Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
User submission
Mom Debates Whether To Ask MIL To Stop Doing Their Kids’ Christmas Stockings
It’s that magical time of the year again… You can feel it in the air. Lights are going up, festive tunes are playing, and Christmas is just around the corner. Among all the joys of the season, traditions are often the most exciting part—they’re the little rituals that make the holiday truly memorable. But what happens when a tradition starts to create a festive dilemma instead of joy?
Take this situation, for example: a mom is stuck in a holiday pickle because her mother-in-law has taken over all the grandkids’ Christmas stockings. What began as a sweet gesture has gradually lost its personal touch, and now the kids are starting to notice. The mother is torn: should she speak up and try to reclaim the stockings, or let Grandma continue her tradition to keep the peace during the holidays? It’s a tricky mix of love, family dynamics, and holiday spirit.
RELATED:
Christmas is a magical time filled with joy, warmth, and the excitement of giving and receiving gifts
Image credits: nomadsoul1 (not the actual photo)
A mom shared her frustration with her mother-in-law giving generic gifts to the grandkids, ruining the family tradition
Image credits: rawpixel.com (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Gagamama2
Stuffing stockings is a timeless Christmas tradition filled with warmth, surprises, and a touch of nostalgia
If you’ve ever paused mid–gift unwrapping and wondered, “Wait, why do we even get presents in stockings?”, you’re not alone. It’s one of those holiday traditions we all follow without really knowing the backstory. Well, turns out this cozy custom has some surprisingly heartwarming (and ancient) roots.
According to Bruce Forbes, professor emeritus of religious studies at Morningside University and author of Christmas: A Candid History, the legend of the stocking full of goodies dates all the way back to St. Nicholas — the real-life Bishop of Myra and the inspiration for Santa Claus himself.
St. Nicholas, Forbes explains, was the only child of a wealthy family who decided to dedicate his life to helping those in need. One of the most famous stories about him involves a poor father with three daughters who couldn’t afford their dowries, meaning they faced a grim future. To save them, the bishop secretly tossed three bags of gold through their window.
In one charming twist of the story, the daughters had hung their freshly washed stockings by the fireplace to dry. As luck (or Christmas magic) would have it, the gold landed right inside the stockings. That’s how, legend says, the tradition of hanging stockings for gifts began: with an act of kindness, a bit of mystery, and a whole lot of heart.
When the grateful father tried to catch his anonymous benefactor to thank him, St. Nicholas insisted that no one should know and that the credit belonged to God. And just like that, a small act of secret generosity transformed into one of the most beloved Christmas traditions we still cherish today.
Giving personal, thoughtful gifts makes the joy of Christmas feel even more magical and meaningful
Now that we know the heartwarming story behind Christmas stockings, let’s talk about what really goes inside them. As Oprah Daily points out, stocking stuffers are the perfect way to give smaller, thoughtful gifts to the people you love, without the stress (or expense) of chasing after big-ticket presents. It’s those tiny surprises that make the morning feel magical.
The beauty of stocking stuffers is that they don’t need to be extravagant, they just need a little heart. Often, all it takes is listening. You’ll pick up on the small things: a favorite snack, a hobby they’ve been into lately, or something they mentioned wanting in passing. Those are the gifts that make people light up because it shows you really know them.
Think of it this way: everyday essentials can be just as delightful as fancy gifts. A lip balm in their favorite flavor, a cozy pair of socks, or their go-to chocolate bar, these are small but thoughtful gestures that say, “I get you.”
If you want to go a bit fancier, jewelry, custom keychains, or tiny gadgets can make a stocking feel extra special. It’s less about how expensive the item is and more about how personal it feels. Even a handwritten note or a little joke gift can bring huge smiles.
At the end of the day, it’s not about how much you spend, it’s the thought behind each item. A stocking filled with care and intention always beats one that feels generic. Especially for kids, a little personalization makes all the difference; it turns Christmas morning into something they’ll remember.
In this particular story, though, it seems like the mother-in-law missed that memo. The mother just wanted their kids to have stockings that felt special and personal, not a one-size-fits-all version of holiday cheer. So, what do you think? Should she speak up and start her own tradition, or let Grandma keep her festive routine for the sake of peace on Christmas morning?
Many people sympathized with the parent, agreeing that the mother-in-law’s generic gifts missed the point and emphasizing how meaningful Christmas traditions truly are
The author went on to explain in detail how her family spends Christmas Day and how the gift-giving tradition usually unfolds
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
25Kviews
Share on FacebookExplore more of these tags
What do you think ?
Bailey 1 month ago
Seems like needless drama. If the poster is that hung up on wanting to do a stocking, put one together at home before they leave, then it's additional excitement for the kids when they are going home to see what Santa left them at their house. That way none of the other kids will feel left out at the grandparents. Making a fuss of it is just going to p**s of the grandparents. If they have a lot of kids to buy for, a stocking makes sense as they can buy bits and pieces, with small variences, so they are all getting roughly the same. Plus if you tell them to stop, the posters kids are just going to feel left out when all the other grand kids get stockings.
Ace 1 month ago
Clearly different families have their own traditions, so it's a tricky one. Maybe the OP could adapt, in the scenario described it's important that all the kids have a similar expectation. When I was a kid the stocking was always special, but a key element of them was that they did not contain any of our 'real' presents, just nie and inexpensive things, generally not personalised. The stocking was what Santa had left, the presents were always from specific people. Ours always included some nuts, a tangerine, some chocolate coins which we were allowed to eat before breakfast.
Natalia 1 month ago
I'm 40+ and my mum still gets me chocolate coins at Christmas!
Load More Replies...
Bailey 1 month ago
Seems like needless drama. If the poster is that hung up on wanting to do a stocking, put one together at home before they leave, then it's additional excitement for the kids when they are going home to see what Santa left them at their house. That way none of the other kids will feel left out at the grandparents. Making a fuss of it is just going to p**s of the grandparents. If they have a lot of kids to buy for, a stocking makes sense as they can buy bits and pieces, with small variences, so they are all getting roughly the same. Plus if you tell them to stop, the posters kids are just going to feel left out when all the other grand kids get stockings.
Ace 1 month ago
Clearly different families have their own traditions, so it's a tricky one. Maybe the OP could adapt, in the scenario described it's important that all the kids have a similar expectation. When I was a kid the stocking was always special, but a key element of them was that they did not contain any of our 'real' presents, just nie and inexpensive things, generally not personalised. The stocking was what Santa had left, the presents were always from specific people. Ours always included some nuts, a tangerine, some chocolate coins which we were allowed to eat before breakfast.
Natalia 1 month ago
I'm 40+ and my mum still gets me chocolate coins at Christmas!
Load More Replies... You May Like Kid Laughs After Breaking Cousin’s Console, Switches To Tears After His Parent's Response Couple Trick Clingy MIL By Changing Their Vacation Plans Last Minute: "Cue The Waterworks And Victimization" MIL Demands Son Leaves Pregnant Wife Alone During Holidays, Is Baffled He Says 'No'
Indrė Lukošiūtė
Mantas Kačerauskas
Mantas Kačerauskas
Related on Bored Panda
10
27