Bored Panda works better on our iPhone app
Continue in app Continue in browser

The Bored Panda iOS app is live! Fight boredom with iPhones and iPads here.

Newly Released ICE Video Adds Missing Context To Fatal Shooting Of Renée Nicole Good
Person seated in a car wearing a beanie and plaid shirt, related to ICE video on fatal shooting context.
18

Newly Released ICE Video Adds Missing Context To Fatal Shooting Of Renée Nicole Good

25

ADVERTISEMENT

Footage filmed by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent has revealed new details about the final moments of Renée Nicole Good, a 37-year-old mother of three who was fatally wounded during a confrontation with federal agents in Minneapolis.

The January 7 footage, recorded on the cellphone of ICE agent Jonathan Ross, was obtained by Minnesota outlet Alpha News and shows the seconds leading up to the incident that has since a nationwide debate on self-defense versus excessive force.

Highlights
  • Cellphone footage filmed by an ICE agent shows the tense seconds before Renée Nicole Good was fatally wounded.
  • The incident has sparked a federal-state clash over investigative authority and access to evidence.
  • The clip is at the center of an investigation into the officer's right to self-defense.

Renee and her wife were allegedly stopped in the middle of a street inside an active ICE enforcement operation, with their SUV partially blocking a lane of traffic and interfering with agents’ movements during the federal sweep.

Observers believe the clip offers crucial information on the context that led to the tragic incident.

RELATED:

    New footage on the final moments of Renée Nicole Good provides crucial context on the tragic incident

    Image credits: patriottakes/X

    ADVERTISEMENT

    According to federal officials, the encounter unfolded amid a protest against planned detentions of Somali migrants in the area.

    In the video, Good is seen seated inside her maroon Honda Pilot, smiling as she looks toward Ross and says, “That’s fine dude. I’m not mad.”

    Her wife, Rebecca Good, can be heard nearby, filming with her own phone and urging the agent to identify himself.

    “Show your face,” Rebecca says. “You want to come at us? You want to come at us? I say go get yourself some lunch big boy. Go ahead.”

    Image credits: AlphaNews/X

    As the confrontation escalates, federal agents order Renee Good to exit her vehicle. She does not comply.

    Instead, the footage shows her revving the engine while agents stand close to the SUV.

    Ross’s camera suddenly jolts violently. It remains unclear whether he was struck by the vehicle or jumped to avoid being hit. Seconds later, Ross fires three shots, including one through the front windshield.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Good is struck and fatally wounded.

    The footage joined a surveillance video to create a more accurate picture of the events

    Image credits: AlphaNews/X

    Her Honda Pilot continues forward, crashing into the back of two parked vehicles. Neither Ross’s footage nor other videos released publicly capture the immediate aftermath of the shooting or the moment Good lost control of the vehicle.

    She was pronounced deceased at the scene. Officials later confirmed three bullets struck her in the face.

    Image credits: AlphaNews/X

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Extra footage provided additional context, showing Good’s SUV pulling onto the street and stopping.

    Roughly 20 seconds later, a passenger believed to be Rebecca exits the vehicle and begins filming. Good then repositions the Honda Pilot, appearing to block the roadway for approximately four minutes.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Ross arrives shortly afterward and is joined by several other federal agents who surround the vehicle. One agent is seen pulling at the driver’s door and allegedly ordering Good to get out.

    Instead, Good pulls the SUV forward, and the rest of the events play out as previously stated.

    The incident has put federal and local governments at odds with each other

    Image credits: ViralVideos

    Image credits: DVanLangenhove

    There has been speculation that Rebecca exited the vehicle intentionally to document a potential confrontation. She is visible holding her phone during the exchange, though it remains unclear when she first began recording.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Ross is described by federal officials as an experienced officer. Six months before the tragic incident, he was dragged roughly 100 yards by a car driven by an illegal immigrant s*x offender.

    The encounter left Ross with a severe right-arm injury requiring 20 stitches.

