Drastic actions are taken when the face behind a character seems out of place. Creative teams usually recast actors and actresses to fix the problem at hand. Sometimes it happens days before production starts — on rare occasions, in the middle of filming. Even good actors and actresses get replaced when the feeling isn’t quite right. Reasons can vary from drastic ones to more minor, petty ones.
Sometimes, the vibe just isn’t there. If the chemistry in the movies or TV series isn’t there, characters could be recast at the snap of a finger. Sometimes, the decision is the correct one, other times — it is the wrong one. Even iconic movie characters are victims of recasting. For example, the classic Back to the Future cast had several changes, some of which happened before the second movie production started and involved the main characters we have come to universally love.
We have compiled the most famous recasting decisions in movies and TV shows. With the list below, you can find out how recasting Game of Thrones characters came to reality and much more. If you think the recasting decision was correct, upvote it. If you had another actor or actress in mind for the role, share it with a comment below.
This post may include affiliate links.
Stuart Townsend As Aragorn In "The Lord Of The Rings" Movies, Replaced By Viggo Mortensen
When production for Lord of the Rings began, Stuart Townsend, a relatively unknown actor in the business, barely lasted a few days as Aragorn. When the director realized Townsend was too young to play the Strider, he quickly cast Viggo Mortenson, who delivered a truly legendary performance.
Stuart Townsend definitley was too thin in the face to be Aragorn. Maybe he could've been an elf instead but Viggo defintiley tops him.
Heath Ledger As Tony In "The Imaginarium Of Doctor Parnassus", Replaced By Johnny Depp, Colin Farrell And Jude Law
To replace the talent that is Heath Ledger, three actors had to portray the character of Tony in The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus. With Heath Ledger passing away, leaving a part of the movie unfilmed, Depp, Farrell, and Law portrayed Tony in a way that highlights the story. Ultimately, the movie is a tribute to Heath Ledger.
That was nice that they finished movie in honor of Heath and it turned out pretty good.
None of the guys that "replaced" Heath accepted payment for the roles, either. IIRC, the money they would have made went to Heath's family instead. They all showed the utmost of class and generosity when they accepted their respective roles.
Load More Replies...And as poor Mr Ledger had died without updating his will to include his young daughter, his three friends who helped complete the movie donated their salaries to little Matilda Ledger. :)
I thought I couldn't like these actors even more... I know they aren't hurting for money but the intent goes far
Load More Replies...Sylvester Stallone As Axel Foley In "Beverly Hills Cop", Replaced By Eddie Murphy
Sylvester Stallone sought to change the screenplay when he got chosen to play Axel Foley. His character would have had more heroism, making Alex a legitimate action hero. The perspective was dismissed, and Eddie Murphy, who gave the movie its distinct charm, took Stallone's place.
I can't think of a Sylvester Stallone movie that wouldn't be improved by replacing him with Eddie Murphy. Rocky fans - I know you'll hate me for saying it - but think about it for a minute and you'll realize that I'm right.
Load More Replies...Wow. Those movies were part of my childhood. I don't think I would've liked them if Stallone was Foley. Eddie Murphy was just great in those movies; he was hilarious
I like this one. White guy replaced by black guy and it's not an issue. Is Foley's colour ever mentioned?
Yes, every time a list like this goes up. You are the one this time.
Load More Replies...Eric Stoltz As Marty McFly In "Back To The Future", Replaced By Michael J. Fox
Marty McFly wouldn't be the iconic character without the involvement of Michael J. Fox. Because of scheduling conflicts, Eric Stoltz got cast as Marty. However, his portrayal of the character and overall bad comedic timing was not quite what director Robert Zemeckis was looking for, and he effectively got recast.
There's a whole "The Movies That Made Us" episode that explains all this and why it happened. It's really interesting and I recommend that show, it's on Netflix.
I read that they wanted Michael J. Fox from the very start, but they couldn't get him and had to cast someone else or lose the money to make the film.
