Cooking is as much about breaking the "rules" as it is about following them. That's why you taste the dish you're preparing even if you're following a recipe.
Even some restaurant chefs might be deemed as anarchists for abandoning convention but still have their tables booked.
So to find out what practices people have thrown out their kitchen window, Redditor ThatSpyGuy made a post on the platform, asking other users, "What commonly repeated cooking tip is just completely wrong?"
I think it's important to highlight that intention is what matters the most around cooking pots. The ability to recognize precisely what you want on your plate and how your actions impact the end results. We can't really categorize all of the replies ThatSpyGuy has received in terms of "bad" and good". What we can do, however, is appreciate the thinking and experimenting.
This post may include affiliate links.
Caramelized onions - 5 minutes. wtf... I see this everywhere. it's takes 20 - 45 minutes to do that
Starting to saute onion and garlic at the same time. Onion takes a lot longer to cook and adding the garlic too early can burn it which can ruin the entire flavour of the dish. So many recipes tell you to do this and I just don't get it!
The prep/cooking time in that recipe you're using is a bald-faced lie.
"Don't cook with a wine you wouldn't drink." I swear this is a rule made up by lushes planning on drinking the wine and using cooking as an excuse to buy it. What I want in a wine to drink is very different than I want in a wine to cook with.
Rinsing off chicken. I know you don't want to get salmonella, but rinsing off chicken just spreads it. Cooking it solves the problem automatically.
Break the spaghetti to cook it faster. All you’re doing is breaking someone’s Italian nana’s heart.
I never heard the cook it faster reasoning. I break it for convenience, easier both to submerge and to eat.
Not washing/cleaning after you cook because of X amount of reasons. Clean as you cook is the way.
Not a cooking tip but a drinking one: Don’t put too many ice cubes in your drink because it will melt and you will end up with too much water. Wrong, the more ice cubes you put the longer the ice will stay and not melt. If you put only one or two, they will melt VERY quickly.
(Ofc exceptions has to be made for “on the rocks” spirits)
Me and my re-usable ice cubes never have this problem :D ETA: double bonus because you can stick them in every nook and cranny of the freezer that is empty. Freezing empty air costs a fortune -and is bad for the environment- Putting some bottles of water in and sticking re-usable ice cubes in small empty spaces really helps
Myth: high heat is like fast-forward for cooking.
Still working to get my dad to understand this one.
"Add seasoning to taste" is a great tip to someone who's already a competent and experienced cook (i.e. a person who doesn't need that tip to begin with).
It is a TERRIBLE tip for an inexperienced and/or infrequent cook. Give a suggested amount of seasoning in your recipe or description.
"Cook until it's ready"
IF I AM NOT PROFESSIONAL HOW CAN I UNDERSTAND THAT IT IS READY? WTF? PLEASE GIVE ME INFORMATION HOW LONG SHOUD I COOK IT
Using extra virgin olive oil to cook. EVOO has a lower smoke point than regular olive oil, so regular olive oil is better for cooking.
When making pie crust, rubbing the butter into the flour or using a fork/knife/pasty blender to achieve "pea-sized" crumbles.
Pretty much every recipe will describe it this way, but the expanding water from the butter drives that beautiful flakiness. Use a cheese grater with moderately large holes. Use very cold butter, and handle the butter lightly so that it doesn't melt into your hands. Grate it and toss it into the flour about 1/3 of the butter at a time, tossing it to coat it with flour. Then make your dough. It will be light and flaky and heading in the direction of puff pastry.
Seriously, I use the same dough recipe I always used and the results are just staggeringly better because of this technique.
ETA Yep, this works for biscuits too.
Cookies: "bake until golden brown"
The cookie sheet will stay hot after it leaves the oven and keep baking the cookies for a minute or so. If you want soft cookies, it's better to take them out when only the edges look golden brown and let them keep cooking outside of the oven.
This is a good general cooking rule - food continues to cook after it's removed from heat, unless it's immediately cooled.
Not really a tip, but a recipe complaint.
Don’t measure flour(or other compressible powders) in volume! Use weight, a cup of sifted flour can be half of a cup of compressed flour.
Leave the burger for a long time, then flip it once.
Lots of people give this advice, including web sites and even chefs.
But then the labs who actually test this stuff find that the burgers are better, and cook faster, if you flip more often.
Yup, I flip every 3-4 mins for 15 minutes otherwise you end up with dry burnt exterior and undercooked middle.
