Woman Earns Good Money, MIL Is Upset She Can’t Take Full Advantage Of It: “But You Are Rich”
“Beggars can’t be choosers.” Living by this self-explanatory proverb is expected from every sensible adult. Asking for help from someone means taking whatever they offer you with gratitude, even if it doesn’t fully resolve your need.
It’s a principle that’s absent in this woman, who needed help with paying her rent. When her son and daughter-in-law offered half of the money, she began questioning their decision. Worse, she also blamed her own children for not being “rich” enough.
You will find the entire story below, along with reactions from readers who didn’t hold back.
Demanding more from someone who has already offered their help is never a good look
Image credits: freepik (not the actual photo)
A woman approached her daughter-in-law to ask for some financial assistance
Image credits: freepik (not the actual photo)
The daughter-in-law offered to pay half, but it wasn’t enough
Image credits: LushGlinty
Having a sense of entitlement could be a way to mask a feeling of unworthiness
Image credits: freepik (not the actual photo)
Encountering an entitled person may automatically lead to assumptions of a possible narcissistic personality, which is understandable. After all, believing you’re deserving of something you’re not shows you have an inflated sense of self-importance, which is one of the many signs of narcissism.
However, this may not always be the case. According to author and relationship therapist Steven Stosny, Ph.D., acting entitled may also be a sign of low self-worth.
In an article for Psychology Today, Stosny explained that self-important people act the way they do to “hide a deeper sense of unworthiness.” According to him, clients who display a sense of entitlement “rarely feel loved.”
“If you’re angry, you perceive threats to some presumed entitlement,” Stosny wrote. “And if you’re entitled, you’re bound to be angry, as the rest of the world will resist your sense of entitlement.”
Stosny’s statement on anger may explain the mother-in-law’s arrogance when her daughter-in-law told her she was only getting half of her rent money. She may also be feeling inferior about having to practically beg for her rent money, which is why she may have masked it with the entitled behavior she displayed.
What makes it more complicated is that the mother-in-law is a parental figure, and technically holds the “power” in the relationship dynamic. However, it does not give them the license to engage in toxic behavior.
In such scenarios, maintaining self-respect is essential. According to licensed clinical social worker Brooke Schwartz, LCSW, taking the high road would be the best reaction.
The woman did just that by calmly explaining why they could only give her mother-in-law 50% of the rent money. She simply hung up the phone without responding aggressively, which made her appear more sensible.
Commenters gave candid responses, primarily criticizing the MIL and offering suggestions
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
47Kviews
Share on FacebookI think this is not even about the money but they way MIL assumed her DIL is "rich" (not knowing that "rich" can be many things, like well to do but not millionaire, etc), but the way MIL played both DIL and son about it. Asking and giving money to family is one thing, being demanded and manipulated and playing of spouses against each other is another thing.
Load More Replies...Some of the commenter's seemed to assume MIL meant this as a one time thing... did I miss that bit? 'cause I assumed she meant "from this day forward". (which is obviously a big fat no)
I would have set MIL up with a financial planner to see where her money goes before I offered to pay *any* of her rent. And I agree with the "pay the rent directly to the landlord" comment.
I think what hit most of us was the entitlement of MIL without any explanation why she suddenly wasn't able to pay her rent anymore. I'd love to hear more about why she suddenly couldnt pay her rent!
Load More Replies...Update: my mother-in-law moved in with us because she lost her apartment. I made a bad choice.
"I'm going to speak to your wife", revealing who in the marriage she thinks she can bully. She was taught a lesson.
How has she managed to pay her rent before this? Why is she now needing money for rent? I suspect something else is going on. Could she possibly have a gambling, or shopping a*******n now? It just doesn't make sense.
I’m thinking it’s one of those pig-butchering scams, some man using a photo of a handsome guy and proclaiming love for some lonely lady and he suddenly needs 10K for his ailing mother, and the monetary demands keep escalating and now she’s broke and can’t pay her rent because all her money’s now in Nigeria.
Load More Replies...I'd help my own mother out immediately. No questions asked. She wouldn't need to pay me back if I could spare it. But this lady and the way she asks is ridiculous. Sounds like a free loader.
"We owe you nothing but have decided to give you two options, A: 50% or B: Nothing. Let us know your decision."
When she says you are rich, say your family is, but not you and offer her THEIR phone number.
You and your husband are kind and considerate 1/2 of today's rent is a nice bit of money. You should congratulate her on no longer getting it. You don't ower her c**p and the fact that you even considered paying any amount is very kind of you. So tell her to find a cheaper place and rescind the initial offer. It's your money not hers so spend it on yourself and your husband. I know you likely dont want to cause any drama but hopefully your husband stands by the decision and MIL can figure it out herself. Sláinte
People in these stories always amaze me. My wife and I are better off than most of our families. We helped my dad while he was alive, we help her mother and also pay for her phone. They never asked us, we just offered what we could and went on with our lives. We help whomever we can, but our families are too proud to ask for help and would never expect money from us. Our families help us in other ways than financially, so there aren't any takers. We all give to each other what we can and do it willingly.