The "scheduling ties" they're speaking about was Micheal J. Fox figuring out how to do Family Ties and Back to the Future.
Eric was too serious of an actor as well. Michael brought the comedic aspects they wanted.
Actually they filings a majority of the film with that guy. MJ Fox was always their first pick, but due to his other roles and work the his schedule was not allowing him. So, toward majority of filming they had Fox come make the movie while he was going back and forth in between all of his other works. The original guy's take on Marty made BTTF look like a dystopian sad outlook. Fox changed all of that.
Wait when did he replace him? There was only 3 back to the futures? Was there a fourth?
I think they filmed a few weeks of the first movie and it just wasn't working with Stoltz .. then came MJFox and saved the movie
Load More Replies...Dougray Scott As Wolverine In "X-Men", Replaced By Hugh Jackman
The Wolverine we know and love today is usually the one portrayed by Jackman, but Dougray Scott, who was already pretty well-known in 1999, was slated to play the gruff hero. Hugh Jackman got the part when Scott's other movie took longer than expected to finish, and the rest, as they say, is history.
It was. John Woo was the director. It ran over its allotted filming schedule, then they had to do reshoots on various scenes. I definitely see it as the weakest instalment of the franchise.
Load More Replies...It's difficult to picture Dougray as a positive character.
Johnny Depp As Gellert Grindelwald In "Fantastic Beasts" Movies, Replaced By Mads Mikkelsen
Johnny Depp seems like a natural fit for the wizarding world of Harry Potter, so it was only natural that fans were happy with his casting. Sadly, when the Depp-Heard scandal hit society, he was practically fired, and Mads Mikkelsen replaced him in the Fantastic Beasts movies. Hopefully, we will see Depp on the big screen soon.
Madds was a much better actor for this roll. I love JD but Madds was a better fit IMOP.
I understand that they changed his appearance to show the passage of time, but why change the eyes so much? The heterochromia was his most recognizable feature but it's barely visible in the third movie.
Fantastic Beasts aren’t iconic. They’ve been pretty mediocre compared to Harry Potter. They just need to make an Auror series where Hermione takes down dark wizards. True Detective meets Harry Potter. Also Johnny is great.
Mads Mikkelsen was a much better Grindelwald. I know that Johnny can be a great actor (which I also happen to be a fan of Johnny Depp) but he was mis-cast as Grindelwald. Not that the series turned out good anyway.
We know why he was replaced and THANK GOD he won. But Mads is in a league all his own too. He is such a wonderful Actor!
I really like Johnny Depp, but he seemed out of place for the role of Grindelwald, like his presence was too overwhelming and strong enough to be the lead character instead of the villan. I prefered Mads Mikkelsen as Grindelwald.
Yeah but they didn’t replace Ezra Miller who has had more disturbing scandals! Makes you wonder
Chris Farley As The Voice Of Shrek In "Shrek" Movies, Replaced By Mike Myers
Chris Farley, a veteran of Saturday Night Live, was recruited to voice the title character in the 1995 film Shrek. Sadly, Farley passed away in 1997. Farley's rendition got left abandoned in favor of fellow SNL veteran Mike Myers. Myers insisted on using his distinctive Scottish accent for the role.
Shrek was originally started in the 90s, but Farley's passing prevented the movie's completion. They essentially had to restart the making of the movie. The version we know today came out in 2001
Load More Replies...I never understood why they didn't cast a Scottish actor if they wanted a Scottish accented Shrek. Billy Connolly would have done it brilliantly.
The Scottish accent isn't "his distinctive accent". Meyers is Canadian.
Yeah, but he's known for doing different voices and accents, especially the scottish one. You cannot tell me that you wouldn't instantly recognize his Scottish voice.
Load More Replies...I would love to hear the Chris Frley version, I thought he was hysterically funny!!
i think he recorded the majority of his lines. you can find a few samples on youtube.