Adding oil to your pasta water to prevent it from clumping. Oil floats in water. Just stir it.
That mayo is superior to butter for grilled cheese. It's not. Yeah, it also gets a nice crust and is easy to spread, but butter tastes way better.
Putting in the garlic first. That's a good way to burn it.
Unless you put the garlic in the oil to flavor it. You must remove the garlic though.
“Microwaving food will destroy nutrient molecules”
Microwaves are far too long-waved to cause any molecular changes. All they do is make molecules vibrate faster. They don’t directly break up molecules.
To actually split chemical bonds you need much shorter wavelengths. UV light at least. It is true that Microwaves can INDIRECTLY cause chemical reactions because they will increase the temperature of the food. But that is no different to any other heat source.
Likely, microwaves preserve nutrients BETTER than boiling/steaming because the heat is delivered faster and the food spends less time in a high temperature state.
Great homemade salsa has to have cilantro. Half of us don’t like cilantro. You can substitute:
Celery Leaves (this is pretty good)
Parsley
Mint Leaves
Leave it out all together
Myth: Using flour makes chicken the crispiest.
Truth: Using Potato Starch makes it WAYYY more crispy.
“When cooking a hamburger patty, press down on it with your spatula to make it cook more evenly/faster.” All this does beside flatten your patty is make all the juices escape, leading to a more dried out burger with less flavour.
Every baking recipe I've seen has you add spices with the dry ingredients. It's so much more flavorful if you add them with the butter and even more so if toast or gently fry them first. You can even use the microwave for this, cook just until fragrant.
Also, all my chocolate stuff got better when I realized that cocoa is a spice. Oil-soluble flavenoids.
That you can't ever have too much garlic. I’ve heard this so many times. My wife made a babaganush one time with so much garlic it burned our mouths. Too much garlic can be a thing.
This one is cooking related.
Myth: never use soap on cast iron.
Reality: you absolutely can use soap and scrub a well seasoned cast iron. Just don't soak it.
No this is not accurate. If you use soap you lose the seasoning. Seasoning is oil that coats and gets in the crannies of the cast iron. Soap dissolves oil, ergo it will remove the seasoning. If for some reason you want or need to put in a drop of soap it will not harm your pan, but it will remove some seasoning. A properly seasoned and maintained cast iron pan will wipe clean under hot water (and a little elbow grease if needed). If you clean with soap you will need to reseason the pan regularly. I've seen this 'myth busting' claim many times here and it's BS. Follow it at your pans peril.
Your reasoning seems rational, but it is false. The seasoned oil on a pan has undergone a chemical reaction that bonds it to the metal and stops it from being dissolved by dish soap.
Load More Replies...
Correct. This is an old carry over from a long time ago when soap had lye in it. Lye is very caustic, and would break down the seasoning on the pan. Since modern soap no longer has lye in it, this is a saying that just hasn't died. Like you said, don't soak it. A little soap if needed, wipe out and rinse and a nee layer of oil or preferred seasoning glaze, and done.
I wash my cast iron pans with soap, dry them well, then put a tiny amount of oil in them. Use a paper towel to spread the oil and polish until you can barely see the oil. The skillet I use was my great grandmother's and I'm in my 60s and this has worked for many decades.
I'll do what I'll do. You do what you do. If you ruin your stuff, it's its not going hurt mine.
Seasoning a pan is oiling and the baking it on. Soap will not remove it as it has platisized.
All I will say is go read the instructions and myth section at Lodge. I can tell people they no nothing all day long, but I have stopped doing so, it is much easier to let them spout nonsense at the makers of their cookware.
I've had my inherited 1890s chicken skillet since I was 12, soap was never necessary because it wiped right out with paper towels. Left it at a buddy's while I worked on a cruise ship, got back and in 5 months he had destroyed the cure with soap and water, took me months to get it back to near normal.
Using dishwashing liquid on a cast iron frying pan IS PERFECTLY FINE. No, it will not "remove the seasoning" unless you are violently scrubbing it with a wire scrubber. No, it will not make the pan rust - again, unless you are violently scrubbing it. If the pan isn't dirty - just greasy from frying something - wipe it out and go about your day. If the pan is dirty - like from making gravy in it or from frying something that burned or from making some sort of meat/pasta dish - let it cool off, put it in the sink, run warm water in it, add dishwashing liquid, wash the pan out, rinse it well, dry it with a paper towel, then put it on a warm stove burner to completely dry, and if you want, wipe it down on the inside with solid shortening. That's it. Clean pan. Source: A SOUTHERNER WHO GREW UP WITH CAST IRON FRYING PANS
The reason not using soap was the rule was because older soaps used lye. Lye would strip away the seasoning. Newer soaps don't contain lye leaving newer detergents safe to use on cast iron.
