“This Was Not My Problem”: Ex-Husband And His Wife Push For Homeschooling, Woman Stands Firm
Interview With ExpertCo-parenting can be tricky at the best of times.
But while some challenges are expected, this Redditor found herself facing a demand she didn’t see coming. Her ex-husband’s new wife told her she should homeschool her kids—just like she does with her own. The problem? Neither the children nor their mother wanted that.
Now, the mom’s firm “no” has sparked a clash between the families. Read on to see how it’s unfolding.
The woman refused when her ex-husband’s new wife insisted she homeschool her kids
Image credits: unsplash (not the actual photo)
Now, her firm stance is stirring up tension
Image credits: unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: DealingMommyXy
Only 15% of separated parents say they co-parent without issues
Image credits: freepik (not the actual photo)
Parenting is no small feat—and splitting up doesn’t make it any easier.
According to research by the UK Department for Work and Pensions, only 15% of separated parents say they manage to co-parent without any hiccups.
For many, the sticking point is clashing parenting styles. About a third of co-parents face this challenge, turning everyday decisions into battlegrounds when each believes they know what’s best for their child.
It’s a tough situation, but not a hopeless one. Divorce service Amicable shares practical ways to set boundaries and keep co-parenting from turning into a constant tug-of-war. Here’s what they suggest:
1. Communicate respectfully
Keep conversations focused on your child’s needs, not past conflicts or personal frustrations. Using neutral, collaborative language,like “How can we best support [child’s name]?”—can help you work together without unnecessary tension.
2. Avoid discussing adult issues with your children
Kids shouldn’t feel responsible for their parents’ conflicts or decisions. Sharing details about money, disagreements, or parenting frustrations can leave children anxious or feeling torn between parents. Keep conversations with your kids simple and reassuring, focusing on their security and wellbeing.
3. Don’t speak negatively about the other parent
It can be tempting to vent when emotions run high, but speaking badly about your co-parent in front of your child can cause confusion and guilt. It can also create loyalty conflicts, leaving your child feeling pressured to take sides.
4. Keep each other in the loop
Smooth co-parenting requires staying organized and communicating about your child’s needs, schedules, and any changes to plans. Using a shared calendar or co-parenting app can help keep everything on track and avoid unnecessary stress.
5. Don’t be afraid to ask for help
If disagreements feel impossible to resolve, seeking outside support can help. Mediation or counseling offers a neutral space to work through issues while prioritizing your child’s best interests.
Co-parenting isn’t easy, but it doesn’t mean it can’t work. With clear boundaries, respectful communication, and a willingness to seek help when needed, it’s possible to create a stable, supportive environment for your child, even after a separation.
Many readers showed their support for the woman
Some, however, felt she was in the wrong for how she handled the issue
24Kviews
Share on FacebookUK so different education system (Scottish system specifically) but both of my parents were qualified and GTCS registered teachers (mum primary, dad secondary chemistry and maths) and both of them decided whilst they liked the idea of living “the good life” in the back end of beyond and homeschooling my and my siblings it was a terrible idea for our education!
What's crazy in the UK is that ANYBODY can home school their children if they want to and they do NOT have to follow the national curriculum. I feel that's total madness! If you're child is in school first and then you want to take them out then you have to get the permission of the head and stuff but if you never enrol them in the first place, you can do what you like within reason.
Load More Replies...US resident here. I generally see homeschooling being done by religious zealots, usually Evangelical Christians. They don't want to subject their kids to things in the secular world and so keep them isolated from music, pop culture and, god forbid... science. I know that not all homeschooling is by religious nuts, but it seems to be done predominantly by them. What I really hate is the lack of socialization and the isolation of the kids.
The OP said the new partner probably isn't teaching them any science because of 'belief differences; so this is almost certainly another religious idiot. (not saying everyone religious is an idiot, but this one is)
Load More Replies...Homeschooling should be illegal. There, I've said it. Unless there's a medical need for the child to stay home and not attend school (in which case the teachers should be visiting to teach!), I don't see any reason for the child to be left at home, at the mercy of their parents' belief system and knowledge level. I've seen enough documentaries about this to know that in most states (US) the regulations are so loose that there's practically no verification of the child's progress. And knowledge is everything. One shouldn't be deprived of good education just because they have idiots for parents. I'm writing about the US because I haven't heard of much homeschooling anywhere else, maybe statistical error levels in some countries.
