll all the way down just to downvote his comments because he keeps me entertained
Load More Replies...That people are embarrassed and uncomfortable being naked in front of strangers is no revelation. The fact that these people are willing to participate in this exercise makes them different than the majority of people who simply would not do this, hence diminishing if not nullifying whatever point you are trying to make.
So do we get the answers or not? What a waste of time that was.
I just scrolled down--didn't bother to look at the pictures. Not fun if I can't find out the answers. Sorry, just doesn't work for me.
