“I Kissed My Brother And Now My Fiancé Wants To Break Up With Me Since He Finds It Weird”
Siblings are often the closest family members a person can have and also buddies who can stick by them during tough times. That’s why most folks are completely fine showing affection to their brothers and sisters, but some people find that very weird.
This is why a woman’s engagement got called off as her jealous fiancé got mad that she had been consoling her brother and kissed him on the cheek. This shocked the woman because she didn’t think she had done anything inappropriate, but her partner clearly thought otherwise.
More info: Reddit
Some people have physical touch as their love language, whereas other folks reserve this kind of behavior only for romantic relationships
Image credits: garetsvisual / Magnific (not the actual photo)
The poster shared that she and her younger brother had always been close and that she hugged and cuddled him to show affection, which her fiancé seemed to find a bit much
Image credits: New Africa / Magnific (not the actual photo)
On her mom’s birthday, when she went to visit her family, her brother ended up crying in front of her, and to console him, she gave him a hug and a peck on the cheek
Image credits: TriangleProd / Magnific (not the actual photo)
When her fiancé saw her with her brother, he told her it was the last nail in the coffin, and that since she seemed to be having an “affair” with her sibling, he wanted to break up
Image credits: Character-Crow309
The man’s mother tried to justify his disapproval by saying he was an only child, but the poster felt confused because she didn’t know if her behavior with her brother was actually inappropriate
The poster shared that because her father was toxic and eventually separated from her mother, she and her younger brother had always been close and she had tried to protect him. She thought of her 17-year-old sibling as her baby and always cuddled and hugged him as much as possible.
According to a survey, most folks feel that showing affection is normal for siblings and that there’s nothing inappropriate about it. Some brothers and sisters might not be okay with physical touch, but those who are can definitely show love for each other that way without it being considered weird.
Unfortunately, it seemed the poster’s fiancé found her relationship with her brother a bit extreme, which is why he kept making odd remarks whenever she showed him affection. He also didn’t seem to like how close she was with her sibling and gave her the side-eye when her younger brother asked to speak to her alone one day.
Some people might feel insecure or jealous when their partner is close with someone else, and professionals explain that this may stem from low self-esteem or a lack of confidence. These people may not be able to put their feelings into words, and might instead react strongly to their partner’s other relationships.
Image credits: beststudio / Magnific (not the actual photo)
When the poster’s fiancé saw her consoling her younger brother and giving him a peck on the cheek, he lost his mind. He accused her of having an affair with her sibling, and said that it was extremely gross of her to do such things. This obviously upset the woman a lot because she didn’t think showing her brother love was wrong at all.
Unfortunately, because the man wasn’t listening to what she had to say, she couldn’t explain to him that her affection for her sibling wasn’t sinister. She was also shocked when he called off their engagement, and his mom tried to explain away his reaction by saying that it was because he’s an only child.
Although single kids have always gotten a bad rap, mental health experts explain that the stereotypes about them aren’t always true. It’s possible that some only children struggle with insecurity or jealousy if their partner is close with other people, but this kind of behavior can be worked on and improved.
Since the poster’s ex-fiancé wasn’t willing to repair their relationship or listen to her side, she didn’t know what else to do. She also cared deeply about her brother, but didn’t know whether her affection toward him was inappropriate, which left her in quite a fix.
What do you think about these sibling dynamics, and do you agree with the man? Do share your thoughts in the comments below.
People were shocked by the man’s behavior and felt that he was completely out of line for taking issue over a normal sibling relationship
Dealing with relationship or dating drama like this? Visit our Family Dynamics Hub for expert-backed guides on toxic roles, boundaries, and rebuilding trust.Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Explore more of these tags
I’m more saddened by, than angry with, the couple of people saying that “cuddling” your sibling or letting them rest their head in your lap while they cry about something that has hurt them is weird. Appropriate cuddling between friends or family members is purely about comfort, connection, and emotional support. Anon is a selfish twát. Why do I use the word “sibling” instead of “brother”? In what I consider normal sibling relationships, their sèx/gender is essentially irrelevant to you both. There’s a similar age gap between my younger brother and me. He’s in his 50’s, a good foot taller, married, and has several kids, but he’s still my little brother and always will be.
The idea that the only interaction between the sexes is, on it's face, a disgusting one coming from sick minds. Ick.
Load More Replies...I was thinking, what if they have a child together and she breastfeeds it. What if she consoles the child when it's 8 yo and hurt, and kisses him on the cheek. What if the child is 14 and hurt, is she allowed to hug him and kiss him. What if the child is 40 and hurt....is there an age where you stop consoling and hugging people?
I am 74 and my 49 year old son lovingly embrace. There is no s*x extant and I think it reveals more of the minds of those that think it then us normals. Which infuriates them.
Load More Replies...This is how controlling behavior starts. Hope OP dumped the doosh. That's not just *a* red flag - that's the whole dang parade!!!
I’m more saddened by, than angry with, the couple of people saying that “cuddling” your sibling or letting them rest their head in your lap while they cry about something that has hurt them is weird. Appropriate cuddling between friends or family members is purely about comfort, connection, and emotional support. Anon is a selfish twát. Why do I use the word “sibling” instead of “brother”? In what I consider normal sibling relationships, their sèx/gender is essentially irrelevant to you both. There’s a similar age gap between my younger brother and me. He’s in his 50’s, a good foot taller, married, and has several kids, but he’s still my little brother and always will be.
The idea that the only interaction between the sexes is, on it's face, a disgusting one coming from sick minds. Ick.
Load More Replies...I was thinking, what if they have a child together and she breastfeeds it. What if she consoles the child when it's 8 yo and hurt, and kisses him on the cheek. What if the child is 14 and hurt, is she allowed to hug him and kiss him. What if the child is 40 and hurt....is there an age where you stop consoling and hugging people?
I am 74 and my 49 year old son lovingly embrace. There is no s*x extant and I think it reveals more of the minds of those that think it then us normals. Which infuriates them.
Load More Replies...This is how controlling behavior starts. Hope OP dumped the doosh. That's not just *a* red flag - that's the whole dang parade!!!



































55
19