What needs to be reinstated is the testing to make sure homeschool kids are at grade level. Most states had them until early 2000s. There's no reason that one educational model will be the best thing for all students and outlawing homeschooling deprives those kids that are thriving in an alternative setting of their opportunities. Most of the homeschooled HS students I worked with were taking college level courses and were more enthused about learning than the ones who were in public school. They had more internship opportunities because they could participate during regular school hours and they accessed more funding and places at college because of the work they'd done. If a child is happier, healthier and less stressed, why have them sit through public school? What is needed is oversight and accreditation not outlawing education.
Load More Replies...Homeschooling is usually a form of educational neglect. Be blunt: "No. That's not going to happen, ever. Please don't bring up the subject of homeschooling again." and when they inevitably do bring it up again. "I've already told you no. That's all I have to say on the subject." If they raise the fairness, parenting difficulties etc. "I don't agree with (wife's) parenting decisions, and I will not withhold socialisation and education from my own children to support her in her mistakes. Please don't raise this again." Document every time, in case you need to show a history of harassment. Also be frank with your kids "We need to be polite with Stepmom, but I don't agree with her about school, or religion, and you need to be careful to think about whether things she and stepsiblings tell you are correct, or just what they believe." Be prepared to sit them down and correct misinformation about evolution, science, morality, sexuality, etc.
I am so happy that homeschooling is not a thing here. Please tell me that the stepmom is at least a fully trained teacher and not a bored and overly controlling mom who can't send send her little angels to school.
I, as a military child, had lots of friends that were homeschooled and they were not only behind me on basic subjects but most were VERY religious based. I wonder where they are in life now.
Homeschooling. While it's hard to support any school system I know about, the homeschooled people whom I had the displeasure to have to meet, are entitled, bratty, throw tantrums even as grown ups, and lack crucial education in at least one area, and most likely, are indoctrinated to believe in some sort of pseudoscience, like biology rid of evolution.
Homeschooling should only be done if there are extraordinary circumstances, such as disabilities, extreme bullying, or other dire issues. Parents should absolutely teach their kids things like manners, how to act in public, tie their shoes, tell time, the alphabet, numbers, and other basic things along with life skills, but school is absolutely essential in so many ways. I am an educator, and things are bad enough with kids getting a decent education due to social media, parental uninvolvement, and so many other things. Forget about homeschooled kids.
She doesn't teach science? There's got to be a law against homeschooling and leaving out the "schooling" part. In my state, homeschooled kids still have to pass the same tests as the public school kids.
Good on your state. Standardized exams aren't perfect but better than leaving kids without any assessment or follow up at all.
Load More Replies...So Aaron + Nicole will soon have 8 kids? Is that what I read? Hope OP + her kids can stay away from that circus as much as possible. OP's kids have already said they want to continue to go to public school. That should be the end of it.
This wouldn't have been a problem if OP's ex didn't cheat to begin with. He made his bed and he can lay in it with his homewrecker wife. NTA
Gotta love the OP's nuclear-option lawyer-up approach. This women clearly knows her kinfolk.
Soon OP's going to have to consider some kind of restraining order as it sounds like they're bordering on harassment. I like the response who asked if they'd also perform their own surgery. New wife and ex need to learn no means no - that's a good home lesson to teach the kids.
For medical reasons, I homeschooled my daughter in the 7th and 10th grades. However, I took it extremely seriously and spent a lot of time preparing lessons and such. I also drew upon my academic parents' experience as teachers for several subjects. My daughter and I both enjoyed it, but also were both ready for her to return to public school when she was better. (We are not religious. At all.)
“It’s unfair for my kids to see her kids go to school…..” Yeah, because kids never want to be “weird,” and most people think homeschooling is weird.
