Woman Protects Her Dog From 2.5YO Nephew, Sister Demands An Apology

Some people argue that we don’t deserve dogs. And maybe it’s true. But I’m sure glad we get to share the earth with our furry four-legged companions. If you’re lucky, you get to live with one. If you were even luckier, you might have grown up around one or two. Kids and dogs can become the best of friends for life, provided parents create the right environment and nurture love and respect between them.

One woman was not impressed when she witnessed her nephew hitting the family pet on the head with a coaster. The elderly golden retriever was snoozing on the couch, minding his own business, when it happened. Since the toddler’s parents turned a blind eye, the woman decided to take matters into her own hands. But some netizens believe she should have dealt with it differently. Bored Panda spoke to two experts to get their opinions. One is Lisa Smith, Founder of The Peaceful Parent. The other is Nicole Ellis, a Certified Professional Dog Trainer and Pet Lifestyle Expert with Rover.

Golden retrievers are known as one of the most gentle dog breeds and make great family pets

Toddler standing in a room near a golden retriever, illustrating moments of parenting and disciplining a young child.

Image credits: LightFieldStudios (not the actual photo)

When one person’s nephew hit their sleeping retriever on the head, she didn’t take it lying down

Mom demands apology from sister after disciplining toddler during family visit about parenting boundaries.

Text excerpt describing a mom demanding an apology from sister for disciplining toddler in a family setting.

Text excerpt about a mother disciplining toddler, emphasizing parenting and correcting behavior to protect family members.

Text excerpt showing a mom explaining disciplining a toddler after taking a coaster away, highlighting parenting conflict.

Text excerpt discussing a mom demanding an apology from sister for disciplining toddler, focusing on parenting conflicts.

Text excerpt expressing refusal to apologize for disciplining toddler, highlighting conflict between mom and sister about parenting.

Two women indoors having a tense conversation about parenting and disciplining a toddler at home.

Image credits: Prostock-studio (not the actual photo)

Text message stating conflict about parenting boundaries as mom demands apology from sister for disciplining toddler.

Image source: Mmemm

Many wanted more details, and at one point, the aunt called someone out for false accusations

Screenshot of an online discussion about disciplining and parenting a toddler aged almost three years old.

Conversation about disciplining a toddler and the mom demanding an apology from sister for parenting choices.

Text exchange discussing toddler disciplining with focus on parenting responsibilities and family dynamics in childcare.

Online discussion about disciplining toddler, with mom demanding apology from sister for parenting approach.

Toddlers aren’t aware that hitting a dog is wrong, a parenting expert weighs in

Image credits: Natali Hordiiuk (not the actual photo)

Toddlers are deeply curious creatures exploring cause and effect, parenting expert Lisa Smith tells Bored Panda during our chat. “They’re still building empathy, still learning that others have feelings,” she says. “If they see a dog flinch or yelp, they’re observing—but they don’t yet grasp pain from another’s point of view unless we help connect those dots.”

The founder of The Peaceful Parent says that sometimes it’s play. Sometimes it’s testing boundaries. Sometimes it’s an expression of overwhelm. “That’s why harsh reprimands aren’t effective,” she adds. “They shut down the learning.”

The expert says that she understands why the aunt is protective of the elderly dog. “Seeing a toddler hit the dog would’ve been jarring. But while her intention was to protect, her reaction likely felt scary and shaming to a young child,” said Smith. “Saying ‘how would you like it if I hit you in the face?’ is a phrase that reflects her anger more than her values—and it models exactly the kind of aggression she was trying to discourage. It also places blame before curiosity, which shuts down learning.”

Smith adds that it could have helped more if the aunt had grounded herself first… “Taken one breath, checked her tone—and then gently but firmly intervened. Something like: ‘Hey, sweetie, we don’t hit Lucky. That hurts him. He’s an old dog and needs gentle hands. Followed by showing the child how to pet softly, and then involving them in caring for the dog (e.g. bringing over his water bowl). That would have built empathy instead of fear.”

