GF Rejects BF’s Proposal Because It Wasn’t “Perfect”, Ends Up Regretting It Later

Proposing can be a nerve-wracking experience. Traditionally, you have to get the parents’ blessing before getting down on one knee and asking your person to spend the rest of their life with you. Talk about putting your relationship in a vulnerable position.

For one guy, his worst nightmare came true when he proposed to his girlfriend of 6 years on vacation in Hawaii and she said no. Her reason? It wasn’t what she was expecting. The guy turned to Reddit to share his sad story. 

More info: Reddit

A marriage proposal can be a daunting affair, as this guy found out the hard way

Man proposing with a ring, woman rejecting his proposal on a sofa.

Image credits: bokodi / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Having discussed marriage at length with his girlfriend and getting her parents’ blessing, he decided to propose during their vacation in Hawaii

Text recounting a rejected proposal in Hawaii; girlfriend regrets decision later.

Text about frequently discussing marriage and mutual agreement to marry.

Text describing a grand wedding proposal with "MARRY ME" letters on the beach, rose petals, and mariachi.

Text discussing a couple's vacation planning challenges and proposal expectations.

A man proposing on a beach while a woman reacts with surprise, reflecting on proposing.

Image credits: Gad Samuel / Pexels (not the actual photo)

After two days of postponing, he finally gathered up the courage to do it while on a romantic night walk at the beach

Text stating belief in a great opportunity, related to proposal regrets.

Text detailing a proposal plan, unexpected arguments, and the decision to postpone doing it the right way.

Text about a proposal plan where ring was left at hotel to avoid losing it during parasailing.

Text about missed sunset proposal; regret over not doing it “the right way.”

Couple walking on the beach at sunset, holding hands.

Image credits: halayalex / Freepik (not the actual photo)

As he reached into his pocket and got down on one knee, his girlfriend stopped him mid-moment, telling him it wasn’t what she expected

Text recounting a couple's evening with a missed chance for a proposal at the beach.

Text about a romantic beach proposal illuminated by city lights and the moon.

Text describing a proposal attempt stopped by the girlfriend, leading to later regret.

Text screenshot about a rejected marriage proposal due to not being done "the right way".

Couple arguing near a stone railing, highlighting a proposal gone wrong.

Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Apparently, she wanted a grander gesture at sunset, with her beloved doggo present

Text about proposal rejection due to not doing it "the right way", with regret expressed afterwards.

Text image discussing regret and tension after a proposal was rejected for not being done "the right way.

Text on a breakup explorations questioning relationship decisions after a rejected proposal.

Text discussing rejected proposal due to not meeting expectations during a vacation.

Man in gray hoodie looking regretful with hand on face, wearing engagement ring.

Image credits: cottonbro studio / Pexels (not the actual photo)

Gutted, the guy stood up, turned around, and went straight back to the hotel, telling his girlfriend they could talk about it the next day

Text conversation about a marriage proposal regret, not meeting expectations.

Text discussing proposal trends on social media, emphasizing the desire for intimate proposals away from the public.

Text conversation about proposal expectations and relationship regrets.

Instagram app icon on a smartphone screen, showcasing social media.

Image credits: Brett Jordan / Unsplash (not the actual photo)

After a few tense days, the couple headed home, and the ungrateful girlfriend spent the night at her parents

Text of a man sharing his disappointment over a rejected proposal that happened during a Hawaii vacation.

Text on background discussing proposal plans, including brunch, parasailing, Teppanyaki dinner, and questioning selfishness.

Text expressing frustration about a proposal being rejected for not being done "the right way.

A man in a plaid shirt looking frustrated, holding his head, during a proposal rejection conversation in a park.

Image credits: wirestock_creators / Freepik (not the actual photo)

When she came back, she emphasized how unhappy she was with his proposal and demanded a do-over

Text about a proposal rejection due to not meeting expectations, focusing on casual attire and lack of prior notice for a special event.

Text discussing proposal requirements, dog as ring bearer, and regret about not meeting expectations.

Text describing a situation where a proposal was rejected for not being done “the right way.”

Couple walking a dog on a sidewalk, surrounded by greenery.

Image credits: marymarkevich / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The guy felt that was unfair and said she’d only become interested in an Insta-worthy engagement recently, originally preferring a more intimate affair

"Text showing 'UPDATE 2:', part of the story about a proposal rejection.

Text reading, "We had the breakup talk," related to a proposal regret.

Text about a self-centered girlfriend who started therapy, related to a rejected proposal done "the right way.

Text about relationship changes and commitment, related to proposal regrets.

Text conversation about proposal rejection over surprises and regret.

Marriage proposal with ring box held in hands, expressing love and commitment.

Image credits: Marko Klaric / Pexels (not the actual photo)

The guy’s girlfriend tried to apologize and told him she regretted her actions, but it was too little, too late

Text snippet about proposal expectations and priorities in relationships.

Text on image discussing regret after rejecting a proposal done "the right way.

