“They Are No Longer Welcome”: Woman Treated Like A Maid In Her Own Home, Puts Her Foot Down
When many of us think about a concept like “boundaries,” we tend to think of abusive partners or overbearing friends. But the first place where we really need to consider drawing lines in the sand is with family. It might be hard or uncomfortable, but nothing can ruin familial relationships than relatives who think they can say and do anything they want.
A woman vented to the internet about her sister and her family who would regularly use her home like a hotel and ignore a large part of her house rules. We reached out to the woman in the story via private message and will update the article when she gets back to us.
Frequent houseguests can very easily overstep their welcome
Image credits: Muffin Creatives (not the actual photo)
A woman wondered what to do about her sister who would visit all the time
Image credits: RDNE Stock project (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Matheus Bertelli (not the actual photo)
Image source: Remote-Caramel7707
People visiting your home can sometimes be too much of a good thing
Image credits: Nicole Michalou (not the actual photo)
An overstaying houseguest is in many ways a bit of a nightmare. After all, you generally wouldn’t let a stranger stay with you, so most of the time, houseguests are friends and family. On paper, this might seem like it’s wonderful, having people you love around is generally the recipe for a good time.
Similarly, it’s also a good feeling to be able to host people and be useful. But just like visiting your parents for Christmas, after a few days, you start to really remember why living alone is not just a benefit, but a necessity. “My house, my rules” might sound so strict and draconian as a child, but when you’ve grown up, you get it.
For example, in this story, the sister and her family walk all over the hostesses’ house rules. Perhaps they don’t take them seriously, or they have decided that, c’mon, we’re family! It’s true that we do tend to extend more grace to our family, but, conversely, this also means that they might behave in ways that would get anyone else kicked out. Sometimes, family simply expects their relatives to always go above and beyond, for free, no less and can’t understand that it’s sometimes too much.
This is a question that has vexed hosts for a long time. You could give them a stern lecture and just kick them out. That would probably work, but it would probably come at the cost of ending this relationship. Unfortunately, the sort of guests who are emotionally aware enough to not take it personally will probably not overstay their welcome in the first place.
Boundaries are necessary for any healthy relationship to last
Image credits: Alex Green (not the actual photo)
Some folks suggest always being clear about time frames before the guests even arrive. However, the unfortunate truth is that if your family doesn’t understand boundaries, then your timeframes are more of a suggestion than a rule. While it might seem a bit harsh, ultimately, it’s better in any relationship if all parties involved understand what lines should not be touched.
Because of the framing of this story, it’s already clear this woman might have some issues here. She is legitimately asking if she is overreacting to wanting to enforce rules in her own home. On top of that, her guests were a negative influence on her child and pulled a “prank” that was downright cruel and horrible. Often it’s one’s in-laws that tend to be more unreasonable, not your siblings.
Boundaries are also important here because she has a pretty significant reason to keep her family in her life. Her kids like them and family is still family. That being said, it’s no reason to be a slob, particularly in someone else’s home. The woman needs to set rules and be willing to enforce them. As hard as this might be with family, it’s ultimately good to do in the long run, for everyone’s sanity.
This might cause the aforementioned “drama,” but it’s worth considering this situation from another perspective. If the sister is willing to cut ties over rules like “don’t make a mess,” it’s then worth considering if this relationship has any value at all. Your family doesn’t owe you anything just for existing, and that’s even more true when it comes to siblings.
Readers did their best to console the woman in the comments
Most people thought she was not at all overreacting
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
The prank was straight out of the bully’s handbook including the part where the sister said she was making it awkward. She should have told the sister that she hasn’t seen awkward yet but she’s going to.
Exactly. In what universe would that be funny??. My late husband liked to prank me, though never like that. I used to say, "How many of us are laughing?"
Load More Replies...I always say good hospitality is built upon good guests... actually I say good customer service involves knowing how to be a good customer, but I think it translates...
Sorry Family imposition is not Customer service ! Customer service is for people paying ! they get a free ride .
Load More Replies...The reason many cultures are like this, when it comes to welcoming family into their homes, is because on the flip side, everyone was taught to respect the other person’s home, be grateful for the hospitality, and just how to behave when allowed out of your cage—-and expected to behave accordingly, ffs! That’s what’s missing here, and it’s the parents who failed. Obviously OP’s/Sister’s and BIL’s parents taught them about family hospitality, but failed to teach them how to act when benefitting from it. Two sides to the coin when it comes to traditions, the proper way to give them and the proper way to receive them.
I found a quote here on BP a while back- “people will continue to suck the life out of you as long as you keep giving them a straw” or something along those lines.
Wet towels on the bed? Show them the washing machine. 45 minute showers? Like, what the heck do you do in a shower for 45 minutes?? Show them the water bill and tell them that EVERYONE ELSE needs a shower, too. They show up late for events? Oh well. Sorry they missed it.
I'vw done 45 minute showers, but it's MY water, so I'm allowed. someone else's water, I'm in and out 15 minutes tops.
