Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
141
Man Refuses To Let Sterile Sister Adopt Late Sister’s Son After She Treats Her Like A Surrogate
Interview With ExpertPlanning for your own death is not something many people like to think about. But it’s super important, especially if you have young children. What will happen to them when you’re gone? Who will take care of them? How do you want them to be raised?
When one woman died suddenly, she left behind a 6-month-old baby. Her sister desperately wanted to adopt the little boy. But she wanted to raise him as her own, never telling him that his biological mother had died. Her brother blocked the adoption and applied to adopt the child himself. It’s caused massive family drama, and the brother is now wondering if he acted in the best interests of the baby. Bored Panda reached out to Cody Barbo to get some expert advice on protecting your children after your death. He’s the Founder and CEO of estate planning platform Trust & Will.
RELATED:
When this woman’s sister passed away, she didn’t think twice about adopting her orphaned baby
Image credits: Kristina Paukshtite/Pexels (not the actual photo)
But her joy at being a mom was short-lived when her brother contested the adoption
Image credits: Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels (not the actual photo)
Image credits: theowaway61016
Parents should ensure plans are in place for their children in the event of their own sudden or untimely death
Image credits: Mikhail Nilov/Pexels (not the actual photo)
An important part of drafting your Will is to nominate a legal guardian who will take care of your minor children if you die. Many times, it will be the other parent. But in some cases, like the man’s sister’s, this isn’t always possible.
“No-one wants to imagine the worst, but planning for it is one of the most loving and protective things a parent can do,” Trust & Will Founder and CEO, Cody Barbo tells Bored Panda during our chat. “Naming a legal guardian ensures your child is raised by someone you trust; someone who shares your values and will provide stability. Without documentation, that deeply personal decision is left up to the courts, and family conflict is far more likely.”
If you have nominated a guardian for your child or children, this person will be expected to take on full parental responsibilities. “A guardian is typically a trusted family member or friend who has agreed to take on this responsibility,” notes U.K.-based law firm LBMW.
“A Will-based estate plan typically includes naming a guardian for your minor children, along with a backup option. It should clearly express who you want to raise your child and any guidance for how you’d like them to be raised,” said Barbo. “At Trust & Will, parents can create a legally valid Will online in as little as 15 minutes — no complicated legal jargon, and no expensive attorney fees.”
LBMW adds that if both parents died without a guardian being appointed, the children may be taken into care until the court appoints a guardian. “In these cases, the court considers the welfare of the child above all else,” reads the site.
Barbo tells Bored Panda that most U.S. states follow a general order of priority, starting with immediate family. This is usually a surviving spouse, then grandparents, then adult siblings, aunts, or uncles. But the court isn’t bound by family ties alone, he says. “They consider who is ‘fit,’ available, and in the child’s best interest. Unfortunately, this process can take time and become emotionally charged, especially if family members disagree.”
The court will take into account things like the child’s age, emotional ties, and the stability of potential homes before deciding where to place the minor. There’s often a welfare checklist that’s used in order to assess the child’s needs. It goes without saying that this is a decision that’s not taken lightly.
According to The Legacy Lawyers’ site, a judge will review the potential guardian’s relationship with the child. They’ll also try to keep things as consistent as possible and not shake up the child’s routine too much. Ideally, depending on the child’s age, it’s preferred that school or child care routines remain the same, and that the minor still has access to, and gets to see or visit, extended family members.
A judge would also look for evidence of parenting ability when it comes to who takes guardianship. “The legal system works to make sure that the adult who receives custody is able to meet the child’s physical and emotional needs,” reads the legal site. “This includes long-term support for food, shelter, clothing, medical care, education, emotional support, and guidance until the children turn 18 years of age.”
The child’s safety and wellbeing is paramount, so the courts would have to consider the potential guardian’s physical and mental health. They’d look for any past records of violence, criminal activity, or use of substances. If the child is old enough, the might have a say in who is becomes their guardian “as long as the judge believes the choice makes good sense.”
When you’re drawing up your will and including a guardianship clause in it, make sure you’ve spoken to the person that you want to look after your child or children. And remember, it’s a massive responsibility and they have every right to refuse to take on the role.
“If multiple people petition for guardianship, or a named guardian is challenged, the court ultimately decides who should take custody based on what’s deemed to be in the best interest of the child,” Barbo told Bored Panda. “While courts do their best, there’s no guarantee they’ll choose the person you would have. That’s why it’s so critical to name a guardian in a legally recognized way.”
Barbo says besides ensuring they’ve nominated a guardian for minors, parents should also consider who will manage any inheritance for their children, how they’d like assets distributed, and whether a trust might be more appropriate.
“The best time to make a will is after any major life event — having a baby, buying a home, or getting married,” he advises. “But honestly, the best time is always before you think you need it.”