Load More Replies...It took a long time to do animated movies in late 90s early 2000s. Still takes a while now but VFX have come a long way
Terrence Howard As James Rhodes In "Iron Man" Movies, Replaced By Don Cheadle
Terrence Howard, James Rhodes in Iron Man, is not a stranger to rumors and controversies. Legends are that Howard got fired for multiple reasons — poor performance and salary disputes being some of them. Don Cheadle came to replace Howard and give a face to the War Machine character.
Me too but I have always liked him better mainly because of the Ocean 11 movies he did.
Load More Replies...There wasn’t a poor performance issue. He knew his worth and wanted to be paid more money.
This confused me so much. It took me a while to realise they're supposed to be the same character
Me too. I was wondering who the heck Don Cheadle was playing through most of the movie and why he got to wear the suit and where the other guy was. I didn't figure it out until the end. 🫢
Load More Replies...I thought Don looked so frail & old compared to everyone else though.
Hugo Weaving As Red Skull In "Avengers" Movies, Replaced By Ross Marquad
Hugo Weaving portrayed an excellent Red Skull, so it was only natural for the Marvel executives to try and get him for several movies. Because of monetary problems, Weaving couldn't portray the character for Infinity War, and Ross Marquand came to replace him. A professional voice impressionist, Marquand copied Weaving in almost every aspect.
Do you sleep well knowing there are people who seem SO SIMILAR to Hugo Weaving? You are in the Matrix.
Load More Replies...Whoa what?! I had no idea it wasn't Weaving. Well done on Ross's voice skills!
Edward Norton As The Hulk, Replaced By Mark Ruffalo
Sometimes, even an A-list actor is not worth keeping around. While Mark Ruffalo might be the face of the modern Hulk, Edward Norton was the second to play it in the 21st century. Luckily, the Hulk got recast when Marvel started to look for a more group-friendly face. In their crosshairs came Ruffalo, the original first choice for Hulk.
I still have not Edward Norton's version but don't forget Eric Bana played the first Hulk. It came out way long before the Marvel Universe came out.
That version does not exist. We do not speak of that.
Load More Replies...As a big Ed Norton fan I was really annoyed when they recast the role, but Ruffalo soon brought me around. Sadly while Norton might be a really good actor he's reportedly a nightmare to work with.
I felt the same when he was recast but Ruffalo is just so good. He brought a more gentle side to the Hulk and very subtle comedy. I swear, Ruffalo's Hulk gets better in each movie
Load More Replies...I think they mean a team player. Norton, while undeniably talented, has a reputation for.being something of a prima donna.
Load More Replies...I like Edward Norton, but to to me Mark Ruffalo is a much better Hulk
I've liked all three versions, they're all different but it's kind of fun.
Huh? A more 'groupfriendly face'?? What does that even mean? Ruffalo is a good Hulk but Norton is one hell of an actor. He also would have been an awesome Hulk.
From everything I have read Edward Norton insisted on taking over the script, editing and a lot of other functions on his "Hulk" movie. They weren't really happy with that. He wasn't considered a team player.
Load More Replies...Claudia Wells As Jennifer In "Back To The Future", Replaced By Elisabeth Shue
In the original movie, Jennifer was seen only at the start and at the end, and Claudia Wells got the role. When it came time to film the sequel, Wells did not reprise her acting role due to family problems. Forced to recast the role, Elisabeth Shue auditioned and got the part of Jennifer.
Katie Holmes As Rachel Dawes In "The Dark Knight" Trilogy, Replaced By Maggie Gyllenhaal
Christopher Nolan wanted Katie Holmes to portray Rachel Dawes for both Batman movies, but because of scheduling and personal problems, she had to refuse it. Maggie Gyllenhaal replaced Holmes and acted in one of the best Batman movies ever. The good thing is that there are no hard feelings on all sides.