My pan is 45 years old, a wedding gift. I scour the pan with salt and a paper towel, or if necessary a little coconut oil soap, rinse it with plain water, rub it with a little Caron & Doucet Oil, and put it upside down into a 175 degree oven for two hours. It’s more non-stick than any Teflon pan I’ve ever owned. Twice over the years, some Helpful Harry has washed it with dish soap. I buried one of them at the bottom of the compost pile, and the other under an apple tree.
No. False. Wrong. Incorrect. This has cropped up over the past few years as younger people discover cast iron, and the pretend they've figured out some secret cheat code that the dumb olds were too useless to pick up on. Nonstick happens on cast iron by polymerizing oils. Soap was designed to CUT THROUGH OIL Once you have a good season built up on your pan, you shouldn't even need to consider soap. Running it under hot water, and wiping it with a NONABRASIVE sponge makes it spotless in literal seconds. After wiping it clean, you stick it back on the burner to dry off, once dry Apply a thin layer of oil using a cotton cloth or paper towel to the entire pan, crank up the heat on the burner to max and wait for the smoking to begin, when oil is no longer visible, turn it off and let it cool. That is how you care for a cast iron pan. That is how many generations of people have cared for cast iron pans. Because it's the best way to do it.
You're a moron redditor. Using soap on a cash iron is how you lose the seasoning. For reference read the comment from Lance d'Boyle
and use a light hand..no scrubbing. when finished dry off and add a thin coat of Crisco.
Funny all these people saying soap is ok and showing their science degrees but if you go to any cast iron venders website they say it's ok to use soap....if you plan to releasing right after. This doesn't mean people haven't had success in their lives using soap and washing cast irons but that is contrary to what the actual manufacturers say to do.
Here is what Lodge says on their website.. "Contrary to popular belief, you can use a small amount of soap to clean cast iron cookware!" This is on their Cast Iron Cleaning FAQs (https://www.lodgecastiron.com/discover/cleaning-and-care/cast-iron/how-clean-cast-iron). A properly seasoned pan can easily take repeated washings with mild soapy water. If the seasoning comes off, or if it develops rust -- IT WAS NOT SEASONED PROPERLY.
Load More Replies...
No!!!! Use corse salt to clean and heat it to dry or it's going to get rusty real quick
My granny, a Souther er, used a set scrub, but she didn't have scouring powder. Wash away. Dry thoroughly and heat on stove to make sure it's dry. About once a year think about resesoning. My 70 yeR old sis still uses our granny's cast iron.
Load More Replies...
People think you can just use eggs and butter at fridge temp for baking but it’s so much better if you do room temp
Use aluminum foil shiny side in.
Reynold's says the shiny side is a result of the manufacturing process and not intended to speed up cooking. The impact of having the shiny side in is so minimal and negligible you will not notice a difference.
This one has been disappearing lately but ...
Don't overcook mushrooms and don't rinse them.
It's nearly impossible to overcook mushrooms. Chitin is hard to break down so just keep cooking them. Rinsing may add water, but it's just more liquid to cook off and may in fact help steam them which helps them release more water. Besides, you should wash all produce before use, especially mushrooms. Doubly so if they are wild.
More heat cooks things faster.
Used to believe it but found out the hard way when shallow frying chicken schnitzels. The outside was burnt and the inside was raw. Now I cook them at the lowest heat and always perfectly cook them.
That you need to separately "cook" tomato paste to get rid of "bad" flavors. You don't. Just buy decent tomato paste and add it when it makes sense in the recipe (after the onions and garlics are fried) . S**t tomato paste will always taste bad, and burning it doesn't help.
Don’t add milk to your mac n cheese! I know the box says to, but use heavy cream instead. It makes the mac so fluffy and the cheese so creamy!
The amount of people I've seen thawing frozen food under HOT water is astounding.
Undercooked poultry is safe to eat. No, it isn't. Just like game meat or any meat.. But those two are worst risks and yes, you can start an epidemy by serving badly cooked poultry and game to your family. I find the hypocrisy of people who hate anti-vaxxers on one side and brag about eating medium turkey on the other side astonishing.
learn to chew harder , make a proper sauce or eat beef!
