Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
600
Muslim Student’s Headscarf Slips, Male Teacher Asks Female Colleague For Help, She Reports Him
In our ever-diversifying world, navigating cultural and religious sensitivities has become more important than ever. Every conversation we have with someone is a chance to either connect with that person or accidentally step on a few toes. Sometimes, even the smallest and most innocent gestures have a way of causing unnecessary misunderstandings. Especially in places like schools, where a variety of backgrounds come together, even the tiniest actions can make a big difference.
One Redditor learned this the hard way when his well-intended request for help with his female Muslim student turned into a report over “unprofessional conduct”.
More info: Reddit
RELATED:
Male teacher asks female colleague to assist his Muslim student with her head scarf, but he gets reported for his actions
Image credits: Max Fischer (not the actual photo)
The teacher notices his student’s head scarf has moved and exposes her hair, thinks it’s inappropriate for him to help her, as he is not related to her
Image credits: The Lazy Artist Gallery (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Arthur Krijgsman (not the actual photo)
Image credits: u/teachertripup
The female colleague reports the teacher to the principle for “unprofessional conduct” after he asks for her help with fixing his Muslim student’s head scarf
The OP (original poster) of this story was a high school science teacher with a surprising knack for accidentally stepping into cultural minefields. The OP moved to an “exclusively white” area seven years prior to the neighborhood receiving a bit of a cultural makeover, introducing some much-needed diversity.
So, the OP had the chance to welcome his first Muslim students, 2 cousins, Amira and Nadia. He was in no way an expert in their religion, but he did have some knowledge on it, as well as in other major religions.
One day, while grading some worksheets, the OP noticed that Nadia’s headscarf had slipped, exposing her hair. He panicked and immediately went to his female colleague, Mrs. Smith, to ask for help, as Amira was out sick. The OP thought that it would have been inappropriate for him to address the issue directly, as a man who was not related to Nadia.
Not wanting to disrespect her religious beliefs, he disrupted Mrs. Smith’s class and asked her if she could help out Nadia. But her reaction was not exactly what the OP expected, as she seemed pretty annoyed by the request. “She made a weird face at me but eventually said, ‘fine’ and went to go get Nadia,” the OP recalls.
After the class, the OP apologized to Nadia for embarrassing her, if he did, and she replied that it was no issue. However, Mrs. Smith didn’t agree, and she reported the OP to the principal for “unprofessional conduct”. That seems a bit extreme, doesn’t it?
The same evening, the OP received a call from the principal informing him that there was a meeting set for the following Monday with Mrs. Smith, Nadia, and her parents. Oh, and a union rep for good measure. Feeling ambushed and confused, the OP was left wondering if he somehow stepped into an alternate universe where doing the respectful thing lands you in hot water.
Image credits: Kampus Production (not the actual photo)
Respecting a student’s religious beliefs is an important part of creating and maintaining an inclusive environment. It’s more than just about avoiding conflicts – it’s about showing that you genuinely value the different ways people see the world. In schools, this kind of respect helps create a welcoming vibe where all students can feel comfortable and understood.
Teachers have the obligation to protect their students and intervene in any situation that may involve discrimination of any kind. Research shows that “teachers are more likely to intervene in bias incidents related to race, religion and disability than other forms of bias.”
By being mindful of religious beliefs, we can prevent small misunderstandings from blowing up into major issues. Plus, embracing diversity, especially in school settings, can make everyone feel a bit more appreciated and connected.
Embracing diversity in schools is all about making sure we are creating an environment where all students and teachers feel welcomed and valued. A simple way we could all do this is by learning about different cultures and perspectives. It can be through workshops, maybe reading up on various traditions, or even just having open conversations with people from different backgrounds and just being sensitive to their beliefs. Which is probably what the OP was trying to do when his intention was misunderstood by his colleague.