I remember reading/hearing that Tom Cruz essentially didn't allow Katie Holmes to do the second one. Obviously, I have no idea if that's actually true. However, I wouldn't really be surprised if it were since it was at the peak of their relationship and scientology stuff
Conan Stevens As The Mountain In "Game Of Thrones", Replaced By Ian Whyte And Then By Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson
In Game of Thrones, The Mountain is a character who has been played by a lot of actors. Conan Stevens portrayed him in season one due to his physical characteristics. Ian Whyte then took up the role, becoming him for season two, before getting replaced by Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson. He seems to fit the description almost point to point.
This makes a lot more sense as to why I was so confused when watching. They replaced a few other characters too (I forget the character names) and because the actors didn't look remotely alike I thought they were whole new characters
Daario Naharis was a pretty drastic change, but Michiel Huisman did a good job with it.
Load More Replies...Haaff-thorr (soft th not hard) Yooleeoos Bee-yorn-sonn
Load More Replies...Colin Firth As The Voice Of Paddington In "Paddington", Replaced By Ben Whishaw
Colin Firth was the original voice of the adorable bear. Firth willingly left the movie as it became clear to all parties involved that his voice was not the right one for the part. Without Ben Whishaw's unique demeanor, which he imparts to the two flawless movies, it is difficult to conceive the marmalade master.
I think Whishaw brought his youth into the voice rather than a much more mature sounding Firth. Perfect casting.
Exactly! Firth is excellent, but his voice doesn't really make sense for an oversized teddy bear.
Load More Replies...Dick York As Darrin Stephens In "Bewitched", Replaced By Dick Sargent
Richard York had a severe back ailment from an incident in 1959 that he got while working a set. In 1969, when Daddy Does His Thing was under production, Richard passed out and was taken to the hospital. Shortly after, Richard Sargent got cast in the show, and left the show shortly after.
Like the actor D**k Sargent but hated him as Darrin. (Oh good grief! BP censored his NAME!).
Same here. He changed Darrin and not for the better. But he was good in everything else I saw him in.
Load More Replies...They should have done this on the Bewitched movie, just change actors mid movie and not say anything about it
I like Sargent in other things…but York was a superior actor and the best Darrin. I’ve been watching Alfred Hitchcock Presents; York is in a bunch of them and always fun to watch. I wish he’d been treated better by Hollywood.
Really confused!. I just assumed he looked and acted different because the mother in law hated him.
Load More Replies...I remember hearing about York's ailments. I liked both Darrens but I liked York's portrayal a bit better. The OG Darren.
Ed Skrein As Daario Naharis In "Game Of Thrones", Replaced By Michiel Huisman
Game of Thrones is not a stranger to recasting minor characters. One of the most visible ones is Daario Naharis. Ed Skrein was the original actor to portray the mercenary, but because of political reasons and (more likely) the wish to act in a Transporter movie, he had to leave the series. Michiel Huisman replaced the actor for the rest of the seasons.
Probably the most jarring re-cast I've ever seen. Most of the time, I don't notice. This one had me going back through episodes to see if I had missed something.
I agree. I didn't really mind the second Daario, but he was just waaaayyy too different in looks, manner, voice, etc. than the original. It was very distracting.
Load More Replies...I thought it was because he got the role in Deadpool (Ajax - the villain) which would have clashed with GoT filming.
Load More Replies...Ed made me want to see the next season so badly and boy was I dissapointed
Same exact reaction as Nupraptor — checking back episodes to see what happened???
Rachel Weisz As Evie In "The Mummy" Movies, Replaced By Maria Bello
In the Frasers’ trilogy of Mummy movies, the character of Evie was played by Rachel Weisz for the first two movies and Maria Bello for the third one. Weisz had problems with the third movie's script and decided to leave the role behind — Bello came to replace her .
It really was bad. Even if she had been in it, the story was horrible
Load More Replies...The chemistry between Fraser and Weisz made a lot of this movie other than it being great.
