Woman Refuses To Give Away Her Kids To Infertile Sister, She Ends Up In Prison For 12 Years
Infertility can be one of the most devastating pieces of news a young couple can receive. Research shows that around 9% of men and 11% of women in the U.S. have experienced fertility problems. Couples cope with the news in different ways, and some even seek help from their siblings.
But what this sister did goes beyond all appropriate ways of dealing with infertility. She had the gall to ask her twin sister to give up her baby because she deserved it more and could take care of it better. Even her parents took her side, since she was always treated like the “golden child.” The young mom-to-be, however, refused and sought help online, asking how to deal with her family.
This woman’s parents and twin sister gave her an ultimatum: give up your baby, or we will cut support
Image credits: nagaets / Freepik (not the actual photo)
The woman didn’t want to, so she asked netizens for advice on how to proceed
Image credits: pressmaster / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Image credits: bearfotos / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Queasy_Owl_1176
Image credits: Alexander Grey / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Single parents still face stigma and judgment in society
Being a single mother is not easy, but lots of women do it and rise to the challenge spectacularly well. As of 2023, there are around 7.3 million single mothers, 1.6 million single fathers, and 48.7 million married parents in the U.S. While they face many economic challenges, such as being the sole breadwinners of the household, they also often are shamed and judged.
So was the mother in this story, but the people judging her were not strangers, but her own family members. In 2014, a UK single-parent charity, Gingerbread, polled 1,500 parents and found that three in four experienced social stigma. Single parents feel judged about their situation, and many are annoyed when they have to explain why they became single parents.
Raising a baby (or two, as in this case!) can be hard as a single parent. It’s even harder when there is no family support. Many single mothers are told to rely on their village to help them get through the challenges of single motherhood. But those who don’t have family support don’t have the luxury of free babysitters, financial help, and emotional support.
But single parents can substitute missing family support with other relationships: friends, coworkers, and community groups. Specific support groups for single parents are an increasingly popular concept. Experts recommend checking out your local YMCA or YWCA, hospitals, public libraries, or Parents Without Partners. The age-old proverb that it takes a village to raise a child is true – it just depends on where you find that village.
Image credits: senivpetro / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Parental favoritism negatively affects both children, even in adulthood
The family dysfunction in this story comes from parental favoritism, according to the new mom. Her parents, she says, always gave her twin preferential treatment and treated her sister as the “golden child.”
Sadly, this phenomenon is more common than we think. Research from Brigham Young University suggests that parents tend to favor daughters, younger siblings, and those who are more agreeable. Interestingly, most of the time, they may do it without even noticing.
In a previous interview with Bored Panda, psychotherapist Haley Neidich explained that parental favoritism has negative consequences for both the neglected and the favored child. “Even the ‘golden child’ can feel trapped by expectations,” she said, “while the less-favored sibling often struggles with self-esteem. Individuals in both roles often end up needing to work through the challenges caused by this in therapy.”
Neidich says that both children need to understand that the favoritism wasn’t either child’s fault. The parents did that to them, and as soon as they recognize that, the sooner they can reconnect. “Recognizing that you and your sibling were both children and that the adults around you caused this dynamic can create a space where healing can occur,” she explained.
“Compassion also helps,” she added. “Many clients realize that the ‘golden child’ carries their own invisible burdens, which can ease resentment and lead to more effective communication. I have seen sibling relationships heal in adulthood and want folks to know that it is absolutely possible to develop a healthy, supportive relationship with your sibling.”
During the next months, the woman posted several updates, and the drama only escalated with each one
Image credits: Camandona / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Image credits: tirachardz / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Eduardo Ramos / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Brooke Balentine / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Fujiphilm / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: bilanol / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Matt Popovich / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Dmitrii Shirnin / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Kindel Media / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Queasy_Owl_1176
Support and advice for the woman poured out in the comments, urging her to go no-contact with her insane family
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Explore more of these tags
I'm a certified nurse midwife and I find it extremely difficult to believe that this woman went through an entire-@ss pregnancy with no one ever realizing there were 2 fetuses. Her growth would be off compared to singleton, which would have caused further testing. 2 fetuses = 2 heartbeats. The early ultrasound around 8 weeks would have shown both fetuses . . . it's not possible for one to hide behind the other at that size. Even at 20 weeks, both fetuses would have been seen. Theoretically it's possible, but practically? Nah. No way this happened.
Yeah, I thought as much (although I'm not an expert like you). Just one of man things that flag this one as a work of fiction. The way the narrative rolls, the way that, having just installed cameras she almost immediately notices the sister's car before she'd even parked and is able to telephone the babysitter before the sister gets to the door, the whole neat and happy ending. Oh, and the sister and BiL committed a massively serious crime in late March, but had already been charged, tried and sentenced by late April? In just four or five weeks? Not a chance.
Load More Replies...More nonsense - can afford a house and full time nanny but not a laptop? In addition to the other red flags others have pointed out. Why repost something so fake?
