Person Refuses To Pay Parents Rent After They Find Out Sister’s Special Treatment
Whether it’s a valid feeling or not, realizing you’re not being treated fairly hurts. Especially when the people responsible for the injustice are the ones you expect to be your closest allies.
So when Reddit user Low_Scholar_2297, who diligently pays rent to their parents, learned that their sister is living there for free, it was as if they were being told she matters more.
And if that wasn’t enough, they were then asked to bump up the payments, and called selfish after agreeing only on the condition that their sibling matches their contribution.
This person’s landlords are their parents, and they wanted to increase their rent
Image credits: freepik (not the actual photo)
But their other “tenant” was getting a much better deal
Image credits: syda_productions (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Low_Scholar_2297
Younger daughters are, in fact, the most commonly favored children by their parents
It’s not easy to research parental favoritism — the culprits aren’t readily admitting to it. But in 2001, J. Jill Suitor, a professor of sociology at Purdue University, recruited more than 500 mothers, each of whom had two or more adult children, and began tracking their responses to questions such as “Which child do you spend more resources on?” “Whom do you feel emotionally closer to?”, and “Whom are you more disappointed in?”
(She has now studied the same families for so long that she has started collecting data on the effects of grandparental favoritism.)
The first surprising result from this data was just how pervasive the favoritism was. According to the study, roughly two-thirds of parents had a preferred child, and that favorite sibling often stayed the same over decades.
There was no set of qualities that guaranteed being the golden child, but, as in our Redditor’s family, favorites tended to be daughters and younger siblings.
A large analysis published in 2025 similarly found that in childhood, daughters were more likely to get preferential treatment from their parents.
And Dr. Suitor found that, in adulthood, the most important factor, “hands down,” was whether parents and children shared similar values, including on religious and political topics.
However, in some ways, parents’ own perception of their favoritism is irrelevant, Dr. Suitor said. In research examining the mental health consequences of favoritism, it’s far more important whether the children perceived unequal treatment.
And one study discovered that parents and children disagreed more than half the time when asked about the amount of differential treatment, who benefited from that inequity, and whether the differences were perceived as fair.
Part of the problem — just like this time as well — is that parents rarely discuss these topics with their children.
Image credits: Getty Images (not the actual photo)
Most of the people who read the story said the author did nothing wrong
Others thought the entire family needed to step up
And some said it was a lose-lose scenario for everyone
However, a few do think OP is the problem
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
This seems like it's UK, not US, but either way, I suspect that 600 a month (pounds, not dollars?), utilities included, is a far better deal than they'd get anywhere else. Young people are struggling everywhere, and it's not going to get any better this year, so moving out is a luxury.
Load More Replies...I agree that OP should keep paying the same amount he has been paying if he doesn't move out, but no more. Just because his parents want to continue supporting their adult daughter doesn't mean OP has to also.
No, because it's reasoning for her not paying anything. She's saving for her life. So is op. They gave her that deal, yet told op he had to pay. So quit endorsing the spoiled brat and expecting other sibling to cover for them. If it wasn't for op extra income to the house it dosent seem they could be paying for sister's insurance let alone continued existence in the house.
Load More Replies...So the rent is based on what each adult child is willing to pay. That sounds like a good business model (I'm being sarcastic, folks).
All the “They can’t force the brat to pay” blow my mind. OF COURSE THEY CAN! It’s easy! “Kiddo, you either pay $XXX or you’re out on the 30th.” It’s EASY! I’m thinking they’ré not very bright in addition to being spineless jellyfish.
Load More Replies...Parents need to grow their backbones and tell their children the price to stay with them. I do think OP should be kept at the same amount with sister paying $400-500/month (since she doesn't have a private apartment like OP). But they really need to stop acting like they have no say what happens in their own home.
I was in the same boat. I was paying 300 a month rent (average one bed house rent at the time was 500/month) and Mom asked if for a few if I could up it to 400. I agreed and 6 months later asked Dad if we could go back to 300 because my job was cutting my hours. He looked confused and my sister blurted out she was not paying anything at all for her room. Turns out mom was needing a bit more for some bills and did not want to ask my sis to start paying. Dad was under the impression I was only paying 200 plus working for Dad at the drop of the hat (which was very often to make up for the cheap rent) and she 100.
The american obsession with kicking their young out or charging them rent to stay. I may be too Latino for this, but if you live together as a family, you pool resources and collaborate and take from each according to their ability and give to each according to their needs, do you not? This is how it always has been done at my place - now I am the one with the most means, and I take care of my elderly mother the same way my parents took care of me when I was young. Is this not what family is supposed to do?
Isn't charging them rent just a form of pooling resources and collaborating?
Load More Replies...This seems like it's UK, not US, but either way, I suspect that 600 a month (pounds, not dollars?), utilities included, is a far better deal than they'd get anywhere else. Young people are struggling everywhere, and it's not going to get any better this year, so moving out is a luxury.
Load More Replies...I agree that OP should keep paying the same amount he has been paying if he doesn't move out, but no more. Just because his parents want to continue supporting their adult daughter doesn't mean OP has to also.
No, because it's reasoning for her not paying anything. She's saving for her life. So is op. They gave her that deal, yet told op he had to pay. So quit endorsing the spoiled brat and expecting other sibling to cover for them. If it wasn't for op extra income to the house it dosent seem they could be paying for sister's insurance let alone continued existence in the house.
Load More Replies...So the rent is based on what each adult child is willing to pay. That sounds like a good business model (I'm being sarcastic, folks).
All the “They can’t force the brat to pay” blow my mind. OF COURSE THEY CAN! It’s easy! “Kiddo, you either pay $XXX or you’re out on the 30th.” It’s EASY! I’m thinking they’ré not very bright in addition to being spineless jellyfish.
Load More Replies...Parents need to grow their backbones and tell their children the price to stay with them. I do think OP should be kept at the same amount with sister paying $400-500/month (since she doesn't have a private apartment like OP). But they really need to stop acting like they have no say what happens in their own home.
I was in the same boat. I was paying 300 a month rent (average one bed house rent at the time was 500/month) and Mom asked if for a few if I could up it to 400. I agreed and 6 months later asked Dad if we could go back to 300 because my job was cutting my hours. He looked confused and my sister blurted out she was not paying anything at all for her room. Turns out mom was needing a bit more for some bills and did not want to ask my sis to start paying. Dad was under the impression I was only paying 200 plus working for Dad at the drop of the hat (which was very often to make up for the cheap rent) and she 100.
The american obsession with kicking their young out or charging them rent to stay. I may be too Latino for this, but if you live together as a family, you pool resources and collaborate and take from each according to their ability and give to each according to their needs, do you not? This is how it always has been done at my place - now I am the one with the most means, and I take care of my elderly mother the same way my parents took care of me when I was young. Is this not what family is supposed to do?
Isn't charging them rent just a form of pooling resources and collaborating?
Load More Replies...








































45
17