So many of these are "my children are jealous/mad/demanding/etc because of..." Yeah, that's what parenting is. Explaining things to your kids. Why do you have kids if you can't parent them in the most basic and bare minimum way?
Why would that keep the children from bonding? Children of mixed families in countries where home schooling isn't an option bond easily. I can't understand anyway how it can be so easy for unqualified people to take up such a difficult and specialised job as that of a teacher. You're telling me, these people know everything from biology to maths to history, and even a second language? Plus the pedagogical knowledge? Yeah, sure!
I understand the appeal of homeschooling your children however, I feel like the experience of going to school and being amongst other kids their own age is also very important.
I only know 3 adults from families that homeschooled and they all have significant social difficulties and trouble maintaining adult relationships and holding down jobs. It's a small sample size but concerns me.
Load More Replies...Having read the update lol most don’t ! I saw the different beliefs so from that it screams she’s one of the bloody god squad lunatics ! N the insistence on homeschooling is typical of Jw,s 🤦♀️they are bat shite crazy , those poor 8 kids lives are over before it starts , their schooling will literally only be on what the lunatic mother thinks they will learn , their schooling rest isn’t even taken in to account ! the cps needs to go around there and have those poor kids assessed , for their ages , cos the mother is not a teacher , she just wants to control each n ever one of those kids ! the ytas are as per trolls , NO is a complete sentence end of job done , as lots suggested a cease n desist letter with the very real threat of court should they continue , the mother needs to wind her neck in n do what’s right for her kids ie proper school !! blessed be op keep us updated plz x
In the states the problem is mostly the fun dame the fundamentalists who won't teach kids science.
Load More Replies...She should tell her lawyer to up the ante, get an order. If the lawyer advises against, get another lawyer.
Keep wasting money until a lawyer says yes? I can see where the things until now haven't gone far enough for the law to take legal action. Sometimes you have to wait for an action or a direct threat before anyone can do anything, including lawyers.
Load More Replies...They just want the education support money for the two kids, it's obvious ex and his wife don't care about what the kids want or what's best for them. I'm a huge supporter of homeschooling, but they aren't offering to do any of the things that make it successful, they just want extra cash.
Those YTAs are mind-numbingly stupid. She's clearly on the page to vent because of the relentlessness of her ex and his wife regarding the even more mind-numbingly stupid idea of homeschooling. I'm not saying homeschooling never works out well, but if it does, it's closer to the exception than the norm. Given the campaign put on by the ex and his wife, I wonder if they would qualify for harassment charges (I have absolutely no idea if they would, but it's something that I would look into if I were in the same position).
Have your lawyer draft a request that all parental communication with you be through an app or through the lawyer himself, and NO communication on any parenting issue be filtered through the kids. Get a judge to sign off on it if you can, or just have the letter delivered to their lawyer. At least that might give you a bit of peace as well as full documentation for future use.
OP clearly stated that this isn't sufficient for him to lose custody. What he will lose is the goodwill of his own children as it goes against their own wishes. Children aren't daft, they'll see all he's really trying to do is keep his new partner sweet rather than putting his children's own needs and preferences first.
Load More Replies...Kids should have more rights than just to be a play toy for their parents. Disillusionment is not good enough. That could be because they don't teach creation myths. Disillusionment is doing a lot of work in your paragraph. Kids deserve an education.
Load More Replies...UK so different education system (Scottish system specifically) but both of my parents were qualified and GTCS registered teachers (mum primary, dad secondary chemistry and maths) and both of them decided whilst they liked the idea of living “the good life” in the back end of beyond and homeschooling my and my siblings it was a terrible idea for our education!
What's crazy in the UK is that ANYBODY can home school their children if they want to and they do NOT have to follow the national curriculum. I feel that's total madness! If you're child is in school first and then you want to take them out then you have to get the permission of the head and stuff but if you never enrol them in the first place, you can do what you like within reason.
