Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
From ‘The Little Prince’ To ‘Forrest Gump’: 28 Fictional ‘Would You Rather’ Dilemmas
Are you ready to make tough fictional decisions?🧙♂️ Then you’re in the right place.
This poll drops you straight into some of the most iconic worlds in pop culture and asks you to choose - even when neither option feels great. One moment, you’re deciding if you’d rather live in Middle-earth or Westeros. The next - you’re forced to pick between facing Voldemort or Darth Vader. And as if that’s not enough, you’ll have to figure out whether life would be better as Michael Corleone or Tony Soprano.
The only rule? You have to choose. There’s no in-between here - just two options and one decision.
If you missed the first part, you can check it out here: Part 1 of the ‘Would You Rather’ Poll.
Scroll down and start! ⚖️
🚀 💡 Want more or looking for something else? Head over to the Bored Panda Quizzes and explore our full collection of quizzes and trivia designed to test your knowledge, reveal hidden insights, and spark your curiosity.💡 🚀
This post may include affiliate links.
#1
Would you rather live a simple life that changes many people (Forrest Gump) or see how the world would be without you (It’s a Wonderful Life)?
RELATED:
#2
Would you rather trade your soul for eternal youth (Dorian Gray) or for unlimited knowledge and power (Faust)?
TotallyNOTAFox 5 days ago
Does youth imply not dying of old age? Because that would mean unlimited time to acquire knowledge
#3
Would you rather emotionally depend on an advanced AI companion (Her) or be secretly filmed for a global reality show (The Truman Show)?
#4
Would you rather live in Middle-earth (The Lord of the Rings) or in Westeros (Game of Thrones)?
Shark Lady 5 days ago
Middle-earth but only after Sauron was defeated and if I can live in The Shire.
#5
Would you rather control fire or control water (Avatar: The Last Airbender)?
LakotaWolf (she/her) 5 days ago
I can already control both! ::turns on the sink and the gas stove:: :D
#6
Would you rather spend one night in the Upside Down (Stranger Things) or one night in the Overlook Hotel (The Shining)?
#7
Would you rather have Donkey (Shrek) as your best friend or Olaf (Frozen)?
#8
Would you rather be trapped in a sinking ship (Titanic) or trapped in a deadly game (Squid Game)?
#9
Which world would you rather live in: Narnia or Wonderland?
Shark Lady 5 days ago
Wonderland would feel like a d**g induced nightmare that you couldn't escape from.
#10
Would you rather die remembered as a hero (Gladiator) or live forgotten but peaceful?
Glen Ellyn 5 days ago
I fully expect that no one will care anything about me or my life. Well, maybe my three children and nine grandchildren, but that's about it.
#13
Would you rather have a fairy godmother (Cinderella) or a talking genie (Aladdin)?
Shark Lady 5 days ago
The Genie is enslaved and can only help you three times. A fairy godmother can keep an eye on you for life!
#14
Would you rather be trapped in your own mind (Shutter Island) or unable to forget anything (Black Mirror)?
#15
Would you rather be in a love story that ends in death (Romeo and Juliet) or one that ends in regret (La La Land)?
#16
Would you rather live in a world where toys are alive (Toy Story) or where emotions are alive (Inside Out)?
Sly Schlang 4 days ago
My plush shark has soft teeth, I treat him well, so I think we would be Friends. I am safe with No 1.
#17
Which family would you rather belong to: The Addams Family or The Simpsons?
#18
Would you rather commit a crime and live with guilt (Crime and Punishment) or never take any moral risks in life?
#19
Would you rather cross the ocean to save someone you love (Finding Nemo) or travel the world to fulfill a lifelong dream (Up)?
#21
Would you rather fall in love with someone who ages backwards (The Curious Case of Benjamin Button) or someone who slowly forgets you (The Notebook)?
#22
Would you rather see the world through a child’s eyes (The Little Prince) or understand the hidden meaning of everything (The Alchemist)?
#23
Would you rather be Michael Corleone (The Godfather) or Tony Soprano (The Sopranos)?
#24
Would you rather live in a world where your role is chosen for you (Divergent) or where you must compete to earn your place (The Hunger Games)?
#25
Would you rather believe in aliens (The X-Files) or ghosts (The Sixth Sense)?
LakotaWolf (she/her) 5 days ago
If all I'm doing is BELIEVING in them, why not both? XD It doesn't say my belief makes them real.
#26
Would you rather live one perfect day over and over again (Groundhog Day) or see your entire future all at once (Arrival)?
TotallyNOTAFox 5 days ago
I think my future is so f****d that I'd probably shortcut right to the end
#27
Would you rather join the Peaky Blinders or the Money Heist crew?
#28
Would you rather be trapped with Hannibal Lecter or Joker?
Remi (He/Him) 4 days ago
Hannibal eats the rude, so just be nice and you can escape together. Joker is completely unpredictable
Add New Image
You May Like Only People Who Watched A Lot Of TV In The 80s & 90s Will Ace This 30-Question Quiz We Prepared 40 General Knowledge Questions - Anything Above 33 Is Impressive 30 Highlighted Countries On The World Map: Score At Least 25/30 In This Geography Challenge From Madonna To Michael Jackson: See How Many 80s Stars You Can Still Recognize
Ikhona Makaluza
Ikhona Makaluza
Gerda K.
Ikhona Makaluza
Related on Bored Panda
