Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
Woman Breaks Up With Boyfriend After An Activity With Her Son Makes His Ex Completely Lose It
Managing a split family, visiting rights and general boundaries with a partner’s kids from a previous marriage is by no means easy. Innocuous things can turn out to be boundary crossing when lines aren’t drawn well.
A woman asked the internet if she was wrong to teach her BF’s son a recipe when his biological mom wanted to have the experience of cooking with him for the first time. We reached out to the woman who made the post via private message and will update the article when she gets back to us.
RELATED:
Bonding with a partner’s kid is generally a good experience
Image credits: NatalieZera / Envato (not the actual photo)
But one woman wondered if she crossed a line when she decided to cook with her BF’s son
Image credits: EkaterinaPereslavtseva / Envato (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Sad_Active8131
It’s easy to side with the protagonist
The internet has given us front-row seats to the messy reality of blended families, and few situations reveal our collective biases quite like the story of a woman who committed the apparent cardinal sin of teaching her boyfriend’s eight-year-old son how to cook his favorite meal. She spent her day off supervising the child as he prepared butter chicken, took a proud photo of him holding his creation, and sent it to both parents with an innocent caption about “Chef Tristan.” The child’s mother responded with fury, accusing her of robbing a milestone moment and “playing family.” The boyfriend sided with his ex-wife, suggesting future activities should be pre-approved. When commenters got hold of this story, they overwhelmingly rallied behind the girlfriend, but the speed and certainty of that collective judgment reveals something interesting about how we navigate the complicated terrain of modern families.
What makes this scenario particularly fascinating is how it splits people along predictable lines based on their own experiences and assumptions about what blended families should look like. Research on moral psychology shows that people evaluate situations through the lens of their existing beliefs about family structure, parenting roles, and relationship hierarchies. Those who’ve been in the girlfriend’s position see an innocent cooking activity being weaponized by an unreasonable ex. Those who’ve been the biological parent in coparenting arrangements might recognize the sting of missing a child’s first experience with something meaningful. We’re not really judging this specific situation so much as revealing which role we identify with most strongly.
The immediate rush to support the girlfriend illustrates what psychologists call in-group bias. The girlfriend presents herself as someone trying her best in a difficult situation, someone who genuinely cares for the child and is being punished for it. She moved in after two years of dating, she makes the child’s favorite meal when he visits, she spends her day off doing activities with him. She’s constructed a narrative where she’s the caring partner being attacked for doing exactly what good partners in blended families are supposed to do. Most commenters accepted this framing wholesale, viewing the mother’s reaction as territorial and unreasonable.
It can be hard to quantify family dynamics in a short, online post
But here’s where it gets complicated. Studies on family systems theory indicate that blended families involve navigating invisible boundaries that may seem arbitrary to outsiders but carry significant emotional weight for those involved. The mother’s explosive reaction suggests this wasn’t really about butter chicken at all. It might have been about watching someone else become important in her child’s life. It might have been about feeling replaced in meaningful moments. It might have been about a longer history of boundary negotiations that never made it into the girlfriend’s telling of the story.
The boyfriend’s response is particularly revealing of the impossible position coparents often find themselves in. He asked his girlfriend to check with his ex-wife before doing activities involving cooking or cutting. To thousands of commenters, this seemed absurd, controlling, and indicative of a man who hadn’t properly separated from his ex-wife. But consider what he’s actually trying to manage, that is, keeping peace between two households so his son can move between them without tension, maintaining a functional coparenting relationship with someone he’ll be tied to for another decade, and supporting his girlfriend while not completely alienating his child’s mother. That’s not being a “wuss,” as the girlfriend later called him. That’s recognizing that his child’s wellbeing depends on adults who can work together.
Research on stepfamily dynamics consistently shows that the most successful blended families are those where biological parents take the lead on parenting decisions and discipline, especially in the early years. This doesn’t mean stepparents or partners can’t form meaningful bonds with children, but it does mean recognizing that biological parents often have feelings about milestone moments that seem irrational to outsiders. A child’s first time cooking a favorite meal might not register as a milestone to someone who’s been in the child’s life for two years, but to someone who’s been there since birth, it absolutely could.
What commenters rarely considered was whether the girlfriend’s response to being asked to communicate more was proportionate. She declared she would refuse to do anything one-on-one with the child going forward. That’s not setting healthy boundaries, that’s punishing an eight-year-old for adult conflicts. It’s the emotional equivalent of flipping the game board when you don’t like the rules.
She also replied to some comments
A lot of readers, predictably, sided with the person who made the post
Later, she shared an update
Image credits: LightFieldStudios / Envato (not the actual photo)
Image credits: DC_Studio / Envato (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Sad_Active8131
She chatted with a few readers in the comments
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
Explore more of these tags
What do you think ?
roddy 4 days ago
Some people are absurd. I can see it now, "It was his first sneeze, I was supposed to be the one to wipe his nose!" ad naseum.