The first two were better than the third. My crush on Brendan kept me coming back for more.
I'd be happy to just pretend the 3rd movie was a fever dream and have another installment. I just watched The Mummy again last night, still so good
She made the right decision; that movie was so bad I walked out when they got to the "joke" about the vomiting yak.
I didn't know they replaced her when I watched movie. I Denver watching movie and thinking about 5 minutes into movie that they killed her character off.
It was funny how they revealed the change onscreen, however. After reading a book she wrote based on their adventures, she was asked if the book character was based on her life. At this time you see her face for the first time (note also that up until now she sort of sounded like Rachel) and she replies "I can honestly say that is a completely different person"
movie should never have been made. Terrible script and she just did not fill the role either. If you are going to make a sequel make it right!
Even when I was little, I always thought Miss Weisz was so beautiful. I wanted her and Mister Fraser to be together XD
Anita Barone As Carol In "Friends", Replaced By Jane Sibbett
Anita Barone portrayed Carol in Friends for one episode, The One With The Sonogram At The End. Because Barone wanted a more vital role in the series, she left the project, and Jane Sibbett came to replace her. Friends' general popularity, even with a small screen time, was enough to make Jane Sibbett a vital part of the series.
I can honestly say that I have NEVER watched a full episode of Friends' and I'm okay with that...
I love FRIENDS, but some dont. Some even hate it. and I'm okay with that. Cause thats how the world is supposed to work.
Load More Replies...I'll probably get banned from BP for this but: Why are people on bored panda so weirdly proud of disliking "friends"? The first season was almost thirty years ago yet it seems like a lot of people are comparing it to what TV is like now. I agree that many of their jokes didn't age well and would most certainly not be made nowadays, but within the range of what was on TV around that time it was rather open-minded (for lack of a better word).
Freddie Stroma As Dickon Tarly In "Game Of Thrones", Replaced By Tom Hopper
The role of Dickon Tarly seems to have suited both of the actors portraying him very well. Knowing that it wouldn't be a recurring role, Freddie committed to Time After Time. Tom Hopper replaced him and admitted that the Dickon Tarly role secured him an acting job in the Umbrella Academy series.
It's kinda the point in UA for his character. They added padding under his clothes but it would be the same for any actor for his UA character
Load More Replies...GOTs replaced so many actors that I had a hard time keeping up with who’s who.
Janet Hubert As Vivian Banks In "The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air", Replaced By Daphne Maxwell Reid
So-called “creative differences” separated Janet Hubert from her role as Vivian Banks in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air. On the other hand, Hubert says that the studio behind the series offered her a horrible deal, which she couldn’t accept. Daphne Maxwell Reid came to replace Hubert for 79 episodes.
Hubert was the perfect mom. You believed it was actually their mom.
Load More Replies...I saw some news, Hubert left because they would prank and bully her too much. She couldn’t take it...... Looks like not a good thing..
There's a YouTube video where Will Smith apologises for the bad treatment and admits he was a brat during the filming. It's an honest sounding apology too that doesn't try to vindicate his actions.
Load More Replies...They actually made a joke about this in the show so it was never a secret it was a different actress.
"You know, Ms. Banks, since you had that baby... there's something different about you."
Load More Replies...Never watched the series but if the role of "Vivian Banks" was to portray a "take no poop" aura from anyone versus a "oh ok just one more bedtime story" vibe the first lady looks deadly as for it
Alessandra Torresani As Ann Veal In "Arrested Development", Replaced By Mae Whitman
These days, Mae Whitman might be the face that best suits Ann Veal's character. In the first season, Alessandra Torresani played the character. The recasting was planned from the very start of the series in order to make the character more forgettable. Ironically, Mae Whitman did such a good job that she got the role full-time.