What’s your take on this story? Why do you think the OP’s colleague reported him for trying to help his student? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
People in the comments say the teacher is not a jerk, as he was only trying to be considerate and respectful to his student’s religious beliefs
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
What do you think ?
Rabbit Of ill Portent(she/her) 1 year ago
He was just trying to be considerate ffs! I can see why he might've been anxious af in thinking of a way to help his student with her hijab because nowadays, it's so easy to accidentally trigger someone. I swear to goddess, it's damned if you do and damned if you don't -_-
Aiden Brough 1 year ago
He's a male. He'd be damned if did and damned didn't. As is apparant by the fact that he tried to point out he's an unrelated male and got damned by his actions. Ridiculous.
R Dennis 1 year ago
A big part of the issue these days is everyone being offended by everything. Understanding intent has been replaced by blind outrage and reactionary behavior. Hopefully this nonsense gets cleared up and op now knows why type of person the other teacher is...
Nota Robot 1 year ago
Mrs. Smith is a c**t for reporting him, regardless of whether he overreacted or not. This could easily have been solved off the record. Sorry for using that word, but I feel it's justified.
Deborah B 1 year ago
I think the male teacher had good intentions, and clearly didn't have appropriate guidance on how to handle the situation. He was clearly trying to be respectful, to the point where he made a big deal of a minor issue. The appropriate thing for the woman teacher to do would be to have had a discussion with him and their principal, consulted with their local muslim community group or mosque, and set a clear guidance. Surely there are policies for how a male teacher should deal with other sensitive issues with female students? What happens if he sees a student in the hall with her skirt tucked into her knickers, or notices that someone has bled through while on her period. Not informing the student leaves them open to public humiliation (especially in a co-ed school), but for a man to tell his teenage girl student she's flashing her knickers is also going to be a major embarassment for her, and open him to censure.
Cooking Panda 1 year ago
As a muslim hijabi woman, I appreciate his action and knowledge about Islam's basic rule like no touching unrelated ppl of different sex. I hope this ends well for OP and Mrs. Smith learn her lesson
Manana Man 1 year ago
I don't see why he needed to do anything. Nadia needs a wardrobe adjustment, Nadia can take care of it. No one needs to say or do anything.
Charity Angel 1 year ago
Having hair showing can be a massive deal, depending on how strict Nadia (and her family) is about this. And as he rightly says, as an unrelated man he should not be looking at her hair (hence the presence of the hijab. While I think he might have been better off asking a female student in the class who's friendly with Nadia to mention it would have been a better shout than getting another teacher involved, he was being respectful. And I think he needs to establish with both Nadia and Amira what they are comfortable with, and sharing that with his colleagues, who are clearly not aware of the religious background here. If Nadia's parents are very strict, she could be in serious trouble for what to an outsider seems a minor wardrobe slip.
Load More Replies... FreeTheUnicorn 1 year ago
This was a situation that hadn't happened before, OP did his best to be considerate and respectful. If there was a plan in place or if he'd been told to handle it inab certain way and he just went rogue, that would be different. But even if this was t the best way, how can there be a complaint? Hopefully they speak to the students and come up with a clear plan for the future, but this type of one off is not worth disciplinary action. It isn't a persistent problem, he wasn't rude, disrespectful or dangerous. This must be some administrator power tripping
Charity Angel 1 year ago
I think it's a serious lack of understanding on Mrs Smith's part, and something she didn't even bother to clarify with either Nadia or just a basic Google. Or maybe she did ask Nadia, and Nadia was embarrassed about being pulled out of class for this - we don't know - but somehow I doubt it. While I don't think involving Mrs Smith was the best move - another female student who gets on with Nadia would probably have been better - going forward he needs to ask Nadia and Amira what they are comfortable with. Are they okay showing a little bit of hair, or is that a massive no-no for them? If they do mind, would they object to him discretely mentioning it so they can fix the problem? I have a suspicion that OP followed a protocol from his previous school, without anyone at the new school having any awareness whatsoever about why that even exists elsewhere.
