Side By Side Comparisons Of The Real Chernobyl Vs. The HBO Version Of It (20 pics)
The majority of us have probably already seen or at least heard of the HBO series, Chernobyl. The show was acclaimed by critics and scored a rating of 9.7 stars out of 10 on IMDB, making it the highest-rated TV show on the platform. Many view the series as a TV masterpiece, which was loosely based on Voices of Chernobyl, a book written by Belarusian Nobel laureate Svetlana Alexievich. In addition to this, people who have lived in the former Soviet Union are praising the creators of Chernobyl for putting enough effort to recreate the chain of events and the environment itself as accurately as possible. Recently, a video essayist Thomas Flight made a fascinating video that does a side by side comparison of the footage from the series with the real videos that were captured during the aftermath of the Chernobyl disaster. Scroll down below to see the screenshots from real as well as fictional footage and don't forget to vote for the best of then and now!
More info: Thomas Flight
This post may include affiliate links.
So much time and effort went into this, amazing that the truth is shown for all to see. May we never have the misery of what the first responders and the rest of the country endured.
A great deal of truth was not provided though like what happened to not just the soldiers, miners and liquidators but also to the entire population of Kiev whose 3 million citizens were either not informed or forced (if they knew) to take part in a huge holiday labor parade thereby getting even more exposure to high levels of radiation as the wind had shifted and a radiation cloud was over the city AND what happened to all the 1 million babies born after their mothers were exposed... not just the deformities but also how the poor little things were cared for throughout the rest of the days that they were alive!! (Many were put in mental institutions even if their mental capacities were unaffected!!) Russian government officials didn't bother to keep records of any of these outcomes and I am sure that was on purpose in order to avoid as much accountability as possible!!
Load More Replies...The Soviets mainly reacted the same way the Americans did on September 11 - a series of previous mistakes, disbelief, confusion, chaos, the firefighters sent to death, self-sacrifice, numerous casualty...
I remember the accident, my father who is a physicist carried with him a Geiger meter checking every day our thyroid gland for radiation. In Greece, where I am from, the radiation cloud reached us and while my country is far away from Ukraine many believe that we are still struggling with the effects of the accident, in forms of various cancer diseases, as probably Easter European countries do too.
The Chernobyl disaster was a devastating nuclear plant accident that occurred on April 26, 1986 at the No. 4 nuclear reactor in the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant near the city of Pripyat in the north of Ukraine (then - Ukrainian SSR).
Only different time (it happened 6 months after the explosion) and it fell because it hit a crane, not becasue of malfunction caused by radiation or anything, like the show seemed to imply.
Load More Replies...Yes - the show does imply it's from radiation, and downplays the part where the chopper hit the cable - but it does clearly show the helicopter hitting a cable. I'm OK with a little bit of "Editorial Liberty" on this one - there were conditions and threats that needed to be communicated to the viewer - and this was a good way of making the point.
So naive those poor people😭then the cover up of the amount of radiation too I was horrified.
Yeah, all radioactive and that! Bloody hell. Show some respect! This was a real and terrifying accident that easily could have become much, much worse. For many of the people affected by it, the outcome could NOT have become any worse - they died an early death because of it.
Load More Replies...To this date, Chernobyl is the biggest nuclear accident to have occurred, or as others put it - the worst man-made accident. The true cost of it is still unknown. Many people were affected directly, but even more of them - indirectly.
Bored panda is wrong. There was a six wheeler robot. https://youtu.be/aLUzbAzdBPc @13:45
Load More Replies...It's interesting that most of these have such attention to detail to make everything exactly the same, but this one is stark in its difference. I wonder why they left the mask off? I can think of a few reasons, but none of them seem worth it to me.
Most likely to capture his facial expressions.
Load More Replies...I think they might have done it in order to emphasize the tragic lack of any effective protection means back then. They were exposed to massive doses of radiation and most of them died within few years from the event.
It's not Legasov on the bottom, it's a completely different person.
Most of them didn't wear any cause they didn't have time to put it on. They just did their job to save others. Check the Wikipedia article about the disaster 👍 It's creepy and sad at the same time.
Load More Replies...So..when will the rest of the billions of us non-HBO subscribers get to see this marvel of make believe? Why not simply show the original documentary to us all?
There's been a few of them on Discovery Channel, many times.
Load More Replies...Didn't they just use the original feed? All broadcast are recorded so the probably have a copy of it and played it on an old VCR.
me too.....I cried when he reported the plane crash in PA on 9/11
Load More Replies...In the HBO series, one of the central characters is Ulana Khomyuk, the scientist from the Belarusian Institute for Nuclear Energy. However, Ulana is fictional, but was based on any scientists that were trying to unravel the real truth behind the Chernobyl disaster. However, it certainly wouldn't be odd to have a woman nuclear scientist in the Soviet Union even at that time as the USSR had an impressive record of training women for STEM roles.
yeah, those that had to 'volunteer' and go on the roofs were royally screwed.
Load More Replies...https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_disaster
Load More Replies...This dude! The job to tell them, 'Hey, Thanks for putting your lives at risk because of incompetence,' had to mess with him.
Bonus was like $30. USD at the time - which to them was a big deal!!! And that's sad.
The second crime here is the failure of what's left of the USSR to fully acknowledge the rest of the deaths from their accident. They acknowledge something like 38 - and that's it. How many, if any, of the hundreds who did their "time" on the roof are still alive today? How many Firefighters? The 'bridge people' are all gone... And of the survivors - how many are fighting cancers?
Apparently the official death toll is 31-52. And that's not changed since the 80's.
But this is a comparison article, what were you expecting?