They barely have a face. You couldn't pick them out of a line up of one
Load More Replies...Lisa Robin Kelly As Lori In "That '70s Show", Replaced By Christina Moore
Lisa departed That '70s Show after medical problems created some personal problems. In 2012, she admitted to having a drinking issue upon leaving That '70s Show, telling ABC News that she was "guilty of a drinking problem." Christine Moore came to replace her as the character of Lori.
I did not think it was a good replacement, she seemed nothing like her
It's sad and ironic that the actress died due to those very problem not to mention that the show did not portray her in a positive light.
Other than perhaps Donna and Kitty, all of the characters were portrayed with flaws, which made them relatable, and provided good story lines
Load More Replies...The Lisa RK episodes are some of the best, she brought incredible energy and presence to the show… and hilarious comedic delivery
Rachelle Lefevre As Victoria In "Twilight", Replaced By Bryce Dallas Howard
Rachelle Lefevre wanted to portray Victoria in Twilight so much that she wrote several letters to Catherine Hardwicke, director of the first movie. Sadly, after two entries into the series, Bryce Dallas Howard, another talented actress, came to portray the character of Victoria. Both actresses seem glad to have the chance and play this character.
I may be in the minority here, but I thought Rachelle was more sinister. I like Bryce Dallas Howard as an actress but just didn't feel like she was right for the role.
I'm with you there. Rachelle was more in line with how I imagined Victoria in the books too.
Load More Replies...Rachelle fit this role so well, I hated to see it re-cast...but the real travesty was the wig they put BDH in. Honestly, whoever was in charge of the wigs in that whole movie should've been fired. Don't get the rats started on this one.
there was some mentioning that Howard didn!t want to play Victoria in first two movise,because the character got just a little screen time.it changed in the third movie so she wanted to come back.i dodnt remember where i read it though
The reason Rachelle was recast in Eclipse is a schedule conflict. It had nothing to do with Bryce.
Tom Ellis As Robin Hood In "Once Upon A Time", Replaced By Sean Maguire
The production was obliged to replace Tom since, at the time, he couldn't commit to portraying Robin Hood and had other obligations to complete. Sean Maguire got the role of Robin Hood, and as far as the public knows, there is no cold blood between Tom Ellis and the production executives.
TOM... I am unashamed to say that he is currently my background screen for my work computer.. Get stressed, minimize windows.. :D
Yes. Clearly the writer got their idioms confused.
Load More Replies...Parker Bagley As Jason Dilaurentis In "Pretty Little Liars", Replaced By Drew Van Acker
Just as Jason's narrative on Pretty Little Liars started to become bigger and more significant, Drew got hired to deliver the much-needed drama for the character. The role became so large, the fans practically demanded for the character to be recast. Notably, Jason returned to Rosewood during Season 2 and began dating Aria.
Aimee Richardson As Myrcella Baratheon In "Game Of Thrones", Replaced By Nell Tiger Free
Like her character, Aimee Richardson also heard some surprising, sad news. During San Diego Comic-Con, she got the news of being fired and laughed it off, posting on social media “Princess for hire.” When Nell Tiger Free took up the role, she reacted calmly and admitted that she was humbled.
Jane Levy As Mandy Milkovich In "Shameless", Replaced By Emma Greenwell
Sometimes, the recasting happens because a better opportunity arises for the actor or actress, thus a decision is made to leave a good role for a greater one. In 2011, Jane left Shameless to play Tessa Altman on the incredibly underestimated yet brilliant television series Suburgatory. In her place came Emma Greenwell, who did a pretty good job.
OI think the character was off for a season or so, with the gap it was less obvious
Load More Replies...Shannon Cochran As Helene Beesly In "The Office", Replaced By Linda Purl
Pam’s mom in The Office is a minor character, with two different actresses portraying her. Shannon Cochran was the original face of Pam’s mom, but because she was touring a theater at the time of her scenes, Linda Purl came into the series. Purl nailed her scenes, creating some legendary moments in the process.
