Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
Bio Mom Is Livid After Stepmom Tells Her Daughters They Have No Claim To Her Wedding Dress
Raising step-children is in a league of its own, but most people would agree that rule number 1 is “treat them like you would your own children.” So when a young stepdaughter, full of hope, asks if she can one day wear your wedding dress, it should feel like a beautiful sign of acceptance.
How you answer that delicate question can instantly draw a line between ‘family’ and ‘bio-family,’ turning a moment of bonding into a lesson in biological hierarchy. One mom learned the hard way that she would need to take a few lessons in equality before her new baby arrives.
More info: Reddit
RELATED:
In a blended family, the question of ‘who gets what’ can be a deeply emotional one that will hurt people’s feelings no matter what
Image credits: beststudio / Freepik (not the actual photo)
A pregnant stepmom was asked by her two stepdaughters if they could one day have her wedding dress and rings for their own weddings
Image credits: Alan Zimmerman / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
She explained that her future biological child would get “first dibs” on heirlooms because of their “DNA”
Image credits: EyeEm / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Her honest answer left the girls heartbroken and ignited a massive, family-wide argument with their mother
Image credits: Some-Tea6877
The stepmom, supported by her husband, stood firm, believing she was right to prioritize her future bio-kids
A heartwarming moment of family bonding took a sharp turn into a lesson on genetics and inheritance. While looking through photo albums with her two stepdaughters, aged 13 and 11, the pregnant stepmom was met with a series of sweet, innocent questions. The stepdaughters, clearly enamored with her, asked if they could one day have her wedding dress and heirloom rings for their own weddings.
Instead of a simple, non-committal answer, the stepmom “softly” explained her inheritance policy: her future biological daughter would get “first dibs” on everything. Her reasoning was that the items were a part of her bio-kid’s “DNA,” and she suggested the girls ask their own mother for heirlooms. This, predictably, left the two young girls feeling deflated, and the sweet moment was officially over.
The sadness quickly turned to anger when the girls went home and reported the conversation to their mother. The bio-mom called, furious, asking why a “new kid” should get priority over the daughters her husband had been raising for years. The stepmom doubled down, repeating that her bio-kids would always have first claim and that it wasn’t her problem if their own mother had no heirlooms to pass down.
Now, everyone in the family is mad, everyone except her husband, that is. She’s left feeling guilty but also standing firm in her belief that she’s in the right. She’s asking the internet if she’s the jerk for drawing a clear, DNA-based line between her biological children and the stepdaughters she’s helping to raise.
Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)
The stepmother’s comment about her biological child having “first dibs” due to “DNA” tapped into one of the deepest and most painful insecurities for children in stepfamilies: the feeling of being a second-tier family member. Research published in the McGill Law Journal highlights that the legal and emotional definition of “family” is complex, and in stepfamilies, children often grapple with where they truly belong.
By creating a clear biological hierarchy for something as emotionally significant as heirlooms, she reinforced the very fears her stepdaughters likely already have. The arrival of a “mutual child is a notoriously delicate time that can further exacerbate these feelings of insecurity.
The parenting charity Family Lives explains that it’s common for existing children to feel pushed out or less important when a new baby arrives. The stepmother’s comment, made while she is pregnant was not just a statement about a dress. It was a more declaration of a new family order where her biological child will have a higher status, confirming her stepdaughters’ worst fears at a uniquely vulnerable moment.
This was a situation where a “prosocial lie” (a white lie told to benefit others) would have been the far kinder and more effective approach. Research on lying and deception in social contexts shows that these small, harmless falsehoods are often used to maintain social harmony and protect others’ feelings.
Instead of her brutally honest and hurtful answer, a simple, non-committal response like, “That’s such a sweet thought, but we have a long time to think about that!” would have preserved the heartwarming moment, validated her stepdaughter’s feelings of belonging, and avoided a massive, unnecessary family conflict.
Do you think she did the right thing by drawing a DNA-centered line, or could a little white lie have been more appropriate given the children’s age? Share your thoughts below!
The internet, however, widely condemned her for creating a painful “bio vs. step” hierarchy in her family, and says she could have played along given that children’s young age
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
Explore more of these tags
What do you think ?
sweet emotion 1 month ago
She could have glossed over the whole thing by being flattered that the girl wanted to look like her and sidetracked them with stories of the wedding. Or she could have said that they would discuss it again when each girl is engaged. The vision of a wedding will likely change dramatically from age 13 to age 20/30-something. There just wasn't any need at this early date to give a hard "no" along with a brutal lesson on the place of step-kids in the hierarchy of blended families.
Zoe Vokes 1 month ago
She’s 13. OP definitely should have said that they’ll talk about it later when she gets engaged but that step daughter will probably want her own dress in her own style. I doubt it would have been an issue. Maybe step daughter or any unborn children won’t want to get married, won’t want a big wedding, will have a different fashion style… OP just made step children feel second best before the baby is even born. They’ll remember this forever and it will affect their relationships with OP and maybe the baby
Load More Replies...
Crystal M 1 month ago
I was the stepchild. My half sister was born when I was 8 and I was treated as hired help. Babysitting, cleaning, cooking, etc. The only thing I wanted from my step-family was validation and kindness, possibly love. These children are too young to understand the dynamic. OP could and should have been more gentle and kind. She's instilling rejection and resentment.
Janelle Collard 1 month ago
I agree with the "OP should have kicked this down the road" comments. Those 2 girls didn't need to hear right now that OP will always consider her bio-kids over them. OP can *think* it all she wants, but to blurt it out like that??? YTA.
sweet emotion 1 month ago
She could have glossed over the whole thing by being flattered that the girl wanted to look like her and sidetracked them with stories of the wedding. Or she could have said that they would discuss it again when each girl is engaged. The vision of a wedding will likely change dramatically from age 13 to age 20/30-something. There just wasn't any need at this early date to give a hard "no" along with a brutal lesson on the place of step-kids in the hierarchy of blended families.
Zoe Vokes 1 month ago
She’s 13. OP definitely should have said that they’ll talk about it later when she gets engaged but that step daughter will probably want her own dress in her own style. I doubt it would have been an issue. Maybe step daughter or any unborn children won’t want to get married, won’t want a big wedding, will have a different fashion style… OP just made step children feel second best before the baby is even born. They’ll remember this forever and it will affect their relationships with OP and maybe the baby
Load More Replies... Crystal M 1 month ago
I was the stepchild. My half sister was born when I was 8 and I was treated as hired help. Babysitting, cleaning, cooking, etc. The only thing I wanted from my step-family was validation and kindness, possibly love. These children are too young to understand the dynamic. OP could and should have been more gentle and kind. She's instilling rejection and resentment.
Janelle Collard 1 month ago
I agree with the "OP should have kicked this down the road" comments. Those 2 girls didn't need to hear right now that OP will always consider her bio-kids over them. OP can *think* it all she wants, but to blurt it out like that??? YTA.
You May Like MIL Tries To Outsmart Bride And Take Over The Wedding, Mother Nature Says “Not Today” “Spiritual Awakening”: 49 People Who Canceled Their Wedding Last Minute Explain What Happened Oldest Son Feels Left Out By Dad Who Taught Only Half-Siblings A Skill That Helped Start Business
Viktorija Ošikaitė
Gabija Palšytė
Rūta Zumbrickaitė
Related on Bored Panda
35
15