Load More Replies... Rabbit Of ill Portent(she/her) 1 year ago
He was just trying to be considerate ffs! I can see why he might've been anxious af in thinking of a way to help his student with her hijab because nowadays, it's so easy to accidentally trigger someone. I swear to goddess, it's damned if you do and damned if you don't -_-
Aiden Brough 1 year ago
He's a male. He'd be damned if did and damned didn't. As is apparant by the fact that he tried to point out he's an unrelated male and got damned by his actions. Ridiculous.
R Dennis 1 year ago
A big part of the issue these days is everyone being offended by everything. Understanding intent has been replaced by blind outrage and reactionary behavior. Hopefully this nonsense gets cleared up and op now knows why type of person the other teacher is...
Nota Robot 1 year ago
Mrs. Smith is a c**t for reporting him, regardless of whether he overreacted or not. This could easily have been solved off the record. Sorry for using that word, but I feel it's justified.
Deborah B 1 year ago
I think the male teacher had good intentions, and clearly didn't have appropriate guidance on how to handle the situation. He was clearly trying to be respectful, to the point where he made a big deal of a minor issue. The appropriate thing for the woman teacher to do would be to have had a discussion with him and their principal, consulted with their local muslim community group or mosque, and set a clear guidance. Surely there are policies for how a male teacher should deal with other sensitive issues with female students? What happens if he sees a student in the hall with her skirt tucked into her knickers, or notices that someone has bled through while on her period. Not informing the student leaves them open to public humiliation (especially in a co-ed school), but for a man to tell his teenage girl student she's flashing her knickers is also going to be a major embarassment for her, and open him to censure.
Cooking Panda 1 year ago
As a muslim hijabi woman, I appreciate his action and knowledge about Islam's basic rule like no touching unrelated ppl of different sex. I hope this ends well for OP and Mrs. Smith learn her lesson
Manana Man 1 year ago
I don't see why he needed to do anything. Nadia needs a wardrobe adjustment, Nadia can take care of it. No one needs to say or do anything.
Charity Angel 1 year ago
Having hair showing can be a massive deal, depending on how strict Nadia (and her family) is about this. And as he rightly says, as an unrelated man he should not be looking at her hair (hence the presence of the hijab. While I think he might have been better off asking a female student in the class who's friendly with Nadia to mention it would have been a better shout than getting another teacher involved, he was being respectful. And I think he needs to establish with both Nadia and Amira what they are comfortable with, and sharing that with his colleagues, who are clearly not aware of the religious background here. If Nadia's parents are very strict, she could be in serious trouble for what to an outsider seems a minor wardrobe slip.
Load More Replies... FreeTheUnicorn 1 year ago
This was a situation that hadn't happened before, OP did his best to be considerate and respectful. If there was a plan in place or if he'd been told to handle it inab certain way and he just went rogue, that would be different. But even if this was t the best way, how can there be a complaint? Hopefully they speak to the students and come up with a clear plan for the future, but this type of one off is not worth disciplinary action. It isn't a persistent problem, he wasn't rude, disrespectful or dangerous. This must be some administrator power tripping
Charity Angel 1 year ago
I think it's a serious lack of understanding on Mrs Smith's part, and something she didn't even bother to clarify with either Nadia or just a basic Google. Or maybe she did ask Nadia, and Nadia was embarrassed about being pulled out of class for this - we don't know - but somehow I doubt it. While I don't think involving Mrs Smith was the best move - another female student who gets on with Nadia would probably have been better - going forward he needs to ask Nadia and Amira what they are comfortable with. Are they okay showing a little bit of hair, or is that a massive no-no for them? If they do mind, would they object to him discretely mentioning it so they can fix the problem? I have a suspicion that OP followed a protocol from his previous school, without anyone at the new school having any awareness whatsoever about why that even exists elsewhere.
Load More Replies...
Related on Bored Panda
40
50