34YO Gets Outed At Fam Party For Lying To Hubby For 10 Years About A Dead Twin, He Divorces Her

Sometimes people lie about the most bizarre things, either because it’s entertaining for them or because they have ulterior motives. These falsehoods tend to slowly spiral out of control until the liar is no longer able to keep up with the story they’ve created.

This is exactly what one woman experienced when her decade-old deception came to light. She had lied to her husband about having a deceased twin brother, but he found out the truth at a family gathering, which ended up causing a lot of drama.

More info: Reddit

Even close family members might not be aware of the secrets of their loved ones

Four women standing outdoors smiling and talking, capturing a sister revealed dead brother lie moment in a sunny park.

Image credits: wirestock / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The poster, who is the eldest of four sisters, mentioned at a family gathering how glad she was to have no brothers, which angered her brother-in-law

Text describing a sister revealed dead brother lie involving family confusion and accidental outing of the falsehood.

Text excerpt explaining the eldest sister’s age and birth order among four sisters, related to sister revealed dead brother lie.

Text excerpt showing siblings’ feelings as sister revealed dead brother lie, reflecting family dynamics and emotional impact.

Text revealing sister’s heartfelt bond with family, touching on brother lie and family dynamics and emotions.

Text saying Ok now that you have the backstory and family history, let’s talk about tonight relating to sister revealed dead brother lie story.

Text excerpt describing a proud parent sharing their son's acceptance to a prestigious university, linked to sister revealed dead brother lie.

Text about family gathering with siblings, highlighting sister revealed dead brother lie in a heartfelt, emotional context.

Text excerpt about sibling appreciation day where the sister is revealed dead brother lie in a family conversation.

Text on a white background reading a statement about telling sisters love and appreciating no gross boys, related to sister revealed dead brother lie.

Family gathered around a table toasting wine glasses during a meal, symbolizing sister revealed dead brother lie theme.

Image credits: Anna Tolipova / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The man had been fed a lie by the poster’s sister, in which she claimed that she had a dead twin brother whom her family never spoke about

Text excerpt from a story revealing a sister's reaction to the brother’s lie about being dead.

Text excerpt showing a sister revealed dead brother lie conversation with heated dialogue between two people.

Text showing a sister revealing her dead brother’s lie as she grabs him by the arm, begging him to hush and go home now.

Text describing a sister revealed dead brother lie about a twin who died during childbirth and family silence rules.

Alt text: Family tension rises after sister reveals dead brother lie during a tense conversation at a celebration.

Sister revealed dead brother lie causing emotional distress and family members following her into the old bedroom.

Text on screen showing a sibling revealing the dead brother lie while describing a family argument about truth.

Text message revealing sister's confession and accusations about a dead brother lie causing family conflict and mistrust.

Text excerpt showing a sister revealing conflict about a dead brother lie involving Amy, Beth, and Jo’s opinions.

Text excerpt showing emotional reaction as sister revealed dead brother lie, expressing confusion and love for sisters.

Three women sitting at a table looking concerned and thoughtful as sister reveals dead brother lie in a tense moment.

Image credits: Freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The poster was painted as the bad guy for exposing her sister’s extreme lie, but despite the drama that ensued, the brother-in-law still had faith in his wife

Sister revealed dead brother lie in a heartfelt message thanking supporters after a difficult and exhausting night.

Text excerpt from a story about a sister revealing her dead brother’s lie, shown in plain black font on white background.

Text on a plain background reading I'll get to the update in a few, answering some FAQ and comments real quick about sister revealed dead brother lie.

Text excerpt with sister revealed dead brother lie theme shown on white background in black font.

Text excerpt discussing parents naming children after Little Women, related to sister revealed dead brother lie context.

Text excerpt about family and noticeable names, highlighting a sister revealed dead brother lie context.

Text message conversation revealing sister exposing dead brother's lie about phone messages in tense family exchange.

Text on a white background showing a personal message about family, tied to sister revealing dead brother's lie.

Text excerpt discussing a sister revealed dead brother lie with no evidence of twins, deaths, funerals, or depression.

Toddler sister watching baby brother sleeping in crib, revealing dead brother lie emotions in a home nursery setting.

