Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
“Not Really A Showgirl”: Disappointed Fans Say Taylor Swift’s New Album Doesn’t Live Up To Expectations
The recently engaged Taylor Swift has dropped her latest album, TheLife of a Showgirl,drawing a slew of negative publicity, with some suggesting it was a rush job.
The backlash came from fans and news outlets alike, with some observing that, unlike her 2024 instalment with 31 tracks, the latest edition only has 12.
Along with the latter, another fan has called it “completely incompatible with the showgirl aesthetic” she is “trying to sell.”
Highlights
- Outlet dubs Swift’s new album “rarely brilliant” and “downright forgettable.”
- Fans say the 12-track album doesn’t fit the “showgirl aesthetic.”
- 50 Cent reacts with glee after hearing his name dropped in one of the songs.
RELATED:
One critic thinks the shorter, less impressive album is due to her “tiring” Eras tour
Image credits: Taylor Swift/Mert Alas/Marcus Piggott
One of the front-runners in the campaign of dissent is Spain’s El País outlet, which dropped a stinging review on the day of the release (October 3).
It described the instalment as a “hesitant, conservative proposal, sometimes following in the wake of her pupils (Olivia Rodrigo and Sabrina Carpenter).”
It went on to dub the 12-track compilation as “rarely brilliant” and, towards the end, “downright forgettable.”
Image credits: Taylor Swift/Mert Alas/Marcus Piggott
“If we add the fact that Swift barely writes lyrically from the perspective of the aggrieved and vengeful ex-girlfriend that we’ve enjoyed so much in the past,” the thrashing continued, “what we’re left with is a transitional album made hastily.”
Critic Carlos Marcos credited this result to her tiring though successful Eras tour.
Another feels Taylor Swift is selling a persona that is not her
Image credits: Taylor Swift/Mert Alas/Marcus Piggott
This view was mirrored on social media when one person wrote:
“Finished listening to The Life of a Showgirl […]- the most confusing part about this album is that sonically it’s completely incompatible with the showgirl/burlesque/cabaret aesthetic it is trying to sell…”
“It has two mildly interesting songs, but for the most part it’s just the same tired, generic pop from her previous two albums, with mostly forgettable toplines and her corny lyrics and flat delivery,” echoed another.
finished listening to The Life of a Showgirl leaks- the most confusing part about this album is that sonically it’s completely incompatible with the showgirl/burlesque/cabaret aesthetic it is trying to sell… pic.twitter.com/sBtSyxTjD5
— petal (@ctrlpetal) October 2, 2025
One commenter found Swift’s lyrics to be selling the bad-girl persona when, in reality, she was the poster girl for a high school goody-two-shoes.
Blake Lively and 50 Cent have since weighed in on the album
Image credits: Taylor Swift/Mert Alas/Marcus Piggott
Notably, The Life of a Showgirl appears to have drawn a more positive reaction from other A-listers.
Blake Lively, for example, appears to have overlooked the chasm in their relationship stemming from her PR war with former co-star Justin Baldoni, and liked Swift’s post announcing her new album’s release.
Image credits: Taylor Swift/Mert Alas/Marcus Piggott
Praise came from another, unsuspecting corner in the form of 50 Cent, but it was not without encouragement.
In one of her tracks, Ruin the Friendship, Swift sings, “And it was not an invitation/ But as the 50 Cеnt song played/ Should’ve kissed you anyway.”
50 Cent appeared thrilled by the fact that Taylor Swift mentioned him in one of her songs
@extendedcl1ps♬ original sound – Extended Clips
Reacting with a post of the album’s cover art, the In Da Club rapper wrote:
Taylor Swift “is popping right now, she shout me out, she don’t shout you out. LOL, THIS IS FOR BIG TIMERS ONLY!”
“Wait, I’m the only shout out on the whole album?” he concluded.
It is not the first time the rapper has endorsed her
Image credits: Taylor Swift/Mert Alas/Marcus Piggott
It is not the first time the rapper appeared to have positioned himself in Swift’s corner.
At the 2009 MTV Video Music Awards, Kanye West chipped in during Taylor Swift’s acceptance speech for Best Female Video.
He grabbed the microphone and said, “Yo, Taylor, I’m really happy for you, I’ma let you finish, but Beyoncé had one of the best videos of all time!”
He once threatened to give Kanye West a black eye over her
Image credits: ctrlpetal
Speaking on an interactive TV show around the time, 50 Cent lashed out at West in absentia, saying:
“I wish he would come take one of my awards so I could black his eye in front of everybody.”
“Even an apology can’t replace what it feels like for the very first time receiving that award. In Taylor Swift‘s head, ‘My first award was Kanye West.’ It’s damaging,” he said, empathizing with the actress.
Now, netizens are saying that Ruin the Friendship is the only song worth listening to
Image credits: ERASERGAY
It appears that Ruin the Friendship is one of the tracks on the disputed album that netizens are happy with.
One commenter said as much and sandwiched in criticism when they wrote:
“It felt like every song was meant for a different album. Ruin the Friendship is the only one that’s worth listening to, imo.”
Netizens think Taylor Swift is the furthest thing from a showgirl
Image credits: qxeenbey4
Image credits: julie_mo
Image credits: SendInTheGuard
Image credits: VillageLeaders
Image credits: jaye_anthony
Image credits: crulue
Image credits: Meli98893817
Image credits: Fly_kid0
Image credits: subwaydrei
Image credits: izzyb33z
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
Explore more of these tags
What do you think ?
WonderWoman 2 months ago
BoredPanda LOVES to TEAR FAMOUS PEOPLE DOWN!!! This site is becoming the National Enquirer and it is so sad they have chosen to do this. BP is constantly tearing celebrities down, especially the women, they all have had work done or cheated their way to being thin, or don't meet standards. They LOVE to HATE.
WonderWoman 2 months ago
BoredPanda LOVES to TEAR FAMOUS PEOPLE DOWN!!! This site is becoming the National Enquirer and it is so sad they have chosen to do this. BP is constantly tearing celebrities down, especially the women, they all have had work done or cheated their way to being thin, or don't meet standards. They LOVE to HATE.
You May Like "What Happened?": Bradley Cooper's Radical Makeover Has Fans Saying He Looks Like Barry Manilow “‘Genes’ Are Fine!”: Michelle Obama’s Casual Look With Ultra-Long Hair Is Breaking The Internet “We Don’t Talk About That”: Glen Powell’s Viral Blunder During Interview Might Expose Dark Side Of Hollywood
Lei RV
Lei RV
Gabija Saveiskyte
Related on Bored Panda
-6
7