"Medium rare chicken" started as a sh*tpost but people started taking it seriously and got sick. Beef is safe to eat undercooked as long as it isn't minced because the bacteria don't penetrate past the outside of the muscle. Salmonella is present throughout the chicken muscle and has to be cooked through to be safe.
I love making omelets. I've watched a lot of videos on people making omelets. Some say you beat the eggs with a fork. You must use a fork! Others say do not use a fork, use a whisk!
It's funny to watch different experts directly contradict one another. I've used both, and don't see any difference. But the way I like best, is to put them in a jar and shake them up.
I've made thousands of omelets, and don't think I will ever make one that is perfect.
Some cooks you should use a low heat. Others say you start with a high heat and let the eggs cool the pan down as it cooks. Some say the omelette is perfect when there is a little brown on the surface. Others say eggs should never be cooked to the point of browning.
So many contradictions, so many different ways.
People say you need your cast iron pan RIPPING HOT before placing your steak for a perfect steak, in my experience, there is such thing as TOO HOT, medium high works best, or else the oil burns and the inside doesn’t cook enough (yes I use high heat oils)
Adding salt to water lowers the boiling point of the water. Wrong. It raises it.
Putting salt on your food AFTER It's cooked. Meh. Cooking in the salt is better.
Salt releases water, so if you want juicy meat/whatever, you should add it later.
That you have to wash ALL rice.
Plenty of rice you do, wash it until the water runs clear.
Many brands of commercial rice are fine to not rinse, they'll tell you not to on the packaging itself.
I made the mistake of letting an islander friend know this and they think I eat from a toilet.
I have spent years, years I tell you trying to perfect home-made pizza. Most recipes I've seen so far say "bake at 350 degrees F" which is utter nonsense. Pizza ovens bake the pizza at around 800 to 900 F. So I finally found out I could get a decent result at home by putting the oven on the highest temp - 500F, and put the pizza on the oven's lowest rack (my broiler is located in the bottom.) Then when the bottom crust is done I put the pizza in the broiler rack below and cook it about 3 mins to get the top done.
"Don't salt your eggs before cooking them, it makes them tough". Whether I'm just making a quick diner-level omelette in a hot pan, or doing a low & slow stir for really tender eggs - salt scheduling has made zero difference.
Jacques Pepin (hey, I love that guy, his Facebook vids are the cure for this evil age) I think got that promulgated, but plenty of folks have tested it and found it doesn't make a difference.
Measuring garlic. Just put as much in as your heart desires. Don't let words on a page tell you how too have a good time.
More garlic!
Your burgers and steak need more than salt and pepper. Worcestershire sauce, aromatics garlic, onions, etc.
That your supposed to rinse pasta after you cook it.
Cold rinsing will stop your pasta from continuing to cook by reducing the residual heat, which is great for pasta to be eaten later, like pasta salad or leftovers. As for sticking together, whether rinsed or unrinsed, the starches will glue the noodles together unless the noodles are coated with something like oil or sauce.
Leaving meat out for 15-30 min to “come to room temperature.” The internal temp of the meat stays low for a lot longer than that. This doesn’t speed up cooking or cause more even cooking. You can speed it up and make it more even by flipping more frequently, though. That means searing comes at the end.
Regardless of all that, resting the meat after cooking is a best practice.
That you're supposed to fluff your rice with a fork just before it's done cooking. This is unnecessary and also kinda dumb because then you're moving around uncooked parts with cooked parts, resulting in unevenly cooked rice.
Also whoever is draining water from their rice and thinks this is normal needs to be imprisoned. I swear I saw a viral video a couple years ago of a tv cook doing this.
I've never heard of fluffing your rice with a fork before it's done cooking. I've always heard to do it after.
My parents still insist on making biscuss using Bisquik. It produces the driest biscuits I've ever had. Biscuits are supposed to be butteray and flaky. Not dried hockey pucks.
I do not understand things like cookie and pancake mix. In the end you have to add all the other ingredients yourself anyway. So essentially you’ve got a box of overpriced flour. That might be handy now since it’s nigh on impossible to find flour here at the moment, but I still refuse to buy it out of principle.
That potatoes can "suck" salt out of an over salted dish. They don't. They can't. All they do is add volume, and potatoes are naturally not very salty.
If you're not dry brining your meats before you cook them, you're missing out. ESPECIALLY applies to chicken.
Add rice to the boiling water... No, no, no, no .. it's a bad way to cook rice.
For the past 30 years I have been cooking rice like this: Put the desired amount of rice in the pot. Rinse them thoroughly with cold water to remove as much "rice dust" as possible.
