Man Refuses To Pay His Stepdaughter For The Cake She Baked For His Birthday, Family Drama Ensues
Family is important to us at every stage of life. Life is much easier when you have loving people supporting you through thick and thin.
So when Reddit user F54tughi556 wanted to pay her daughter for a cake she baked, the woman thought she was encouraging the teen’s passion.
But her husband (the man who was celebrating his birthday for which the cake was made), thought the compensation would be teaching the girl that all relationships are transactional. And that’s not something he believes. So he refused to do so.
After hearing her husband’s negative response, the woman sold the present she got for him and gave the money to her daughter. The couple got into a huge fight, and it made the woman reconsider her actions. Eventually, she made a post on the ‘Am I the [Jerk]’ subreddit, asking if she was in the wrong.
This man was about to celebrate his 45th birthday, but his wife wanted him to pay for the cake his stepdaughter had baked him
Image credits: Xiang Gao (not the actual photo)
After he refused, the woman sold the gift she had bought for him and gave the money to her daughter
Image credits: Philip Lindvall (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Timur Weber (not the actual photo)
Image credits: F54tughi556
Experts believe that while you should not feel that you have to “pay” for every good thing your teen does, reinforcement of good behavior will help ensure that it continues. It shows that you notice when your teen is being good and not just when they do something wrong.
Possible teen rewards include:
- A hug. This simple gesture can mean more than we normally think;
- A subscription. Maybe they have a favorite magazine that will reduce their screen time or there is a streaming service they have wanted to start using;
- Car privileges. Even an extra hour or two of car privileges will allow them to stay at the mall or coffee shop a little longer with their friends;
- Concert tickets. If your teen is dying to see their favorite band that is coming to town, you can reward them with a pair of tickets and let them invite a friend to attend the show with them;
- Extended curfew. Similar to prolonged car privileges, an additional hour on their weekend curfew can help establish trust;
- Redesigned bedroom. A teenager’s bedroom is their place in the house and it is always nice to move furniture around or add a fresh feel to the decor as they grow up.
But of course, there’s a difference between being rewarded for your good behavior and expecting your parents to virtually employ you.
After her story went viral, the original poster (OP) explained that her daughter gets her allowance from her, and that the teen did actually expect to get paid for the cake
Among the hottest of parenting debates is whether or not you should pay your kids to do chores, with plenty of reasonable and valid arguments on both sides.
At the end of the day, it’s “a deeply personal decision, and every family should do what fits their unique financial situation,” says Ksenia Yudina, CFA, founder and CEO of UNest, a service that helps families save for college. “But it can be a great way to start teaching your kids about the value of money and instill healthy financial habits from an early age.”
In fact, studies have shown that children begin to grasp the concept of money by age three and that many of their money habits are set by age seven. So parents do need to start teaching their kids about these things as soon as possible in one way or the other. By the time they’re sixteen, it can be incredibly hard to change their ways.
People almost unanimously said that the woman was in the wrong
With a few thinking that “everyone sucks here”
I have a feeling that this is a symptom of a larger problem in the marriage. It doesn't make sense on its own why this should be a big deal. And the daughter didn't ask to be paid, anyway. I wonder if it might have to do with the dynamics of being a blended family. That maybe she feels that he does not treat *her* daughter fairly. This argument seems like a proxy for something else that we don't know about. Frankly I suspect what is needed is marital counseling to get the root of the problem.
If my partner tried to retrospectively charge me for my birthday cake and then sold the gift they gave me, I would be thinking that they perhaps shouldn't be a partner, and I'd save the counselling money.
Load More Replies...
Oh man! All the money I could have made over the years... It just never occurred to me to charge my brothers, Mom, Dad, friends, friends' kids etc for the cakes I've baked them. Dann, I could've made a killing 😅😅😅 But in all seriousness, unless you own a bakery and bake a cake for a costumer (which wasn't the case here), a cake is a gift 🍰
I knowwww. I bake for our friends/relatives, my mum decorates, we coulda been rich. We're a large family
Load More Replies...
I have a feeling that this is a symptom of a larger problem in the marriage. It doesn't make sense on its own why this should be a big deal. And the daughter didn't ask to be paid, anyway. I wonder if it might have to do with the dynamics of being a blended family. That maybe she feels that he does not treat *her* daughter fairly. This argument seems like a proxy for something else that we don't know about. Frankly I suspect what is needed is marital counseling to get the root of the problem.
If my partner tried to retrospectively charge me for my birthday cake and then sold the gift they gave me, I would be thinking that they perhaps shouldn't be a partner, and I'd save the counselling money.
Load More Replies... Oh man! All the money I could have made over the years... It just never occurred to me to charge my brothers, Mom, Dad, friends, friends' kids etc for the cakes I've baked them. Dann, I could've made a killing 😅😅😅 But in all seriousness, unless you own a bakery and bake a cake for a costumer (which wasn't the case here), a cake is a gift 🍰
I knowwww. I bake for our friends/relatives, my mum decorates, we coulda been rich. We're a large family
Load More Replies... 
45
192