The expert adds that the aunt’s protectiveness was valid. But her tone and phrasing were misaligned with a toddler’s developmental stage. “So yes, the message needed to be delivered—but it needed to come from a place of calm teaching, not reactivity,” she explained.

A dog trainer and pet lifestyle expert gives their advice when it comes to toddler/dog interactions

Nicole Ellis is a Certified Professional Dog Trainer and Pet Lifestyle Expert with online pet marketplace, Rover. Ellis agrees that toddlers are still learning impulse control and empathy, which is why she says supervision is key. “Interrupt, redirect, and teach gently and consistently,” the expert told Bored Panda during an interview.

Ellis says if you spot your young child pulling a dog’s tail, or hitting them, you should immediately intervene. “Calmly remove the child from the situation—never punish the dog for reacting,” she said. Parents or caregivers should also model gentle interaction. “Say, We use gentle hands with dogs,’ and show how to softly pet the dog,” suggests the trainer.

She adds that it helps to practise with stuffed animals. “Role-play how to treat a dog kindly using toys, and praise the child when they’re gentle,” Ellis advises, adding that you should not blame the child. “Toddlers are exploring, not being malicious. Use this as a teachable moment.”

Finally, the expert advises that you praise the dog. “Reward your dog for remaining calm—but never force them to stay in a situation where they feel uncomfortable,” she said.

Scientists have found that dogs are magic. Just kidding. But here’s what they do say about getting your child a furry friend…

Toddler walking a small dog on a leash outdoors, illustrating parent and child responsibility and discipline concept.

Image credits: Robert Eklund (not the actual photo)

Show me a kid who hasn’t asked for a puppy at least once in their life, and I’ll take that unwanted puppy! I know my own son has begged for a little furball at least five times—this year alone. But because we already have a dog, and I’m not yet ready to raise another baby, adopting a pup will have to wait… That said, I’ll probably cave sooner than I think.

There are major benefits that come with children growing up around animals. And they’re scientifically proven. For example, recent pediatric health studies foundthat kids who live with pets (especially dogs) during their first year of life actually have stronger immune systems than those who do not.

The researchers say that exposure to doggos could have “positively boosted the maturation of their immune system during infancy.” And when these children did get sick, they needed shorter courses of antibiotics than those who lived in “petless” homes.

Another study revealed that dogs can help prevent allergies in children. If the child’s parent suffers from respiratory allergies or asthma, the child is much less likely to develop similar issues if they have a dog in the house. But the experts say early exposure is key—meaning you should get that pup before your kid turns one.

Scientists also say that dogs are magic. Just kidding. But only sort of.

A Medical News Today study found that children in households with a dog had lower stress levels. While another revealed that exposure to dogs early in life could help to stave off childhood eczema. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that “having a pet dog in the home was associated with a decreased probability of childhood anxiety.”

One teacher who took part in a study about classroom pets said, “Having pets is an INVALUABLE aid for helping the children gain pride, caring, and empathy for the needs of themselves and others.”

Smith agrees. “Caring for another life will require your child to become a more compassionate individual,” she told Bored Panda. “Feeding or walking them, at times they may have other things they would rather be doing, will mean that they have to step outside of themselves, and practice being selfless.”

Of course, caring for a pet teaches children life lessons, too. “Accomplishing small tasks (such as filling up their water dish) will help them feel like they are competent and will also give them a sense of accomplishment,” notes the Drake Center for Veterinary Care. And, it teaches them unconditional love.

Practice the “pat, pet, pause” method to keep your kids and pets safe

Toddler playing with a dog outdoors on grass, depicting parenting and child discipline themes in a natural setting.

Image credits: Kateryna Hliznitsova (not the actual photo)

It’s one thing to wax lyrical about the benefits of having a dog around your child. But we can’t ignore the dangers. Like the risk of the child being bitten. Or the dog getting hurt. That’s why experts say it’s important for kids to learn to respect dogs both within and outside of the home.