Then add cold water toothed rice, so they are covered by approximately 2,5cm/ 1 inch of cold water.
Add salt and put on a lid.
Put the pot on the stove at medium heat. Let it come to a boil while stirring every now and then.
When all the water has been sacked up by the rice, turn of the heat and let the pot sit for 10 minutes with the lid on.
It only takes 20 minutes to cook rice this way instead of 25-30 minutes, and they come out perfectly cooked every single time!!
Oh yeah... bad tip nr. 2 I've learned to no longer follow... "make the sauce/ gravy" as the very last part of the meal.
No, no, no, no .... for the past 4 years I've learned to ALWAYS start cooking the whole meal with the onions and other veggies or herbs for the sauce/ gravy. It takes a long time to get that deep flavor to bind everything together, and a good sauce can lift a meal from "plain everyday quick meal" to "restaurant quality home cooking".
That searing meat seals in the juices. I mean, seared meat is delicious but the more you sear the drier it's gonna be.
It does not 'seal in the juices'. The improvement in taste is caused by the Maillard reaction between amino acids and reducing sugars that gives browned food its distinctive flavor.
Putting milk/cream in scrambled eggs. Completely unnecessary if cooked with proper technique.
That pork chops have to be cooked to shoe leather. Store bought is sage. I have changed opinions by grilling mine to medium and they are very juicy.
Actually, probably that most meats are overdone.
People still remember trichinosis infections and it is bloody terrifying. It is safer now but some don't want to take the risk. With meats that are safe to eat undercooked - which is certainly not all of them - the opinion of overcooked depends wholly on the diner. Some would say anything more cooked than "still mooing" is overdone, and fair for them. Some wouldvsay "fully cooked" is a minimum, and that is fair for them too.
Putting lemon slices on fish. No idea why people do that. The sushi shop I used to order at always put a slice of lemon on top of my salmon chirashi bowl, which resulted in the salmon under it to get really discolored, ugly and kinda tough to chew, and tasted more like lemon than salmon in the end.
Myth: adding milk to scrambled eggs makes them fluffier. It ACTUALLY makes them less fluffy.
Well, that's just not true at all. I've done them both ways. Milk makes them both fluffier and juicier. Without milk makes them meatier and a little more flavorful. I prefer without milk, but with cheese.
Always use a temperature probe or thermometer. Many recipes tell you to cook for a certain time but I take the temperature and it's undercooked. I make an air fryer meatloaf that says it's done in 20 minutes.it always takes 45 minutes till it's cooked in the middle.
One of the best things I ever bought for cooking is a probe thermometer on a cable that attaches to a programmable timer. Thermometer in roast, cable gets closed in the oven door and attached to the timer. Set the temperature and the timer goes off when that internal temp is reached.
Load More Replies...
I'm kind of a new cook myself (single guy in an apartment), and I always try to season my food before cooking or while cooking, but I always feel the need to season afterwards. Maybe it's because I'm not using enough salt/pepper. I also don't really tend to use much olive oil when pan-frying my food. I usually lean more towards butter.
The one thing that my mom taught me that his stayed with me is that you can always add more seasoning you can't take it out. This is especially true with salt.
Load More Replies...
You DON'T wash chicken as raw chicken within the water it is washed in gets splashed elsewhere which can contaminate other food. Raw chicken whether in water or not is still not something to mix with other food.
Always use a temperature probe or thermometer. Many recipes tell you to cook for a certain time but I take the temperature and it's undercooked. I make an air fryer meatloaf that says it's done in 20 minutes.it always takes 45 minutes till it's cooked in the middle.
One of the best things I ever bought for cooking is a probe thermometer on a cable that attaches to a programmable timer. Thermometer in roast, cable gets closed in the oven door and attached to the timer. Set the temperature and the timer goes off when that internal temp is reached.
Load More Replies... I'm kind of a new cook myself (single guy in an apartment), and I always try to season my food before cooking or while cooking, but I always feel the need to season afterwards. Maybe it's because I'm not using enough salt/pepper. I also don't really tend to use much olive oil when pan-frying my food. I usually lean more towards butter.
The one thing that my mom taught me that his stayed with me is that you can always add more seasoning you can't take it out. This is especially true with salt.
Load More Replies... You DON'T wash chicken as raw chicken within the water it is washed in gets splashed elsewhere which can contaminate other food. Raw chicken whether in water or not is still not something to mix with other food.
