Woman Declares War On Noisy Toddler, Calls CPS, Loses Everything But Her Own Echoing Silence

When you live in an apartment building, there are bound to be some clashes with your neighbors, be it over parking, trash disposal, or, as was the case for Reddit user Osoimopt, noise.

A family moved in above the woman, and she claimed she tried to be understanding at first, but the child’s tantrums had become so loud and frequent that she could no longer work.

Not knowing what to do, the Redditor called the authorities to investigate. However, she told the “Am I the [Jerk]?” community that it only made things worse, and now she is unsure if it was even the right move. So, she wants them to help her make sense of the situation.

This woman said she could no longer work from home because her neighbor’s toddler was having too many tantrums

A toddler crying with tears, expressing a tantrum in a blue polka dot outfit.

Image credits: yanadjana / envato (not the actual photo)

However, it sounds like neither the police nor child protective services thought her concerns were reasonable

Text discussing neighbor calling CPS due to toddler's tantrums in a new apartment setting.

Text about a mom explaining her toddler's tantrums, sharing contact info for noise concerns.

Text expressing frustration about a toddler's tantrums disturbing remote work.

Text about complaints regarding a child's tantrums and the disturbance caused, involving apartment management.

Officer talking to a woman outdoors, related to CPS call over toddler tantrums.

Image credits: Kindel Media / pexels (not the actual photo)

Text discussing a report made to CPS on a mother due to her toddler's frequent tantrums.

Text about a woman facing backlash for calling CPS on a mom due to toddler tantrums, involving a heated argument.

Text message about a breakup over calling CPS on a mom due to toddler tantrums.

Image credits: osoimopt

Vicki Broadbent of Honest Mum thinks the woman has been completely unreasonable

Image credits: Honest Mum

We showed this story to our parenting expert Vicki Broadbent and asked her to tell us more about temper tantrums.

Vicki Broadbent, who is a writer, director, broadcaster, and founder of the family blog Honest Mum, has three kids of her own, so she knows all about them.

“It is normal, common, and formative behavior for toddlers and young children to have tantrums,” Broadbent told Bored Panda. “They cannot regulate their emotions and tantruming is a way of expressing themselves.”

Temper tantrums range from whining and crying to screaming, kicking, hitting, and breath-holding. They’re equally common among boys and girls and usually happen between the ages of 1 to 3.

The specifics depend on the child: some kids may have tantrums often, and others have them rarely, but generally, tantrums are common during the second year of life (when language skills are developing) because toddlers can’t always say what they want or need—and because words describing feelings are more complicated and will develop later, a frustrating experience may cause a tantrum. But, as language skills improve, tantrums tend to decrease.

“Whilst parents can comfort and distract the child, they are not magicians and cannot stop tantrums nor should they want to,” Vicki Broadbent, author of The Working Mom: Your Guide to Surviving and Thriving at Work and at Home, said. “Tantrums communicate pain or frustration at being unable to do something, hunger, thirst, and overtiredness, so we as parents can respond to their cues. The neighbor should wear noise-cancelling headphones or consider moving to a remote island where birds, animals, and humans won’t bother her! Not sure where that is though!”

Neighbors usually resolve their conflicts without involving the authorities

Image credits: Gabriel Ponton / unsplash (not the actual photo)

Research shows that when neighbor vs. neighbor conflicts arise, people:

• Discussed issues personally with their neighbor 49%;
• Called police 27%;
• Notified the neighborhood or owners association 15%;
• Sent a letter, note, or email 11%;
• Went to court 4%;
• Went to mediation 4%;
• Took another action 4%;
• Took no action 14%

While the Redditor said she did try to talk to the mother, it’s unclear how far their conversations progressed.

Sasha Philip, who practiced civil litigation before becoming a certified professional mediator and arbitrator, highlights that taking calm, measured steps to resolve conflicts with your neighbors can lead to greater understanding and harmony on the block.

And it’s amazing how effective words can be. “I’ve had neighbors who’ve contacted me and said, you know, I thought my neighbor was trying to [exterminate] my tree. And then we had a conversation in mediation, and now we can walk to each other’s houses and ask for a cup of sugar. And oh, my goodness, those are the moments that you live for as a mediator … And they happen. They happen, and it’s not that uncommon,” Philip explains.

That is also reflected in the numbers. Usually, people find common ground with their neighbors because when there’s a conflict, it:

• Is mutually settled 40%;
• Resolves itself 35% (neighbor moved, behavior stopped, etc.);
• Is solved by an outside party 11% (police, court, association, etc.);
• Remains unresolved 14%.

At the end of the day, “parents must understand they should not feel guilt nor shame if their children tantrum, especially in public,” Vicki Broadbent said. “If others punish you with judgemental looks or comments, ignore or smile politely, not letting them bother you. Most often those judgmental strangers simply cannot remember their own children tantruming or themselves doing so.”

“Sometimes no amount of comfort can help to ease a child’s tantrums and they simply need to shout it out until they calm down. Often distracting them with a game, book, or toy is a great way to help them forget whatever it is they’re upset about,” the mom added.

“As they become older, you can explain to them in more detail why they can’t have X or Y, or that they need to eat or sleep. Practising mindful exercises like deep breathing from a young age can help them learn to self-soothe.”

“Please remember, however, that children cannot reason until the age of 5-7, depending on the individual!” the Vicki highlighted.

People have been saying the woman was way out of line

Reddit comment discussing toddler tantrums, autism, and parenting challenges related to CPS involvement.

Comment criticizing a woman for involving CPS because a toddler throws tantrums.

Comment criticizing using CPS for toddler tantrums, stating "3-4 tantrums a day is nothing for a toddler lmao, YTA.

Reddit comment criticizing a woman for calling CPS about toddler tantrums; suggests alternative coping methods.

Reddit comment criticizing a woman for calling CPS over a toddler's tantrums.

Comment criticizing a woman for calling CPS over a toddler's tantrums, stating crying isn't evidence of neglect.

Online comment criticizing a woman for contacting CPS over toddler tantrums.

Text comment criticizing someone for calling CPS due to a toddler's tantrums.

Reddit comment criticizing a woman for calling CPS due to toddler tantrums, suggesting the action was extreme.

Comment criticizing a woman for calling CPS on a mom due to toddler tantrums, suggesting she is wrong.

Text response criticizing a woman's decision to call CPS over toddler tantrums.

Text post criticizing someone for calling CPS over toddler tantrums, suggesting noise-canceling headphones instead.

Text screenshot discussing a woman calling CPS over toddler tantrums and facing criticism.

Comment criticizes a woman for calling CPS on a mom over toddler tantrums, labeling the action as unjustified neglect.

Text response criticizing a woman for calling CPS over toddler tantrums, emphasizing misuse of resources.

Text conversation humorously describing toddler tantrums; mentions calling CPS over toddler behavior.

Comment criticizing a person for calling CPS on a mom due to toddler tantrums.

Text post justifying calling CPS about toddler tantrums and child's welfare.

Reddit comment discussing calling CPS on a mom due to a toddler's tantrums and concerns for child welfare.

Reddit comment discussing calling CPS due to a toddler's tantrums, questioning if it was necessary or child abuse.

Reddit comment criticizing a woman for involving CPS over a toddler's tantrums.

Text in image discussing opinions on calling CPS due to toddler tantrums.

Text discussing opinions on mental health impact from a woman's decision to call CPS on a mom due to toddler tantrums.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!