Load More Replies...US resident here. I generally see homeschooling being done by religious zealots, usually Evangelical Christians. They don't want to subject their kids to things in the secular world and so keep them isolated from music, pop culture and, god forbid... science. I know that not all homeschooling is by religious nuts, but it seems to be done predominantly by them. What I really hate is the lack of socialization and the isolation of the kids.
The OP said the new partner probably isn't teaching them any science because of 'belief differences; so this is almost certainly another religious idiot. (not saying everyone religious is an idiot, but this one is)
Load More Replies...Homeschooling should be illegal. There, I've said it. Unless there's a medical need for the child to stay home and not attend school (in which case the teachers should be visiting to teach!), I don't see any reason for the child to be left at home, at the mercy of their parents' belief system and knowledge level. I've seen enough documentaries about this to know that in most states (US) the regulations are so loose that there's practically no verification of the child's progress. And knowledge is everything. One shouldn't be deprived of good education just because they have idiots for parents. I'm writing about the US because I haven't heard of much homeschooling anywhere else, maybe statistical error levels in some countries.
What needs to be reinstated is the testing to make sure homeschool kids are at grade level. Most states had them until early 2000s. There's no reason that one educational model will be the best thing for all students and outlawing homeschooling deprives those kids that are thriving in an alternative setting of their opportunities. Most of the homeschooled HS students I worked with were taking college level courses and were more enthused about learning than the ones who were in public school. They had more internship opportunities because they could participate during regular school hours and they accessed more funding and places at college because of the work they'd done. If a child is happier, healthier and less stressed, why have them sit through public school? What is needed is oversight and accreditation not outlawing education.
Load More Replies...Homeschooling is usually a form of educational neglect. Be blunt: "No. That's not going to happen, ever. Please don't bring up the subject of homeschooling again." and when they inevitably do bring it up again. "I've already told you no. That's all I have to say on the subject." If they raise the fairness, parenting difficulties etc. "I don't agree with (wife's) parenting decisions, and I will not withhold socialisation and education from my own children to support her in her mistakes. Please don't raise this again." Document every time, in case you need to show a history of harassment. Also be frank with your kids "We need to be polite with Stepmom, but I don't agree with her about school, or religion, and you need to be careful to think about whether things she and stepsiblings tell you are correct, or just what they believe." Be prepared to sit them down and correct misinformation about evolution, science, morality, sexuality, etc.
I am so happy that homeschooling is not a thing here. Please tell me that the stepmom is at least a fully trained teacher and not a bored and overly controlling mom who can't send send her little angels to school.
I, as a military child, had lots of friends that were homeschooled and they were not only behind me on basic subjects but most were VERY religious based. I wonder where they are in life now.
Homeschooling. While it's hard to support any school system I know about, the homeschooled people whom I had the displeasure to have to meet, are entitled, bratty, throw tantrums even as grown ups, and lack crucial education in at least one area, and most likely, are indoctrinated to believe in some sort of pseudoscience, like biology rid of evolution.
Homeschooling should only be done if there are extraordinary circumstances, such as disabilities, extreme bullying, or other dire issues. Parents should absolutely teach their kids things like manners, how to act in public, tie their shoes, tell time, the alphabet, numbers, and other basic things along with life skills, but school is absolutely essential in so many ways. I am an educator, and things are bad enough with kids getting a decent education due to social media, parental uninvolvement, and so many other things. Forget about homeschooled kids.
She doesn't teach science? There's got to be a law against homeschooling and leaving out the "schooling" part. In my state, homeschooled kids still have to pass the same tests as the public school kids.
Good on your state. Standardized exams aren't perfect but better than leaving kids without any assessment or follow up at all.
Load More Replies...So Aaron + Nicole will soon have 8 kids? Is that what I read? Hope OP + her kids can stay away from that circus as much as possible. OP's kids have already said they want to continue to go to public school. That should be the end of it.
This wouldn't have been a problem if OP's ex didn't cheat to begin with. He made his bed and he can lay in it with his homewrecker wife. NTA
Gotta love the OP's nuclear-option lawyer-up approach. This women clearly knows her kinfolk.