Load More Replies...I can seldom stand anyone for more than two hours, not two days and they can stay in a motel, not my home.
or me lol the biliss of not having family other than myself and my two kids as live at home but work so i get peace that would literally kill me
Load More Replies...AFAIK, in cultures where hospitality for family is expected, there is also the expecation on the guest to be respectful, help out where they can, and generally not behave like the hosts are their maids. In other words: Sister and BIL should cook and clean! They also should be on time.
Anyone asking is this how you treat your family only deserves to have that question flipped back to them. If I'm supposed to help my family then my family should also be helping me, so if I'm letting my family stay my family can help around the house or at the very least not make my daily routine unmanageable. You need to have respect to get respect, if you're incapable of respecting others you're undeserving of respect yourself. So if I'm going to respect your wishes to stay here you're going to respect my wishes to stay here, which means you are welcome in my house as long as you treat me and my house in such a way that I will continue to welcome you here, if I begin to feel unwelcome in my own home due to your behavior you'll be leaving my home. Treat me like family, not like you're entitled because we're family but the way you're expecting me to treat you because we're family - the door swings both ways or it only swings one way as you leave.
Yikes. With the update, this story is so much more complicated than the surface story. Immigrant siblings struggling with the norms of their new world. Kudos to OP for adapting to her responsibilities and environment. A smack upside the head for the visiting sibling who takes advantage of OP's hospitality, rude AF. The darn thing is that the second OP says no in anyway or even request shorter stays, mommy and daddy dearest back home will be chewing her head off for not being a good sibling. Old rules in new world don't work.
At which point OP should grey-rock her parents and remind them that this is HER house; hence, HER rules. Unless they're going to come and rent an Airbnb for their entitled child and family, they should respect that. Being fa-a-a-a-mily in no way entitles you to disrespect someone's abode, and/or the hosts. The next time Sister and fa-a-a-a-mily come to town, a list of local (but not TOO local) hotels and a brief message expressing regret(😈) for being unable to host them now and hereafter should shut all of that nonsense down.
Load More Replies...they would have done this only one time and then would never set foot on my property let alone my house again. Sad that OP had to put up with such douchebags for so long. familiy is no right to be an a*****e or wannabe prankster..
Oh my ... only on company's dime and in a hotel, have I ever showered 45 minutes or even longer. Actually, 3 hours, I did. But ... on company's dime. For having to live Mo-Fr somewhere I know nothing and no one and don't really want to be, I might run out of stomach capacity to eat (or rather downstream thereof, but effectively identical - I just can't waste hours on eating at a time anymore), might tire my hands playing guitar, and still be too awake to sleep, but have hours of the day left. And, I'd never do that at my sister's. Anyway, tell them very firm a set of basic rules they have to accept to be accepted over, and if they don't feel able to do so, ... your house, your rules. They have theirs, there they can shower 24 hours a day and fill every shelf with dirty laundry or plates or whatever...
What were you doing for three hours? How does a shower take that long?? 🤯
Load More Replies...Pretty straight forward , simply leave the place the way they left it which mean they would have to redo the bed , wash the laundry and so on , oh and barrely any food or drink in the fridge , they will change their habits pretty fast . Unless you enjoy being abused .
That prank would have been the last straw. Do not keep expecting a better outcome. 'No' is a complete sentence. You do not need to explain yourself. They need to go to a hotel.
A prank/joke is only such if Everyone laughs 😃 these entitled jerks would Never be welcome overnight ever again. Culturally, I understand that's hard for you and that's OK. But, please do grow a nice, shiny Western backbone. People like these are the reason hotels close by exist.
that so called prank was despicable cruel as far from funny as anyone can get hes well tbh id never let him in my house or my life they dont respect you and your family so yup as lots said hand em lists of places they can stay like 5 miles plus away your home is your castle their issue its called decisions n consequences thwy make the decision to be rude messy disrespectful they pay the consequences end off
I think op needs to tell them all no. Just be done with having guests over at all. She says relatives have stayed with her for years. Then she is in danger every time one of them is a guest that they just wont leave. They could set up shop and stay for an undetermined length of time. That is not ok. Just say no to toxic family. Make-up a reason and keep them out of your house. Oh and btw if any of them do move in with your permission you need to charge rent.
It's time for you to leave, right now not tomorrow. This has not been a good experience. I mean it. Now.
The prank was straight out of the bully’s handbook including the part where the sister said she was making it awkward. She should have told the sister that she hasn’t seen awkward yet but she’s going to.
Exactly. In what universe would that be funny??. My late husband liked to prank me, though never like that. I used to say, "How many of us are laughing?"
Load More Replies...I always say good hospitality is built upon good guests... actually I say good customer service involves knowing how to be a good customer, but I think it translates...
Sorry Family imposition is not Customer service ! Customer service is for people paying ! they get a free ride .
Load More Replies...The reason many cultures are like this, when it comes to welcoming family into their homes, is because on the flip side, everyone was taught to respect the other person’s home, be grateful for the hospitality, and just how to behave when allowed out of your cage—-and expected to behave accordingly, ffs! That’s what’s missing here, and it’s the parents who failed. Obviously OP’s/Sister’s and BIL’s parents taught them about family hospitality, but failed to teach them how to act when benefitting from it. Two sides to the coin when it comes to traditions, the proper way to give them and the proper way to receive them.