Not even the writers of a really, really, really bad telenovela would put out a story like this. They would be too embarassed. And that says something. The stamina of OP is something, though. Not sure if inspiring or psychotic... 😐
This is either bullpoop rage bait, or there's a whole family that needs locked up and the key thrown away. I'm leaning heavily towards the first option.
My cousin was always bisexual. She married a guy and had a kid. He m0lested her younger sister. She almost shot him but said she stopped when she saw her baby’s car seat in her car. So they divorced. She ends up meeting her now wife. his family tried to take the kid from her since her p**o ex couldn’t. I was babysitting and something similar happened with her ex’s family trying to barge in. This was in the 80s so no camera. But cuz had a weird feeling and rushed home to find them there with the cops saying she kidnapped their kid! Luckily when I opened the door, I knew the cop who I had babysat for before. People do crazy things. The surprise twin thing is hard to believe though.
I never take anything on Reddit as automatically true, AITA is just awful for fake BS in particular. But this is is just horrifyingly badly written nonsense
There *is* a certain aroma in the air, now you mention it.
Load More Replies...I already started to doubt this story when OP's mom called to tell her to give her unborn child to her sister because she "deserves it". Then with the whole "hidden" twin, I was just reading for entertainment purposes only. It's kinda sad that people feel the need to make up such ridiculousness for some much needed attention but, then again, it makes for some great creative writing practice!
Not a single news article to be found about the kidnapping or the trial or the jail sentence. I feel this would be big news if it actually happened. I don't believe this is real at all.
Nice fantasy, think some of the things through next time, so it's not so obviously fake. I'm guessing the OP is a young teenager.
You have a rich fantasy life, I'll give you that. That doesn't make up for the fact that you're an idiot.
I suppose it’s reasonable to question the truth of a post like this. After all, sites like Reddit and Bored Panda are the modern equivalent of old Jerry Springer tv chats shows. But I have seen enough in my life to at least mark this tale as “plausible.”
I'm a certified nurse midwife and I find it extremely difficult to believe that this woman went through an entire-@ss pregnancy with no one ever realizing there were 2 fetuses. Her growth would be off compared to singleton, which would have caused further testing. 2 fetuses = 2 heartbeats. The early ultrasound around 8 weeks would have shown both fetuses . . . it's not possible for one to hide behind the other at that size. Even at 20 weeks, both fetuses would have been seen. Theoretically it's possible, but practically? Nah. No way this happened.
Yeah, I thought as much (although I'm not an expert like you). Just one of man things that flag this one as a work of fiction. The way the narrative rolls, the way that, having just installed cameras she almost immediately notices the sister's car before she'd even parked and is able to telephone the babysitter before the sister gets to the door, the whole neat and happy ending. Oh, and the sister and BiL committed a massively serious crime in late March, but had already been charged, tried and sentenced by late April? In just four or five weeks? Not a chance.
Load More Replies...More nonsense - can afford a house and full time nanny but not a laptop? In addition to the other red flags others have pointed out. Why repost something so fake?
Not even the writers of a really, really, really bad telenovela would put out a story like this. They would be too embarassed. And that says something. The stamina of OP is something, though. Not sure if inspiring or psychotic... 😐
This is either bullpoop rage bait, or there's a whole family that needs locked up and the key thrown away. I'm leaning heavily towards the first option.
My cousin was always bisexual. She married a guy and had a kid. He m0lested her younger sister. She almost shot him but said she stopped when she saw her baby’s car seat in her car. So they divorced. She ends up meeting her now wife. his family tried to take the kid from her since her p**o ex couldn’t. I was babysitting and something similar happened with her ex’s family trying to barge in. This was in the 80s so no camera. But cuz had a weird feeling and rushed home to find them there with the cops saying she kidnapped their kid! Luckily when I opened the door, I knew the cop who I had babysat for before. People do crazy things. The surprise twin thing is hard to believe though.
I never take anything on Reddit as automatically true, AITA is just awful for fake BS in particular. But this is is just horrifyingly badly written nonsense
There *is* a certain aroma in the air, now you mention it.
Load More Replies...I already started to doubt this story when OP's mom called to tell her to give her unborn child to her sister because she "deserves it". Then with the whole "hidden" twin, I was just reading for entertainment purposes only. It's kinda sad that people feel the need to make up such ridiculousness for some much needed attention but, then again, it makes for some great creative writing practice!
Not a single news article to be found about the kidnapping or the trial or the jail sentence. I feel this would be big news if it actually happened. I don't believe this is real at all.
Nice fantasy, think some of the things through next time, so it's not so obviously fake. I'm guessing the OP is a young teenager.
You have a rich fantasy life, I'll give you that. That doesn't make up for the fact that you're an idiot.
I suppose it’s reasonable to question the truth of a post like this. After all, sites like Reddit and Bored Panda are the modern equivalent of old Jerry Springer tv chats shows. But I have seen enough in my life to at least mark this tale as “plausible.”


























































































12
26