    Image credits: Disclaimergate/X

    ADVERTISEMENT

    The Trump administration has repeatedly characterized the shooting as an act of self-defense, arguing Good used her vehicle as a weapon. Detractors argue the officer acted disproportionally to the danger he was presented with.

    Image credits: krassenstein/X

    “I can believe that her d**th is a tragedy while also recognizing that it is a tragedy of her own making,” Vice President JD Vance said about the case.

    State and local officials have rejected that framing. Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey, in particular, bluntly said video evidence undermines the self-defense claim, calling it “garbage.”

    Good’s wife blamed herself for encouraging her to confront the federal agents

    Image credits: KellyScaletta

    Image credits: ManiamAkash

    Conflicting accounts have emerged about Good’s role in the protest.

    For instance, friends told The New York Post that she was part of a network of activists coordinated through her six-year-old son’s charter school who were actively resisting ICE.

    The school, Southside Family Charter School, has publicly promoted a “social justice first” philosophy and involvement in political activism.

    Image credits: factpostnews/X

    Good and Rebecca moved to Minneapolis last year and enrolled the infant at the school. The couple is understood to have left the US after Donald Trump’s victory in the 2024 election, briefly relocating to Canada before settling in Minnesota.

    Good was a registered voter, though her party affiliation is not listed. No public voting records were available for Rebecca.

    Image credits: Status Coup News/YouTube

    Witnesses at the scene claimed the couple were acting as legal observers. In emotionally raw footage captured after the shooting, Rebecca admitted she encouraged her wife to confront federal agents.

    “I made her come down here, it’s my fault,” she cried.

    Good’s mother, Donna Ganger, has denied claims her daughter was involved in organized protests, saying Renee “wouldn’t have been part of anything like that.”

    The shooting has since expanded into a broader legal and political dispute over federal authority

    Image credits: Status Coup News/YouTube

    The shooting has triggered a widening legal and political fallout.

    Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty has called on the public to submit any video or evidence directly to her office, citing concerns about the Trump administration’s decision to leave the investigation solely to the FBI.

    Image credits: s4rah_dev

    Image credits: KGUN9/YouTube

    Moriarty confirmed federal investigators seized Good’s vehicle immediately after the shooting and that state authorities have not been granted access to it or to forensic evaluations conducted by the FBI.

    “The ICE officer does not have complete immunity here,” Moriarty said, pushing back against claims made by federal officials.

    The Minneapolis shooting came one day before federal immigration agents fired and wounded two people outside a hospital in Portland, Oregon, further intensifying scrutiny of federal enforcement tactics nationwide.

    As investigators continue to review footage, shell casings, and witness accounts, the cellphone video filmed by the agent himself has become central to the debate.

    “Cold blood.” Some viewers believe the footage dismantles the idea of the officer acting in self-defense

    Image credits: RealJohnDough

    Image credits: JR_OSINT

    Image credits: ANicole8321

    Image credits: briansbloodline

    Image credits: Jakron

    Image credits: LucasSa56947288

    Image credits: RichardHanania

    Image credits: SundaeDivine

    Image credits: harryjsisson

    Image credits: AdameMedia

    Image credits: davidgokhshtein

    Image credits: AutismCapital

    Image credits: Brick_Suit

    Image credits: MostlyPeaceful

    Image credits: 1DigitalC

    Poll Question

    Total votes ·

    Thanks! Check out the results:

    Total votes ·
    Share on Facebook
    Abel Musa Miño

    Abel Musa Miño

    Writer, Entertainment News Writer

    Read more »

    Born in Santiago, Chile, with a background in communication and international relations, I bring a global perspective to entertainment reporting at Bored Panda. I cover celebrity news, Hollywood events, true crime, and viral stories that resonate across cultures. My reporting has been featured on Google News, connecting international audiences to the latest in entertainment. For me, journalism is about bridging local stories with global conversations, arming readers with the knowledge necessary to make up their own minds. Research is at the core of my work. I believe that well-sourced, factual storytelling is essential to building trust and driving meaningful engagement.

