“Cringy”: Viral Dawson’s Creek Scene Sparks Debate After James Van Der Beek’s Passing

Following actor James Van Der Beek‘s demise, a heated debate unfolded on social media as fans revisited his performance in the iconic teen drama Dawson’s Creek.

The 48-year-old actor passed away on Wednesday, February 11, 2026, after a long battle with cancer. Hours later, a clip from the show resurfaced on X and garnered 800k views as fans reflected on his most memorable role. 

“His legacy will always be remembered,” one fan wrote. 

Fans revisit James Van Der Beek’s highly memed Dawson’s Creek scene

Young man from Dawson's Creek in a viral cringy scene sparking online debate after James Van Der Beek's passing

Image credits: Sony Pictures Television

Van Der Beek was best known for playing Dawson Leery in the series, which ran from 1998 to 2003. In the third-season episode, True Love, originally aired on May 24, 2000, Dawson tearfully parted ways with longtime friend and love interest, Joey. 

The scene, which became the source of the “Crying Dawson” meme, ignited mixed feelings over two decades later. While some viewed it as a part of his legacy, others were unimpressed with Van Der Beek’s performance. 

“Honestly, I always thought that they should have redone that since his crying was cringy,” one user wrote. 

Another commented, “Christ, we watched some absolute sh*t growing up, didn’t we?”

One of the most iconic scenes in Dawson’s Creek is when Dawson lets Joey go.
A moment that also spawned James Van Der Beek’s legendary crying face meme. His legacy will always be remembered 💔… pic.twitter.com/5NakQO9Sja

— ScenesThatSlap (@scenesthatslap) February 11, 2026

On the other hand, some fans found the moment “heartbreaking” and “relatable,” while several could not help but join Dawson in shedding tears because of their affection for the show and its deceased star.

“This scene is the defining moment of my TV-watching childhood. RIP James,” a viewer shared.

James Van Der Beek made an honest confession about the crying scene

Four Dawson's Creek cast members sitting on a wooden dock by the water in a viral cringy scene discussion.

Image credits: Getty Images

Van Der Beek was aware of the infamous crying scene’s memefication and opened up about its origins in a 2012 interview with HuffPost.

He revealed that the now-memorable moment was completely unscripted. Since he had been “living with this character for a while,” he could not help but react emotionally to the scene’s high-voltage drama. 

“I remember being completely surprised by it because it was completely sincere,” he said. 

He also did not mind netizens using the scene to poke fun at him, seeing the humorous side of his six-year stint on the show boiled down to a four-second clip. 

“From the minute I became aware of it, it just cracked me up,” he added. 

26 years later, Dawson’s Creek’s love triangle still has fans divided 

Man with shoulder-length hair and beard holds baby wrapped in blanket, linked to cringy viral Dawson's Creek scene debate.

Image credits: vanderjames

The infamous meme aside, revisiting the scene triggered unresolved emotions in fans who are still not over the love triangle between Dawson, Joey, and Pacey. 

The episode saw Dawson finally coming to terms with Joey having feelings for Pacey as he encouraged her to pursue them. Twenty-six years later, the resolution to their overarching romantic subplot continues to receive divisive reactions. 

“I always hated this, though. She’s not property, she didn’t need his permission,” one user said. 

A second wrote, “After all the years she wanted him, and she ends up choosing the other one. I totally did not like that they did that.” 

“They might as well have ended the series atp for me cause I couldn’t stand her and pacey,” a third commented. 

James Van Der Beek and Katie Holmes at an event, linked to viral Dawson's Creek scene sparking debate after passing.

Image credits: Jim Spellman/Getty Images

Despite the fate of their characters, actress Katie Holmes, who played Joey, paid tribute to her late co-star through a handwritten letter posted on Instagram.

“I am so grateful to have shared in a piece of James’ journey. He is beloved,” she wrote. 

Van Der Beek was diagnosed with stage 3 colorectal cancer in 2023. He is survived by his family, including his wife, Kimberly Brook, and their six children. 

Dawson’s Creek is currently available to watch on Tubi and Hulu. 

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!