Text about a woman's dismissive thoughts and regret regarding a rejected proposal.

Text about a rejected proposal and its regrettable aftermath, highlighting the importance of doing things "the right way.

Image credits: Axelbarillas

Fed up, the guy decided to end the couple’s six-year relationship altogether, preferring to sleep on the couch until his girlfriend could move out

OP begins his story by telling the community that he and his girlfriend had been together for 6 years. Over Thanksgiving weekend, he took her on a week-long vacation to Hawaii with the hope of proposing to her.  

He adds that the issue was that his girlfriend wanted a grand marriage proposal but, considering the trip was somewhat last-minute, he didn’t have the time to pull off anything that elaborate. Regardless, he figured a proposal in Hawaii would do.

On their second day, they went out for dinner and drinks. OP says his girlfriend had mentioned before that she wanted a sunset proposal, but he opted to pop the question during a romantic late-night beach walk instead.

Well, while OP dropped to one knee, his girlfriend stopped him and said, “I hope you’re not about to propose to me right now, this isn’t what I expected.” Gutted, OP got up and walked back to the hotel. 

When the next day came, OP’s girlfriend told him she wanted him to propose again, just this time at sunset. OP said he couldn’t since he’d already been rejected, but she argued it wasn’t a rejection, it just wasn’t how she expected it to go down. After 4 tense days, they returned home, and OP’s girlfriend went to stay with her parents for the day. 

In an update to his original post, OP tells readers that his girlfriend had always been a bit self-centered but, since going to therapy, she’d become more compassionate—something that encouraged his idea to propose in the first place.

Despite that, and based on her dismissive and disrespectful behavior, OP decided to end things and sleep on the couch until she could pack up her things and go live with her parents.

Based on what OP tells us in his post, it would definitely seem that his girlfriend was too focused on the superficialities, missing the entire point of his proposal. 

That being said, if all goes well, you’re only proposed to once in your life, so perhaps she felt entitled to everything being just how she had imagined it. 

Woman sitting on a bench with a cardboard box, looking regretful after rejecting proposal.

Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Proposals these days can get quite elaborate, with some even going viral on social media. So, if you’re thinking of popping the question, what are some interesting proposal ideas?

In her article for Hitched, Maisie Peppitt puts forward some proposal suggestions that are guaranteed to get a yes. Some of our favorites include recreating your first date, going on a private tour of a museum, hiring a hot air balloon on safari, taking a private yacht cruise at sunset, proposing on a road trip, or going impromptu ring shopping.

In an article for the BBC, Michele Velazquez of The Heart Bandits in Los Angeles says her most intricate proposal event was in a rooftop garden in New York, where delights for the bride-to-be featured a custom monogram at the bottom of the pool, towering orchid arrangements, a gift of Manolo Blahnik shoes, and a string quartet.

Maybe something like that was out of OP’s budget, but we’re sure with a little more planning and discussion, he could have come up with a proposal closer to what his girlfriend had in mind. Perhaps it was just never meant to be.

Bored Panda reached out to psychologist Dr. Deborah Hecker to get her professional take on the situation. 

When we asked her what she thought of OP’s girlfriend’s behavior, she had this to say, “Although the woman wanted a grand setting for the proposal, but understood the limitations, the two agreed on a proposal at sunset. However, OP unilaterally changed the setting, rationalizing that she would still be happy.” 

Hecker goes on, “He was wrong to have done that as they were united in their decision, and she trusted him to honor it. Her disappointment, therefore, is understandable.”

Hecker added, “The manner in which she handled her disillusionment, by asking him for a redo, was insensitive, emasculating, and arrogant. It would have been much better if she had accepted the proposal and later talked to him about her disappointment.”

We asked Dr. Hecker for one piece of advice she’d offer to someone considering popping the question. 

“The most important part of how-to-propose is in the details. My advice to someone figuring out how to create the perfect proposal is to know your partner’s preferences and customize the proposal as much as possible,” concluded Hecker. 

What would you have done if you’d found yourself in OP’s shoes? Would you have tried again, or walked away? Let us know your opinion in the comments! 

In the comments, folks agreed that the girlfriend was full of red flags and wondered what her wedding expectations might have been if that was how she reacted to the proposal

Text exchange discussing immaturity and life experience in a proposal rejection situation.

Text commentary on GF rejecting proposal for not being done the right way, expressing regret.

Comment about rejection of a proposal, expressing surprise at wedding expectations.

Screenshot of a comment saying "Rejected proposal equals breakup," related to proposal regrets.

Text post about a proposal in Japan affected by Typhoon Jebi, ending with a perfect outcome.

Reddit comment criticizing rejection of a proposal due to unmet grand gesture expectations.

A Reddit comment criticizing someone for worrying about a rejected marriage proposal due to it not being "the right way.

Comment with advice following rejected proposal, suggesting it was a lucky escape.

Text comment about a rejected proposal due to not being done the right way, implying future regret.

Reddit comment about a proposal and relationship regrets.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!