People had lots of questions and the man provided more info in the comments
“Sam’s a person, not an opportunity”: many felt the baby went to the right sibling
Some netizens felt the brother was selfish and should have allowed his sister to adopt Sam
The dilemma of whether to share the truth of a child’s biological background can present challenges, as highlighted in the struggle of the siblings over the newborn’s adoption. Similarly, understanding the psychological and emotional landscape of parental duties, especially when faced with unequal responsibilities, offers insight into these complex family dynamics. The story of a husband needing to step into the shoes of caregiving duties showcases the necessity for open communication and shared responsibilities in parenting.
Insights on handling shared parenting challenges can be found in cases of parental responsibilities that balance both individual and collective family needs.
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
What do you think ?
Joey Jo Jo Shabadoo 8 months ago
Not only was Amy planning on lying to the child, according to the OPs comments, she expected everyone in the family to lie to him too or she would cut them off. Putting aside what a disrespect thst is to her sister's memory, how would the kid feel when he learned the truth one day? The OP is giving the boy a better life.
LakotaWolf (she/her) 8 months ago
I'm an adopted child who found out at age 6, because I was snooping around through my parents' important papers upstairs. I found a photo of a woman holding a baby and it said "Crystal and Rose, 1982". I was like, "MY name is Crystal. I was born in 1982. Who's Rose?" So I asked my mom. She broke down crying and told me that I was adopted. The tl;dr of that situation is that I didn't care that I was adopted. But the point is that I found out - I GUARANTEE that Sam would have found out about Jane eventually, one way or the other. At the very least it would have come about when medical history questions about his paternal family came up, and even if Amy tried to keep up the lie, the truth WOULD eventually come out. And depending on how old Sam was at that point, it could have destroyed his trust in his adoptive parents for good. I can say that, as an adopted child, if my parents had tried to hide it from me/forced others to lie about it, I would never forgive them once I found out.
Load More Replies...
Monsen 8 months ago (edited)
Sister is disgusting. Almost seems she is happy someone - her younger sibling - died, so she can have a baby and play pretend. She is not mentally healthy and should look for other options coping with her grief smh
Royal Stray 8 months ago
Yeah, I'm wondering if it really was due to her husbands crime when he was 19 they had issues, and not because they deemed her a poor fit for adoption. If it was over the crime it must have been something relatively serious as a minor crime wouldn't cause this much trouble
Load More Replies...
FreeTheUnicorn 8 months ago
Anyone who would hide a person's own adoption from them is going to be a bad parent. Someone who would erase a sibling from their family is sick and vindictive. Sam would is lucky he had another option.
Joey Jo Jo Shabadoo 8 months ago
Not only was Amy planning on lying to the child, according to the OPs comments, she expected everyone in the family to lie to him too or she would cut them off. Putting aside what a disrespect thst is to her sister's memory, how would the kid feel when he learned the truth one day? The OP is giving the boy a better life.
LakotaWolf (she/her) 8 months ago
I'm an adopted child who found out at age 6, because I was snooping around through my parents' important papers upstairs. I found a photo of a woman holding a baby and it said "Crystal and Rose, 1982". I was like, "MY name is Crystal. I was born in 1982. Who's Rose?" So I asked my mom. She broke down crying and told me that I was adopted. The tl;dr of that situation is that I didn't care that I was adopted. But the point is that I found out - I GUARANTEE that Sam would have found out about Jane eventually, one way or the other. At the very least it would have come about when medical history questions about his paternal family came up, and even if Amy tried to keep up the lie, the truth WOULD eventually come out. And depending on how old Sam was at that point, it could have destroyed his trust in his adoptive parents for good. I can say that, as an adopted child, if my parents had tried to hide it from me/forced others to lie about it, I would never forgive them once I found out.
Load More Replies... Monsen 8 months ago (edited)
Sister is disgusting. Almost seems she is happy someone - her younger sibling - died, so she can have a baby and play pretend. She is not mentally healthy and should look for other options coping with her grief smh
Royal Stray 8 months ago
Yeah, I'm wondering if it really was due to her husbands crime when he was 19 they had issues, and not because they deemed her a poor fit for adoption. If it was over the crime it must have been something relatively serious as a minor crime wouldn't cause this much trouble
Load More Replies... FreeTheUnicorn 8 months ago
Anyone who would hide a person's own adoption from them is going to be a bad parent. Someone who would erase a sibling from their family is sick and vindictive. Sam would is lucky he had another option.
You May Like Woman Is Made To Choose Between Work And Husband's Family, Picks Her Career: "Just Figure It Out" "AITA For Telling My Wife We Can Adopt Her Nephews But Not Her Niece?": Family Chaos Erupts Over Troubled Kids MIL Demands Son Leaves Pregnant Wife Alone During Holidays, Is Baffled He Says 'No'
Jonas Žvilius
Greta Jaruševičiūtė
Mantas Kačerauskas
Related on Bored Panda
54
46