My mom and I did the same, however, certainly NOT when it is "demanded". And we checked if the one we gave the money to was indeed in need or spent their money on unhinged things. For all you know MIL could have spent her money on a tomboy lover or such.
Load More Replies...The thing to do is to offer to help them budget so that they can manage their own expenses. Cut out the subscriptions, Starbucks, weed, parties, smoking and any other indulgencies until you can afford your obligations.
Hahaha I think this tells us more about you than the OP. 😁
Load More Replies...Why do you assume that, and why would it matter? Do you think things like this only happen in the US?
Load More Replies...This isn't about rich people hoarding wealth, it's about MIL's entitlement.
Load More Replies...Not in the way the money for full rent was demanded by MIL. And certainly not without any conversation about how MIL spends her money.
Load More Replies...I have a mother who is a variation of this. She asked to borrow £1k. She's my mother, so I *gave* her £3k. The very next day, my sister tells me that my mother has just been complaining about how selfish I am. The woman just can't help herself, she can't bring herself to be normal, happily accept a gift and say thank you. She *has* to spew nastiness and in her mind, control and dominance.
Load More Replies...I think this is not even about the money but they way MIL assumed her DIL is "rich" (not knowing that "rich" can be many things, like well to do but not millionaire, etc), but the way MIL played both DIL and son about it. Asking and giving money to family is one thing, being demanded and manipulated and playing of spouses against each other is another thing.
Load More Replies...Some of the commenter's seemed to assume MIL meant this as a one time thing... did I miss that bit? 'cause I assumed she meant "from this day forward". (which is obviously a big fat no)
I would have set MIL up with a financial planner to see where her money goes before I offered to pay *any* of her rent. And I agree with the "pay the rent directly to the landlord" comment.
I think what hit most of us was the entitlement of MIL without any explanation why she suddenly wasn't able to pay her rent anymore. I'd love to hear more about why she suddenly couldnt pay her rent!
Load More Replies...Update: my mother-in-law moved in with us because she lost her apartment. I made a bad choice.
"I'm going to speak to your wife", revealing who in the marriage she thinks she can bully. She was taught a lesson.
How has she managed to pay her rent before this? Why is she now needing money for rent? I suspect something else is going on. Could she possibly have a gambling, or shopping a*******n now? It just doesn't make sense.
I’m thinking it’s one of those pig-butchering scams, some man using a photo of a handsome guy and proclaiming love for some lonely lady and he suddenly needs 10K for his ailing mother, and the monetary demands keep escalating and now she’s broke and can’t pay her rent because all her money’s now in Nigeria.
Load More Replies...I'd help my own mother out immediately. No questions asked. She wouldn't need to pay me back if I could spare it. But this lady and the way she asks is ridiculous. Sounds like a free loader.
"We owe you nothing but have decided to give you two options, A: 50% or B: Nothing. Let us know your decision."
When she says you are rich, say your family is, but not you and offer her THEIR phone number.
You and your husband are kind and considerate 1/2 of today's rent is a nice bit of money. You should congratulate her on no longer getting it. You don't ower her c**p and the fact that you even considered paying any amount is very kind of you. So tell her to find a cheaper place and rescind the initial offer. It's your money not hers so spend it on yourself and your husband. I know you likely dont want to cause any drama but hopefully your husband stands by the decision and MIL can figure it out herself. Sláinte
People in these stories always amaze me. My wife and I are better off than most of our families. We helped my dad while he was alive, we help her mother and also pay for her phone. They never asked us, we just offered what we could and went on with our lives. We help whomever we can, but our families are too proud to ask for help and would never expect money from us. Our families help us in other ways than financially, so there aren't any takers. We all give to each other what we can and do it willingly.
My mom and I did the same, however, certainly NOT when it is "demanded". And we checked if the one we gave the money to was indeed in need or spent their money on unhinged things. For all you know MIL could have spent her money on a tomboy lover or such.
Load More Replies...The thing to do is to offer to help them budget so that they can manage their own expenses. Cut out the subscriptions, Starbucks, weed, parties, smoking and any other indulgencies until you can afford your obligations.
Hahaha I think this tells us more about you than the OP. 😁
Load More Replies...Why do you assume that, and why would it matter? Do you think things like this only happen in the US?
Load More Replies...This isn't about rich people hoarding wealth, it's about MIL's entitlement.
Load More Replies...Not in the way the money for full rent was demanded by MIL. And certainly not without any conversation about how MIL spends her money.
Load More Replies...I have a mother who is a variation of this. She asked to borrow £1k. She's my mother, so I *gave* her £3k. The very next day, my sister tells me that my mother has just been complaining about how selfish I am. The woman just can't help herself, she can't bring herself to be normal, happily accept a gift and say thank you. She *has* to spew nastiness and in her mind, control and dominance.
Load More Replies...




























46
44