Image credits: EyeEm / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Eventually, the dishonest sister, Beth, came clean about her lie, but she didn’t apologize to the poster or her family for her actions

Text excerpt from a document discussing a sister revealing a dead brother lie involving a birth certificate.

Text discussing family dynamics with a sister revealed dead and brother's lie affecting their relationships and fairness.

Text excerpt discussing a sister revealing a dead brother lie and reflecting on tact in a sibling conversation.

Text discussing a sister revealing a dead brother lie, focusing on facts and avoiding drama in the situation.

Text update on a white background with the sister revealed dead brother lie keyword concept.

Text excerpt highlighting a sister revealed dead brother lie, showing emotional family conflict and distress.

Text excerpt discussing a sister revealing a dead brother lie and family tension about the truth.

Text on a white background with a quote about sympathy, empathy, and an apology related to a family situation involving a sister and brother lie.

Text message revealing sister confronted brother about the lie after hours of denial, sister revealed dead brother lie exposed.

Text excerpt discussing family secrets and revealing a sister's lie about her brother.

Young woman with serious expression on phone call, depicting sister revealed dead brother lie theme in a home setting.

Image credits: jet-po / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The poster felt that since Beth’s husband was a first responder and had married her, though she was a single mom, the lie was her way of continuing her victimhood

Text showing a sister revealed dead brother lie, mentioning Chase as a first responder and his connection to Madison since age 2.

Text excerpt discussing a sister revealed dead brother lie involving heroism and victims advocacy in personal relationships.

Sister revealed dead brother lie to appear vulnerable and gain sympathy in a complicated relationship with a small child involved.

Text excerpt highlighting deceit and manipulation, illustrating sister revealed dead brother lie in a personal relationship context.

Text excerpt discussing unresolved family conflict and a sister revealed dead brother lie in personal communication.

Text expressing hope for happiness, health, and therapy as sister revealed dead brother lie causes reflection on life choices.

Text excerpt about a sister revealing dead brother lie with no additional family details shared or asked about.

Hand holding a torn photo of a sister and brother, symbolizing the sister revealed dead brother lie story.

Text message on a white background expressing gratitude for support after sister revealed dead brother lie situation.

Two women standing close together outdoors, showing support and comfort in a sister revealed dead brother lie situation.

Image credits: Freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The poster shared a final update after her dad passed away about how Beth had gotten arrested at his end-of-life ceremony

Text excerpt revealing sister's grief after discovering brother's lie, reflecting on family dynamics and emotional struggle.

Text describing a family tragedy involving the sister revealing a dead brother’s lie after their dad passed away unexpectedly.

Text excerpt about a sister revealed dead brother lie, describing therapy and family dynamics challenges.

Text excerpt discussing the emotional cost of keeping the peace and the sister revealed dead brother lie impact.

Text excerpt discussing family reactions after dad's death and sister revealed dead brother lie about parents' end-of-life wishes.

Text excerpt showing a sister's emotional meltdown revealing brother lie and family conflict over wishes.

Text excerpt from a sister revealing the dead brother lie, describing a family conflict and father's preference.

Text excerpt showing a conversation about sorting items and a mention of dad’s watch collection in a sister revealed dead brother lie context.

Text excerpt about a sister revealing a dead brother lie, highlighting family conflict and refusal to answer questions.

Collection of wristwatches and bracelets neatly arranged in a box, symbolizing time and a sister revealed dead brother lie.

Image credits: EyeEm / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Beth’s behavior seemed to spiral out of control, which pushed her husband to file for divorce and petition for full custody

Text on a white background reading I wasn’t there but my son is wearing the first luxury watch my dad bought showing sister revealed dead brother lie theme.

Woman upset at brother’s funeral, revealing grief and tension after sister revealed dead brother lie at the ceremony.

Text on a screen showing a message about a brother-in-law’s bruises and conflict, related to sister revealed dead brother lie.

Text passage about a sister revealed dead brother lie, discussing therapy, drinking, and family struggles.

Text on white background describing a family dispute, relating to sister revealed dead brother lie and custody petition.