Laura Benanti As Kara's Mom In "Supergirl", Replaced By Erica Durance
Since Laura was from New York City, she couldn't continue portraying Alura Zor-El, since the second season saw production in Vancouver. Erica Durance, who portrayed Lois in Smallville, was given the part of Kara's mother, hiring another actress who had already portrayed Lois Lane in another show.
Unfortunately, Henry Cavill as Geralt of Rivia in The Witcher, replaced by Liam Hemsworth
Me too! The first few seasons captured that kind of sweet, naive idea that was also prevalent in the first Superman movie (the one with Christopher Reeve). Loved it.
Load More Replies...Didn't know that must not have seen that and I am a,big Snellville fan.
David Michael Scott As Beric Dondarrion In "Game Of Thrones", Replaced By Richard Dormer
Since Beric Dondarrion was a minor character in the first season, David Michael Scott was cast to portray the loyal lord. With the character becoming more vital to the story overall, Richard Dormer came in to act as the head of house Dondarrion. It was a minor recasting that only a few fans noticed.
So many characters, half the time I assumed it was a new character not a different actor.
Load More Replies...I have face blindness and really depend on costumes to follow a series. This montrosity needed name tags or floating thought bubbles. I really feel bad for people can recognize faces wondering why all these different people played the same character.
How about the time that Geneviève Bujold was replaced by Kate Mulgrew as Captain Janeway in Star Trek: Voyager? vg3-63e9bc...c280a1.jpg
Jake T. Austin As Jesus In "The Fosters", Replaced By Noah Centineo
After Season 2, Jake announced that he was quitting the program on Twitter. Additionally, there were speculations as to why Jake left The Fosters. Some think he did it since his part got diminished in Season 3. When Noah joined the cast, it was revealed that Jesus got sent to boarding school.
Molly Ephraim As Mandy Baxter In "Last Man Standing", Replaced By Molly McCook
After Fox salvaged the program from cancellation, Molly Ephraim couldn't carry on as Mandy. Additionally, she couldn't come back to play the role because she had already begun working on other projects. Molly McCook was given the chance to portray the character in her own way.
Not the same Molly Ephraim WAS Mandy, McCook was ok, but She wasn't Mandy.
She had already gotten another job, the production company has to get another girl.
Load More Replies...The show didn't try to pretend nothing changed. The first episode in that season mentioned her being blonde and taller.
Ross Butler As Reggie Mantle In "Riverdale", Replaced By Charles Melton
Who could have known that Netflix could change careers? Ross Butler portrayed the frenemy Reggie Mantle, but because of his commitment to 13 Reasons Why, the producers had to recast the character with Charles Melton. When season two came to reality, Melton was glad to get the call, calling it a “Christmas gift.”
Gotta say, it was a welcome change Melton really portrays the role perfectly.
Aml Ameen As Capheus Onyango In "Sense8", Replaced By Toby Onwumere
Aml Ameen played Capheus for season one of Sense8 and had a lot of faith in returning to the series. However, a split in the cast developed with Lana Wachowski, with both having different creative ideas, thus clashing. Aml got fired, and Toby Onwumere got chosen for the part.
I remember that. In the first scene with the new actor, another character says. "I haven't seen you in a while. You look different." He replies "I FEEL different!" And then the series continued. I liked it as a nod to the viewers "yes, we switched actors, now let's pretend no one cares."
Luke Grimes As James Kent In "True Blood", Replaced By Nathan Parsons
Luke Grimes portrayed James Kent in the sixth season of True Blood and only for one season. There are several reasons why Grimes left the role, with the more formal one being that the character was taking a more creative path. Rumors are that Grimes quit and Parsons got involved because the original actor didn't like the sexuality of the character.
Parson's was great, and if the issue was that Grimes didn't want to play a gay role then he's a putz.
