“AITA For Wanting My Husband To Get Rid Of An Ex-GF Memory Box But Wanting To Keep One Of My Own?”

Every relationship has its unspoken tests, those small but powerful moments that force us to rethink how well we understand each other. Sometimes it’s about finances, sometimes it’s about family, and other times it’s about something as simple as what we choose to keep, or let go of, from our past.

Objects carry memories, and when those memories involve old relationships, things can quickly get complicated. That’s exactly what happened to today’s Original Poster (OP) when she stumbled upon her husband’s old box of high school girlfriend memorabilia. After asking him to get rid of it, he promised to do so on one condition: if she got rid of her ex’s memorabilia too.

More info: Reddit

Expecting a partner to let go of memories of their ex while holding tightly onto your own can make even the most loving relationship feel unbalanced

Couple sitting on floor surrounded by moving boxes, discussing memory box dilemma involving ex-girlfriend and late ex-boyfriend items.

Image credits: Gustavo Fring / Pexels (not the actual photo)

The OP and her husband bought their first house and were downsizing when the wife discovered a shoebox of her husband’s high school ex-girlfriend’s keepsakes

Text post about wife wanting husband to toss ex-GF memory box but keep her late ex-BF’s, criticized for hypocrisy.

Text discussing a wife wanting husband to toss ex-GF's memory box but keep late ex-BF's, raising accusations of hypocrisy.

Text excerpt discussing downsizing and deciding what to keep during a move, related to relationship memory box issues.

Text on a white background stating a person found an old shoebox among a man's belongings during sorting.

Text excerpt about deciding what to do with an ex-girlfriend’s memory box containing photos and memorabilia.

Image credit: ThrowawayExMemoryBox

Woman looking at a memory box holding a letter, depicting conflict over ex-GF and late ex-BF keepsakes and hypocrisy.

Image credits: cottonbro studio / Pexels (not the actual photo)

She asked him to discard it, but he became defensive and refused, and said he would do it if she also gave up her own shoebox of a deceased college boyfriend

Text discussing keeping or discarding an ex-boyfriend memory box, related to wife wanting man to toss ex-GF’s box.

Man refuses to toss ex-GF's memory box while keeping late ex-BF's, wife criticized for hypocrisy in relationship dispute.

Text about a man’s late ex-BF’s memory box kept while wife demands tossing ex-GF’s, sparking hypocrisy debate.

Text on a white background about a mother discarding belongings abruptly after a man's passing, highlighting memory box conflict.

Text on a white background discussing a memory box unopened for almost a decade, related to late ex-BF's items.

Text on screen discussing memory boxes from ex-relationships, highlighting a wife's hypocrisy in keeping late ex’s box but not the other.

Image credit: ThrowawayExMemoryBox

Couple having a serious conversation about memory boxes, highlighting wife wanting man to toss ex-GF's keepsakes.

Image credits: Viktoria Slowikowska / Pexels (not the actual photo)

However, for her, the shoebox held the only remaining memories of her late boyfriend, making her feel the situations weren’t comparable

Text on white background about a wife finding her husband’s ex-girlfriend’s memory box despite a promise to discard it.

Text excerpt discussing wife wanting man to toss his ex-girlfriend's memory box but keep her late ex-boyfriend's, sparking hypocrisy debate.

Text showing a wife discussing getting rid of her shoebox while her husband keeps his ex-girlfriend’s memory box, highlighting hypocrisy.

Text discussing the differences in keeping memory boxes of an ex-girlfriend versus a late ex-boyfriend, highlighting hypocrisy.

Text on a white background expressing difficulty in gaining perspective on a wife wanting man to toss ex-GF’s memory box but keep late ex-BF’s memory box.

Woman questions if she is hypocritical for wanting husband to toss ex-girlfriend's memory box but keep her late ex-boyfriend's.

Image credit: ThrowawayExMemoryBox

Two years later, she found the box still in the house and felt hurt, unsure if she was being unreasonable for wanting him to get rid of it while keeping hers

The OP and her husband have been together for eight years, married for three, and by all accounts are happy. They bought a house, built a home, and even downsized together. However, during the moving process, she discovered a shoebox tucked away among her husband’s things, and inside were old photos, letters, and keepsakes from a high school ex.