Text showing emotional struggle in family as sister revealed dead brother lie, refusing to speak and causing a downward spiral.

Text excerpt showing a person deciding to stop updating and focus on themselves amid a sister revealed dead brother lie situation.

Text image with the phrase: Thanks for listening to me vent. Y’all are almost as good as therapy, related to sister revealed dead brother lie.

Image credits: lurkandtaway85

The poster shared that she was going to take a step back from her sister’s drama and focus on her own life for a while

The OP had always been on good terms with all of her family members, especially her sisters, and she also probably felt that she knew their lives well. That’s why she was extremely shocked to learn about the big lie that her sibling, Beth, had been telling her husband about having a deceased twin brother.

The poster didn’t feel the need to continue with such a falsehood, so she told Chase, Beth’s husband, the truth in front of their whole family. Usually, therapists advise that one should only carry out a confrontation in private, as this gives the other person enough space to come clean without fear of intense judgment.

Obviously, the poster’s bluntness let the cat out of the bag and pushed the family into chaos. Her mom and siblings felt that she was wrong for handling the situation so brashly. Eventually, after a lot of denial, Beth came out with the truth, but she didn’t apologize to her family for her actions.

It’s clear that her lie spiralled out of control, and after a while, she couldn’t see any other option than to continue with the story. Mental health experts state that people often have to tell more and more falsehoods to cover up the first one they told, and later on, fear or guilt might keep the cycle going.

Woman lying down indoors with hand on forehead, reflecting on sister revealed dead brother lie in a sunlit room.

Image credits: Freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

After Beth’s confession, the sisters still remained in contact with each other, but things took a turn for the worse after their father passed. Instead of being there for her family, Beth fussed over her dad’s possessions, threw a tantrum about his last rites, and also got plastered at his funeral, which led to the authorities being involved.

Sometimes, people like to create chaos or play the victim so that they can get the attention they crave. These meltdowns or tantrums might also be a way to shirk responsibility and be seen as someone who needs saving. It’s possible that Beth felt this way and wanted her husband and family to keep doing her bidding.

The poster soon realized that she could no longer keep dealing with her younger sister’s drama. So, after her dad’s funeral, she decided to focus more on her own family and not pay any heed to Beth’s chaotic life. This is probably the only way she could get the peace that she really needed to grieve and move on.

The OP’s sister must have felt that she’d be able to get away with her lie and bad behavior, but her husband eventually decided to file for divorce. Hopefully, reaching this kind of rock bottom in her life might teach her the value of family and honesty.

Have you ever come across anyone who made up a fake story like this? Do share your experiences with us, and let us know how you’d deal with a situation like this.

Folks were shocked by Beth’s lies and bizarre behavior, and felt that the poster was right for keeping her distance

Screenshot of an online comment discussing the sister revealing the dead brother lie and the instability involved.

Screenshot of a social media comment imagining Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy playing out a scene about sister revealed dead brother lie.

Text excerpt discussing a sister revealing a dead brother lie and related family dynamics.

Screenshot of a social media comment discussing lies, manipulation, and toxic behavior related to a sister revealing a dead brother lie.

Reddit comment discussing family dynamics and therapy after sister revealed dead brother lie within the family context.

Reddit user expressing relief about focusing on herself, hinting at a sister revealed dead brother lie discussion.

Comment on a forum discussing a sister revealed dead brother lie, suggesting fake twin siblings who died at birth.

Screenshot of an online comment discussing a sister who revealed a dead brother lie and the emotional consequences faced.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment describing old wooden chests filled with relics, related to sister revealed dead brother lie.

Comment discussing a brother's name choice and its impact, related to sister revealed dead brother lie story.

Screenshot of a forum comment discussing a sister revealing a dead brother lie and family tensions online.

Text post sharing a sister-revealed-dead-brother-lie prank and family photos of the fictional brother Timmy.

Text post discussing the consequences of lying about a dead sibling and how such lies are eventually revealed.

Comment about Beth's glass walls cracking and falling apart, highlighting a sister revealed dead brother lie situation.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing missing updates about triplets and narcissism in a bingo card game post.

User comment expressing concern and sadness about Beth needing help, related to sister revealed dead brother lie topic.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!