Santino Fontana As Greg In "Crazy Ex-Girlfriend", Replaced By Skylar Astin
On the CW, one-year contracts are so uncommon that when Season 2 rolled around, Santino already had other film and theatrical projects he was pursuing. Skylar's introduction as Greg was a perfect opportunity to "get into the perceptual changes" and drastically change the way we see the character.
The part was a total butt head. But better than the main ,make character, Josh.
How about Andy Whitfield having to be replaced as Spartacus by Liam McIntyre. Had to be done since Andy tragically passed from cancer after the first season. I definitely preferred Whitfield and it too me a beat to be ok with McIntyre.
Agreed. Although I didn’t mind McIntyre, Whitfield just had that spark as Spartacus. The series was definitely not as good without him, RIP :-(
Load More Replies...Can we please stop with the "you probably didn't know" and "you've been doing this ALL WRONG" titles? And the majority of this list has been thrown around over and over and over... so actually, a lot of people probably did know. Reading all the comments before mine - sounds like a new, actually exciting list could be made.
I agree. Of course people knew. Especially the roles that have been played by different actors in different movies. Nobody didn’t know that Mark Ruffalo replaced Edward Norton for example.
Load More Replies...Lavender Brown in HP changing from a heavier Black girl to a tiny white girl the MOMENT her character was set to appear regularly in the series???
Lecy Goranson as Becky in "Roseanne", replaced by Sarah Chalke, who was replaced by Lecy Goranson again.
and back and forth and back and forth to the point the creators used both of them in the same scene just for laughs.
Load More Replies...How about that time Geneviève Bujold was replaced by Kate Mulgrew to play Captain Janeway on Voyager? vg3-63e9bc...0525ff.jpg
There was a scene in The Fresh Prince Of Bel Air where there was a little kid that was replaced by a much older kid and they all did a fourth wall break in the first episode of the new season about how the kid grew so much over summer :-) It was a good way to deal with the obvious.
I dispute the characterization of several of these movies as "iconic"
Phil Burns as Morty Seinfeld replaced by Barney Martin. John Randolph as Frank Costanza replaced by Jerry Stiller. Larry David as Newman (voice only) replaced by Wayne Knight.
How about Andy Whitfield having to be replaced as Spartacus by Liam McIntyre. Had to be done since Andy tragically passed from cancer after the first season. I definitely preferred Whitfield and it too me a beat to be ok with McIntyre.
Agreed. Although I didn’t mind McIntyre, Whitfield just had that spark as Spartacus. The series was definitely not as good without him, RIP :-(
Load More Replies...Can we please stop with the "you probably didn't know" and "you've been doing this ALL WRONG" titles? And the majority of this list has been thrown around over and over and over... so actually, a lot of people probably did know. Reading all the comments before mine - sounds like a new, actually exciting list could be made.
I agree. Of course people knew. Especially the roles that have been played by different actors in different movies. Nobody didn’t know that Mark Ruffalo replaced Edward Norton for example.
Load More Replies...Lavender Brown in HP changing from a heavier Black girl to a tiny white girl the MOMENT her character was set to appear regularly in the series???
Lecy Goranson as Becky in "Roseanne", replaced by Sarah Chalke, who was replaced by Lecy Goranson again.
and back and forth and back and forth to the point the creators used both of them in the same scene just for laughs.
Load More Replies...How about that time Geneviève Bujold was replaced by Kate Mulgrew to play Captain Janeway on Voyager? vg3-63e9bc...0525ff.jpg
There was a scene in The Fresh Prince Of Bel Air where there was a little kid that was replaced by a much older kid and they all did a fourth wall break in the first episode of the new season about how the kid grew so much over summer :-) It was a good way to deal with the obvious.
I dispute the characterization of several of these movies as "iconic"
Phil Burns as Morty Seinfeld replaced by Barney Martin. John Randolph as Frank Costanza replaced by Jerry Stiller. Larry David as Newman (voice only) replaced by Wayne Knight.
