Pushy MIL Thinks She Can Name DIL’s Baby, Goes Ballistic When She Doesn’t Get Her Way

Some families have little traditions that are heartwarming, like Sunday dinners or matching pajamas on holidays, while others have traditions that are a little more intense. Some clans pass down secret recipes, some inherit family heirlooms, and some, apparently, get saddled with the same two baby names for generations.

Traditions can be lovely, but when they start feeling less like a fun custom and more like an ancient curse, maybe it’s time for a little revision.

One Redditor’s in-laws took tradition to a whole new level by expecting her to name her baby Henry, whether she liked it or not.

More info: Reddit

Some families pass down recipes and heirlooms, others pass down drama and baby names

Pregnant woman in a yellow dress, looking concerned while sitting on a bed, contemplating family name tradition.

Image credits: galitskaya / Freepik (not the actual photo)

One woman refuses to obey her mother-in-law and won’t name her baby Henry as their family tradition dictates, causing drama

Text screenshot discussing family tradition disagreement over baby names.

Pregnant woman discusses breaking 100-year-old baby name tradition, causing family tensions over historical name choice.

Text describing a family tradition of first-born men named James or Henry, now challenged.

Text about rejecting 100-year-old baby name tradition to choose a unique name for their child.

Baby clothes with "Henry" name, breaking tradition, on a woven basket with a wooden toy and greenery nearby.

Image credits: WonderfullyMade13914 / Etsy (not the actual photo)

In the husband’s family, every boy has been named Henry or James for generations, so the mother-in-law expects her grandson to be named Henry as well

Mother-in-law visits, brings clothes embroidered with the name Henry for the baby; sparks family history debate.

Woman rejects traditional name; prefers choosing her child's first name, suggests Henry as a middle name.

Text about a mother-in-law reacting dramatically to a broken baby name tradition.

Text screenshot discussing rejection of a 100-year-old baby name tradition for clarity.

Elderly woman looking upset on sofa, discussing family history tradition.

Image credits: The Yuri Arcurs Collection / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The woman and her husband have already decided on the name, which will not be Henry

Text about rejecting a 100-year-old baby name tradition amid family pressure.

Text about family conflict following rejection of traditional baby name.

Text discussing baby's name tradition rejection and associated family drama.

Text explaining a family's similar naming traditions, with a woman's decision on rejecting a 100-year-old baby name.

Image credits: After_Ad3961

The woman tells her mother-in-law she will not be naming her baby Henry, then gets accused of ruining a century-old tradition

The OP (original poster), a glowing and very pregnant 28-year-old, is thrilled to be expecting a baby with her husband. They’d spent months picking out the perfect name, something meaningful, unique, and special. But there was one tiny problem: that name was not Henry.

Now, we all know that some in-laws can be intense, but the OP’s mother-in-law was ready to take this name debate to the Supreme Court. She showed up with hand-embroidered baby clothes, each one proudly displaying the name Henry. Bold move.

The OP thanked her but gently reminded her that they were going in a different direction with the name. At this point, the baby’s name might as well be “Drama,” because the mother-in-law immediately called in reinforcements, pleading with her son, aka the OP’s hubby, to “not let her do this to the family.”

Yes, because choosing a different baby name is the equivalent of launching an attack on their entire bloodline. She even suggested a sneaky compromise: legally name him Henry but just call him something else. Because what kid wouldn’t love years of confusion and paperwork errors?

After enduring a storm of guilt trips, the OP had enough. Thanks to a mix of hormones and frustration, she finally snapped and called the tradition “stupid.” Her mother-in-law stormed out, and soon enough, the OP’s husband started receiving a barrage of dramatic texts from his father and sister about how the OP had ruined everything by rejecting their tradition.

Woman frustrated at partner indoors, discussing family baby name tradition in a plant-filled room.

Image credits: Timur Weber / Pexels (not the actual photo)

Family traditions can be a beautiful way to remember history and connect generations, but they shouldn’t feel like a contractual obligation. The key is balance: embracing meaningful traditions while making space for new ones. Holding on to the past is great, but evolving traditions to fit modern life can be even better. After all, if families never updated their customs, we’d all still be marrying off daughters for a couple of goats.

When traditions start feeling like an inescapable rule book written by ancestors who never considered alternative options, they can become more of a burden than a blessing. The OP’s mother-in-law might need some time to adjust to the idea that, shockingly, babies can have names other than Henry, and maybe, just maybe, she’ll stop trying to manipulate the OP into changing her baby’s name.

Because naming a baby is a very personal choice. Some parents go the sentimental route, while others pick a name with a strong meaning, ensuring it reflects values they want to instill in their child.

To find out more about this topic, Bored Panda reached out to Sophie Kihm, editor-in-chief at Nameberry, for some comments.  She told us that every set of parents has their own priorities when selecting a baby name. For many, it’s important to consider how the name sounds with the last name and middle name, while other parents prefer using names that honor loved ones, or names that fit well with siblings’ names.

We asked Kihm how parents can balance traditional family names with modern names. She explained, “Parents are becoming much more creative in the ways they honor loved ones with baby names. Although many people still use the honor name outright, we’ve observed other parents choosing more modern names that are inspired by their loved ones. For example, if Grandma’s favorite color was purple, a parent might give their daughter a name like Violet or Lavender in her honor.”

We wanted to know what impact naming a child after someone from the past can have on the child’s identity. Kihm told us that typically, kids will develop their own sense of self, even if named after someone from the past. However, if there are strong expectations tied to the namesake, it could place pressure on the child. It’s important for parents to be cautious when naming their child after someone with a controversial or tragic history.

We also wanted to know why some families feel so strongly about passing down names. She explained that, in many families, passing down a name is seen as a significant honor. A name carries a lot of weight, symbolizing identity, respect, and affection for the individual they’re named after. It’s also often a family tradition that conveys reverence and admiration for the person whose name is being passed on.

We asked Kihm what advice she would give parents dealing with pressure from family to choose a name. She told us, “A child’s name is the choice of the parents. Grandparents may have opinions, but it is within the parents’ rights to set boundaries around the baby name conversation. If a parent does not want to pass down a family name for their child, they should not do it. No one is required to uphold a family tradition.”

What do you think? Should our mom-to-be have caved to tradition, or was she right to choose the baby name she wanted? Let us know in the comments!

Netizens side with the woman, saying she is not a jerk in this story, as she and her husband have the right to give their baby whatever name they want

Reddit discussion on rejecting a baby name tradition, with users debating family naming customs.

Text exchange discussing a woman's rejection of a 100-year-old baby name tradition.

Reddit comments discussing the reaction of a MIL to a woman changing a name tradition.

Comments about choosing the baby name Oliver over a 100-year-old family tradition.

Text exchange about a baby name tradition, focusing on family naming rules and their significance.

Text discussing complications from a tradition of naming all male grandkids the same, highlighting paperwork issues.

Comment discussing rejection of 100-year-old baby name tradition and family independence.

Text comment discussing tradition and family influence, mentioning MIL's concern for grandchild.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!