At first, she wasn’t angry; after all, many people hang onto little scraps of their past. Besides, she also kept a memory box of her ex who tragically passed away in a car accident years ago. Those few mementos were the only things she had left of him, as his family swiftly discarded the rest.

Still, she asked her husband if he’d be okay discarding it, and he resisted, claiming that he’d “forgotten” about the box and would deal with it later, but only if the OP also got rid of hers. Fast forward two years, and she stumbled upon the shoebox again. Despite promising to get rid of it, her husband hadn’t, and that left her deeply upset.

Remembering that he had said he would get rid of the shoebox if she did, she was left in a dilemma as she noted that their reasons for keeping the boxes were not to be compared, as her ex wasn’t living, but his was.

Wife angrily demands man toss ex-GF's memory box while keeping her late ex-BF's, highlighting hypocrisy in the argument.

Image generated by Bored Panda using ChatGPT

According to Cosmopolitan India, it’s common for people to carry things from their past into new relationships, including memories, experiences, and even physical items like gifts, letters, photographs, or clothing from former partners. Some keep these mementos out of sentimentality or simply out of habit, seeing them as harmless reminders.

However, others may interpret such keepsakes as signs of lingering attachment to an old relationship, which can sometimes create tension with a current partner. Elle highlights that keeping mementos from past relationships can become unhealthy when it interferes with the present. For example, failing to move on emotionally, or disregarding a new partner’s feelings.

They also note that allowing these items to spark frequent arguments or tension is a sign that the relationship is entering an unhealthy spot. However, Brides Today emphasizes that striking a balance with keepsakes from past relationships starts with determining whether you’re holding onto an item for personal memories or if it still carries emotional ties to a previous partner.

Open communication is also essential, they state, explaining that if your partner feels uncomfortable, you should discuss your perspectives and look for a compromise. Prioritizing the current relationship is key, so if a keepsake causes tension or makes your partner feel undervalued, it may be better to let it go.

Netizens criticized the OP, expressing sympathy for her loss but also pointing out that keeping her own box while asking her husband to throw his away came across as hypocritical. They argued that the principle should be equal treatment, adding that grief doesn’t automatically make one person’s memories more important than another’s.

What do you think about this situation? Would you keep a memory box from an ex if your partner asked you to throw it away, or would you let it go? We would love to know your thoughts!

Netizens insisted that the author was not just being unreasonable, but also highly hypocritical

Comment expressing hypocrisy over wife wanting man to discard ex-girlfriend’s memory box but keep her late ex-boyfriend’s items.

Reddit comment discussing wife wanting man to toss his ex-GF's memory box but keep her late ex-BF's, highlighting hypocrisy.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing keeping mementos and the hypocrisy of tossing one ex's memory box but keeping another’s.

Reddit user shares opinion on wife wanting man to toss ex-GF’s memory box but keep late ex-BF’s, highlighting hypocrisy debate.

Comment discussing wife wanting man to toss ex-GF’s memory box but keep late ex-BF’s, highlighting hypocrisy and insecurity.

Reddit comment discussing hypocrisy about keeping memory boxes of ex-partners in a relationship conflict.

Comment expressing that wife is hypocritical for wanting man to toss ex-GF's memory box but keep her late ex-BF's.

Comment about wife wanting man to toss ex-girlfriend’s memory box but keep late ex-boyfriend’s box, criticized for hypocrisy.

Text discussing hypocrisy as a wife wants husband to toss ex-GF’s memory box but keep her late ex-BF’s items

Screenshot of an online comment discussing hypocrisy about keeping ex-girlfriend and late ex-boyfriend memory boxes.

Text post discussing a wife wanting man to toss ex-GF's memory box but keep late ex-BF's, criticized for hypocrisy.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing the hypocrisy of wanting to toss an ex-GF's memory box but keep a late ex-BF's belongings.

Screenshot of an online forum discussing wife wanting man to toss ex-GF’s memory box but keep late ex-BF’s.

Reddit comment criticizing wife for hypocrisy wanting man to toss ex-GF's memory box but keep late ex-BF's.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing hypocrisy about keeping ex-girlfriend’s and late ex-boyfriend’s memory boxes in a relationship.

Text comment from user youngandirresponsibl saying YTA and advising to pick battles, related to wife wanting man to toss ex-GF memory box but keep her late ex-BF’s.

Screenshot of online discussion about a wife asking to toss ex-girlfriend’s memory box but keep late ex-boyfriend’s box.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!