Soon OP's going to have to consider some kind of restraining order as it sounds like they're bordering on harassment. I like the response who asked if they'd also perform their own surgery. New wife and ex need to learn no means no - that's a good home lesson to teach the kids.
For medical reasons, I homeschooled my daughter in the 7th and 10th grades. However, I took it extremely seriously and spent a lot of time preparing lessons and such. I also drew upon my academic parents' experience as teachers for several subjects. My daughter and I both enjoyed it, but also were both ready for her to return to public school when she was better. (We are not religious. At all.)
“It’s unfair for my kids to see her kids go to school…..” Yeah, because kids never want to be “weird,” and most people think homeschooling is weird.
So many of these are "my children are jealous/mad/demanding/etc because of..." Yeah, that's what parenting is. Explaining things to your kids. Why do you have kids if you can't parent them in the most basic and bare minimum way?
Why would that keep the children from bonding? Children of mixed families in countries where home schooling isn't an option bond easily. I can't understand anyway how it can be so easy for unqualified people to take up such a difficult and specialised job as that of a teacher. You're telling me, these people know everything from biology to maths to history, and even a second language? Plus the pedagogical knowledge? Yeah, sure!
I understand the appeal of homeschooling your children however, I feel like the experience of going to school and being amongst other kids their own age is also very important.
I only know 3 adults from families that homeschooled and they all have significant social difficulties and trouble maintaining adult relationships and holding down jobs. It's a small sample size but concerns me.
Load More Replies...Having read the update lol most don’t ! I saw the different beliefs so from that it screams she’s one of the bloody god squad lunatics ! N the insistence on homeschooling is typical of Jw,s 🤦♀️they are bat shite crazy , those poor 8 kids lives are over before it starts , their schooling will literally only be on what the lunatic mother thinks they will learn , their schooling rest isn’t even taken in to account ! the cps needs to go around there and have those poor kids assessed , for their ages , cos the mother is not a teacher , she just wants to control each n ever one of those kids ! the ytas are as per trolls , NO is a complete sentence end of job done , as lots suggested a cease n desist letter with the very real threat of court should they continue , the mother needs to wind her neck in n do what’s right for her kids ie proper school !! blessed be op keep us updated plz x
In the states the problem is mostly the fun dame the fundamentalists who won't teach kids science.
Load More Replies...She should tell her lawyer to up the ante, get an order. If the lawyer advises against, get another lawyer.
Keep wasting money until a lawyer says yes? I can see where the things until now haven't gone far enough for the law to take legal action. Sometimes you have to wait for an action or a direct threat before anyone can do anything, including lawyers.
Load More Replies...They just want the education support money for the two kids, it's obvious ex and his wife don't care about what the kids want or what's best for them. I'm a huge supporter of homeschooling, but they aren't offering to do any of the things that make it successful, they just want extra cash.
Those YTAs are mind-numbingly stupid. She's clearly on the page to vent because of the relentlessness of her ex and his wife regarding the even more mind-numbingly stupid idea of homeschooling. I'm not saying homeschooling never works out well, but if it does, it's closer to the exception than the norm. Given the campaign put on by the ex and his wife, I wonder if they would qualify for harassment charges (I have absolutely no idea if they would, but it's something that I would look into if I were in the same position).
Have your lawyer draft a request that all parental communication with you be through an app or through the lawyer himself, and NO communication on any parenting issue be filtered through the kids. Get a judge to sign off on it if you can, or just have the letter delivered to their lawyer. At least that might give you a bit of peace as well as full documentation for future use.
OP clearly stated that this isn't sufficient for him to lose custody. What he will lose is the goodwill of his own children as it goes against their own wishes. Children aren't daft, they'll see all he's really trying to do is keep his new partner sweet rather than putting his children's own needs and preferences first.
Load More Replies...Kids should have more rights than just to be a play toy for their parents. Disillusionment is not good enough. That could be because they don't teach creation myths. Disillusionment is doing a lot of work in your paragraph. Kids deserve an education.
Load More Replies...


































49
67