When an elderly couple from Nimes, France, decided to clear out their home in 2021, they came across a quirky-looking wooden mask with a beard. The item had been passed down to the husband from his grandfather, who had been a colonial governor in French-occupied Africa.
Wanting to get rid of it and make some money on the side, the unnamed pair (81 and 88 years old) contacted a local antiques dealer known as Mr. Z, who bought the art piece for $158.
In 2021, an elderly couple was clearing out their home when they came across a wooden African mask with a beard
Image credits: France 3 Occitanie
Little did they know that Mr. Z would go off to sell the same item for $4.4 million at a specialized auction in Montpellier.
The valuable Ngil mask is believed to date back to the 19th century, and was used for purification rites. Carved from wood, it belonged to the Ngil, a Fang secret male society that operated in Gabon, Central Africa, until the 1920s.
The pair contacted a local antiques dealer, who bought the item for $158 and later auctioned it for over $4 million, according to court records
Image credits: France 3 Occitanie
The valuable Ngil mask is believed to date back to the 19th century and is one of twelve in the world
The elderly couple has taken the art dealer, known as Mr. Z, to court
View this post on Instagram
The pair claims that Mr. Z withheld information about the real value of the mask
Image credits: africanews
“This piece of kaolin-coated cheesewood is exceptional in terms of its rarity, as only a dozen or so other reference specimens are known to exist worldwide in Western museums and collections,” Artnet News reported.
Though the mask had initially been listed for sale by the auction with an estimate of between $318,000 and $420,000, the item sold in March 2022 for much more.
The elderly couple, who found out about the sale by reading the newspaper, has taken legal action against the art dealer, arguing that the man withheld information about the real value of the mask.
In a similar case, the French court ruled in favor of the original owners of the art piece
Image credits: africanews
They claim he didn’t display the traditional piece in his shop and instead got in touch with three auction houses in France to have African artifacts specialists estimate the price of the artwork.
The last update on the case came on June 28 of this year, when an appeals court in Nimes ruled that the case “appears to be well-founded in principle.”
“Only a person with a perfect knowledge of the art market is capable of mounting a sale through an auction house after having requested carbon-14 expertise [a scientific method used to determine the age of an artifact] and enlisted the help of an expert in African masks,” the couple stated.
The French court said that the case “appears to be well-founded in principle”
The defense, on the other hand, argued that Mr. Z “is a second-hand dealer and not an antique dealer and cannot be considered a valuation professional.”
According to Artnet News, the court has ordered the proceeds of the sale to be frozen until a verdict is reached.
Mr. Z has tried to settle the case out of court by offering to pay the elderly couple $315,000 in compensation, but the pair’s children opposed.
The defense, on the other hand, argued that Mr. Z is a “second-hand dealer and cannot be considered a valuation professional”
Image credits: Marie-Lan Nguyen (not the actual photo)
In the past, there’s been a similar situation in France that could hint at a possible resolution of the case. Owners of paintings by Nicolas Poussin, which were misattributed to another lesser-known painter, were able to obtain restitution after the art pieces were authenticated, Le Monde reported.
Most people defended the art dealer, saying that, unless he lied about the mask’s worth, he’s not guilty of anything
Value is determined by what people care about (not disregarding the rarity and history, just saying).
Your philosophical comment does not pay my rent, no matter how little I value the act of paying it.
Load More Replies...
It depends on who set the price. If the dealer mislead (and 99% of them will) they will have an uphill battle proving it. I buy from estate sales. If I find a bargain I can make a nice profit. They got their price, lucky me. I don't however, make offers on items I appraise, I'm USPAP certified and follow the ethics guidelines. No appraiser should be making an offer. But they do, and will steal whatever they can in a highly competitive business. Send pictures to Sotheby's or Christy's. They appraise for free in hopes of finding a treasure to auction.
If the art dealer had not been able to sell it for the amount he paid for it, would these people be prepared to give him his money back? Once you sell an item, it's gone, you have no further rights to it or the profits made from it.
Value is determined by what people care about (not disregarding the rarity and history, just saying).
Your philosophical comment does not pay my rent, no matter how little I value the act of paying it.
Load More Replies... It depends on who set the price. If the dealer mislead (and 99% of them will) they will have an uphill battle proving it. I buy from estate sales. If I find a bargain I can make a nice profit. They got their price, lucky me. I don't however, make offers on items I appraise, I'm USPAP certified and follow the ethics guidelines. No appraiser should be making an offer. But they do, and will steal whatever they can in a highly competitive business. Send pictures to Sotheby's or Christy's. They appraise for free in hopes of finding a treasure to auction.
If the art dealer had not been able to sell it for the amount he paid for it, would these people be prepared to give him his money back? Once you sell an item, it's gone, you have no further rights to it or the profits made from it.
43
11