Spocks's Mom 3 days ago
Oh, look, huh, it's Junior's first kiss! Quick!! Get the camera!!
Load More Replies...
Lee Gilliland 4 days ago
They dump their kid on a girlfriend with no warning and no instruction and then get mad because she had fun with the kid. How about these idiots get the parenting award of the year?
Janelle Collard 4 days ago
OP's ex-boyfriend + his ex-wife are the @ssh0les. OP has no reason to apologise for teaching Tristan to cook *one* meal. Overreact much, ex-BF?
Upstaged75 3 days ago
Of all the stupid things to get angry/offended over. Ex-wife is a jealous shrew. Too bad for the kid - sounds like she would have been a good influence for him.
ॐBoyGanesh 3 days ago (edited)
The glaringly obvious fact here is that OP & her (ex)bf were not partners. They were not a team. The ex-bf made it abundantly clear he is going to bend to his ex’s demands & feelings and no one is ever going to come before that. OP was correct in describing him as a wüss.
kimora nixion 3 days ago
your just doing your job as a parent and if his mom hadnt cooked with him yet and you qoute on qoute "robbed her of that experience " and she had 8 years to cook with her son for the first time
Paula Glasscoe 2 days ago
Just want to say it’s quote, unquote - it represents the “ marks at the beginning and end when you write something somebody has said. Not a big deal but thought you might like to know. Totally agree, 8 is old to have not at least done cupcakes or something!
Load More Replies...
FreeTheUnicorn 3 days ago
Always good to hear that people have broken up with awful people before the awfulness escalates
Tabitha 3 days ago (edited)
Sounds like the BF is still hung up on his ex-wife, and OP would’ve always taken a back seat to her, would’ve always been an afterthought in his mind. OP is better off out of that kind of hot mess. Now BF is free to kowtow to his ex about everything, in hopes she’ll maybe someday take him back.
SheamusFanFrom1987 1 day ago (edited)
OP ought to tell the spineless ex to "talk" to Tristan as to why that will be the first and last butter chicken he will have with OP. Seriously, who argues about being "first" whatever...??? Honestly, if Tristan were my kid, I'd be going "Oh great, then I will be expecting a butter chicken feast after this *Kidding, kidding*". Those two ding-dongs of ex and ex-wife deserve one another. Hopefully Tristan isn't taking it too hard that that was the first and the last butter chicken with OP while his spineless excuse of a DNA-donor ought to stop pestering OP and start buttering up back to his nutso ex like the chicken he is instead!!! -_-"
Beth Wheeler 2 days ago
This lady did nothing wrong in cooking with Tristan. She didn't let him use knives or the oven, he was safe at all times and had fun. Tristan's parents are complete perks in their reactions and treatment of her. Glad she broke with him.
Catmom 3 days ago (edited)
Good for her! She saw the HUGE red flag. 2+ decades ago, my DH, my tween stepdaughter, and I visited my toddler niece and my sister. My SD had so much fun, told her mom about it, and innocently referred to my niece as her cousin. Her mother snapped, "She's NOT your cousin. She's your father's wife's sister's child!" I met my husband years after she dumped him for one of her affair partners. The cousin incident was the most benign of the ex's endless, toxic, sometimes violent behavior. She tortured my husband through their 2 kids, which of course was much worse for them. I love my husband, we're married 26 years now, and he's my partner in all things. But had I known what his ex was capable of, how it would affect my mental health, I'd have RUN.
Spencer's slave no longer 3 days ago (edited)
Good grief! My oldest grandson's favourite meal is butter chicken. His parents make it, we all buy it as takeaways, I make it with him. Nobody cares who cooks it! As long as the child eats the food they had fun cooking, why is it such a big issue? My daughter in law knows I sneak things in the food I make and we laugh because she does the same. The girlfriend was 100% right in walking away.
Beak Hookage 3 days ago
OP takes care of the kid and he has a great time, but the egg donor only thinks about herself and throws a dummyspit. How incredibly selfish!
azubi 3 days ago
Not on board with NTA's this time. Parents are tricky, separated parents even more, and it always pays to ask them if they are okay with what you are planning with their children. They appreciate it as a matter of respect. She didn't know it, and I think the Ex was out of line to blow up this way, but OP's refusal to acknowledge that it's not trivial having your ex's new spouses parenting one's children turns it into a fight with a mother about the child, and this makes her TA.
Kate Johnson 3 days ago
A good reason not to waste your time dating folks with children. Way too much drama, little reward.
The Other Guest 3 days ago
You wasted your own time. You could have closed the tab at any moment & chose not to.
Load More Replies...
roddy 4 days ago
Some people are absurd. I can see it now, "It was his first sneeze, I was supposed to be the one to wipe his nose!" ad naseum.
Spocks's Mom 3 days ago
Oh, look, huh, it's Junior's first kiss! Quick!! Get the camera!!