I found a quote here on BP a while back- “people will continue to suck the life out of you as long as you keep giving them a straw” or something along those lines.
Wet towels on the bed? Show them the washing machine. 45 minute showers? Like, what the heck do you do in a shower for 45 minutes?? Show them the water bill and tell them that EVERYONE ELSE needs a shower, too. They show up late for events? Oh well. Sorry they missed it.
I'vw done 45 minute showers, but it's MY water, so I'm allowed. someone else's water, I'm in and out 15 minutes tops.
Load More Replies...I can seldom stand anyone for more than two hours, not two days and they can stay in a motel, not my home.
or me lol the biliss of not having family other than myself and my two kids as live at home but work so i get peace that would literally kill me
Load More Replies...AFAIK, in cultures where hospitality for family is expected, there is also the expecation on the guest to be respectful, help out where they can, and generally not behave like the hosts are their maids. In other words: Sister and BIL should cook and clean! They also should be on time.
Anyone asking is this how you treat your family only deserves to have that question flipped back to them. If I'm supposed to help my family then my family should also be helping me, so if I'm letting my family stay my family can help around the house or at the very least not make my daily routine unmanageable. You need to have respect to get respect, if you're incapable of respecting others you're undeserving of respect yourself. So if I'm going to respect your wishes to stay here you're going to respect my wishes to stay here, which means you are welcome in my house as long as you treat me and my house in such a way that I will continue to welcome you here, if I begin to feel unwelcome in my own home due to your behavior you'll be leaving my home. Treat me like family, not like you're entitled because we're family but the way you're expecting me to treat you because we're family - the door swings both ways or it only swings one way as you leave.
Yikes. With the update, this story is so much more complicated than the surface story. Immigrant siblings struggling with the norms of their new world. Kudos to OP for adapting to her responsibilities and environment. A smack upside the head for the visiting sibling who takes advantage of OP's hospitality, rude AF. The darn thing is that the second OP says no in anyway or even request shorter stays, mommy and daddy dearest back home will be chewing her head off for not being a good sibling. Old rules in new world don't work.
At which point OP should grey-rock her parents and remind them that this is HER house; hence, HER rules. Unless they're going to come and rent an Airbnb for their entitled child and family, they should respect that. Being fa-a-a-a-mily in no way entitles you to disrespect someone's abode, and/or the hosts. The next time Sister and fa-a-a-a-mily come to town, a list of local (but not TOO local) hotels and a brief message expressing regret(😈) for being unable to host them now and hereafter should shut all of that nonsense down.
Load More Replies...they would have done this only one time and then would never set foot on my property let alone my house again. Sad that OP had to put up with such douchebags for so long. familiy is no right to be an a*****e or wannabe prankster..
Oh my ... only on company's dime and in a hotel, have I ever showered 45 minutes or even longer. Actually, 3 hours, I did. But ... on company's dime. For having to live Mo-Fr somewhere I know nothing and no one and don't really want to be, I might run out of stomach capacity to eat (or rather downstream thereof, but effectively identical - I just can't waste hours on eating at a time anymore), might tire my hands playing guitar, and still be too awake to sleep, but have hours of the day left. And, I'd never do that at my sister's. Anyway, tell them very firm a set of basic rules they have to accept to be accepted over, and if they don't feel able to do so, ... your house, your rules. They have theirs, there they can shower 24 hours a day and fill every shelf with dirty laundry or plates or whatever...
What were you doing for three hours? How does a shower take that long?? 🤯
Load More Replies...Pretty straight forward , simply leave the place the way they left it which mean they would have to redo the bed , wash the laundry and so on , oh and barrely any food or drink in the fridge , they will change their habits pretty fast . Unless you enjoy being abused .
That prank would have been the last straw. Do not keep expecting a better outcome. 'No' is a complete sentence. You do not need to explain yourself. They need to go to a hotel.
A prank/joke is only such if Everyone laughs 😃 these entitled jerks would Never be welcome overnight ever again. Culturally, I understand that's hard for you and that's OK. But, please do grow a nice, shiny Western backbone. People like these are the reason hotels close by exist.
that so called prank was despicable cruel as far from funny as anyone can get hes well tbh id never let him in my house or my life they dont respect you and your family so yup as lots said hand em lists of places they can stay like 5 miles plus away your home is your castle their issue its called decisions n consequences thwy make the decision to be rude messy disrespectful they pay the consequences end off
I think op needs to tell them all no. Just be done with having guests over at all. She says relatives have stayed with her for years. Then she is in danger every time one of them is a guest that they just wont leave. They could set up shop and stay for an undetermined length of time. That is not ok. Just say no to toxic family. Make-up a reason and keep them out of your house. Oh and btw if any of them do move in with your permission you need to charge rent.
It's time for you to leave, right now not tomorrow. This has not been a good experience. I mean it. Now.











































49
33