Woman Flees Dinner Table After FIL’s Insult, Wonder If She Was A Jerk For Doing It

Punchlines. We all love them. Until you become one, that is. Yes, roasting is all fun and games but sometimes humor can hurt, and you just can’t laugh at being laughed at. That’s when things stop being comedy and start being cruel.   

That’s pretty much what happened to one woman who turned to an online community to vent about how her fat-shaming father-in-law, an off-color joke, and an unsupportive husband turned a family dinner into a disaster with no dessert.  

 More info: Reddit

There’s nothing wrong with a bit of roasting, but some jokes can drift into insult territory if you’re not careful

Woman eating at a family dinner while others, including a man, sit around the table in a bright room.

Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

One woman, eating a salad in an effort to lose some weight, was having dinner with her in-laws when her father-in-law took a swipe at her weight

Text excerpt discussing a man calling daughter-in-law fat while husband laughs and defends his father at dinner.

Man calls daughter-in-law fat during family meal, husband laughs and defends his dad, leaving her upset and humiliated.

Family enjoying outdoor meal together, highlighting tension as man calls daughter-in-law fat while others react.

Image credits: The Yuri Arcurs Collection / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Humiliated, the woman left the dinner and retreated to her room until her in-laws left, but then her husband came in demanding to know why she’d walked out

Alt text: Woman upset after man calls daughter-in-law fat in front of guests while husband laughs and defends his dad

Text discussing a man calling his daughter-in-law fat while husband laughs and defends his father.

Man calls daughter-in-law fat in front of family, wife aghast as husband laughs and defends father, tense confrontation at home.

Image credits: wavebreakmedia_micro / Freepik (not the actual photo)

When she told him it was because of his dad’s cruel insult, he told her she was being too sensitive and slammed her for “disrespecting” his family

Text excerpt describing a daughter-in-law upset after being called fat by her father-in-law, with husband defending him.

Text excerpt from a man’s story about his father in law calling his daughter-in-law fat and debating if he overreacted.

Image credits: Annonymous656466

After her mother-in-law piled on with a long text about how inappropriate her behavior had been, she turned to netizens to ask if leaving the table had been a jerk move

The original poster (OP) thought hosting her in-laws would be a normal, polite dinner. She cooked, set the table, and quietly ate yogurt and salad after her husband nudged her to lose some weight. Everything seemed civil until a simple question about her meal choice turned the evening into a painfully awkward spectacle that nobody saw coming.

Mid-bite, her father-in-law squinted and loudly announced that a salad wouldn’t fill her “fat” rear end up. Cue giggles from relatives, plus her husband cackling along. Stunned and humiliated, she pushed back from the table and retreated to her bedroom, leaving the guests and their half-eaten dinners in her wake.

After his family left, her husband stormed into their room, furious she’d abandoned his parents. When she explained why, he waved it off as a joke, accused her of being too sensitive, and slammed her for “disrespecting” his family. According to him, defending your spouse isn’t required when it’s “just humor”.

Later, her mother-in-law sent her a wall of text scolding her for her inappropriate behavior, so now she’s wondering if she overreacted and blaming herself because this is “just how he is.” After she shared her tale and concerns online, netizens weighed in on the whole mess.

Um, since when is public body-shaming dinner conversation? And be honest, what would you have done if you’d been in OP’s shoes? The fact that nobody (not even her husband) called her father-in-law out for his so-called “joke” just adds insult to injury. So, when does banter cross the boundary into bullying?

Group of people socializing indoors as man laughs and others react, illustrating man calling DIL fat in front of everyone.

Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The experts at Emotional Mind Dynamic say the fine line between banter and bullying comes down to the foundation of the relationship, the level of trust, expectations, boundaries, respect, and the perception, not only of the behavior, but also of the relationship itself.  

If there’s a respectful relationship and you’re sure that your words won’t be misunderstood or hurt, feel free to say them. If you aren’t, don’t. Only with solid two-way trust can you be sure it’s still banter, if not, you’re risking making someone feel bullied. And you don’t want to be a bully, right?

OP stormed out, but what’s a better way to deal with a “joke” that crosses a line? Well, the pros from Talkspace say that, when you find yourself facing someone’s offensive humor, it’s vital to first check in with your emotional state – it’ll help you craft your clapback for maximum impact. Nice. 

Here’s another tip: consider your relationship with the person. While there are no rules about who you should stand up to, it’s worth thinking about your connection and the implications of your history and future together. Basically, if those things don’t matter to you, lay the smackdown. Not so easy for OP.

Perhaps she should take a page out of her father-in-law’s book and be “honest and straightforward” with a joke or two about him. Bullies hate a victim who fights back, and the old man probably has more than a few weak spots. 

What’s your take? Was OP’s early exit all that inappropriate, or do her in-laws own her an apology? Share your thoughts in the comments!

In the comments, readers agreed that the original poster was not the jerk in the situation and slammed her husband for laughing along at her expense

Screenshot of a Reddit discussion about a husband calling his daughter-in-law fat and the impact on their relationship.

Screenshot of a social media comment about a man calling his daughter-in-law fat while her husband laughs and defends his father.

Screenshot of a social media comment advising against having people over, including husband who laughs and defends father calling DIL fat.

Comment discussing a man calling his daughter-in-law fat while her husband laughs and defends his father.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing toxic family dynamics and the impact on self-esteem after a hurtful insult.

Screenshot of an online comment discussing a man calling his daughter-in-law fat while her husband laughs and defends him.

Screenshot of an online comment calling a husband garbage after he laughed when man called daughter-in-law fat.

Screenshot of an online comment discussing a toxic family dynamic affecting self-esteem after a man calls his daughter-in-law fat.

Reddit comment discussing a man calling his daughter-in-law fat, while her husband laughs and defends his father.

Screenshot of a forum comment discussing a man calling his daughter-in-law fat in front of everyone while her husband laughs and defends him.

Comment discussing husband fat shaming daughter-in-law while defending her father-in-law's insults publicly.

Comment on disrespectful man calling daughter-in-law fat while husband laughs and defends his father in a family conflict.

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!