Load More Replies... Lee Gilliland 4 days ago
They dump their kid on a girlfriend with no warning and no instruction and then get mad because she had fun with the kid. How about these idiots get the parenting award of the year?
Janelle Collard 4 days ago
OP's ex-boyfriend + his ex-wife are the @ssh0les. OP has no reason to apologise for teaching Tristan to cook *one* meal. Overreact much, ex-BF?
Upstaged75 3 days ago
Of all the stupid things to get angry/offended over. Ex-wife is a jealous shrew. Too bad for the kid - sounds like she would have been a good influence for him.
ॐBoyGanesh 3 days ago (edited)
The glaringly obvious fact here is that OP & her (ex)bf were not partners. They were not a team. The ex-bf made it abundantly clear he is going to bend to his ex’s demands & feelings and no one is ever going to come before that. OP was correct in describing him as a wüss.
kimora nixion 3 days ago
your just doing your job as a parent and if his mom hadnt cooked with him yet and you qoute on qoute "robbed her of that experience " and she had 8 years to cook with her son for the first time
Paula Glasscoe 2 days ago
Just want to say it’s quote, unquote - it represents the “ marks at the beginning and end when you write something somebody has said. Not a big deal but thought you might like to know. Totally agree, 8 is old to have not at least done cupcakes or something!
Load More Replies... FreeTheUnicorn 3 days ago
Always good to hear that people have broken up with awful people before the awfulness escalates
Tabitha 3 days ago (edited)
Sounds like the BF is still hung up on his ex-wife, and OP would’ve always taken a back seat to her, would’ve always been an afterthought in his mind. OP is better off out of that kind of hot mess. Now BF is free to kowtow to his ex about everything, in hopes she’ll maybe someday take him back.
SheamusFanFrom1987 1 day ago (edited)
OP ought to tell the spineless ex to "talk" to Tristan as to why that will be the first and last butter chicken he will have with OP. Seriously, who argues about being "first" whatever...??? Honestly, if Tristan were my kid, I'd be going "Oh great, then I will be expecting a butter chicken feast after this *Kidding, kidding*". Those two ding-dongs of ex and ex-wife deserve one another. Hopefully Tristan isn't taking it too hard that that was the first and the last butter chicken with OP while his spineless excuse of a DNA-donor ought to stop pestering OP and start buttering up back to his nutso ex like the chicken he is instead!!! -_-"
Beth Wheeler 2 days ago
This lady did nothing wrong in cooking with Tristan. She didn't let him use knives or the oven, he was safe at all times and had fun. Tristan's parents are complete perks in their reactions and treatment of her. Glad she broke with him.
Catmom 3 days ago (edited)
Good for her! She saw the HUGE red flag. 2+ decades ago, my DH, my tween stepdaughter, and I visited my toddler niece and my sister. My SD had so much fun, told her mom about it, and innocently referred to my niece as her cousin. Her mother snapped, "She's NOT your cousin. She's your father's wife's sister's child!" I met my husband years after she dumped him for one of her affair partners. The cousin incident was the most benign of the ex's endless, toxic, sometimes violent behavior. She tortured my husband through their 2 kids, which of course was much worse for them. I love my husband, we're married 26 years now, and he's my partner in all things. But had I known what his ex was capable of, how it would affect my mental health, I'd have RUN.
Spencer's slave no longer 3 days ago (edited)
Good grief! My oldest grandson's favourite meal is butter chicken. His parents make it, we all buy it as takeaways, I make it with him. Nobody cares who cooks it! As long as the child eats the food they had fun cooking, why is it such a big issue? My daughter in law knows I sneak things in the food I make and we laugh because she does the same. The girlfriend was 100% right in walking away.
Beak Hookage 3 days ago
OP takes care of the kid and he has a great time, but the egg donor only thinks about herself and throws a dummyspit. How incredibly selfish!
azubi 3 days ago
Not on board with NTA's this time. Parents are tricky, separated parents even more, and it always pays to ask them if they are okay with what you are planning with their children. They appreciate it as a matter of respect. She didn't know it, and I think the Ex was out of line to blow up this way, but OP's refusal to acknowledge that it's not trivial having your ex's new spouses parenting one's children turns it into a fight with a mother about the child, and this makes her TA.
Kate Johnson 3 days ago
A good reason not to waste your time dating folks with children. Way too much drama, little reward.
The Other Guest 3 days ago
You wasted your own time. You could have closed the tab at any moment & chose not to.
Load More Replies... You May Like Woman Is Made To Choose Between Work And Husband's Family, Picks Her Career: "Just Figure It Out" Woman Refuses To Host Thanksgiving For 30 People, Pushy Family Still Tries To Guilt-Trip Her Into It Parents Assume Childfree Cousin Will Babysit For Them On A Trip; Receive A Shocking Surprise Instead
Jonas Žvilius
Indrė Lukošiūtė
Dominyka Proškėnaitė
Related on Bored Panda
41
26