Woman Doesn’t Trust Her Marriage After Husband Becomes Adamant About Naming Their Baby After Late GF

For some, grief softens with time, and for others, it lingers as a quiet presence in every chapter that follows.

Reddit user Cassievvvah thought she could make peace with her husband’s memories of his late girlfriend. Before they married, he was upfront about how much she had meant to him before she passed away.

But now, as the couple prepares to welcome their first child, that trust has been shaken. Her husband wants to name the baby after his ex, and he isn’t letting the idea go.

Can you ever really move on after losing the love of your life?

Man in suit sitting on stairs with hands on head, looking stressed over naming baby after first girlfriend and upsetting wife

Image credits: Vitaly Gariev / unsplash (not the actual photo)

This woman started to worry about how much her husband was still holding on to the past

Text excerpt about husband losing his first girlfriend at 21 and wanting to name baby after her, upsetting wife.

Text about man losing his first girlfriend, naming baby after her, and upsetting his wife in a personal story.

Text excerpt about husband wanting to name baby Emmy or Grace after his first girlfriend, upsetting wife.

Text excerpt about naming a baby after a first girlfriend, highlighting man, first GF, and wife upset.

Baby lying under a purple blanket, representing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife.

Image credits: Jonathan Borba / unsplash (not the actual photo)

Man upset his wife by wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend he lost at 21 years old.

Text excerpt discussing a man insisting on using his first girlfriend’s name as a middle name for his baby, upsetting his wife.

Text on a white background stating someone said only a jealous person would hesitate to use it as they do.

Text about man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, causing upset with his wife.

Text showing a man losing his first girlfriend at 21 and later wanting to name his baby after her, upsetting his wife.

Upset wife sitting on bed looking away while man lies down, reflecting tension over baby name and first girlfriend.

Image credits: Vitaly Gariev / unsplash (not the actual photo)

Text excerpt discussing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, causing upset with his wife.

Text excerpt about emotional confession and feelings, relating to man losing first girlfriend and naming baby after her.

Alt text: Text about a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife years later.

Text expressing insecurity in marriage after husband wants to name baby after his first girlfriend, causing upset in wife.

Young woman in a yellow sweater sitting by a window, appearing thoughtful and upset about relationship struggles.

Image credits: Getty Images / unsplash (not the actual photo)

Text excerpt about a man upset over naming his baby after his first girlfriend upsetting his wife, highlighting relationship conflict.

Text showing a wife questioning her husband about upsetting her by naming their baby after his first girlfriend at 21.

Image credits: Cassievvvah

Turns out, a lot of people try to name their children after their exes

Image credits: Kelly Sikkema / unsplash (not the actual photo)

A few years ago, Instagram model Sumner Stroh alleged that she not only had an affair with Maroon 5’s vocalist Adam Levine, but that a few months later, he messaged her out of nowhere, saying his wife was pregnant.

According to Stroh’s screenshots, Levine’s text said: “Ok serious question. I’m having another baby and if it’s [a] boy I really wanna name it Sumner. You ok with that?”

The singer later released a statement denying the affair. “I used poor judgment in speaking with anyone other than my wife in ANY kind of flirtatious manner. I did not have an affair, nevertheless, I crossed the line during a regrettable period in my life,” it read.

Levine said that “in certain instances it became inappropriate,” but that he had “addressed that and taken proactive steps to remedy this with my family.”

Following these developments, many women tweeted, revealing that they, too, had been named after their dad’s exes, “the other woman,” or old crushes.

Even the woman behind this story didn’t see it coming

Reddit conversation about a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife and counseling advice.

Screenshot of a relationship forum discussing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife.

Screenshot of online discussion about man losing his first girlfriend, naming baby after her, and upsetting his wife.

Comments discussing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend at 21, upsetting his wife.

Screenshot of an online discussion about a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife.

Screenshot of an online conversation where a commenter questions having a child with a man causing upset over baby naming.

Screenshot of a Reddit conversation discussing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend and upsetting his wife.

Experts say couples should extensively discuss baby names as they’re getting ready to have one

Image credits: Getty Images / unsplash (not the actual photo)

HuffPost asked two experts to share their thoughts on the topic, and baby name consultant Taylor A. Humphrey said that it’s typically the women who are the name innovators in the relationship. Men aren’t thinking about the significance as much.

“In my business, I’ve noticed that women tend to be more dialed into the realm of possibility when it comes to names,” she explained.

“As connective and communal creatures, women have friends, sisters, and cousins who are having babies and are more likely to take note of what those children’s names are, giving them vast reserves of creativity when it comes to naming their own children.”

Men, on the other hand, tend to consider what they’ve heard before, which includes who they’ve interacted with and what they’ve grown comfortable with.

“It’s why they’re more likely to recommend an ex’s name if they had a positive association with that person,” Humphrey said. “It’s a way of transferring their positive memories from one person onto their offspring.”

Pamela Redmond, the CEO of baby naming site Nameberry, thinks cases like this one highlight why it’s a good idea to compile a list of names that are strictly off-limits.

“People rule out names associated with a creepy kid from fourth grade or an unappealing literary character, so why not an ex?” Redmond said.

“It doesn’t matter how nice the name is, I don’t think you should use an ex for a baby, period,” she added. “You may not have residual feelings, but the name still has … strong associations that are very different for both parents, and that can cause future conflicts.”

Most of those who read the woman’s confession believe she’s not overreacting

Reddit comment discussing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife.

Comment discussing man losing his first girlfriend at 21 and upsetting wife by wanting to name baby after her.

Screenshot of an online discussion about a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife.

Comment text on a social media post discussing a man losing his first girlfriend at 21 and later upsetting his wife by wanting to name his baby after her.

Reddit comment discussing emotional impact of a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife.

Reddit comment discussing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife.

Screenshot of a heated online discussion about a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend, upsetting his wife.

Comment expressing anger and advice about divorce and baby naming conflict after man wants to name baby after first girlfriend.

Comment discussing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend and upsetting his wife over naming.

Text post discussing a man upset wife by wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend at 21.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend and upsetting his wife.

Comment discussing a man who lost his first girlfriend at 21 and causing issues by wanting to name baby after her.

Alt text: Man upset as wife refuses to name baby after his deceased girlfriend, causing tension and need for therapy support.

Comment discussing using the name of a first girlfriend for a baby, relating to man losing first GF at 21 and upset wife.

Comment discussing that children should not carry parents' feelings or be named in a way that causes discomfort or resentment.

Some, however, think she should compromise

Reddit discussion about man losing first girlfriend and wanting to name baby after her, upsetting his wife over grief and respect.

Screenshot of a forum comment saying YTA and mentioning honesty, related to man losing his first GF and baby name conflict.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing a man naming his baby after his first girlfriend and upsetting his wife.

Reddit comment about a man wanting to name his baby after his first girlfriend and upsetting his wife.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!