    Read less »
    Abel Musa Miño

    Abel Musa Miño

    Writer, Entertainment News Writer

    Born in Santiago, Chile, with a background in communication and international relations, I bring a global perspective to entertainment reporting at Bored Panda. I cover celebrity news, Hollywood events, true crime, and viral stories that resonate across cultures. My reporting has been featured on Google News, connecting international audiences to the latest in entertainment. For me, journalism is about bridging local stories with global conversations, arming readers with the knowledge necessary to make up their own minds. Research is at the core of my work. I believe that well-sourced, factual storytelling is essential to building trust and driving meaningful engagement.

    What do you think ?
    Rusty’scate
    Community Member
    Premium
    2 months ago Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    They are not the military they are not police! I don’t care how many camera angles they show this from it was excessive force. The cop was at the front left side of the vehicle and she tried to leave exit stage right the police officer that Kiiiiiiii-led her to a half step to his left to avoid “Being hit” it was barely a step his movement happened in about .003 seconds the woman was pulling out away from ice who mind you are not police they ARE NOT Military. They are riff raff looking for the only job in the government they can get only requirement is being born in America beyond a reasonable doubt. Americans have the right to protest and actual police and military are given the actual tools for crowd control that don’t include getting shot like paintballs and bean bags. If this woman was an unarmed threat why was she not tazed or paintball Ed? Ppl who think this is a rational way of dealing with protesters are completely gob smacked.

    AndyR
    Community Member
    1 month ago Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Let's not pretend they're anything other than brown shirts at this point. America needs to wake up before they sleepwalk into a mess they can't get out of.

    Load More Replies...
    LizzieBoredom
    Community Member
    2 months ago (edited) Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Ross walked swiftly away from the vehicle after shooting Goode in the face so he didn't appear injured. Also, isn't the first rule of cop school "Don't stand in front of running vehicles"?

    AndyR
    Community Member
    1 month ago Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    They didn't go to cop school. If they had, they'd have a better idea of when you can use lethal force (spoiler alert - you can't use it to prevent a suspect fleeing).

    Load More Replies...
    Danielle Scott
    Community Member
    1 month ago Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Not shooting - M****R - get it right. SHE WAS M******D because the COWARD Jonathan Ross was pissed off that she wasn't terrified of him, so he M******D her.

    Load More Comments
    Rusty’scate
    Community Member
    Premium
    2 months ago Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    They are not the military they are not police! I don’t care how many camera angles they show this from it was excessive force. The cop was at the front left side of the vehicle and she tried to leave exit stage right the police officer that Kiiiiiiii-led her to a half step to his left to avoid “Being hit” it was barely a step his movement happened in about .003 seconds the woman was pulling out away from ice who mind you are not police they ARE NOT Military. They are riff raff looking for the only job in the government they can get only requirement is being born in America beyond a reasonable doubt. Americans have the right to protest and actual police and military are given the actual tools for crowd control that don’t include getting shot like paintballs and bean bags. If this woman was an unarmed threat why was she not tazed or paintball Ed? Ppl who think this is a rational way of dealing with protesters are completely gob smacked.

    AndyR
    Community Member
    1 month ago Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Let's not pretend they're anything other than brown shirts at this point. America needs to wake up before they sleepwalk into a mess they can't get out of.

    Load More Replies...
    LizzieBoredom
    Community Member
    2 months ago (edited) Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Ross walked swiftly away from the vehicle after shooting Goode in the face so he didn't appear injured. Also, isn't the first rule of cop school "Don't stand in front of running vehicles"?

    AndyR
    Community Member
    1 month ago Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    They didn't go to cop school. If they had, they'd have a better idea of when you can use lethal force (spoiler alert - you can't use it to prevent a suspect fleeing).

    Load More Replies...
    Danielle Scott
    Community Member
    1 month ago Created by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Not shooting - M****R - get it right. SHE WAS M******D because the COWARD Jonathan Ross was pissed off that she wasn't terrified of him, so he M******D her.

    Load More Comments
    You May Like
    Related on Bored Panda
    Popular on Bored Panda
    Trending on Bored Panda
    Also on Bored Panda
    ADVERTISEMENT