Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
Man Forced To Raise His Brother As His Own After Parents Abandon Him, Wonders If He Should Tell Him
Raising a child as a young adult is a pretty harrowing task that, arguably, most 20 year old’s are not equipped for, but it doesn’t mean that one shouldn’t try if that’s the hand that fate dealt them. A man asked the internet if he was wrong to never reveal to his kid brother that he wasn’t actually his father.
As it turns out, the man’s parents didn’t want anything to do with their newborn, so he decided to take him in and raise him as a father together with his girlfriend. Now his relatives are constantly pressuring him to reveal the truth. Later, he shared a few updates on how he decided to proceed.
RELATED:
Talking with kids about difficult subjects can often be tricky
Image credits: Bagler_kat (not the actual photo)
So one man asked the internet how to handle telling his brother, who he raised, that he’s not his dad
Image credits: dvatri (not the actual photo)
Image credits: AmINotTheA**hole
Children have a right to know where they are from
Telling a child that they are adopted is one of the most important things adoptive parents will ever tell them, and it should be done with sensitivity. Adoption is not something to be hidden but something to be revealed with care, for it is directly linked to a child’s sense of identity, belonging, and trust. To many children, their family is the unproblematic center of life. To discover that this basis began differently than they believed it had is confusing. How the news is presented will determine not only how they feel about their adoption, but how they feel about themselves and their place in the family.
Unless presented poorly, the news can leave wounds that will take a few years to mend. If a child stumbles upon it inadvertently, by carelessness of words, slip of a relative, or some record found late in life, it will be heard as something shameful that needed to be hidden. The hiding becomes betrayal, and the child will wonder why they were kept in the dark, or if their adoptive parents were afraid of losing their love. This sense of distrust, though, can prove more damaging than the information itself.
Ultimately, most experts suggest that it’s important to tell the child as soon as possible, within reason. Some even go as far as to recommend telling the truth to an infant or toddler, repeating it at times. They are too young to understand, but therein lies this strategy’s advantage. They can absorb the information before absorbing its implications, so when they are old enough to be told more, the revelation isn’t as “shocking.”
Image credits: Andrea Piacquadio (not the actual photo)
Telling the truth is complex, but necessary
Handled with sensitivity, the conversation can solidify parent-child bond. Adoption, if explained candidly and with love, is not a story of rejection but a story of choice. The children must be told that they were wanted, that their entering the family was not a compromise but a deliberate and important decision. Parents can frame the truth at a level that is suitable for their age. When very young, it can be simply a story of how they came to be in the family, but as children get older, they will pose more searching questions about their birth families, origins, or adoption circumstances. Crucially, however, time must be given for these questions to be asked, and no question is met with shame or evasion.
It’s also necessary to remember that adoption is not one big reveal but an ongoing dialogue. The understanding of children deepens as they get older, and what makes sense at age five won’t cut it with the questions they’ll have at age fifteen. One constant is that the parent should not lie. Answers that get an eight year old to stop asking questions will just cause issues later. Returning to the conversation periodically allows them to sort through new feelings and provides a guarantee that the topic matter is available for discussion. This ongoing vulnerability enables adoption to be not one small definitive secret but a regular, accepted part of their life story.
Telling a kid that they are adopted is so much more than providing information. It is about affirming security, love, and trust. Patient and cautious parents can make what might otherwise be a difficult revelation into a story of belonging, one that speaks to the countless ways that families come to be, and the enduring love that makes a family whole.
Image credits: August de Richelieu (not the actual photo)
Some readers wanted to hear more
Most thought no one was the villain
A few also shared similar stories
People left their suggestions in the comments
A few believed his family was too harsh on him
Some thought he needed to tell his brother sooner
Image credits: jm_video (not the actual photo)
Later, he shared what they decided to do
Image credits: YuriArcursPeopleimages (not the actual photo)
Image credits: AmINotTheA**hole
Readers were happy things worked out
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
Explore more of these tags
What do you think ?
SheamusFanFrom1987 3 months ago
The late Yondu Udonta said it before "He may have been your father, but I'll always be your daddy." An important enough reminder that while many can be s***m-donors, few actually become father figures. May OP, Josh, and family live happy lives and never worry about labels ever again :-)
LakotaWolf (she/her) 3 months ago
As an adopted child whose adoptive father was absolutely the best dad a small, scruffy, weird girl could have asked for, I actually started crying when I heard that line in the movie. URGH the feels XD
Load More Replies...
Jeolas1 3 months ago
I know from experience how traumatic it is when everyone around you - even close friends - know something as intimate as biological parentage about you but YOU don't - and then you only find out decades later. That feeling that there's something not quite right with you? It doesn't come from growing up with someone who is not your biological dad. It comes from relatives and friends looking at you KNOWING this and keeping it secret.
SheamusFanFrom1987 3 months ago
The late Yondu Udonta said it before "He may have been your father, but I'll always be your daddy." An important enough reminder that while many can be s***m-donors, few actually become father figures. May OP, Josh, and family live happy lives and never worry about labels ever again :-)
LakotaWolf (she/her) 3 months ago
As an adopted child whose adoptive father was absolutely the best dad a small, scruffy, weird girl could have asked for, I actually started crying when I heard that line in the movie. URGH the feels XD
Load More Replies... Jeolas1 3 months ago
I know from experience how traumatic it is when everyone around you - even close friends - know something as intimate as biological parentage about you but YOU don't - and then you only find out decades later. That feeling that there's something not quite right with you? It doesn't come from growing up with someone who is not your biological dad. It comes from relatives and friends looking at you KNOWING this and keeping it secret.
You May Like "I Was Completely Disowned": Man Confronts Parents Who Hired A PI To Track Him Down After 15 Years Mom Lets Aunt Raise Her Son Because He "Ruins Their Picture Perfect Family," Shocked He Starts Calling Her Mom Family Learns The Power Of “No” The Hard Way After Showing Up Uninvited For Christmas Eve
Indrė Lukošiūtė
Gabija Palšytė
Indrė Lukošiūtė
Related on Bored Panda
49
16