Adopted Sis Keeps Boasting That She’s “The Chosen One”, Bro Finds It Obnoxious And Snaps At Her

Family rituals and running jokes can be a source of comfort or conflict. What starts as a playful tradition can sometimes reveal wounds, especially in blended families where roles and relationships are more complex. Repeated comments or inside jokes meant to be funny can unintentionally highlight differences, favoritism, or insecurities among siblings.

This story illustrates exactly that. Today’s Original Poster (OP) shared that their adopted sister repeatedly referred to herself as the “chosen one” in her family, a line that has long been taken lightly by most relatives. However, when they decided they’d had enough, the moment revealed deeper emotions and dynamics.

More info: Reddit

Sometimes what starts as playful teasing or inside jokes can sometimes become a source of tension, highlighting unresolved feelings that have been simmering for years

Family outdoors in autumn, parents interacting with their young daughter, highlighting adopted sis chosen one joke backfiring story.

Image credits: bristekjegor / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Before the author and their brothers were born, their mom had a daughter with a previous partner, but the daughter was later adopted by their dad when he married their mom

Text excerpt from a post about an adopted sister’s longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after brother reveals bio dad never chose her.

Text excerpt showing a longstanding chosen one joke by an adopted sister about bio dad never choosing her.

Image credits: AbbreviationsFair886

Young adults socializing at a party, illustrating the adopted sis chosen one joke backfiring family story.

Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Growing up, the sister often joked that she was the “chosen one”,  a playful running gag that annoyed them but amused the rest of the family

Text describing a longstanding chosen one joke by adopted sister backfires after brother says bio dad never chose her.

Text excerpt about adopted sister's longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after brother reveals bio dad never chose her.

Image credits: AbbreviationsFair886

Young man and woman in a wooden kitchen arguing, illustrating sibling tension and the chosen one joke backfiring story.

Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

As adults, during a night out, they snapped at her over the recurring joke, making a comment about her biological father not choosing her

Text excerpt discussing a sister’s longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after brother says bio dad never chose her.

Text excerpt about adopted sis' longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after bro says bio dad never chose her.

Text post about adopted sis' longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after bro says bio dad never chose her.

Image credits: AbbreviationsFair886

The incident reached their parents, who were angry at them, while siblings and partners criticized the comment as cruel

The OP stated that their mother had a daughter with another partner who eventually walked away. When their mother met their father, the daughter was now adopted by the new stepdad, who raised her as his own and showered her with love alongside his biological children including the OP.

Growing up, the adopted sister leaned into this origin story, often joking that while her siblings were “stuck” with their dad, she was the one he chose. Everyone else seemed to take it in stride from laughing, teasing, to just treating it like a running gag. For the OP, though, the joke never landed the same way.

Fast-forward to adulthood, and the adopted sister was still pulling out the “chosen one” line at gatherings, including a recent night out with the OP, their siblings and their partners. For the most part, it had become a quirky family tradition where the sister often told the story of her adoption, so as usual, she slipped in the fact that she was the “chosen one” again.

Fueled by alcohol and frustration, the OP finally snapped, pointing out that while the sister may have been chosen by their dad, she wasn’t chosen by her biological father. The words stung immediately, leaving the sister hurt and the rest of the group stunned.

Their siblings called the comment out as cruel and the night ended early with an Uber ride home, and before long, word had reached their parents who thought their comment was not just rude but unnecessarily harsh.

To better understand why long-running family jokes can spark tension, Bored Panda spoke with relationship coach and marriage counselor Mildred Okonkwo who explained that seemingly harmless “chosen one” jokes can have lasting effects on siblings.

Three people sitting in a dim room showing tension after adopted sis’ longstanding chosen one joke backfires with brother’s comment.

Image credits: Drazen Zigic / Freepik (not the actual photo)

“The thing is that children are incredibly perceptive, and consistent messaging about ‘specialness’ can shape how others see themselves and their roles in the family,” she said, noting that siblings may internalize feelings of jealousy or inadequacy, sometimes developing coping strategies like people-pleasing or emotional withdrawal.

We asked Okonkwo why some children in blended families feel compelled to assert their “special” status repeatedly. She explained, “Whether aware of it or not, it’s pretty much a strategy to ensure their voice is heard and their needs are recognized. It’s almost like leaving a personal stamp that says they matter there.”

She added that this behavior should not be mistaken as stemming from arrogance but from navigating uncertainty, subtle comparisons, or fears of being overshadowed by step-siblings.

Okonkwo also shared guidance for families when a sibling finally reacts after years of hearing a recurring joke. “It’s important to pause and acknowledge the reaction without judgment,” she advised. “Avoid dismissing it as ‘just a joke’ or telling them to ‘lighten up’, because that can reinforce the sense that their emotions aren’t legitimate.”

Instead, she recommended calmly helping the joke-teller understand the impact of their words while modeling empathy and healthy boundaries. “Not all jokes appear harmful, but at the same time, the feelings of everyone has to be handled thoughtfully in real time because these moments can prevent resentment from festering and even strengthen sibling relationships.”

Netizens leaned heavily toward calling the OP the villain in this story, pointing out that their sister’s “chosen one” joke was likely rooted in deep insecurity. A smaller but notable group of netizens, however, noted that the sister’s constant joke was immature and needed to stop, but still argued that the OP’s remark was unnecessarily cruel.

What do you think about this situation? Do you think the sister was wrong for repeating the joke, or was the OP for finally snapping? We would love to know your thoughts!

Netizens were affirmed that while hearing the joke might have been annoying to the author, they were wrong for making such an unnecessary comment

Reddit comment about adopted sister’s longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after brother says bio dad never chose her.

Screenshot of a forum comment discussing the adopted sister's longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after brother's reply.

Screenshot of an online comment discussing adopted sister's longstanding chosen one joke and bio dad not choosing her.

Reddit user discusses adopted sister's longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after brother reveals bio dad never chose her.

ALT text: Reddit comment discussing adopted sibling joke backfiring and bio dad choosing all kids in family conflict context

Screenshot of Reddit comment discussing adopted sis’ longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after brother mentions bio dad never chose her.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing the adopted sis longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after bro’s bio dad.

Screenshot of Reddit comment discussing adopted sis joke backfiring after bro says bio dad never chose her.

Reddit comment discussing adopted sis longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after bro says bio dad never chose her.

Screenshot of a forum comment discussing the adopted sis longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after bro says bio dad never chose her.

Text post about sibling conflict and adopted sister joke backfiring when bio dad never chose her in family dynamics.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing an adopted sister’s longstanding chosen one joke backfiring after brother’s response.

Reddit comment revealing fallout from adopted sister's longstanding chosen one joke after brother says bio dad never chose her.

Screenshot of an online discussion about adopted siblings and a longstanding chosen one joke backfiring in a family conflict.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing a longstanding chosen one joke backfiring in a family dispute.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!