Load More Replies...Interestingly enough, one of the most realistic depictions in the show was an elderly Bolshevik Zharkov. Although fictional, Zharkov perfectly conveys the Soviet politics and ideology. Moments after the disaster, he is encouraging his comrades to not spread "misinformation," which basically means that no one should tell anything to the public. "No one leaves. And cut the phone lines. Contain the spread of misinformation," he says in the show.
They raised the red flag as a symbol of finished work there. So it was the same act as raising the flag on Ivo Jima or on the moon.
Load More Replies...The flag is a zoom in on the lighthouse itself
Load More Replies...Sad and moving to think that even such a small detail as how far the water got was significant for those living through it. They might have wished for those glorious jets...
right one actually could be true for some cars depending on the engineer who's after it. The Russian technique is very tricky at that point - a rough/strong and decent-minded (also - often - creative) person is all it needs. Plus, the driver's devotion matters a lot too - he could go slower and push the engine closer to the limit but it would take more time - but people haven't been educated or at least told that it would do huge impact to threat (which was also kept in secret from public for a long time)
Load More Replies...I don't understand how spraying the radiation with water helps do anything. The radiation soaks in it doesn't just sit on the surface. It seems like maybe the water was just to make everyone feel better while actually only contaminating the water as well, which would then soak into the ground.
Usually the radiation is coming from radioactive dust particles and debris, the water washes those down the storm sewers.
Load More Replies...I still can't believe that is Stellan Skarsgård. Bill Anderson from Mamma Mia. Father to abusive Perry from BLL and Penniwise the clown.
Don't forget he is also the Father of Alexander Skarsgard the most beautiful man on the Planet. Ed
Load More Replies...This is an amazing book about Chernobyl. https://smile.amazon.co.uk/Chernobyl-Prayer-Chronicle-Penguin-Classics/dp/0241270537/ref=sr_1_4?crid=124PBW4D8RJL2&keywords=chernobyl+book&qid=1560717629&s=gateway&sprefix=chernob%2Caps%2C238&sr=8-4
The original book "Voices of Chernobyl" is what the writer of this HBO special based it on though the book cited above is "A new translation of Voices from Chernobyl based on the revised text -" per that website where it is sold.
Load More Replies...Natalie Utko surely you are a troll.... while it isn't a documentary, the writer and producers did their best to show the realities of the situation most everyone found themselves in during the years long aftermath of this MAN MADE RUSSIAN disaster. It is sad that it didn't take it as far as it could have and showed what that aftermath entailed in the lives of the citizens who were unlucky to be anywhere close to that reactor!! a great deal of the truth of the aftermath was not provided as in what happened to not just the soldiers, miners and liquidators but also to the entire population of Kiev whose 3 million citizens were either not informed or forced (if they knew or suspected) to take part in a huge holiday labor parade thereby getting even more exposure to high levels of radiation as the wind had shifted and a radiation cloud appeared over the city with some of the highest levels of radiation there were!! ...
AND what happened to all the 1 million babies born after their mothers were exposed... not just the deformities but also how the poor little things were cared for throughout the rest of the days that they were alive!! (Many were put in mental institutions even if their mental capacities were unaffected!!) Russian government officials didn't bother to keep records of any of these outcomes and I am sure that was on purpose in order to avoid as much accountability as possible!!
Load More Replies...still - very culture-banal understanding caused it to be a bit off from reality in some actually decent aspects. but yes, good job and closer than most of the shows.
Load More Replies...And also the background is WOW!!! The work on the details of the show was just tremendous. It's unbelievable how exact was the depiction of everyday stuff in american show. I was born in Ukraine in 1984, husband is 9 years older and we couldn't keep saying every few minutes "Look, that thing, that furniture, that cup, that nightgown (etc) - like my mum had in the 80-s!!! - but how did they found it???" Just absolutely amazing job and such attention to every insignificant detail of all the scenes. It's like a time-machine to my childhood. Never seen smth like that even in our films or shows
We remembered D Day,but we should also remember the people who gave they're lives to save us. with the same egards .Why don't we remember them? Maybe this series is an eyeopener.
I have just finished it, very well, done, gripping (even though i knew the story), absolutely recommended watching. Emily Watson was amazing in it.
Всичко в този сериал е толкова автентично! Върна ме в онова ужасно време! Плаках на всички епизоди.
I was born in Poland just a few months before this catastrophe and as I get older I have more and more health issues that are most likely cause by radioactive cloud from Chernobyl back then. it's kinda wild to think that how I am now is because of that. Can't imagine how people who were living close to it are doing.
still - very culture-banal understanding caused it to be a bit off from reality in some actually decent aspects. but yes, good job and closer than most of the shows.
Load More Replies...And also the background is WOW!!! The work on the details of the show was just tremendous. It's unbelievable how exact was the depiction of everyday stuff in american show. I was born in Ukraine in 1984, husband is 9 years older and we couldn't keep saying every few minutes "Look, that thing, that furniture, that cup, that nightgown (etc) - like my mum had in the 80-s!!! - but how did they found it???" Just absolutely amazing job and such attention to every insignificant detail of all the scenes. It's like a time-machine to my childhood. Never seen smth like that even in our films or shows
We remembered D Day,but we should also remember the people who gave they're lives to save us. with the same egards .Why don't we remember them? Maybe this series is an eyeopener.
I have just finished it, very well, done, gripping (even though i knew the story), absolutely recommended watching. Emily Watson was amazing in it.
Всичко в този сериал е толкова автентично! Върна ме в онова ужасно време! Плаках на всички епизоди.
I was born in Poland just a few months before this catastrophe and as I get older I have more and more health issues that are most likely cause by radioactive cloud from Chernobyl back then. it's kinda wild to think that how I am now is because of that. Can't imagine how people who were living close to it are doing.