The single best thing parents can do to improve the safety of dog-child interactions is to read your dog’s body language. That’s according to the Animal Humane Society (AHS).

“Practice this skill with your child by teaching them common dog cues in advance, and verbalizing what you’re seeing during supervised interactions,” reads the site. “You may be surprised to learn that a wagging tail does not equate to happiness, or that a dog staying very still could be indicating extreme discomfort.”

They also advise that you teach kids to ask for permission before engaging—and that includes asking the dog. “We call this pat, pet, pause whereby a child (or adult) pats their leg to invite a dog over for affection, softly pets the dog, then pauses to allow the dog to decide whether they’d like to receive more pets or move on,” explains AHS. 

It’s important to always respect a dog’s boundaries. “Children should never invade a dog’s personal space, sit, lay or climb on a dog, or steal their toys or treats,” warns AHS. “Respect is key, and we want to avoid your dog developing any negative associations with your child (or worse, acting aggressively).”

Integrating supervised playtime between kids and pets can help promote a positive relationship while building trust.

“Does your canine love to play fetch? Show your kid how to roll or throw a ball or toy for your dog,” suggests AHS. “Is your pup food motivated? Help your child toss treats or offer your dog a few licks of peanut butter from a spoon.”

The Society’s experts say the more your dog associates these positive experiences with your child, the more likely their relationship will bloom.

But AHS warns that you should never leave your child unattended with the family dog. “When you’re not able to actively observe their interactions, keep kids and dogs separated with the use of baby gates or room dividers, especially when your kids are young and still learning how to share the same space as their furry friend,” notes the site.

People had mixed reactions, with some warning the situation could have been worse

Comment discussing discipline and responsibility in parenting, mentioning a dog snapping at a child and fault.

Comment text on a forum discussing parenting, with a user supporting disciplining a toddler and opposing apologies.

Comment discussing toddler discipline and a mom demanding an apology from sister about parenting issues.

Commenter discussing discipline and parenting, suggesting the dad should intervene to teach proper behavior to the child.

Text post discussing disciplining toddler and a mom demanding apology from sister about parenting approach.

Comment text on a social media post discussing disciplining a toddler and a mom demanding an apology from her sister.

Commenter explains why disciplining a toddler requires careful words and approaches, highlighting parenting challenges.

Commenter discusses supervising children and concerns about parenting while addressing toddler discipline issues.

Alt text: Mom demands apology from sister after disciplining toddler, sparking debate on parenting and child behavior management.

Comment on a post discussing disciplining toddlers and the importance of parents managing their child's behavior responsibly.

Comment discussing different views on disciplining toddlers and the importance of effective parenting without apology demands.

Comment discussing toddler discipline and the importance of gentle parenting and clear boundaries with children and pets.

Text comment advising to get down to toddler’s level and say we don’t hit, related to disciplining toddler and parenting.

Comment text about disciplining toddler and mom demanding apology from sister in family conflict discussion.

Mom demands apology from sister for disciplining toddler, sparking family conflict over parenting and child discipline approaches.

Alt text: Mom demands apology from sister for disciplining toddler highlighting issues in proper parent supervision.

Mom demands apology from sister after disciplining toddler, sparking debate on how about you parent your child approach.

Mom demands apology from sister for disciplining toddler, highlighting parenting conflict and toddler behavior concerns.

Text conversation about mom demanding apology from sister for disciplining toddler and family drama over parenting choices.

Mom demands apology from sister after disciplining toddler, highlighting parenting and family discipline conflict online.

Alt text: Online discussion about disciplining a toddler and parenting challenges involving family dynamics and behavior correction.

Text post from Hercisback1 discussing giving an apology to maintain family peace after disciplining toddler.

Commenter discussing parenting and discipline, emphasizing paying attention to a toddler and appropriate communication methods.

Screenshot of online comment discussing a mom demanding apology from sister for disciplining toddler.

Text excerpt from discussion about mom demanding apology from sister for disciplining toddler and parenting conflicts.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!